Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

ANd I am taking bets as to how long until Alex Jones starts screaming "False Flag" about this attack.
 
I think one of the major (though extremely subtle) challenges of this conversation is the conflation of insult and offense. Yes, Muslims will obviously take offense at images of Mohammad, but said images are not insults directed at Muslims (in the same way a hook-nosed caricature demeans Jews). One could say the same thing about Christians and Piss Christ.

Honestly, I don't know if there's an easy way to walk the tightrope between the two. Maybe I'm naive to think most people will be able to refrain from overreaction, and contemplate the difference.

I certainly don't disagree with any of that. I'm trying to actually get around that by focusing on the result rather than the intent (an in-the-eye-of-the-beholder thing) - could someone who is ostensibly not in the "target group", as it were, nevertheless honestly and legitimately think and feel that they were being targeted?

Here's one fun idea: International Draw Mohammad In A Nice Way Day. It's the day where you draw Mohammad, but in a way that is definitely not insulting. Moderates probably wouldn't mind, and the extremists will stand out more than ever.

Muslim Girl magazine actually suggested something like this (although not exactly) in response to Geller's event.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. "Eroding" is too strong. Images of Mohammed weren't even a "thing" a couple of decades ago. They've only become worth drawing because of the reaction they get.

Not drawing Mohammed is equivalent to not using the n-word. We aren't suffering an erosion of our free speech because of it - we find other ways to say what we want. So too with the Mohammed pictures - there are other ways to express ideas and not drawing cartoons of Mohammed doesn't damage our overall free speech rights one bit.

I am not allowed to use profanity on this forum. I do not feel my ability to express myself is limited by this restriction. If images of Mohammed were prohibited here, I would have even less cause to object to that.

But not all people feel that way. I for one fell that my expression is limited by this fact in fact a few years back i created a thread to this very effect.
 
This.
Freedom of Speech is NOT negotiable.

Totally right. I don't understand why some people don't get that.
Where I live there is a few Muslims who I discuss matters of history with. One of them ,like me has a interest in the military history of the Islamic conquest and in the castles and forts of Moorish Spain. We regularly loan each other books and so forth and I make sure(I think he does to)not to talk about modern affairs with him. Its like we both know this is something we would fall out over. I put human decency first,he puts a musty old book first.
Its tragic,I mean its 2015. At basics we are irreconcilably different because he believe a late sixth century meccan merchant holds the keys to human behavior and the cosmos and I believe in reason,modern science and basic equality.
 
True, but given their history,Christians have no business pointing fingers at Muslims for using violence to advance their religons.
Yes, Islam is much worse today then Christiney is for having an extermists problem, but there is nothing inherent in Islam that makes it worse then Christianity. The mess we have now is due to historiacal events.
For much of the Middle Ages,Islam was a lot more tolerent then Christianity. Times have changed.

Sad story. Tell it to Reader's Digest. Meanwhile I don't have to reach back even as far as the Middle Ages, to find out that atheists have also been douchebag mass-murderers from time to time:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dechristianisation_of_France_during_the_French_Revolution
The programme of dechristianization waged against Catholicism, and eventually against all forms of Christianity, included: ... the enactment of a law on October 21, 1793 making all nonjuring priests and all persons who harboured them liable to death on sight.

The climax was reached with the celebration of the goddess "Reason" in Notre Dame Cathedral on 10 November 1793. The dechristianization campaign can be seen as the logical extension of the materialist philosophies of some leaders of the enlightenment.
[...]

Under threat of death, imprisonment, military conscription, and loss of income, about twenty thousand constitutional priests were forced to abdicate and hand over their letters of ordination, and six thousand to nine thousand of them agreed or were coerced to marry... By the end of the decade, approximately thirty thousand priests had been forced to leave France, and others who did not leave were executed. Most French parishes were left without the services of a priest and deprived of the sacraments. Any non-juring priest faced the guillotine or deportation to French Guiana.​

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_Soviet_Union

... Thus the USSR became the first state to have, as an ideological objective, the elimination of religion[2] and its replacement with universal atheism. The communist regime confiscated religious property, ridiculed religion, harassed believers, and propagated atheism in schools.

[...]

Marxist–Leninist atheism has consistently advocated the control, suppression, and elimination of religion. Within about a year of the revolution, the state expropriated all church property, including the churches themselves, and in the period from 1922 to 1926, 28 Russian Orthodox bishops and more than 1,200 priests were killed. Many more were persecuted.
​

Is that why you're so reluctant to criticize violent extremism in Islam? Because you're acutely aware that atheists have been just as bad (if not worse)?
 
Last edited:
If you say your goal is to offend only the extremists and not all the other people who don't share the extremists' views, how are the non-extremists going to tell?

A better question is, "Why should it matter what the non-extremists feel about it?"

I'm not going to stop calling anti-vaxxers and alt.med believers dangerous idiots, even though some of them are simply confused, lacking understanding of what they're doing; because they're still dangerous idiots. They have the opportunity to investigate and use critical thinking to evaluate claims like the rest of us.

If moderate Muslims, or Christians, or Ba'ha'i are offended by something someone says or draws, the reasonable reaction would be at worst to say "I guess those people causing offense are just jackasses, and not worth my time or attention," and ignore them from there. (As a Christian, and as a GLBT person, this is something I deal with every single day, often several times a day, in many places and context.) At best, one can hope that they examine their offense, and the belief system that causes it.

If being offended causes them to say "Gee, you know, maybe the fanatical extremists are right, and I should go out and murder the infidels too," then they never were truly moderates, just extremists who were finally pulled out of their sheltered lives and confronted with the real world.

Again, it only appears to be Muslims that people are worried about offending. I have not yet seen similar concern being paid to offending moderate Christians.
 
A better question is, "Why should it matter what the non-extremists feel about it?"

Because being a dick without need or purpose helps no one and accomplishes nothing.

Again, it only appears to be Muslims that people are worried about offending. I have not yet seen similar concern being paid to offending moderate Christians.

Did you see my link above?
 
Last edited:
You're right.
If a religious group is offended by what we post here on this forum and initiates a DDOS attack, shutting down ISF, we pretty much asked for it to happen. (Said none of you after it happened)
There are many ways of dealing with DDOS. It is not the apocalypse you imagine. Unless icerat is a total noob (which he obviously is not) any DDOS would be dealt with in short order.
 

No, you haven't. That thread was a joke from the start. It's clear from a cursory examnination that thread that no one is seriously considering whether they are offending Catholics, or if they are, it's only in a highly qualified way. Nothing like what people here are suggesting with regard to Muslims.

But then, it's been a very long time since Catholics went around killing people for disagreeing with them.
 
On the other hand, the sole reason to have a Mohammed cartoon contest is because the cartoons offend. Were it not for the offense, no contest would have occurred. The offense is the point.

And, as previously pointed out, this is not true. Another even better reason to hold such a contest is as a protest; to demonstrate to extremists, and their apologists and supporters, that we refuse to be intimidated into curtailing our freedom of expression to mollify some violent extremists.

What better way to protest attempts to curtail freedom than engaging in precisely those behaviours they wish to curtail? That is the entire point of protests, whether its for freedom of speech, freedom of association, freedom to be openly GLBT, freedom to sit in the front of the bus alongside whites, or any number of other civil rights.
 
No, you haven't. That thread was a joke from the start. It's clear from a cursory examnination that thread that no one is seriously considering whether they are offending Catholics, or if they are, it's only in a highly qualified way.

No, it was pretty clear that the OP of that thread was intentionally wanting to be needlessly and deliberately inflammatory to Catholics, and I flat-out told him so several times in that thread.

But suit yourself, I suppose.
 
Should a-holes have free speech rights, or not? Would those be the same rights that you expect for yourself?

Yes.
In fact, for a number of years I was under oath to preserve,protect and defend the rights of these Alpha Hotels against all enemies,foreign and domestic. It the kind of thing you hold you nose at but do anyway because the instant you begin declaring some opinions unworthy of protection you have pretty much lost the battle for free speech;it's just a matter of how long until you lose it entirely.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom