Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Sad story. Tell it to Reader's Digest. Meanwhile I don't have to reach back even as far as the Middle Ages, to find out that atheists have also been douchebag mass-murderers from time to time:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dechristianisation_of_France_during_the_French_Revolution
The programme of dechristianization waged against Catholicism, and eventually against all forms of Christianity, included: ... the enactment of a law on October 21, 1793 making all nonjuring priests and all persons who harboured them liable to death on sight.

The climax was reached with the celebration of the goddess "Reason" in Notre Dame Cathedral on 10 November 1793. The dechristianization campaign can be seen as the logical extension of the materialist philosophies of some leaders of the enlightenment.
[...]

Under threat of death, imprisonment, military conscription, and loss of income, about twenty thousand constitutional priests were forced to abdicate and hand over their letters of ordination, and six thousand to nine thousand of them agreed or were coerced to marry... By the end of the decade, approximately thirty thousand priests had been forced to leave France, and others who did not leave were executed. Most French parishes were left without the services of a priest and deprived of the sacraments. Any non-juring priest faced the guillotine or deportation to French Guiana.​

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_Soviet_Union

... Thus the USSR became the first state to have, as an ideological objective, the elimination of religion[2] and its replacement with universal atheism. The communist regime confiscated religious property, ridiculed religion, harassed believers, and propagated atheism in schools.

[...]

Marxist–Leninist atheism has consistently advocated the control, suppression, and elimination of religion. Within about a year of the revolution, the state expropriated all church property, including the churches themselves, and in the period from 1922 to 1926, 28 Russian Orthodox bishops and more than 1,200 priests were killed. Many more were persecuted.
​

Is that why you're so reluctant to criticize violent extremism in Islam? Because you're acutely aware that atheists have been just as bad (if not worse)?

If you think I have been reluctant to criticise Islamic Extremism,check my posting history.
My whole point is that Christians have, on occasion, been just as bad and I don;t like Christian Fundies puttin on airs about it.
And to make this into a religious war between Christainity and Islam..which a number of Christian fundies are trying to do..would be a disaster.
 
Should a-holes have free speech rights, or not? Would those be the same rights that you expect for yourself?

Here's my own answer:

Of course they should have free speech rights. And they are the same rights I expect for myself. However, it doesn't make them not a-holes.
 
My whole point is that Christians have, on occasion, been just as bad and I don;t like Christian Fundies puttin on airs about it.
And to make this into a religious war between Christainity and Islam..which a number of Christian fundies are trying to do..would be a disaster.

This seems like something of a straw man. Nobody in this thread is arguing on the basis of Christianity vs. Islam. Did you mean to post your attack on such arguments in a different thread? Perhaps on a different forum entirely?
 
Outside of Northern Ireland, that is.

No. The Northern Ireland violence was not religious. It was political. The correlation between political sides and religious affiliation is a historical artifact, but it's coincidental to the conflict, not a part of it. There are no religious doctrinal issues or differences involved in the dispute.
 
No. The Northern Ireland violence was not religious. It was political. The correlation between political sides and religious affiliation is a historical artifact, but it's coincidental to the conflict, not a part of it. There are no religious doctrinal issues or differences involved in the dispute.

Calling them Nationalists and Unionists would be more accurate since that's what they were fighting over and not Transubstantiation.
 
And, as previously pointed out, this is not true. Another even better reason to hold such a contest is as a protest; to demonstrate to extremists, and their apologists and supporters, that we refuse to be intimidated into curtailing our freedom of expression to mollify some violent extremists.

What better way to protest attempts to curtail freedom than engaging in precisely those behaviours they wish to curtail? That is the entire point of protests, whether its for freedom of speech, freedom of association, freedom to be openly GLBT, freedom to sit in the front of the bus alongside whites, or any number of other civil rights.

I understand that, and wasn't saying that the offense was the sole end of the contest, but rather that it was the means to the end. That is, were it not for the offense caused, the act of drawing Mohammed wouldn't be a protest at all.

The offense is an intrinsic part of the motivation, not a merely regrettable side effect.

And, again, if the offense were limited in its effect to the extremists, then I'd have no problem with it at all, but it's not. It serves to alienate decent, reasonable Muslims for no particularly worthy reason in my opinion.

Again, have a gander at the question I posted way back in #136. It's not quite directed to the act of protest as such, but close enough. Is that the sort of explanation you would be willing to give a close Muslim friend who finds the abuse of his religious beliefs offensive?
 
I understand that, and wasn't saying that the offense was the sole end of the contest, but rather that it was the means to the end. That is, were it not for the offense caused, the act of drawing Mohammed wouldn't be a protest at all.

The offense is an intrinsic part of the motivation, not a merely regrettable side effect.

And, again, if the offense were limited in its effect to the extremists, then I'd have no problem with it at all, but it's not. It serves to alienate decent, reasonable Muslims for no particularly worthy reason in my opinion.

Again, have a gander at the question I posted way back in #136. It's not quite directed to the act of protest as such, but close enough. Is that the sort of explanation you would be willing to give a close Muslim friend who finds the abuse of his religious beliefs offensive?

Putting aside the fact that if I were put in similar circumstances as the moderate friend, and I have been actually, that I would not take offense, a burden placed on others to adhere to one's arbitrary religious beliefs is not at all reasonable. And failure to so adhere cannot reasonably be considered "abuse." If observant Jews want to refrain from eating pork or shellfish or mixing meat and milk, that's their own business. But it would be completely unreasonable of them to expect, let alone demand, that others adhere to the same restrictions. Likewise, if Muslims want to refrain from drawing a picture of their prophet, that's their business. But extending that rule to non-Muslims is simply unreasonable. It is more than just unreasonable. It's offensive.
 
Have you read it? I'm on pg 11 and it's an argument over whether pursuing a hunger strike to its end is suicide. Maybe it gets more persuasive later on.
 
That's the phrasing the paper's author uses.

He also says that "no one has seriously suggested that theological differences are the root cause of our problems". (Perhaps he hadn't read your posts?)

Anyhow, that is different to Islamists, where theology (whether half baked or not) is crucial to their behavior and antipathy to the west.
 
Putting aside the fact that if I were put in similar circumstances as the moderate friend, and I have been actually, that I would not take offense, a burden placed on others to adhere to one's arbitrary religious beliefs is not at all reasonable. And failure to so adhere cannot reasonably be considered "abuse." If observant Jews want to refrain from eating pork or shellfish or mixing meat and milk, that's their own business. But it would be completely unreasonable of them to expect, let alone demand, that others adhere to the same restrictions. Likewise, if Muslims want to refrain from drawing a picture of their prophet, that's their business. But extending that rule to non-Muslims is simply unreasonable. It is more than just unreasonable. It's offensive.

Reasonable folk can disagree, I suppose, but I can't get worked up over the fact that others are offended by drawings of the Prophet, and I can sympathize them when so many folks draw pictures of the Prophet only to protest the fact that others don't want them to.

Rather like burning flags to protest the fact that others get upset when you burn flags and for no other reason. (Mind you, I would feel differently if the issue was a law against flag burning and not mere sensitivities.)
 
Why is the responsibility of my speech proportional to the actions of other people?

Because you only control your own actions. Just as the terrorist is responsible for her actions, so too are you responsible for yours.
 
Let me ask you this: I tend to think that the reason it is wrong to call black people by a racial slur is that it is deeply offensive to them and given the history of the term (and also the fact that I am white), this offense is perfectly reasonable. Do you agree with this assessment?
...

...

I had thought about this one, and I'm not entirely sure how to answer it clearly, and without causing misunderstanding. I would say that this is a significantly different situation because 1) the insult is to something that the target has no control over, specifically his genetic phenotype; and 2) the slur is still strong associated with often violent oppression based solely on the fact of that genetic phenotype.

That said, I still think offense in that case is irrational; though as I said before, understandable. Acting out violently on that offense is invalid on a roughly equal level to the Muslim extremists. However, given the recent and ongoing nature of the problem of Racism in the USA, I would say that anyone of that race confronted with such a slur would be perfectly rational to react with wariness and a certain amount of defensiveness, given the frequency with which such a slur is combined with violence or institutionalized discrimination against the target of the slur.

Did that make sense? If not, I can try again when I'm not at work, and have more time.

Now, of course, you may find belief in Islam to be silly or irrational, but a religious belief can be deeply held, providing significant influences to one's values, norms, beliefs and so on.
Irrational, yes; silly no. Being a (fairly orthodox) Christian, I fully understand the nature of deeply held religious beliefs, and acknowledge that my beliefs are not strictly rational. However, throughout my adult life I have been in a constant state of re-examination of my beliefs, and have changed them considerable since I was young and still accepting everything I was taught unquestioningly.

And at least some Muslims take deep offense (and believe that offense to be justified and reasonable, on the basis of their faith) at insults of the Prophet. And I don't see that offense as any less reasonable, from the perspective of a Muslim, than the offense taken by a black American when confronted with racial epithets.
I do see it as less reasonable, since being Muslim is a choice, while being Black is not (unless you're Michael Jackson, apparently). Being Muslim does not come with the history of systematic enslavement and discrimination that being Black in America has.

Nothing I've said about emotionalism is to say that they should not have those reactions. Offense is almost instinctive behaviour; and irrationality is one of the characteristics of being human. The problem comes when offense is upheld as a legitimate basis for taking action against the source of the offense; and especially as a legitimate justification for calling for the silencing of the offender. I experience offense multiple times a day, because of my religion, my ancestry, and my gender identity, much of it from here (I don't get out much lately). I recognize it for what it is, put it aside, and proceed with as much rationality as I am capable of. I understand that my offense is not a legitimate basis to attack others and demand they be silenced; and that my best course of action is simply to ignore them.

However, I also recognize that a few of those who offer offense may be willing to go beyond speech and resort to violence against my person; and prepare myself to evade or defend against such violent attacks.
 
I think that there is a moral distinction in the manner in which offense is caused.

Sometimes, one causes an offense as an unintended, though foreseeable, side effect of his actions. For instance, when we discuss Islam, we may well offend some Muslims, maybe even in ways we can foresee, but our intention is to discuss the issue, not to cause offense.

On the other hand, sometimes we cause offense intentionally, either because the offense is the end we desire (we just want to piss off somebody) or because it is a means to our end (we want to piss off someone so they react and others can see their reaction, or we want to piss off Muslims so they become used to the degradation and stop reacting).

I think that when the offense is itself the end pursued, the action is least defensible. Similarly, when causing offense is the means, it is less defensible than the case in which causing offense is a side effect of an otherwise unobjectionable act.

I don't know exactly what this competition was about, but my guess is that it was aiming for offense either as a means or an end, whereas examples involving this forum imagine the offense as a foreseeable side effect.

(These distinctions are commonly introduced in Catholic moral teachings as the doctrine of double effect, but one need not buy the context of their use in theology to conclude that there is a real moral difference to be considered here.)

Freedom of Speech also means that offenders can (and should) be publicly identified as irresponsible morons or flaming posterior orifices as the case may be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom