Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I'm going to be perfectly honest and admit that I'd likely feel differently about this if it wasn't for Pamela Geller being involved. I just hate her so much.

Geller is beneath contempt,and one of the worse aspects of the attack is that it creates sympathy for her.
But that is irrevlent to the free speech isues invovled.
 
A LA hangout for the Crips is your model of society?

It is an example of where certain speech acts will be met with violence, possibly fatally. Furthermore, we all know that such situations exist, and those of us who are keen on staying alive and unharmed, will avoid such incitement.

Thankfully, I rarely come across such a dramatic example of the consequences of shooting off my mouth. But I cannot deny that such situations exist. And, I don't think anyone even tangentially familiar with current events doesn't understand the risk in publicly insulting Mohammed.
 
No, I am reacting to those who think free speech is some holy ideal, not to be constrained, and worth dying for.

Bleep blorp.

Freedom riders.

Bull Connor was just an entirely predictable and avoidable consequence of people making a fetish of some so-called "right"; those people must accept their responsibility for the violence they incited.
 
Last edited:
And,yeah, appeasement..and makes no bones, this is what some people are advocating.....always works so well.
 
The consequences of offending Christians is that some Christians will get vocally butthurt about it.

The consequences of offending Muslims is that some douchebag thug will try to kill you for it. It is exactly this difference of consequences which both clearly illustrates where the real problem lies, and also explains why it is important to protest such responses with acts of speech which are necessarily offensive to the object of our protests.

And knowing this, do you suppose the consequences of slurring Christianity and insulting Islam are the same? Plainly, recognizing the difference means I know there are different risks involved.

If drawing pictures of Mohammed is so important to me that I think it's worth risking my life - so be it. But to claim that cartoon-Mohammed is a proxy for a general right of freedom of expression is an overreach.
 
The concept of free speech is not worthy of the pedestal it's being put on. It very much is negotiable, and reasonable people see that limits are worth having. There is such a thing as hate speech and speech that offends or harms. To excuse bad behavior under some holy indulgence connected to free speech insults, not only the idea, but the speaker - absolving them of the responsibility for the consequences of their speech and removing the very meaning of that speech they relied upon.
I don't think you understand what free speech means.

"Hate speech" is a chimera, it's a conflation of two unrelated things, and as such has no business existing in a rational society.

Speech that offends is inevitable. Not matter how circumspect you are, you are going to offend someone. There have been multiple statements made by you in this thread that I could very easily take offense to if I was that sort of person. But I don't, because doing so is pointless, irrational, immature, and unproductive; and unworthy of a rational actor.

I've seen you use the "speech can cause harm" thing, but I still have not seen you produce an adequate justification for that claim except some vague assertion of "incitement", which I'm also not convinced you understand. Incitement is a direct call to others to cause harm to a third party, or engage in potentially harmful behaviour (such as rioting). Offending someone is not incitement by any rational measure.

BTW, I'm still waiting for you to answer my other questions. Are you able to answer them? So far all I have seen are vague dismissals and insults.

If a child spouts out a swear word, I do not blame the child. Neither do I frame it as a free speech issue. Why? Because the child doesn't have the same intent and meaning when speaking that an adult is assumed to have. They become blameworthy only when they use the word seeking some effect, an effect expected by societal norms. When the child is grown and blameworthy, we absolutely do attach blame to their use of words because we detect intent, intent to harm another through language.
Explain how words that do not directly demand violent action can harm. Explain how offense can harm. Explain how profanity can cause harm.

Ignoring the intent and the consequences in a general appeal to free speech fails to consider what communication is all about. Doing so taints the very ideal raised up on the pedestal. Real free speech cannot be held up so, it must grapple with human beings and our messy interactions with our fellows.
This doesn't make much sense. Could you rephrase it?

There is nothing particularly holy about the notion of free speech and we are quick to abandon it when it suits our purposes. Don't let the bad actors here hide behind the mask of some noble cause related to rights. They are not pro free speech.

That is completely irrelevant. They might not be in favour of free expression, but they still have that right; and to deny it to them is to deny it to all.

They didn't invite an imam to speak at their event.

Non sequitor. This has no meaning in this context. Free speech does not mean giving someone else a platform for their speech, it means not restricting them from speaking on their own platform. You clearly do not understand what free speech is.

They are piggy backing on a generally useful principle to further a nasty agenda and then want to escape the consequences of their behavior.

Again, nonsensical. They are speaking what they feel like speaking. They are not inciting anyone to violence. By your logic, Gay Pride parades and events should be prohibited, because they are offensive and incite people to violence. Doctors should be banned from performing elective abortions, and clinics should be closed, because they are offensive and incite people to violence.

Your very existence is offensive. Do you plan to stop existing to save the delicate sensibilities of people offended by you?

Where do you draw the line, and by what standard other than your personal preference?

Again, you don't seem to understand how speech works. Freedom of expression is one of the two most fundamental human rights, along with freedom of self-determination. Without those, all other rights fall. One cannot have freedom of religion, freedom from religion, freedom of association, or any one of the other myriad of freedoms that rely on expression.

And so far, you have not stated anywhere where you draw the line, or by what standard. What qualifies as "hate speech". What qualifies as "harm caused by speech". You assert a right to be free from offense, but by what standard to you assert it?

Stripping away all your flowery rhetoric about "reasonable civilization", the only thing you have said in this entire thread is that you oppose granting anyone you disagree with a similar freedom to speak their minds. Asserting that anyone who offends your sensibilities, or the sensibilities of some third party, should be silenced; and you declare common cause with violent extremists who wish to do so, however much you would like to deny it, by capitulating to their demands. That is not reasonable civilization, that is cowardice and petty demagoguery, which are not virtues.

You've effectively created your own religion, with it's own dogmas and tenets, and chosen to label it "reasonable civilization". Well guess what, lots of other people find that offensive. You can't have it both ways. Either you're in favour of universal equal rights, or you're a demagogue demanding that everyone else adhere strictly to your worldview. In that, you have common cause with the religious fanatics; the only difference is the specific worldview you adhere to, and how violent you are willing to be to enforce it.
 
It is an example of where certain speech acts will be met with violence, possibly fatally. Furthermore, we all know that such situations exist, and those of us who are keen on staying alive and unharmed, will avoid such incitement.

Thankfully, I rarely come across such a dramatic example of the consequences of shooting off my mouth. But I cannot deny that such situations exist. And, I don't think anyone even tangentially familiar with current events doesn't understand the risk in publicly insulting Mohammed.

Bleep blorp.

Political prisoners.

The Gulag Archipelago was just an entirely predictable and avoidable consequence of people choosing not to toe the party line in Soviet Russia (what a country!). Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn has nobody but himself to blame for the abuse he endured under that regime. Hell, it was "free speech" that got him into trouble, which makes him extra douchey in your book.
 
And,yeah, appeasement..and makes no bones, this is what some people are advocating.....always works so well.

Where does it end? They(the appeasers) think they can get off easy by getting people to stop scribbling Mahomet but if you're not bowing to Mecca and praying five times a day are you really being properly respectful of Allah and his prophet? Not to the kind of people who will shoot someone over a drawing.
 
And knowing this, do you suppose the consequences of slurring Christianity and insulting Islam are the same? Plainly, recognizing the difference means I know there are different risks involved.

If drawing pictures of Mohammed is so important to me that I think it's worth risking my life - so be it. But to claim that cartoon-Mohammed is a proxy for a general right of freedom of expression is an overreach.

It is not an overreach. If muslims can stop speach they do not like with threats of violence, do you really imagine other groups will not adopt the same strategy to silence speech they oppose? You may not care about Mohammed cartoons, but if we give in on this, it will not be the end of the use of violence to suppress speech. Better to never give in at all.
 
No, I am reacting to those who think free speech is some holy ideal, not to be constrained, and worth dying for.

Just how far should this constraint go? If someone organizes a Death to Israel rally, during which people chant Death to Israel...and someone who finds it profoundly offensive throws a live grenade at them... should the chanters be held responsible for their irresponsible incitement?
 
But to claim that cartoon-Mohammed is a proxy for a general right of freedom of expression is an overreach.

It's not a proxy, it's the thing itself. A threat of violence against it is a threat of violence against the thing itself.

An act of protest against the threat is the thing itself. An attack on that protest is an attack on the thing itself.

It's absurd to say that an act of expression is not an exercise of the freedom of expression. It's absurd to say that an attack on that act is not an attack on that freedom.
 
...

...

I had thought about this one, and I'm not entirely sure how to answer it clearly, and without causing misunderstanding. I would say that this is a significantly different situation because 1) the insult is to something that the target has no control over, specifically his genetic phenotype; and 2) the slur is still strong associated with often violent oppression based solely on the fact of that genetic phenotype.

That said, I still think offense in that case is irrational; though as I said before, understandable. Acting out violently on that offense is invalid on a roughly equal level to the Muslim extremists. However, given the recent and ongoing nature of the problem of Racism in the USA, I would say that anyone of that race confronted with such a slur would be perfectly rational to react with wariness and a certain amount of defensiveness, given the frequency with which such a slur is combined with violence or institutionalized discrimination against the target of the slur.

Did that make sense? If not, I can try again when I'm not at work, and have more time.

I don't think that the fact one is skin color and the other religion is all that essential (see below), but I appreciate the thoughtful response.

Irrational, yes; silly no. Being a (fairly orthodox) Christian, I fully understand the nature of deeply held religious beliefs, and acknowledge that my beliefs are not strictly rational. However, throughout my adult life I have been in a constant state of re-examination of my beliefs, and have changed them considerable since I was young and still accepting everything I was taught unquestioningly.


I do see it as less reasonable, since being Muslim is a choice, while being Black is not (unless you're Michael Jackson, apparently). Being Muslim does not come with the history of systematic enslavement and discrimination that being Black in America has.

I don't really view religion as being a simple choice in the sense you suggest here. A believer believes that his religion is true, that what it teaches is a correct view of the world, and that aside from truth, his own well-being in a very deep sense is at stake (salvation, in the terms of Christianity). It is not as if he can reason, "It seems that these beliefs do not fit in well in this society, so perhaps it is better if I change what I believe." To do so is to give up on what the believer views as fundamental truths about the nature of his existence and his relationship to his Creator, as well as to jeopardize his possibility of a rewarding afterlife.

So, yes, of course, at some point each religious person presumably makes a choice to believe or not (though I'm not sure how conscious that might be, so even that seems controversial), but I don't regard religion as something which can be easily changed.

And I'm not too sure how the permanence and non-voluntary nature of black skin makes the offense all that different than the offense of the true believer.

Nothing I've said about emotionalism is to say that they should not have those reactions. Offense is almost instinctive behaviour; and irrationality is one of the characteristics of being human. The problem comes when offense is upheld as a legitimate basis for taking action against the source of the offense; and especially as a legitimate justification for calling for the silencing of the offender. I experience offense multiple times a day, because of my religion, my ancestry, and my gender identity, much of it from here (I don't get out much lately). I recognize it for what it is, put it aside, and proceed with as much rationality as I am capable of. I understand that my offense is not a legitimate basis to attack others and demand they be silenced; and that my best course of action is simply to ignore them.

I certainly haven't said, broadly speaking, that those who offend Muslims shouldn't have the right to do so, or that they shouldn't do so -- not broadly. I've said that protesting the extremism of a few by deeply offending the bulk of (Sunni?) Muslims is both imprudent and immoral. It is the wanton, deliberate nature of the offense and the fact that it makes no distinction between reasonable believer and dangerous extremist that suggests to me that it is a morally dubious strategy.

However, I also recognize that a few of those who offer offense may be willing to go beyond speech and resort to violence against my person; and prepare myself to evade or defend against such violent attacks.
 
I've seen you use the "speech can cause harm" thing, but I still have not seen you produce an adequate justification for that claim except some vague assertion of "incitement", which I'm also not convinced you understand.

If I published a poster about someone, claiming they were a drug-selling pedophile, put those posters up around the neighborhood where they lived, it is very likely to cause them harm.

Incitement is a direct call to others to cause harm to a third party, or engage in potentially harmful behaviour (such as rioting). Offending someone is not incitement by any rational measure.

Incite: verb
verb: incite; 3rd person present: incites; past tense: incited; past participle: incited; gerund or present participle: inciting

encourage or stir up (violent or unlawful behavior).

BTW, I'm still waiting for you to answer my other questions. Are you able to answer them? So far all I have seen are vague dismissals and insults.

No, I cannot answer your questions. You will have to find your own answers.

Explain how words that do not directly demand violent action can harm. Explain how offense can harm. Explain how profanity can cause harm.

Oooh, I have just the example. Someone holds an anti-Muslim event with a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed...

Again, you don't seem to understand how speech works. Freedom of expression is one of the two most fundamental human rights, along with freedom of self-determination. Without those, all other rights fall. One cannot have freedom of religion, freedom from religion, freedom of association, or any one of the other myriad of freedoms that rely on expression.

But shouldn't people also be willing to accept that their speech has consequences?

And so far, you have not stated anywhere where you draw the line, or by what standard. What qualifies as "hate speech". What qualifies as "harm caused by speech". You assert a right to be free from offense, but by what standard to you assert it?

This is a live issue for the courts. One of the problems in this dialogue is the insistence on some "bright line" where none exists. Trying to make the right of free speech into an ideal doesn't work in practice.

How much do you support free speech? Is it an ideal you hold dearly enough to kill for? To die for? Some Muslims have just such an ideal they would kill for. Is that a club we want to belong to?

Anyone who is keen to die for their right of self expression has a readily available means to do so. But we don't fly in droves to ISIS-controlled territories with our posters of Mohammed having sex with a pig. Why not? Because, despite all the rhetoric here about how freedom of expression must be protected and nourished at all costs, we recognize the futility of pushing that view in ISIS territory.

And yet, this same logic - that certain acts will provoke a violent response - is dismissed in this case as victim blaming.
 
I see. So if some western women continued to wear short-shorts even after many Muslims had made it clear they found it deeply offensive to their religious identities, that's OK because those females may not be doing so primarily to offend Muslims. And if extremists were to attack such attired women in the streets, the victims wouldn't be partially responsible for the same reason. It's a question of intention.

I don't think you'll find any place I've said the victims are partially responsible for their attacks. I think that perhaps you're confusing me with someone else.


However, if following one of these attacks of outrage, other women were to sport similar gear in order to protest these attacks, that would be a different story. That could be incitement to violence.

Again, I haven't spoken in terms of incitement.

I have said that protesting Islamic extremism by deliberately offending Muslims is imprudent; that if your goal is to end extremist violence, this is a bad way to do it. I've also said that deliberately offending the bulk of Muslims for this purpose seems an insensitive and wrong thing to do.

But I haven't spoken of incitement, deserving the attack, or anything like that.
 
It is not an overreach. If muslims can stop speach they do not like with threats of violence, do you really imagine other groups will not adopt the same strategy to silence speech they oppose? You may not care about Mohammed cartoons, but if we give in on this, it will not be the end of the use of violence to suppress speech. Better to never give in at all.

We do it already. We ask courts for gag orders and injunctions. Sometimes they are granted. If such orders are violated, prison can follow. So, yeah, sometimes speech is suppressed with threats of violence.

And no, we don't see a rash of free speech suppression by way of violent threats. In fact, we sometimes see the opposite - the violence inspires others, now made attentive by the news, to duplicate the prohibited act. The strategy is not a good one if the intent is to prevent such expressions.

Where we do see wholesale suppression of free speech is in the contracts we make with each other. Everything from trade secrets to non-disclosure clauses in settlement agreements. The reason those are constrained is because we believe they will cause harm.

No one was prevented from drawing their Mohammed cartoon here, we shouldn't forget that. You can even see the results posted online. The question is whether or not the next such event will be judged important enough to take the risk. That, I cannot say. I won't be holding one myself, nor attending one.
 
Just how far should this constraint go? If someone organizes a Death to Israel rally, during which people chant Death to Israel...and someone who finds it profoundly offensive throws a live grenade at them... should the chanters be held responsible for their irresponsible incitement?

Each party has to decide for themselves whether it's worth it or not. Just as the Muslim attackers decided they were going to attack. We do not control this decision-making process, all we can do is criticize it afterward.
 
Evidence? Everything I've seen suggests that they were perfectly willing to accept the consequences and meet them head-on.

The consequences being escaped are the shouldering responsibility part and accepting some of the blame.
 
We do it already. We ask courts for gag orders and injunctions. Sometimes they are granted. If such orders are violated, prison can follow. So, yeah, sometimes speech is suppressed with threats of violence.

You're seriously comparing the enforcement of laws to terrorist threats? That's perhaps the dumbest thing you've said so far, which is an accomplishment, I have to say.

And no, we don't see a rash of free speech suppression by way of violent threats.

Not yet, because so far we aren't really giving in to terrorism. But if we do (and you seem to be advocating that we should), it's only a matter of time.

Where we do see wholesale suppression of free speech is in the contracts we make with each other. Everything from trade secrets to non-disclosure clauses in settlement agreements. The reason those are constrained is because we believe they will cause harm.

No. The reason those constraints are accepted is because they are the result of voluntary interactions. If someone entered into such a contract because of the threat of violence from one party, the contract would be void, and for good reason.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom