Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Have you read it? I'm on pg 11 and it's an argument over whether pursuing a hunger strike to its end is suicide. Maybe it gets more persuasive later on.

Keep reading. Page 11 is actually the start of his wider discussion of theological differences between Protestants and Catholics in relation to the conflict. [EDIT: It even starts with the first sentence on that page!]
 
Last edited:
Is that why you're so reluctant to criticize violent extremism in Islam? Because you're acutely aware that atheists have been just as bad (if not worse)?

You forgot the mass imprisonment and murder of various religions in China, starting with the Revolution, and escalated during the Great Leap Forward.

But that's all still tu quoque. All it demonstrates is that fundamentalist Muslims have no monopoly on ideologically-driven violence.
 
I don't see the two situations as all that similar. I tried to sketch some of the differences back in post 364.

On the one hand, women choose their clothing for many reasons (comfort, fashion, etc.). It may be that a woman chooses clothing realizing it will offend someone, but not for the sake of offense.

On the other hand, the sole reason to have a Mohammed cartoon contest is because the cartoons offend. Were it not for the offense, no contest would have occurred. The offense is the point.

These strike me as quite different situations. In terms of morality, offense-as-a-side-effect is much less dubious than offense-as-an-end (or as a means).

In terms of prudence, reasonable Muslims are not likely to learn to distrust their society when any fool can see that there are many reasons to choose clothing that have nothing to do with intention to offend Muslims, but there are no obvious reasons to have Mohammed cartoon contests aside from the capacity to offend.

I hope that clarifies the differences in the two situations.

I see. So if some western women continued to wear short-shorts even after many Muslims had made it clear they found it deeply offensive to their religious identities, that's OK because those females may not be doing so primarily to offend Muslims. And if extremists were to attack such attired women in the streets, the victims wouldn't be partially responsible for the same reason. It's a question of intention.

However, if following one of these attacks of outrage, other women were to sport similar gear in order to protest these attacks, that would be a different story. That could be incitement to violence.
 
I read your post, but it was irrelevant to my point.

Yes, Geller is a bad person.

But "whoop-di-do" is not an appropriate response to correction. You can dispute the correction, you can defend the error as insignificant. But you should not react as if the allegation of error itself is something inconsequential.
The allegation is contrived in as much as it's a smoke screen, it's insignificant in that she has spouted equivalent anti-Obama birther nonsense, and I'm not convinced it's true that she never said it, given she quoted and supported the person's views who supposedly did say it.

Who supposedly said it that she was merely quoting, has she ever revealed the name, and how were her blog readers told what she did and didn't believe from the person she quoted? She changed the original blog entry so no one can now check what was actually said at the time. How is denying it ONLY after the backlash evidence she never believed it?
 
Last edited:
The concept of free speech is not worthy of the pedestal it's being put on. It very much is negotiable, and reasonable people see that limits are worth having. There is such a thing as hate speech and speech that offends or harms. To excuse bad behavior under some holy indulgence connected to free speech insults, not only the idea, but the speaker - absolving them of the responsibility for the consequences of their speech and removing the very meaning of that speech they relied upon.

If a child spouts out a swear word, I do not blame the child. Neither do I frame it as a free speech issue. Why? Because the child doesn't have the same intent and meaning when speaking that an adult is assumed to have. They become blameworthy only when they use the word seeking some effect, an effect expected by societal norms. When the child is grown and blameworthy, we absolutely do attach blame to their use of words because we detect intent, intent to harm another through language.

Ignoring the intent and the consequences in a general appeal to free speech fails to consider what communication is all about. Doing so taints the very ideal raised up on the pedestal. Real free speech cannot be held up so, it must grapple with human beings and our messy interactions with our fellows.

There is nothing particularly holy about the notion of free speech and we are quick to abandon it when it suits our purposes. Don't let the bad actors here hide behind the mask of some noble cause related to rights. They are not pro free speech. They didn't invite an imam to speak at their event. They are piggy backing on a generally useful principle to further a nasty agenda and then want to escape the consequences of their behavior.
 
Last edited:
And, again, if the offense were limited in its effect to the extremists, then I'd have no problem with it at all, but it's not. It serves to alienate decent, reasonable Muslims for no particularly worthy reason in my opinion.

Again, I fully disagree. A reasonable Muslim should realize and accept that strictures that apply to them do not apply to non-believers. I'm perfectly capable of being friends with people who ridicule my faith, because I recognize that it's an irrational belief they're ridiculing, and not me; because it is not reasonable for me to demand that they share my beliefs, or adhere to the strictures my beliefs impose upon me. They don't think significantly less of me as a person because I have those beliefs, and I don't think significantly less of them because they ridicule them. I could hope they'd be nicer about it; but they have their reasons, and I don't see that making an issue about it is either rational or productive.
 
Because you only control your own actions. Just as the terrorist is responsible for her actions, so too are you responsible for yours.

So why don't I have a responsibility to not draw pictures of Buddha, or Jesus, or Christopher Hitchens?
 
Because you only control your own actions. Just as the terrorist is responsible for her actions, so too are you responsible for yours.

Which puts control on what is considered irresponsible speech in the hands of those willing and able to dole out brutality in response to speech they consider to be blasphemous.
 
Ofcourse it's free...so are the results...invariably violence in this case. Look, I am not denying that religious fundamentalism...particularly Islamic fundamentalism is a big issue. Atleast with Hindu fundamentalism, it is llargely localised and people outside India haven't had to experience it.

The issue of fundamentalism has to be addressed in a more sane manner. I think one way is for the Islamic moderates to stop pussyfooting and whining about how they cannot be held collectively responsible for the actions of terrorists. The fact is that their dithering and claiming the "no true scotsman" fallacy actually feeds the problem.
But really, what was the agenda of the organisers behind this little exercise?

I'm more concerned with the agenda of the shooters.
 
So why don't I have a responsibility to not draw pictures of Buddha, or Jesus, or Christopher Hitchens?

It's no different at all. You are as free to draw those pictures as pictures of Mohammed. However, if you are wise, you also understand that while you are free to do any of these things, the consequences of doing so may be different.

The consequences of your actions are not under your control. This is a property of the world, not our wish for the world to be one preferred way. The things you list are different because they are different. I may very well wish to drink a gallon of scotch, but you would rightly think me foolish if I wondered, "If I can drink a gallon of milk without ill effect, why will drinking a gallon of scotch kill me?"
 
This stunt was none of those things though. It was designed to get this response.

Satire is there to make you think.

What these morons did makes others ACT out. It just happens that they found even bigger idiots who like to kill when their delicate sensibilities are harmed.

It's well know that Muslims have poor impulse control, right?
 
I'm going to be perfectly honest and admit that I'd likely feel differently about this if it wasn't for Pamela Geller being involved. I just hate her so much.
 
Yes, but not today, not in Texas.

So the usual bomb throwers(Pamela Geller, Robert Spencer and Geert Wilders) held a little art exhibit and cartoon contest to "celebrate free speech" and antagonize adherents of the ROP.

So two men, Lutherans presumably, drove up, got out and started shooting. They're dead. Killed by police. A security guard was wounded but has been released from hospital.

Their car is to be detonated by the bomb squad.

http://dfw.cbslocal.com/2015/05/03/breaking-shooting-in-garland/


One more piece of evidence, among many others, that islam needs a reformation (better said transformation)* now. Not later. Involving important theological, educational and institutional aspects of islam.

Exposing muslims to a rational criticism of islam is crucial here (how on Earth can one believe that merely complying to the requirements of sharia regarding non-muslims under muslim rule, e.g. is absolutely forbidden to criticize islam and Muhammad, can solve something on long run?).

At least a quranic criticism on a par with biblical criticism is a must (Muhammad the 'desert warrior', hearing voices coming entirely from his head / finite beings' academic interpretation is one of my preferred here by the way), muslims should be made aware that there is solid justification for critical views at the academic level and that only rational argument is the only defence allowed.

At the beginning one should expect an increased hostility from the part of muslims no doubt but on the long run it is much more probable that the long awaited muslim counterpart of liberal Christianity will finally be born and even becoming mainstream. Capable to maintain this status even if muslims are majorities worldwide. Anyways no matter what muslims do we will have at least a more saner world (in this problem at least for indeed humans are very often irrational in many others), keeping the doors wide open for a much better world.

I'm afraid that merely hoping that a more westernized islam will somehow become the norm, also stable on long run even if muslims become large majorities, via efforts coming entirely from inside is at best wishful thinking. Indeed if nothing changes in important ways it is much more probable from existing evidence that the slightest problems inside the western societies will push even more toward the past.

But if only small problems can push so many muslims toward the chimera of 'returning to the pure islam of Muhammad and the first generations of muslims' I cannot imagine what will happen if more serious societal problem appear...The 'rabbit hole' is much more deeper than it is accepted today openly (leading ultimately to the very problematic basics of islam), denying the obvious solves, how else, nothing.


*Ayaan Hirsi Ali's proposals deserve to be mentioned here, the most important things to be 'reformed' are:

1. Muhammad’s semi-divine and infallible status along with the literalist reading of the Qur’an, particularly those parts that were revealed in Medina;
2. The investment in life after death instead of life before death;
3. Sharia, the body of legislation derived from the Qur’an, the hadith, and the rest of Islamic jurisprudence;
4. The practice of empowering individuals to enforce Islamic law by commanding right and forbidding wrong;
5. The imperative to wage jihad, or holy war.
 
Last edited:
The concept of free speech is not worthy of the pedestal it's being put on. It very much is negotiable, and reasonable people see that limits are worth having. There is such a thing as hate speech and speech that offends or harms. To excuse bad behavior under some holy indulgence connected to free speech insults, not only the idea, but the speaker - absolving them of the responsibility for the consequences of their speech and removing the very meaning of that speech they relied upon.

Are you talking about anti-hate speech legislation...or something else?
 
Keep reading. Page 11 is actually the start of his wider discussion of theological differences between Protestants and Catholics in relation to the conflict. [EDIT: It even starts with the first sentence on that page!]

Finished it. I was on page 11 of the pdf which is page 9 of the paper proper.

The theological differences he points to are Protestants don't trust Catholics to deal fairly thinking they're two-faced silver tongued snakes who never say what they mean. Cs can't work with Ps because of the P's Calvinist "There's Right And There's Wrong" ethos. These things are not what the fighting was about. These are only things standing in the way of ending the fighting.


ETA-Also meant to say, Thank you for bringing the paper to my attention. It was an interesting read. Merci!
 
Last edited:
It's not an excuse, it's a reality.

Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?

But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.

Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.

A LA hangout for the Crips is your model of society?
 
The concept of free speech is not worthy of the pedestal it's being put on. It very much is negotiable, and reasonable people see that limits are worth having. There is such a thing as hate speech and speech that offends or harms. To excuse bad behavior under some holy indulgence connected to free speech insults, not only the idea, but the speaker - absolving them of the responsibility for the consequences of their speech and removing the very meaning of that speech they relied upon.

If a child spouts out a swear word, I do not blame the child. Neither do I frame it as a free speech issue. Why? Because the child doesn't have the same intent and meaning when speaking that an adult is assumed to have. They become blameworthy only when they use the word seeking some effect, an effect expected by societal norms. When the child is grown and blameworthy, we absolutely do attach blame to their use of words because we detect intent, intent to harm another through language.

Ignoring the intent and the consequences in a general appeal to free speech fails to consider what communication is all about. Doing so taints the very ideal raised up on the pedestal. Real free speech cannot be held up so, it must grapple with human beings and our messy interactions with our fellows.

There is nothing particularly holy about the notion of free speech and we are quick to abandon it when it suits our purposes. Don't let the bad actors here hide behind the mask of some noble cause related to rights. They are not pro free speech. They didn't invite an imam to speak at their event. They are piggy backing on a generally useful principle to further a nasty agenda and then want to escape the consequences of their behavior.

And one of the consequences is that they get shot and killed?
 
It's no different at all. You are as free to draw those pictures as pictures of Mohammed. However, if you are wise, you also understand that while you are free to do any of these things, the consequences of doing so may be different.

That is, indeed, the very point.

The consequences of offending Christians is that some Christians will get vocally butthurt about it.

The consequences of offending Muslims is that some douchebag thug will try to kill you for it. It is exactly this difference of consequences which both clearly illustrates where the real problem lies, and also explains why it is important to protest such responses with acts of speech which are necessarily offensive to the object of our protests.

The consequences of your actions are not under your control. This is a property of the world, not our wish for the world to be one preferred way. The things you list are different because they are different. I may very well wish to drink a gallon of scotch, but you would rightly think me foolish if I wondered, "If I can drink a gallon of milk without ill effect, why will drinking a gallon of scotch kill me?"
Milk: A healthful and nutritious supplement for your body that even so will harm you if taken in extreme quantities.

Scotch: An intoxicating and judgement-impairing poison that causes pleasant sensations in some and causes harm in all who partake of even small quantities. The harm is recoverable when taken in small quantities, but in large quantities it kills, and that much more readily than milk ever could.

Hm. Scotch seems like an apt analogy to Islamic extremism. Of course the analogy breaks down at the point where it robs Islamic extremists of agency--which is necessary to your thesis, I think. Acts of protest only have significance, purpose, and legitimacy when their object is human beings with agency and responsibility for their actions. No sane person protests bugs, or robots, or chemical solutions.
 
I'm going to be perfectly honest and admit that I'd likely feel differently about this if it wasn't for Pamela Geller being involved. I just hate her so much.

Why is it OK for you to hate her but it's not OK for her to hate Muslims?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom