Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

We do it already. We ask courts for gag orders and injunctions. Sometimes they are granted. If such orders are violated, prison can follow. So, yeah, sometimes speech is suppressed with threats of violence.
No, you don't understand free speech.

And no, we don't see a rash of free speech suppression by way of violent threats. In fact, we sometimes see the opposite - the violence inspires others, now made attentive by the news, to duplicate the prohibited act. The strategy is not a good one if the intent is to prevent such expressions.
Really? You are that ignorant of history? You've not heard of the Soviet gulags? The Great Leap Forward? The Democratic People's Republic of Korea? None of these events have people inspired to free speech, except in the most furtive and evasive way. Speech is heavily curtailed, and to even be suspected of speaking prohibited things results in imprisonment and death. Worse, it has inspired informers, rather than speak freely, even among their friends, people rat each other out to the oppressors, hoping to save their own skins by informing on someone else. In ancient Egypt and Rome, to speak out against the Pharaoh or Emperor was punishable by a gruesome death. Did that inspire protest or revolt? No, it inspired silence and acquiescence.

Protesting against oppression only works in an otherwise pluralistic and moral society. Ask the Armenians or Ba'ha'i of their protests against Islam, and their desire to freely practice their religion. Ask the Falun Gong and Tibetans of their protests against the Chinese government. Ask the North Koreans about... well, you can't, because they're not allowed to talk to foreigners without official clearance and supervision, and are executed if they do. Protest only works if those you are protesting against value your life. When they don't, then they are killed, sometimes by the millions.

Where we do see wholesale suppression of free speech is in the contracts we make with each other. Everything from trade secrets to non-disclosure clauses in settlement agreements. The reason those are constrained is because we believe they will cause harm.
And you fail yet again. This is not suppression of free expression. These are examples of voluntary agreements entered into for mutual benefit. When the terms are broken, the violators are punished by civic sanctions for breach of contract. They are not constrained because society thinks they will cause harm, they are constrained because the parties involved in the contract believes that doing so is mutually beneficial. No one who is not a signatory to the contract is in any way bound to adhere to those constraints. Trying to enforce them on anyone else is stupid and will result in anything from laughing dismissal, to legal sanctions against the attempted enforcer.

You clearly and obviously have no idea what freedom of expression means, and what it applies to.
 
And n***** is just a word. But if you stand on a street corner yelling the n-word at blacks, you're going to get some angry and upset people, and not all of them will be black. Probably not even the majority will be black. Are the people who get angry upset over the n-word extremists?

We're not talking about anger here, we're talking about threats of violence and acts of murder.

And yes, anyone who threatens to kill you for that is absolutely an extremist. Let alone if they actually try to make good on their threat.
 
The consequences being escaped are the shouldering responsibility part and accepting some of the blame.

IOW the ones the Muslims kill are partly responsible for their own deaths.

That is victim blaming.
 
I agree, but the person I responded to claimed that getting "angry and upset" over drawings is extremism. It's not. There are countless minor things that can get people angry and upset.

Yes, I might eventually get shot if I kept it up long enough, and there's no excuse for killing someone over a word, but wouldn't you wonder why I was doing it in the first place? Doesn't deliberately insulting people seem kind of dumb? Would you go to a bar in the South and start telling redneck jokes?

No doubt. I suggest people refrain from smearing the KKK, what with their propensity for brutality. Deliberately insulting people is dumb.
 
We have a civility rule on this forum. It is a good rule. It promotes quality communication over insult and diatribe. The civility rule enhances free speech, it does not blunt it.
This is a pragmatic matter that is limited exclusively to this forum. That in no way limits the freedom of expression of anyone involved in this forum, only their freedom to do it here. It is purely a voluntary association. If people don't like the rules here, they are perfectly free to go somewhere else to speak as incivily and insultingly as they wish.

The civility rules do not enhance freedom of speech, they do not limit it; they do not address it at all.

And in any case, the principle is very frequently violated by those who know how to skirt the rules. Incivility, insult, and diatribe are common; they simply take a form that does not violate strict interpretation of the letter of the rules.

The reason for this is simple. Free expression is important because we are interested in communication. But all communication is not equal. Stupidity, insult, offense and pointlessness do exist. Those things degrade dialogue. And we do not have to put up with the foul because we like the better efforts.

And stupidity, offense, and pointlessness should be defended in society; because there is no objective definition of stupidity, offensiveness, or pointlessness. These are all purely subjective judgments subject to the whims of those making the judgments. And we do have to put up with the foul in many places, because the power to restrict what they are allowed to express is the power to restrict what we are allowed to express.
 
I agree, but the person I responded to claimed that getting "angry and upset" over drawings is extremism. It's not. There are countless minor things that can get people angry and upset.

Yes, I might eventually get shot if I kept it up long enough, and there's no excuse for killing someone over a word, but wouldn't you wonder why I was doing it in the first place? Doesn't deliberately insulting people seem kind of dumb? Would you go to a bar in the South and start telling redneck jokes?

Your posts are getting me angry and upset and are very provocative, please stop posting.
 
Yes, I might eventually get shot if I kept it up long enough, and there's no excuse for killing someone over a word,
No, there isn't; yet some people here seem to think there is.

but wouldn't you wonder why I was doing it in the first place?

No, why should I, your bad attitude doesn't hurt me, no matter how annoying. Better to just ignore you.
 
Just to be clear; people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people...correct? Or is it that people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people who have a reputation for violent retribution?

Should people stop saying and doing things that knowingly upset me... or do I have to engage in a campaign of price-tag violence before earning that privilege?

By marplots and Fud's own words they should quit posting here because they are making others angry and they are provocative but we don't have the body count to make our wishes effective.
 
Just to be clear; people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people...correct? Or is it that people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people who have a reputation for violent retribution?

Should people stop saying and doing things that knowingly upset me... or do I have to engage in a campaign of price-tag violence before earning that privilege?

Obviously, that's a broad generalization I made. Obviously there are times when you need to exercise your rights no matter how angry it might make people. Two gays wanting to get married is going to get people upset, but that should not stop them.

This though, is not one of those instances:
"The Sunday night event in Garland invited cartoonists to send in caricatures of Mohammed."

What possible good is going to come from Mohammed cartoons? Would these same cartoonists make caricatures of blacks getting lynched? Jews on their way to the gas chambers? Planes crashing into the Twin Towers? Women being raped?

I know exactly why this group- American Freedom Defense Initiative- did this. This is exactly what they were hoping for: for some wackos to come unglued and attack them so their beefed up security could take them out. And now they can say, "See??? We told you Muslims are evil!"
 
Last edited:
Evidence? Everything I've seen suggests that they were perfectly willing to accept the consequences and meet them head-on.

In most situations knowing you may be killed yet going on is viewed as an act of courage.
 
Obviously, that's a broad generalization I made. Obviously there are times when you need to exercise your rights no matter how angry it might make people. Two gays wanting to get married is going to get people upset, but that should not stop them.

This though, is not one of those instances:
"The Sunday night event in Garland invited cartoonists to send in caricatures of Mohammed."

What possible good is going to come from Mohammed cartoons? Would these same cartoonists make caricatures of blacks getting lynched? Jews on their way to the gas chambers? Planes crashing into the Twin Towers? Women being raped?

I know exactly why this group- American Freedom Defense Initiative- did this. This is exactly what they were hoping for: for some wackos to come unglued and attack them so they're beefed up security could take them out. And now they can say, "See??? We told you Muslims are evil!"

You were in on their planing sessions?
 
No, there isn't; yet some people here seem to think there is.



No, why should I, your bad attitude doesn't hurt me, no matter how annoying. Better to just ignore you.

That's absurd. Of course you would wonder why a white guy stood on a street corner for seven hours in Compton calling blacks n****** until he was shot by a couple of gangbangers. Is that normal behavior? No. We don't go around randomly insulting people because we all know some people are nuts.

Bear in mind, I have no problem with criticism. Yes, we should point out the KKK is a hateful racist organization, the idiocy that goes on in organized religion, the problems in the black community, the racism that still exists in America, etc.

Maybe you can tell me: What trenchant criticism are we making of Islam by drawing Mohammed getting ass-******? Is that going to encourage Muslims to think about the radical element within their communities?
 
No problem.

It would depend on how likely that result follows from their actions. In my view this is no different than any other action I might take with attached risks that I can foresee.

The moral dimension does not remove the cause and effect aspect. Clearly, removing the morality gives us rules about expecting causes to have effects: "Those who play with fire shouldn't be surprised when they get burned."

I do not see how adding a moral element to this changes anything. The cause and effect continues to operate, just as before. So long as the actions of others can be predicted, I can expect a certain outcome, despite my moral stance on what "ought" to be. In fact, saying the world, and other moral agents "ought" to behave in a certain manner is stating that they do not act in the preferred manner. Otherwise, the "ought" would have no target as a counterfactual imperative.
 
But it's not just the mechanism. The kind of speech that is being restricted is very different, and that makes all the difference. Even if we consider only government restrictions on speech, the restrictions that the US government enforces are fundamentally different than the restrictions that, say, North Korea enforces. That the methods of enforcement are superficially similar does not make these restrictions equivalent at all. Why is this not obvious to you?

The restrictions are equivalent only in that restrictions do exist. An unbridled, unlimited right to free speech is a myth. It is a myth in North Korea, in Iran, and in the US. It is a myth for very pragmatic reasons - free speech doesn't always deliver the result we desire. We understand there may be unintended or unwanted consequences.

If, "causes Muslim extremists to attack you" is an unwanted consequence, then don't do the behavior - at least so long as that behavior doesn't outrank the risk.
 
"Not all Catholics are Nationalists, and not all Protestants are Unionists, and no one has seriously suggested that differences in theological beliefs are the root cause of our problems."

And the two paragraphs after that read

"But this is not to say that religion should be dismissed. It is well established that one of the many fears Northern Ireland Protestants harbor is the fear of being culturally and religiously absorbed in an all-Ireland state in which they would account for 20% of the population. A state they would vehemently insist on calling a theocratic state.

"But beyond that, I will argue in this paper, that religion plays a critical but little understood role in the conflict, one, which, if not acknowledged and addressed, could seriously handicap the prospects for a negotiated settlement."

Differences in theological beliefs are the root cause of Islamic terrorism.

And denying the religious factors of Islamic terrorism would be just as stupid as claiming that "The Northern Ireland violence was not religious. It was political. The correlation between political sides and religious affiliation is a historical artifact, but it's coincidental to the conflict, not a part of it."
 
Obviously, that's a broad generalization I made. Obviously there are times when you need to exercise your rights no matter how angry it might make people. Two gays wanting to get married is going to get people upset, but that should not stop them.

This though, is not one of those instances:
"The Sunday night event in Garland invited cartoonists to send in caricatures of Mohammed."

What possible good is going to come from Mohammed cartoons? Would these same cartoonists make caricatures of blacks getting lynched? Jews on their way to the gas chambers? Planes crashing into the Twin Towers? Women being raped?

I know exactly why this group- American Freedom Defense Initiative- did this. This is exactly what they were hoping for: for some wackos to come unglued and attack them so their beefed up security could take them out. And now they can say, "See??? We told you Muslims are evil!"

So people should be allowed to say and do things that upset other people, on condition that you approve of their reasons for saying and doing those things. I'm not sure that's a great idea.
 
The restrictions are equivalent only in that restrictions do exist. An unbridled, unlimited right to free speech is a myth. It is a myth in North Korea, in Iran, and in the US. It is a myth for very pragmatic reasons - free speech doesn't always deliver the result we desire. We understand there may be unintended or unwanted consequences.

If, "causes Muslim extremists to attack you" is an unwanted consequence, then don't do the behavior - at least so long as that behavior doesn't outrank the risk.

This is the key part. Pick your battles. Certainly you have the right to tell jokes about Jesus outside the local Baptist church. And certainly we should prosecute the twice-paroled Christian nut who stabs you. But what did you accomplish by asserting your free speech rights? What good did it do?
 
No, marplots, it does NOT enhance free speech. How can it possibly enhance free speech when it by definition restricts speech? It's positively Orwellian to suggest otherwise.

Because it filters out nonsense and failure. All speech is not equivalent.

The civility rule on this forum enhances civility. This is useful, but it is only worth the price because this is a private forum. The civility rule does not prevent anyone here from expressing uncivil thoughts in other venues, and other venues are available to all of us who post here.

Indeed, and I do not inhabit those places as a general rule.

But the terrorists don't accept ANY valid venue for Mohammed cartoons, so you cannot appeal to civility as justification for censoring those cartoons.

Please do not put the burden on me to justify crazy jihadists. However, understanding that crazy jihadists exist means I will consider them as part of the context of the world I live in, just as I would any other danger. I recognize they are not civil, and are in fact, monstrous. But I do not wish to become monstrous myself, nor to be uncivil merely to make a point about monsters. Rather, I prefer to remain civil in the hope that it will attract others to a more pleasant way of living. We are better than the terrorists. We don't have to act in ways that encourage them. We don't have to give them opportunities to become martyrs for a foolish cause by being foolish ourselves.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom