Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I'm sorry. It was supposed to be a night of thoughtful debate and probing intellectual discussion of how to deal with the fringe elements in Islam.

I despise those people and their racist babble. But you have no idea if the plan was to provoke a terrorist attack, that might very well have killed and maimed nearly everyone participating. Maybe the security was hired to protect people in case something they didn't want to happen occurred. That seems way more likely.
 
Because it filters out nonsense and failure. All speech is not equivalent.



Indeed, and I do not inhabit those places as a general rule.



Please do not put the burden on me to justify crazy jihadists. However, understanding that crazy jihadists exist means I will consider them as part of the context of the world I live in, just as I would any other danger. I recognize they are not civil, and are in fact, monstrous. But I do not wish to become monstrous myself, nor to be uncivil merely to make a point about monsters. Rather, I prefer to remain civil in the hope that it will attract others to a more pleasant way of living. We are better than the terrorists. We don't have to act in ways that encourage them. We don't have to give them opportunities to become martyrs for a foolish cause by being foolish ourselves.

This. 100% this.

And I wonder if the people arguing against Marplots would be arguing quite so vociferously if this had been a "Caricature of Martin Luther King Jr." contest organized by some white supremacists.
 
I despise those people and their racist babble. But you have no idea if the plan was to provoke a terrorist attack, that might very well have killed and maimed nearly everyone participating. Maybe the security was hired to protect people in case something they didn't want to happen occurred. That seems way more likely.

If they didn't want to put people at risk...why organize a caricature of Mohammed contest? We KNOW that sets off crazy people. So why do it?

What did they prove with this? That we have the freedom to draw caricatures of Mohammed? Thanks, I already knew that. That some Muslims are crazy? Knew that too.

This was an absolutely pointless event. There was no reason to do it other than to get people upset. This was the equivalent of the KKK marching down a street in an inner city black neighborhood. And now two idiots are dead, and maybe they could have pulled back from their religious craziness, but we'll never know because the Muslims Suck Organization wanted to make a point about free speech. Well played, American Freedom Defense Initiative.
 
And yet again you prove you do not understand what free speech is. The fact that I have to explain how this is not free speech means that you are probably unable or unwilling to understand.

I take it then that you agree that some speech can be harmful? That was the entire point being made with that example.

In other words, you cannot even support your own assertions.

From your point of view? No. No support I give will suffice.

You were the one who insisted that appeasement is necessary, yet you refuse to justify it.

Appeasement (what a loaded word that is) isn't necessary, unless you don't want to suffer the consequences of doing the opposite. There is no mystery here - our actions have consequences. It isn't appeasement to recognize this simple fact.

You were the one who insisted I run away from harm to someplace where people are peaceful and inoffensive. So where is that place? Where in the world is a place that is peaceful and inoffensive and safe from the violent because of their inoffensiveness?

You only have to run away to the extent you don't wish to suffer the harm that comes from not running away. You are free to put yourself at risk. Many do, for many reasons. What seems disingenuous is to then complain about suffering the foreseeable consequences of your own choices.

I'm betting you won't answer this, because such a place cannot possibly exist. It's a ludicrous pipe dream.

I'm betting you won't think I've answered it to your satisfaction because I'm not following the script properly. Thankfully, we can both win our bets.

Nope, you fail again. The words and pictures did not cause any harm to the terrorists; yet they chose to react with violence. The violent credo of the intolerant and emotionally stunted caused harm. Show me an example of words that are not a direct incitement to violence causing harm. Show me an example of profanity causing harm.

Sure. Here's an example of the first: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/03/19/us-target-settlement-idUSKBN0MF04K20150319 - $10 million in harm. Is that enough?

Here's an example of the second: http://www.wxyz.com/news/region/livingston-county/brighton-police-crackdown-on-disorderly-conduct-
The harm in this second case is called "breach of the peace."

As far as any harm that stems from depictions of Mohammed, the question is more properly asked of an Islamist scholar. The pictures don't bother me. But, of course, being a mature adult, I understand others may feel differently. When those others feel so strongly they are going to attack on that basis, I tend to believe them.

Do you count "offense" and "insult" as harms? Some seem to do so. Whole nations do so. This isn't an idea manufactured to support a position, it actually exists in the world.
 
This. 100% this.

And I wonder if the people arguing against Marplots would be arguing quite so vociferously if this had been a "Caricature of Martin Luther King Jr." contest organized by some white supremacists.

Unknown, but they should.

"Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people." - Eleanor Roosevelt
 
Just to be clear; people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people...correct? Or is it that people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people who have a reputation for violent retribution?

Should people stop saying and doing things that knowingly upset me... or do I have to engage in a campaign of price-tag violence before earning that privilege?

I knowingly upset people all the time. I could hardly post my opinions in strongly worded form without drawing ire here. The question is whether we have some purpose in mind, and what other options may serve as well or better.

I accept that my contentiousness will reduce my social capital here as a consequence of an unpopular opinion. But I think expressing my views is a purpose worth the trouble. If I thought someone here was going to shoot at me for my opinions, I'd have to reevaluate my calculation. Apparently, the risk of attack was worth holding a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed for the people organizing the event. At least it was prospectively. We will have to wait and see if they hold the event again.
 
Last edited:
I know right?

I mean, I'd like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting (insert any group here). I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from calling then (insert that group's insulting name here) doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

:rolleyes:

Indeed. I'd like to live in a world where I could eat continuously and not get fat. Maybe if I eat enough, this world will appear. Because not eating continuously would just be appeasement.
 
IOW the ones the Muslims kill are partly responsible for their own deaths.

That is victim blaming.

Not if they are victims of their own stupidity, or is that victim blaming too?

I reject the concept of victim blaming as both shallow and useless. It's predicated on the notion that "blame" is a discrete thing to be handed to one party or another as an indivisible unit. This is not the case. All you have to do is look at negligence law to see how fault is actually parceled out in real-world examples.

"Victim blaming" is a pointless exercise in poisoning the well.
 
I know right?

I mean, I'd like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting (insert any group here). I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from calling then (insert that group's insulting name here) doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

:rolleyes:

I know right?

I mean, I'd like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for acting gay in public. I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from acting gay in public doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

;)
 
By marplots and Fud's own words they should quit posting here because they are making others angry and they are provocative but we don't have the body count to make our wishes effective.

I am willing to suffer the consequences of my actions. It is my fault. I accept this. You may blame me for my actions - they are willfully undertaken and sometimes designed to provoke.

However, if things are going to get violent, there will be a new set of consequences for me to consider. Perhaps, in that case, I would withdraw. Are things going to get violent?
 
I am willing to suffer the consequences of my actions. It is my fault. I accept this. You may blame me for my actions - they are willfully undertaken and sometimes designed to provoke.

However, if things are going to get violent, there will be a new set of consequences for me to consider. Perhaps, in that case, I would withdraw. Are things going to get violent?

Well, there's always a risk. How cowardly are you?
 
Indeed. I'd like to live in a world where I could eat continuously and not get fat. Maybe if I eat enough, this world will appear. Because not eating continuously would just be appeasement.

I know you can do better than this. I've actually seen you show flashes of wit now and then.
 
And I wonder if the people arguing against Marplots would be arguing quite so vociferously if this had been a "Caricature of Martin Luther King Jr." contest organized by some white supremacists.

If a couple of dudes in body armor carrying AKs with drum mags showed up and tried to kill them...yeah. That's sorta the important part.
 
If they didn't want to put people at risk...why organize a caricature of Mohammed contest? We KNOW that sets off crazy people. So why do it?

To show (hopefully) that a critical mass of people exist who won't be cowed into giving up their freedoms to appease extremists.

What did they prove with this? That we have the freedom to draw caricatures of Mohammed? Thanks, I already knew that. That some Muslims are crazy? Knew that too.

Actually, they proved that we have a long way to go do defend our freedoms. Even in Texas (Texas for God's sake!), you can't criticize Islam without spending $10,000 on security (and needing it). Hopefully, the next time, there will be no attack, and after a few dozen more held without incident, it will be possible to forgo the $10,000 expenditure on security.

This was an absolutely pointless event. There was no reason to do it other than to get people upset. This was the equivalent of the KKK marching down a street in an inner city black neighborhood. And now two idiots are dead, and maybe they could have pulled back from their religious craziness, but we'll never know because the Muslims Suck Organization wanted to make a point about free speech. Well played, American Freedom Defense Initiative.

Not pointless at all. And the attack was not pointless either. There is a battle going on, and it remains to be seen who will emerge victorious. Thank God there are plenty of people brave enough to fight for free speech. There are so many people here who aren't, unfortunately.
 
Not pointless at all. And the attack was not pointless either. There is a battle going on, and it remains to be seen who will emerge victorious. Thank God there are plenty of people brave enough to fight for free speech. There are so many people here who aren't, unfortunately.

Oh, don't think the efforts aren't appreciated though. Just as soon as the more heroic here win the Muslim free speech war, on that very day, I'm going to start drawing pictures of Mohammed. It's on my bucket list.

Which reminds me. To those who don the robes of patriotism and tell themselves they are fighting for my freedoms - you can stop now. I have all the freedom I can stand. Stop getting killed now please.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom