The concept of free speech is not worthy of the pedestal it's being put on. It very much is negotiable, and reasonable people see that limits are worth having. There is such a thing as hate speech and speech that offends or harms. To excuse bad behavior under some holy indulgence connected to free speech insults, not only the idea, but the speaker - absolving them of the responsibility for the consequences of their speech and removing the very meaning of that speech they relied upon.
I don't think you understand what free speech means.
"Hate speech" is a chimera, it's a conflation of two unrelated things, and as such has no business existing in a rational society.
Speech that offends is inevitable. Not matter how circumspect you are, you are going to offend someone. There have been multiple statements made by you in this thread that I could very easily take offense to if I was that sort of person. But I don't, because doing so is pointless, irrational, immature, and unproductive; and unworthy of a rational actor.
I've seen you use the "speech can cause harm" thing, but I still have not seen you produce an adequate justification for that claim except some vague assertion of "incitement", which I'm also not convinced you understand. Incitement is a direct call to others to cause harm to a third party, or engage in potentially harmful behaviour (such as rioting). Offending someone is not incitement by any rational measure.
BTW, I'm still waiting for you to answer my other questions. Are you able to answer them? So far all I have seen are vague dismissals and insults.
If a child spouts out a swear word, I do not blame the child. Neither do I frame it as a free speech issue. Why? Because the child doesn't have the same intent and meaning when speaking that an adult is assumed to have. They become blameworthy only when they use the word seeking some effect, an effect expected by societal norms. When the child is grown and blameworthy, we absolutely do attach blame to their use of words because we detect intent, intent to harm another through language.
Explain how words that do not directly demand violent action can harm. Explain how offense can harm. Explain how profanity can cause harm.
Ignoring the intent and the consequences in a general appeal to free speech fails to consider what communication is all about. Doing so taints the very ideal raised up on the pedestal. Real free speech cannot be held up so, it must grapple with human beings and our messy interactions with our fellows.
This doesn't make much sense. Could you rephrase it?
There is nothing particularly holy about the notion of free speech and we are quick to abandon it when it suits our purposes. Don't let the bad actors here hide behind the mask of some noble cause related to rights. They are not pro free speech.
That is completely irrelevant. They might not be in favour of free expression, but they still have that right; and to deny it to them is to deny it to all.
They didn't invite an imam to speak at their event.
Non sequitor. This has no meaning in this context. Free speech does not mean giving someone else a platform for their speech, it means not restricting them from speaking on their own platform. You clearly do not understand what free speech is.
They are piggy backing on a generally useful principle to further a nasty agenda and then want to escape the consequences of their behavior.
Again, nonsensical. They are speaking what they feel like speaking. They are not inciting anyone to violence. By your logic, Gay Pride parades and events should be prohibited, because they are offensive and incite people to violence. Doctors should be banned from performing elective abortions, and clinics should be closed, because they are offensive and incite people to violence.
Your very existence is offensive. Do you plan to stop existing to save the delicate sensibilities of people offended by you?
Where do you draw the line, and by what standard other than your personal preference?
Again, you don't seem to understand how speech works. Freedom of expression is one of the two most fundamental human rights, along with freedom of self-determination. Without those, all other rights fall. One cannot have freedom of religion, freedom
from religion, freedom of association, or any one of the other myriad of freedoms that rely on expression.
And so far, you have not stated anywhere where you draw the line, or by what standard. What qualifies as "hate speech". What qualifies as "harm caused by speech". You assert a right to be free from offense, but by what standard to you assert it?
Stripping away all your flowery rhetoric about "reasonable civilization", the only thing you have said in this entire thread is that you oppose granting anyone you disagree with a similar freedom to speak their minds. Asserting that anyone who offends your sensibilities, or the sensibilities of some third party, should be silenced; and you declare common cause with violent extremists who wish to do so, however much you would like to deny it, by capitulating to their demands. That is not reasonable civilization, that is cowardice and petty demagoguery, which are not virtues.
You've effectively created your own religion, with it's own dogmas and tenets, and chosen to label it "reasonable civilization". Well guess what, lots of other people find that offensive. You can't have it both ways. Either you're in favour of universal equal rights, or you're a demagogue demanding that everyone else adhere strictly to your worldview. In that, you have common cause with the religious fanatics; the only difference is the specific worldview you adhere to, and how violent you are willing to be to enforce it.