Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

We have a civility rule on this forum. It is a good rule. It promotes quality communication over insult and diatribe. The civility rule enhances free speech, it does not blunt it.

The reason for this is simple. Free expression is important because we are interested in communication. But all communication is not equal. Stupidity, insult, offense and pointlessness do exist. Those things degrade dialogue. And we do not have to put up with the foul because we like the better efforts.
 
Each party has to decide for themselves whether it's worth it or not. Just as the Muslim attackers decided they were going to attack. We do not control this decision-making process, all we can do is criticize it afterward.

The consequences being escaped are the shouldering responsibility part and accepting some of the blame.

So in my hypothetical rally case, the victims should shoulder responsibility, accept some of the blame, and quit whining about so called "freedom of speech". Correct?
 
You're seriously comparing the enforcement of laws to terrorist threats? That's perhaps the dumbest thing you've said so far, which is an accomplishment, I have to say.

I'm sorry you feel that way. In both cases, freedom of express is limited through threats. Just because you agree with one mechanism and disagree with the other doesn't mean they both don't exist and both do not limit free speech.

The tie-in is that there are foreseeable consequences to speaking freely about many topics, pictures of Mohammed are just one type.
 
So in my hypothetical rally case, the victims should shoulder responsibility, accept some of the blame, and quit whining about so called "freedom of speech". Correct?

I'm sorry, I do not recall what your hypothetical was about.
 
I'm sorry, I do not recall what your hypothetical was about.
No problem.

Just how far should this constraint go? If someone organizes a Death to Israel rally, during which people chant Death to Israel...and someone who finds it profoundly offensive throws a live grenade at them... should the chanters be held responsible for their irresponsible incitement?
 
"Not all Catholics are Nationalists, and not all Protestants are Unionists, and no one has seriously suggested that differences in theological beliefs are the root cause of our problems."

Differences in theological beliefs are the root cause of Islamic terrorism.

Nope...the person responsible for the grenade should be arrested, or more preferably (according to some) be shot dead.

No one is denying that people who indulge in terrorism should be punished.

However, by your example...a grenade was thrown, and there was loss of life. In the end, was it all worth it?
 
It's well know that Muslims have poor impulse control, right?

The excuses made for the terrorists by some of the people on this thread are bordering on racism. "Well, they're just ignorant brown savages, you can't expect them to act like civilized white folks; so if you rile them up, it's your own fault if they decide to thump you for it." It's the "soft bigotry of low expectations"; the belief that those demonstrating irrational and violent behaviour should be held to a lower standard because of their race or ethnicity. In this case, religion seems to have a hand in lowering expectations as well.

And, for some reason, asserting that everyone everywhere is equally human, and should be held to equal standards, is somehow wrong.
 
Hm. Scotch seems like an apt analogy to Islamic extremism. Of course the analogy breaks down at the point where it robs Islamic extremists of agency--which is necessary to your thesis, I think. Acts of protest only have significance, purpose, and legitimacy when their object is human beings with agency and responsibility for their actions. No sane person protests bugs, or robots, or chemical solutions.

I think it's an apt analogy for a certain mindset. There's an underlying belief that sufficient offense or outrage similarly impairs judgement and reduces human agency. That people suffering under such offense, through no fault of their own cease to be rational humans and become unthinking violent animals, and are not fully responsible for the harm they do in their rage.

Funnily enough, this only appears to apply to people of a certain colour.
 
I'm sorry you feel that way. In both cases, freedom of express is limited through threats. Just because you agree with one mechanism and disagree with the other doesn't mean they both don't exist and both do not limit free speech.

But it's not just the mechanism. The kind of speech that is being restricted is very different, and that makes all the difference. Even if we consider only government restrictions on speech, the restrictions that the US government enforces are fundamentally different than the restrictions that, say, North Korea enforces. That the methods of enforcement are superficially similar does not make these restrictions equivalent at all. Why is this not obvious to you?
 
Nope...the person responsible for the grenade should be arrested, or more preferably (according to some) be shot dead.

No one is denying that people who indulge in terrorism should be punished.

However, by your example...a grenade was thrown, and there was loss of life. In the end, was it all worth it?

I think you're confused about my argument here. I'm not excusing terrorism of any sort. The fact that some terrorism is secular doesn't make it any more moral than religious terrorism, and I'm not suggesting otherwise.
 
It is not an overreach. If muslims can stop speach they do not like with threats of violence, do you really imagine other groups will not adopt the same strategy to silence speech they oppose? You may not care about Mohammed cartoons, but if we give in on this, it will not be the end of the use of violence to suppress speech. Better to never give in at all.

http://www.aljazeera.com/news/europ...rch-sparks-violence-20131020132010789429.html
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/10/10/serbia-gay-pride-parade-riots_n_757329.html
http://www.buzzfeed.com/hunterschwarz/anti-gay-protestors-attack-pride-march-in-russia
http://mpetrelis.blogspot.com/2008/05/moldovan-gay-pride-threatened-cops.html

See, that's what happens when you allow freedom of expression. These queers clearly brought it on themselves. Yes, the violence was wrong, but the marchers knew what the response would be, and therefore share the responsibility, since they clearly incited the attackers. If they had just quietly gone about their lives instead of flaunting their queerness in people's faces, this would not have happened. In a reasonable and civilized country, the would be prevented from this sort of disturbance of the peace. The Moldovans clearly had the right idea, refusing allow the queers to incite people with their parade, and refusing to assist when the queers were understandably attacked by the people they incited.

Anti-Abortion Violence
See, that's what happens when you allow people to have non-medical abortions, etc.
 
I think some folk are confused about what extremism is. Let's be clear if someone gets angrey and upset over DRAWINGS of a guy who has been dead for 1400yrs who they-clearly-have never met,they are already a extremist. Getting that upset over drawings of someone you don't know is extreme. Its a extreme reaction,that's what extremism is. A insane,illogical reaction to something that would not worry a normal human being.
Those that are bothered by these drawings are already extremists. For flips sake they are just drawings.

And n***** is just a word. But if you stand on a street corner yelling the n-word at blacks, you're going to get some angry and upset people, and not all of them will be black. Probably not even the majority will be black. Are the people who get angry upset over the n-word extremists?
 
No, they weren't Lutherans. No, they weren't killed by police. Jesus, get some facts.

Ellison is a Muslim. Jesus, get some facts.


They were killed by rent-a-cops, not police.

Gawd, this thread started out badly.

Facts are negotiable. eg, Austrralia's SBS said the art critics were shot by "Garland police officers". So I'm assuming they are, whether they were on the city payroll at that specific time or not.

FYI. In English, irony and sarcasm are sometimes used to highlight the background to an event. It gives a richer picture.
 
We have a civility rule on this forum. It is a good rule. It promotes quality communication over insult and diatribe. The civility rule enhances free speech, it does not blunt it.

No, marplots, it does NOT enhance free speech. How can it possibly enhance free speech when it by definition restricts speech? It's positively Orwellian to suggest otherwise.

The civility rule on this forum enhances civility. This is useful, but it is only worth the price because this is a private forum. The civility rule does not prevent anyone here from expressing uncivil thoughts in other venues, and other venues are available to all of us who post here.

But the terrorists don't accept ANY valid venue for Mohammed cartoons, so you cannot appeal to civility as justification for censoring those cartoons.
 
And n***** is just a word. But if you stand on a street corner yelling the n-word at blacks, you're going to get some angry and upset people, and not all of them will be black. Probably not even the majority will be black. Are the people who get angry upset over the n-word extremists?

They are if they start shooting at the yeller. Most definitely.
 
If I published a poster about someone, claiming they were a drug-selling pedophile, put those posters up around the neighborhood where they lived, it is very likely to cause them harm.

And yet again you prove you do not understand what free speech is. The fact that I have to explain how this is not free speech means that you are probably unable or unwilling to understand.

No, I cannot answer your questions. You will have to find your own answers.
In other words, you cannot even support your own assertions.

You were the one who insisted that appeasement is necessary, yet you refuse to justify it.

You were the one who insisted I run away from harm to someplace where people are peaceful and inoffensive. So where is that place? Where in the world is a place that is peaceful and inoffensive and safe from the violent because of their inoffensiveness?

I'm betting you won't answer this, because such a place cannot possibly exist. It's a ludicrous pipe dream.

Oooh, I have just the example. Someone holds an anti-Muslim event with a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed...
Nope, you fail again. The words and pictures did not cause any harm to the terrorists; yet they chose to react with violence. The violent credo of the intolerant and emotionally stunted caused harm. Show me an example of words that are not a direct incitement to violence causing harm. Show me an example of profanity causing harm.

But shouldn't people also be willing to accept that their speech has consequences?
You keep saying that like it should mean something here. It doesn't.

This is a live issue for the courts. One of the problems in this dialogue is the insistence on some "bright line" where none exists. Trying to make the right of free speech into an ideal doesn't work in practice.
Erm, what? This makes no sense again.

How much do you support free speech? Is it an ideal you hold dearly enough to kill for? To die for? Some Muslims have just such an ideal they would kill for. Is that a club we want to belong to?
I hold it as an ideal that I would defend against attempts to repress it, with equivalent force to that used to repress it. Because if I do otherwise, I end up enslaved to someone else's conception of what I should be and how I should live. If someone tries to suppress me by financial means, I will use financial means to fight that suppression. If someone tries to suppress me by taking away a job or platform, I will find a new job or platform, or avail myself of available legal recourse to regain it. If someone tries to suppress me with violence, I will defend myself with sufficient violence to end that threat.

If you are threatened with violence over something you say, or something you are, what will you do? Will you defend yourself? Or will you grovel and beg? Appease the violent? That is the credo of cowards and collaborators; and only results in more violence. The more people who see that violence will get them what they want, the more people who will use it. Appeasement doesn't end the violence, it merely allows it to flourish unchecked. "All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."

Appeasement doesn't mollify the violent, it emboldens them. It doesn't result in a peaceful society, it results in oppression, enslavement, and genocide.

Do you consider yourself a pacifist? If not, what do you consider worth defending?

And yet, this same logic - that certain acts will provoke a violent response - is dismissed in this case as victim blaming.

Yet more false equivalencies. I'm beginning to wonder if you are actually deliberately being this dishonest, or if you are truly that confused in your thinking.
 
It is not an overreach. If muslims can stop speach they do not like with threats of violence, do you really imagine other groups will not adopt the same strategy to silence speech they oppose? You may not care about Mohammed cartoons, but if we give in on this, it will not be the end of the use of violence to suppress speech. Better to never give in at all.

I go back and forth on this, and I think I've come around to Marplot's point of view: yes, you have the right to draw whatever you want, but why would you do something that will knowingly upset people?

Let's take freedom of speech. Yes, I have the right to stand on a street corner and say horribly racist and sexist things, but can I really be surprised when I eventually get punched in the face for it? If you take a random group of people, and start insulting them in the worst way you know how, a few are going to react with more than just angry stares. That's just how people are. There's always a few weirdos in every group. So why do it in the first place?

What happens if we don't draw Mohammed cartoons? Are our freedoms being eroded? Have the terrorists won? Is Sharia Law next? I don't buy the slippery slope argument, and I don't understand this need to deliberately piss Muslims off. It's stupid. It's like going to the Westminster Dog Show and telling everyone how much dogs suck. Yeah, you have the right to do it, but why would you?

It's worse than stupid. It's counter-productive. You can't shame or insult people into changing their beliefs. They'll just dig in their heels even more. The vast majority of Muslims aren't radicalized or extremists. There are millions of Muslims living peaceful lives in America. I think they would agree that Islamic extremists are a HUGE problem in the Muslim world. Getting the extremists riled up with these cartoons is not helping the situation.
 
They are if they start shooting at the yeller. Most definitely.

I agree, but the person I responded to claimed that getting "angry and upset" over drawings is extremism. It's not. There are countless minor things that can get people angry and upset.

Yes, I might eventually get shot if I kept it up long enough, and there's no excuse for killing someone over a word, but wouldn't you wonder why I was doing it in the first place? Doesn't deliberately insulting people seem kind of dumb? Would you go to a bar in the South and start telling redneck jokes?
 
Last edited:
I go back and forth on this, and I think I've come around to Marplot's point of view: yes, you have the right to draw whatever you want, but why would you do something that will knowingly upset people?

Just to be clear; people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people...correct? Or is it that people should stop doing things that knowingly upset other people who have a reputation for violent retribution?

Should people stop saying and doing things that knowingly upset me... or do I have to engage in a campaign of price-tag violence before earning that privilege?
 
I would like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting a long-dead, murderous pedophile. I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from insulting the long-dead, murderous pedophile doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

I know right?

I mean, I'd like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting (insert any group here). I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from calling then (insert that group's insulting name here) doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom