phiwum
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2010
- Messages
- 13,590
I agree that there's a moral distinction in the manner in which the offense is caused, but I don't think it's clear cut.
Certainly, it is not clear cut. It's quite a grey area.
I agree with the bulk of what you say, but let me clarify some things.
I think that causing offense as an end is the most morally suspect situation, but there may be cases in which even that act may be morally acceptable. The details matter. Similarly, there are cases in which unintentionally but knowingly causing offense is morally prohibited. The comparison I was making was intended roughly as "all other things being equal...".
I also think that you misunderstand my concern about causing offense. I can't get too worked up over the offense taken by those who are already radicalized and willing to kill others over drawings. I'm more concerned about the offense we cause those Muslims who are decent, reasonable people.
If we could direct offense, as a form of protest, only to those who directly threaten violence, I don't think I'd have any issue at all. So, by and large, I think I agree with what you say, but I'm not sure it captures all of the issues in the actual situation we're discussing. I think that the actions of Geller, et al., tend to support the extremist cause by alienating Muslims who would otherwise pose no threat, and furthermore that intentionally causing offense as she does is not merely imprudent but immoral.