Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

In this case, yes, it was the only solution.

The other choices are much worse. We can go with a heavier hand at policing these people, Simpson was on probation for lying to the FBI and was tweeting about moojahedeen and martyrdumb using #texasattack in the hours leading up to their spectacular failure and Soofi was a Pakistani immigrant but that will lead to the same predictable cries of Racism! and Islamophobia! and Xenophobia! that the usual suspects always trot out.

Or we can put the scribblers in jail for not sufficiently respecting Mahomet.

The best choice of bad choices is to simply live and let live and shoot back at those who can't.
 
True, but given their history,Christians have no business pointing fingers at Muslims for using violence to advance their religons.
Yes, Islam is much worse today then Christiney is for having an extermists problem, but there is nothing inherent in Islam that makes it worse then Christianity. The mess we have now is due to historiacal events.
For much of the Middle Ages,Islam was a lot more tolerent then Christianity. Times have changed.

Yeah, a lot of what you just said simply isn't true.
 
I think some folk are confused about what extremism is. Let's be clear if someone gets angrey and upset over DRAWINGS of a guy who has been dead for 1400yrs who they-clearly-have never met,they are already a extremist. Getting that upset over drawings of someone you don't know is extreme. Its a extreme reaction,that's what extremism is. A insane,illogical reaction to something that would not worry a normal human being.
Those that are bothered by these drawings are already extremists. For flips sake they are just drawings.
 
True, but given their history,Christians have no business pointing fingers at Muslims for using violence to advance their religons.
Yes, Islam is much worse today then Christiney is for having an extermists problem, but there is nothing inherent in Islam that makes it worse then Christianity. The mess we have now is due to historiacal events.
For much of the Middle Ages,Islam was a lot more tolerent then Christianity. Times have changed.
There is a logical falicy there...tu something.or another...
 
To be clear: Do you consider caricatures of Mohammad (just Mohammad, not all Muslims or even Muslims in general) to be along the same line as these other examples?

Only in the sense that, if a non-Islamist, non-jihadist Muslim was looking at it, would she be able to tell that whatever message it was trying to convey was being targeted at Islamists or jihadists, and not at her?
 
I would not say it is moral or prudent to cause offense in order to quell extremist attacks.

I would, however, say that it can be moral and prudent to cause offense as an act of protest against extremists who use threats of violence as a tool to quell the exercise of human rights.

Protest is by nature offensive to some, but it is still legitimate. I think that the question of whether it is prudent to confront those who threaten you with violence is one that should be left up to each of us individually. I also think that certainly in a society of free people, the choice to protest threats of violence, with acts of speech, should be protected by our government and upheld by our fellow citizens.

The moral issue is complex, but as I see it, the fact that you alienate, offend and anger a much larger group of perfectly innocent Muslims in order to piss off the extremists makes me doubt that it is morally acceptable.

As far as prudence, I'm a bit confused by your claim.

Prudence is generally gauged in terms of furthering one's ends: does the action put me in a better position or a worse? You admit that purposely offending Muslims is ineffective at quelling the violence. I think it increases the potential for violence. What good do you think it does? In what sense is it prudent?

I'm not sure what you mean by "upheld by citizens". I'd prefer it if Geller didn't say the things she says (and I'd prefer she doesn't believe what she says either), and I think criticizing what she says is appropriate. Does that mean I'm not "upholding" her speech rights?
 
Perfect outcome. We need more incidents like this to enflame tensions, solidify and renew divisions, and undermine the multicultural "one world, borders are oppressive, man!" project which destroys unique peoples and cultures by inundating them with whoever can breed most irresponsibly.

If Muslims and Africans and Mexicans and whoever else cannot keep their reproduction at sustainable levels, and cannot get their own (considerable) lands and nations in order, the solution is not to let them flood more successful societies with their excess humanity.

There should be about five Muslims per nation in the west, as visiting professors etc.

This idea that everyone has a right to live in the west, and boats full of worthless eaters should be admitted to Italy and the EU generally, and that nations are passé and genetics are interchangeable can have only one result: a barbaric, brown, backward, Muslim planet.

Quite enough of this globe already fits that description.

No people should be forced into a breeding competition or a cultural tug of war within their own borders.

Is this from a lost chapter of The Turner Diaries?
 
But are they offending moderate Moslems? Is the prohibition observed by all billion+ Moslems worldwide or only a sect here or a schism there? And within them how many are really hardline about it? You know there are Catholics that eat meat on Fridays and just say, whatever.
 
You're suggesting people avoid purposely offending Muslims in order to quell extremist attacks aimed at offensive expression. Dress is a form of expression. Under the right circumstances, women dressed in shorts might be considered deliberate religious offense. In that situation, women should avoid wearing shorts in order to insure not offending violent extremists.

I don't see the two situations as all that similar. I tried to sketch some of the differences back in post 364.

On the one hand, women choose their clothing for many reasons (comfort, fashion, etc.). It may be that a woman chooses clothing realizing it will offend someone, but not for the sake of offense.

On the other hand, the sole reason to have a Mohammed cartoon contest is because the cartoons offend. Were it not for the offense, no contest would have occurred. The offense is the point.

These strike me as quite different situations. In terms of morality, offense-as-a-side-effect is much less dubious than offense-as-an-end (or as a means).

In terms of prudence, reasonable Muslims are not likely to learn to distrust their society when any fool can see that there are many reasons to choose clothing that have nothing to do with intention to offend Muslims, but there are no obvious reasons to have Mohammed cartoon contests aside from the capacity to offend.

I hope that clarifies the differences in the two situations.
 
Why is this even a concern?

Because my memory told me that somewhere in this thread that the argument that offending jihadists could be done without offending non-jihadist Muslims was advanced, but now I can't find it in this ever-growing, fast-moving thread, and I might have been wrong in thinking I saw it.

All over the world, non-extremists somehow manage to put up with, ignore, or otherwise not react violently to offenses aimed in their general direction. Why on earth would we not expect the same of non-extremist muslims, and take for granted that they will be no worse off than any other non-extremists? Why should we have any special concern just for Muslims?

All I'm saying is that if you don't care, that's fine (there are lots of people and categories of people I don't care if I offend). Just be open and honest about who, specifically, you're offending and why.
 
In the meantime, apparently, an Islamic Clergyman has declared the two idiots to be "heroes of Islam "...

In Pakistan, in case anybody wondered.

May every other terrorist skid mark suck so black-holishly at their murderous attempts as they do at being remotely human.
 
If I dangle a hunk of meat in front of a lion and the lion mauls me to get it, that's on me. The lion is acting according to his nature, he can't change that. Elton Simpson and Nadir Soofi were men. They chose to get offended, load up on guns and bombs and go looking for someone to punish. They are the ones who need to change.

To qualify this further: No matter what sympathies I may have for people who are offended by hateful speech, this is where my sympathy ends. A lion acts on instinct and conditioning alone. A human is supposed to have the ability to be rational, to consider actions and consequences. Offense does not explain these men's actions. It is purely irrational emotion, instinctive and conditioned.

It is possibly understandable how irrational emotional reactions like offense can cause someone a modicum of temporary emotional distress. Spur-of-the-moment reactions such as anger may be understandable, even making specious threats may be understandable. I would even concede that a possible argument can be made that hauling off and punching the offender in the heat of the moment may be in some way understandable.

But the moment premeditation enters the picture, this is no longer understandable, and cannot in any way be justified by any form of irrational emotional reaction. This requires planning, coordination, and above all, time. It requires some modicum of rational thought, and justification for the act. That is not offense, that is something far worse.
 
Is this from a lost chapter of The Turner Diaries?

Lighter note here,I'm not kidding I used(when I was 18-im35 now)to go out with a girl who carried a copy around like a colostomy bag. It was pretty weird because I come from a travelling community or to racist cranks I'm a "pikey". She had to tell her pals I came from a normal house bound family.
Anyway she was in her last school year and she was asked to do a family history project. It turned out in the mid 19th century her direct descendant was a clerk in British India who married the daughter of a mixed race anglo-indian couple. She was not best pleased. I thought it was funny.

We sometimes get caught up in asking what makes a extremist,is clear to me at least where Muslims are concerned its birthed by Islam itself. There are christian,Hindu even Buddhist terrorists,many who suffered just as much colonially or suffer economically today,just as much as Muslims do in some places. Yet Islam is the only worldwide terror campaign. Its clearly not a human fault but a Islamic fault.
 
But are they offending moderate Moslems?

It depends on the specific depiction.

Is the prohibition observed by all billion+ Moslems worldwide or only a sect here or a schism there?

As has been pointed out earlier in this thread, the prohibition on depictions in general is not observed by all billion+ Muslims worldwide.

And within them how many are really hardline about it?

You'll have to define "hardline". But I, at least, draw a distinction between doing something to take a stand because someone says they'll respond with violence if I dare do that, and between doing something to simply be a dick to someone who merely says "Hey, I kinda don't like that. Could you please stop doing it?"

And if it turns out that you can't do the former without also doing the latter, at least recognize that you are doing the latter.
 
Only in the sense that, if a non-Islamist, non-jihadist Muslim was looking at it, would she be able to tell that whatever message it was trying to convey was being targeted at Islamists or jihadists, and not at her?

I think one of the major (though extremely subtle) challenges of this conversation is the conflation of insult and offense. Yes, Muslims will obviously take offense at images of Mohammad, but said images are not insults directed at Muslims (in the same way a hook-nosed caricature demeans Jews). One could say the same thing about Christians and Piss Christ.

Honestly, I don't know if there's an easy way to walk the tightrope between the two. Maybe I'm naive to think most people will be able to refrain from overreaction, and contemplate the difference.

Here's one fun idea: International Draw Mohammad In A Nice Way Day. It's the day where you draw Mohammad, but in a way that is definitely not insulting. Moderates probably wouldn't mind, and the extremists will stand out more than ever.
 
So far, I haven't seen anyone in this thread advocating causing offense as an end in itself, or justifying doing so. Even the bigots who are the subject of this thread did not do so as an end in itself, but for a larger purpose. In every case I've seen here, it has always been advocated as a means to an end. Those who cause offense as an end in itself, have a name: Trolls.

I agree. I included offense-as-an-end primarily for completeness' sake. I tend to think the difference here is offense-as-a-means, or offense-as-a-side-effect.

I disagree.

"Offense" is an irrational, emotional response to something which challenges a particular worldview or belief. And that's all it is. It has no other basis for existing, and no reason to be taken seriously. To act on such offense is emotionally immature. It's feelings, not reason, and there is no reason to respect such feelings.

Offending someone cannot make them radical or extremist; that tendency has to already exist in order to be triggered by feelings of offense. It is a sign of rationality and emotional maturity that one can deal with these feelings without becoming violent or otherwise attempting to enforce one's worldview on others.

If "moderate" Muslims cannot handle being offended by those who do not share their religious beliefs and cultural worldview, then that is a problem with them, not a problem with those who do not share their religion or culture. Again, I am not seeing anyone similarly complaining about someone causing offense to Christians (which the very existence of this site, and others like it, does), or Wiccans, or members of any other, less violent, religion. It only comes up in the context of Islamic extremism. Why is that?

I'm not sure how to take this.

Let me ask you this: I tend to think that the reason it is wrong to call black people by a racial slur is that it is deeply offensive to them and given the history of the term (and also the fact that I am white), this offense is perfectly reasonable. Do you agree with this assessment?

Now, of course, you may find belief in Islam to be silly or irrational, but a religious belief can be deeply held, providing significant influences to one's values, norms, beliefs and so on. And at least some Muslims take deep offense (and believe that offense to be justified and reasonable, on the basis of their faith) at insults of the Prophet. And I don't see that offense as any less reasonable, from the perspective of a Muslim, than the offense taken by a black American when confronted with racial epithets.

Do you find the two situations similar or different? Is the black American emotionally immature, based on what you said above? If not, what accounts for the difference?

Thanks.
 
There is a logical falicy there...tu something.or another...

Not going for a tu quoque,but just pointing out that Islam is no more inherently violent then Christianity.

The key word is inherent. I disagree with ..and have often argued with..those who try to minimize the problem of Islamic Extremism by pointing to Christian extremists. And I am sickened by the de facto excuse making that some on the left make for Islamic Militants.
 
I think one of the major (though extremely subtle) challenges of this conversation is the conflation of insult and offense. Yes, Muslims will obviously take offense at images of Mohammad, but said images are not insults directed at Muslims (in the same way a hook-nosed caricature demeans Jews). One could say the same thing about Christians and Piss Christ.

Honestly, I don't know if there's an easy way to walk the tightrope between the two. Maybe I'm naive to think most people will be able to refrain from overreaction, and contemplate the difference.

Here's one fun idea: International Draw Mohammad In A Nice Way Day. It's the day where you draw Mohammad, but in a way that is definitely not insulting. Moderates probably wouldn't mind, and the extremists will stand out more than ever.

The point is Christians bitch a lot about Piss Christ,but they don't try to kill the guy who created it.
A couple of hundred years ago, things would have been different.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom