Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Thankfully, we are not required to make that choice. But perhaps you live in a world chock-full of such choices between death and injustice.

Are you kidding me? What country do you live in? That kind of thing goes on in the US every single day; and most of the rest of the world as well. Every time I go out looking clearly and openly Transgendered, I take that risk. Not a huge risk, admittedly; but a risk. Last summer two gay teens were murdered exactly one block from my house, simply for the fact that they were gay; by a man who deliberately targeted gays for violence. (It's not been determined if religion was an issue; but he does have a name that is typically indicative of a recent convert to Islam, and was not a recent immigrant. So the possibility exists.) That is an uncommon, but not unheard of, event that can and does occur anywhere in this country; even in a city as supposedly liberal as mine. In fact, thanks to recent immigrants from Russia (brought in for tech industry jobs), violence against GLBTs has been on the rise here.

And not just this country; but in the vast majority of the world. It's certainly true for most of the Middle-East and Africa and central Asia, where being openly GLBT is effectively a death sentence, and dissenters are frequently jailed and killed. It's the case in China, where anyone protesting the oppression of Tibet and various minority groups are routinely rounded up and jailed.

There is nowhere in the world where someone, somewhere does not face oppression or threats of harm simply because of who they are.

I don't envy you that and suggest you move to a more civilized part of the planet if possible.
Sure, just tell me where that is, and how you are going to send me the money to get there, and I'll be happy to go.

Look for a country where we do not go out of our way to cause offense, where getting along with each other has a higher value than rote idealism, where maturity and examination of possible consequences for actions hold sway, where people make responsible choices about what they do instead of trying to find someone to blame.
I'd rather live in a country where I free to express myself, so long as I do not harm others, than live in fear that anything I say or do will be repressed by those who would rather "go along to get along".

This is not indicative of a "civilized" country; but of a fearful and conformist one. A civilized country is one where anyone can express any facet of themselves that does not cause harm to others, without fear of violent reprisal. Such a utopia exists nowhere in this world.

Why don't you tell me what country best exemplifies your worldview. I'm willing to bet you won't be able to find even one. And if you do, I'm also willing to bet that they severely restrict immigration from "undesirable" regions.

It's quite telling that, when confronted with the subject of injustice and oppression, your advice is to "run away". That's beyond cowardly, and beyond victim blaming. I'm not really sure what to call it, except profoundly ignorant of reality. What do you do with all those people who are unable to run away from oppressors and fanatics? Do advise them to capitulate? To just get along with the people who want to kill and enslave them?

I noticed you still haven't addressed the issue of abortion clinics or Pride events. Do you consider those "incitement", given the amount of violence that they attract worldwide?

Unlike you, I prefer to work to make my home more civilized, rather than running away and hiding, then creating elaborate and bizarre justifications for why doing so is somehow not inherently cowardly or hypocritical.
 
Some of these posts have to be coming from the Marketing Department of the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation.
 
What if the loyal minority decides that it is "deeply offended" by the way the women of the majority decide to dress? What if the loyal minority decides that these women are deliberately dressing that way to antagonize them? What if certain members of that loyal minority decide to start throwing acid at improperly dressed woman, as punishment for "deeply offending" their religious sensibilities? Should those women be blamed for inciting violence?

I am discussing whether it is a good idea (both in terms of morality and prudence) to purposely offend Muslims in order to quell extremist attacks aimed at offensive speech.

I don't think I've said anything at all that suggests we ought to change the way we dress in order to please Muslims. In fact, I'm not sure how anyone could get that impression.
 
If I dangle a hunk of meat in front of a lion and the lion mauls me to get it, that's on me. The lion is acting according to his nature, he can't change that. Elton Simpson and Nadir Soofi were men. They chose to get offended, load up on guns and bombs and go looking for someone to punish. They are the ones who need to change.
 
So, we should purposely encourage people to cause offense so that it will be safe to cause offense. And to hell with the otherwise decent Muslims who will feel deeply offended and targeted by such behavior, because, you know, it's all for the good in the long run.

You know, it's telling that this issue only comes up with regard to Islam. I don't see anyone getting all up on arms about offending fundamentalist Christians, or New Agers, or Bigfooters, or other True Believers; which is something that happens constantly. In fact, many people in this very thread have engaged in such offense. No one seems to care about the impact of federal legalization of Gay marriage; despite the fact that some extremist Christian and Mormon fundamentalists have threatened uprisings and violence.

And I see that certain people still do not appear to have addressed the issue of abortion clinic bombings.

Why is blame-the-victim only played when it involves Islamic extremists?
 
I am discussing whether it is a good idea (both in terms of morality and prudence) to purposely offend Muslims in order to quell extremist attacks aimed at offensive speech.
I would not say it is moral or prudent to cause offense in order to quell extremist attacks.

I would, however, say that it can be moral and prudent to cause offense as an act of protest against extremists who use threats of violence as a tool to quell the exercise of human rights.

Protest is by nature offensive to some, but it is still legitimate. I think that the question of whether it is prudent to confront those who threaten you with violence is one that should be left up to each of us individually. I also think that certainly in a society of free people, the choice to protest threats of violence, with acts of speech, should be protected by our government and upheld by our fellow citizens.
 
No kidding.

But it does.

So maybe don't do it? If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.

Seems pretty simple to me.

Your very wrong. If someone says they believe a apple is a steam locomotive they open themselves up to ridicule. They are maintaining something absurd and should b treated like a moron.
If someone says they believe in winged horses and a dead guy who flew to heaven 1400yrs ago they likewise open themselves up to ridicule. Furthermore absurd beliefs should be mocked and challenged-thats one of the whole points of freedom of expression. You can say something silly like"I don't like drawings of a died peado i have never met"but you can't expect sane human beings to humor you,indeed you should expect mockery. You can object to said mockery-but in a democratic society your right to object ends at the other persons nose. You say something stupid-you get mocked.
Where would it end if we did otherwise. Would we be unable to mock creationists because it offends them. Should we cease mocking and insulting idiots who think crop circles are evidence of interstellar anal probing ewocks.
If you have a silly belief AND go about in public stating said silly belief you must expect to have yourself and your silly belief laughed at. Belief in islam-or any religion-is exactly the same as someone believing in unicorns,or live cabbage patch dolls. And if you think cabbage patch dolls are real you should be mocked mercissily. Why should belief in a dead guy who flew on a winged horse be any different.
People do silly things,if they are mentally ill they should be helped otherwise they should be made to suffer the mockery there beliefs warrant. They can argue back,but that's it. If they use violence they are 100% to blame. We are talking about,at least,young adults to full grown humans. If they are going to get upset over DRAWINGS they should,nay must,be mocked and ridiculed.
 
Some people certainly do deserve to be offended. Jihadists. Islamists. Ultraorthodox Jews who use "modesty patrols" to harass women for dressing indecently in "their" neighborhoods. Evangelical Christians who are virulently anti-LGBTQ. Dictatorships and oppressive governments worldwide.

But when you're offending those who need to be offended, how much do you care about collateral damage? If you're using anti-Semitic hook-nosed caricatures to criticize the Hasidim, how are non-Hasidic Jews going to feel? If you're laughing while going "ching chong ching chong" in order to mock the repressive policies of Xi Jinping's government, what are the Chinese victimized by those very policies going to think of you? If you want to stick it to the likes of Fred Phelps and Rick Santorum by using the pages of a Bible as toilet paper, what is the reaction of pro-gay Christian congregations going to be? If you want to give the metaphorical finger to ISIS or the muslim Brotherhood by drawing Muhammad as a leering, bomb-wielding child molester, are all those Muslims who hate the Islamic State or the Brotherhood going to nod their heads along with you and say "That's right, give 'em what-for!"?

If you say your goal is to offend only the extremists and not all the other people who don't share the extremists' views, how are the non-extremists going to tell?
 
I am discussing whether it is a good idea (both in terms of morality and prudence) to purposely offend Muslims in order to quell extremist attacks aimed at offensive speech.

I don't think I've said anything at all that suggests we ought to change the way we dress in order to please Muslims. In fact, I'm not sure how anyone could get that impression.

You're suggesting people avoid purposely offending Muslims in order to quell extremist attacks aimed at offensive expression. Dress is a form of expression. Under the right circumstances, women dressed in shorts might be considered deliberate religious offense. In that situation, women should avoid wearing shorts in order to insure not offending violent extremists.
 
CeI think that causing offense as an end is the most morally suspect situation,
So far, I haven't seen anyone in this thread advocating causing offense as an end in itself, or justifying doing so. Even the bigots who are the subject of this thread did not do so as an end in itself, but for a larger purpose. In every case I've seen here, it has always been advocated as a means to an end. Those who cause offense as an end in itself, have a name: Trolls.

If we could direct offense, as a form of protest, only to those who directly threaten violence, I don't think I'd have any issue at all. So, by and large, I think I agree with what you say, but I'm not sure it captures all of the issues in the actual situation we're discussing. I think that the actions of Geller, et al., tend to support the extremist cause by alienating Muslims who would otherwise pose no threat, and furthermore that intentionally causing offense as she does is not merely imprudent but immoral.

I disagree.

"Offense" is an irrational, emotional response to something which challenges a particular worldview or belief. And that's all it is. It has no other basis for existing, and no reason to be taken seriously. To act on such offense is emotionally immature. It's feelings, not reason, and there is no reason to respect such feelings.

Offending someone cannot make them radical or extremist; that tendency has to already exist in order to be triggered by feelings of offense. It is a sign of rationality and emotional maturity that one can deal with these feelings without becoming violent or otherwise attempting to enforce one's worldview on others.

If "moderate" Muslims cannot handle being offended by those who do not share their religious beliefs and cultural worldview, then that is a problem with them, not a problem with those who do not share their religion or culture. Again, I am not seeing anyone similarly complaining about someone causing offense to Christians (which the very existence of this site, and others like it, does), or Wiccans, or members of any other, less violent, religion. It only comes up in the context of Islamic extremism. Why is that?
 
Sorry, but on freedom of speech there is little room for compromise.
The group in Texas seems to be a bunch of bigots,but in the US,thank the FSM,even bigots are entilted to have their right of freedom of speech protected.
On this issue I am a hard liner.
And congratulations to that Texas Lawmen. Taking down two people with assault rifles with a handgun is some might fine shooting.
 
Do you wait until they shoot a security guard and maybe even kill someone else before you attempt to deal with the problem? Or is the Wild West exchange-of-gunfire method your only proposed solution?

In this case, yes, it was the only solution.
 
If you say your goal is to offend only the extremists and not all the other people who don't share the extremists' views, how are the non-extremists going to tell?
Why is this even a concern?

Non-extremist Christians seem to get along just fine in a world where the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence perform without hindrance. Non-extremist Jews seem to survive the slings and arrows of outrageous blood libel and offensive stereotypes without having to go out and kill anyone.

All over the world, non-extremists somehow manage to put up with, ignore, or otherwise not react violently to offenses aimed in their general direction. Why on earth would we not expect the same of non-extremist muslims, and take for granted that they will be no worse off than any other non-extremists? Why should we have any special concern just for Muslims?
 
Why is this even a concern?

Non-extremist Christians seem to get along just fine in a world where the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence perform without hindrance. Non-extremist Jews seem to survive the slings and arrows of outrageous blood libel and offensive stereotypes without having to go out and kill anyone.

All over the world, non-extremists somehow manage to put up with, ignore, or otherwise not react violently to offenses aimed in their general direction. Why on earth would we not expect the same of non-extremist muslims, and take for granted that they will be no worse off than any other non-extremists? Why should we have any special concern just for Muslims?
This^^^^.
^n....
 
Why is this even a concern?

Non-extremist Christians seem to get along just fine in a world where the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence perform without hindrance. Non-extremist Jews seem to survive the slings and arrows of outrageous blood libel and offensive stereotypes without having to go out and kill anyone.

All over the world, non-extremists somehow manage to put up with, ignore, or otherwise not react violently to offenses aimed in their general direction. Why on earth would we not expect the same of non-extremist muslims, and take for granted that they will be no worse off than any other non-extremists? Why should we have any special concern just for Muslims?

True, but given their history,Christians have no business pointing fingers at Muslims for using violence to advance their religons.
Yes, Islam is much worse today then Christiney is for having an extermists problem, but there is nothing inherent in Islam that makes it worse then Christianity. The mess we have now is due to historiacal events.
For much of the Middle Ages,Islam was a lot more tolerent then Christianity. Times have changed.
 
You know, it's telling that this issue only comes up with regard to Islam. I don't see anyone getting all up on arms about offending fundamentalist Christians, or New Agers, or Bigfooters, or other True Believers; which is something that happens constantly. In fact, many people in this very thread have engaged in such offense. No one seems to care about the impact of federal legalization of Gay marriage; despite the fact that some extremist Christian and Mormon fundamentalists have threatened uprisings and violence.

And I see that certain people still do not appear to have addressed the issue of abortion clinic bombings.

Why is blame-the-victim only played when it involves Islamic extremists?

I don't think anything I've said counts as victim-blaming. I know there are a lot of folks in this discussion, and it's hard to keep straight who said what. If you disagree, let me know where I blamed the victim and what you think I blamed him for.

Until we clarify that, I'm not sure I understand your question, insofar as it is directed to me.
 
But when you're offending those who need to be offended, how much do you care about collateral damage? If you're using anti-Semitic hook-nosed caricatures to criticize the Hasidim, how are non-Hasidic Jews going to feel? If you're laughing while going "ching chong ching chong" in order to mock the repressive policies of Xi Jinping's government, what are the Chinese victimized by those very policies going to think of you? If you want to stick it to the likes of Fred Phelps and Rick Santorum by using the pages of a Bible as toilet paper, what is the reaction of pro-gay Christian congregations going to be? If you want to give the metaphorical finger to ISIS or the muslim Brotherhood by drawing Muhammad as a leering, bomb-wielding child molester, are all those Muslims who hate the Islamic State or the Brotherhood going to nod their heads along with you and say "That's right, give 'em what-for!"?

To be clear: Do you consider caricatures of Mohammad (just Mohammad, not all Muslims or even Muslims in general) to be along the same line as these other examples?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom