luchog
Neo-Post-Retro-Revivalist
No, you don't understand free speech.We do it already. We ask courts for gag orders and injunctions. Sometimes they are granted. If such orders are violated, prison can follow. So, yeah, sometimes speech is suppressed with threats of violence.
Really? You are that ignorant of history? You've not heard of the Soviet gulags? The Great Leap Forward? The Democratic People's Republic of Korea? None of these events have people inspired to free speech, except in the most furtive and evasive way. Speech is heavily curtailed, and to even be suspected of speaking prohibited things results in imprisonment and death. Worse, it has inspired informers, rather than speak freely, even among their friends, people rat each other out to the oppressors, hoping to save their own skins by informing on someone else. In ancient Egypt and Rome, to speak out against the Pharaoh or Emperor was punishable by a gruesome death. Did that inspire protest or revolt? No, it inspired silence and acquiescence.And no, we don't see a rash of free speech suppression by way of violent threats. In fact, we sometimes see the opposite - the violence inspires others, now made attentive by the news, to duplicate the prohibited act. The strategy is not a good one if the intent is to prevent such expressions.
Protesting against oppression only works in an otherwise pluralistic and moral society. Ask the Armenians or Ba'ha'i of their protests against Islam, and their desire to freely practice their religion. Ask the Falun Gong and Tibetans of their protests against the Chinese government. Ask the North Koreans about... well, you can't, because they're not allowed to talk to foreigners without official clearance and supervision, and are executed if they do. Protest only works if those you are protesting against value your life. When they don't, then they are killed, sometimes by the millions.
And you fail yet again. This is not suppression of free expression. These are examples of voluntary agreements entered into for mutual benefit. When the terms are broken, the violators are punished by civic sanctions for breach of contract. They are not constrained because society thinks they will cause harm, they are constrained because the parties involved in the contract believes that doing so is mutually beneficial. No one who is not a signatory to the contract is in any way bound to adhere to those constraints. Trying to enforce them on anyone else is stupid and will result in anything from laughing dismissal, to legal sanctions against the attempted enforcer.Where we do see wholesale suppression of free speech is in the contracts we make with each other. Everything from trade secrets to non-disclosure clauses in settlement agreements. The reason those are constrained is because we believe they will cause harm.
You clearly and obviously have no idea what freedom of expression means, and what it applies to.