Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I agree that there's a moral distinction in the manner in which the offense is caused, but I don't think it's clear cut.

Certainly, it is not clear cut. It's quite a grey area.

I agree with the bulk of what you say, but let me clarify some things.

I think that causing offense as an end is the most morally suspect situation, but there may be cases in which even that act may be morally acceptable. The details matter. Similarly, there are cases in which unintentionally but knowingly causing offense is morally prohibited. The comparison I was making was intended roughly as "all other things being equal...".

I also think that you misunderstand my concern about causing offense. I can't get too worked up over the offense taken by those who are already radicalized and willing to kill others over drawings. I'm more concerned about the offense we cause those Muslims who are decent, reasonable people.

If we could direct offense, as a form of protest, only to those who directly threaten violence, I don't think I'd have any issue at all. So, by and large, I think I agree with what you say, but I'm not sure it captures all of the issues in the actual situation we're discussing. I think that the actions of Geller, et al., tend to support the extremist cause by alienating Muslims who would otherwise pose no threat, and furthermore that intentionally causing offense as she does is not merely imprudent but immoral.
 
I think he's a person who's trying to correct a misconception, or at least to give Geller's defense.

Your commitment to truth knows a few bounds, huh?
That depends on if the corrected truth is just as bad as the asserted truth.

Brainster espouses similar anti-Obama views as Geller so he'd like her not to be a complete loon. But one need only go to her blog to find her own loony tunes:
http://pamelageller.com/2009/12/jews-refuse-to-get-on-obamas-trains.html/
Obama is pressuring Jews to "evacuate" from parts of Israel? And what Warsaw ghetto does the muhammadan president have in mind? I think I am gonna hurl.

The Jews will not go. The Jews will not submit to this century's nazis and Mansourian poser. No way, bloodsuckers. Not again. Never again.

http://pamelageller.com/2014/11/pamela-geller-breitbart-column-getting-out-the-nazi-vote.html/
Getting out the Nazi vote. It’s no accident that Rice and the Netanyahu “***********” bombs were dropped right before the election
There is so much conspiracy theory nonsense on her blog it only took a couple seconds to find that.

So does it matter if her excuse for why she didn't say Obama is the love child of Malcolm X is that she was just posting what someone else said and the Malcolm X comment was a minor part of what she quoted?
Actually, this statement from Pamela Geller heads the actual post in question: “The ‘Atlas says that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child’ charge has gone viral among leftards and lizards. The only problem with it is that it is false. I am not the author of this post, and I posted it because the writer did a spectacular job documenting Obama’s many connections with the Far Left. The Malcolm X claim is one minor part of this story, and was of interest to me principally as part of the writer’s documentation that Stanley Ann Dunham could not have been where the Obama camp says she was at various times. I do not believe that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child, and never did — but there remain many, many unanswered questions about his early life and upbringing.” - See more at: http://pamelageller.com/rebuttals-to-false-charges/#sthash.LFzcoak4.dpuf
So she quotes a guy, later says, (paraphrasing obviously) "I don't believe that minor part of what the guy said but I quoted it anyway and didn't say I didn't believe it until it made me look even more stupid than I actually am."

The whole, "look how they distort her comments", campaign is no more than a slight of hand: look here, don't look over there. It's a common tactic by the Freepers like Breitbart's heirs. The woman is a loony CTer. Trying to deny that because the Malcolm X comment was someone else's she quoted does not change anything.

And by the way, try to find the original blog entry where she supposedly was only quoting someone else and you only get her correction.

This whole page of false charge rebuttals is mind bogglingly ironic given her entire shtick is spewing false charges about other people.


** Note, trying to shoot a bunch of people is immensely worse.
 
Last edited:
I have an understanding of the risks involved with being outside. I might get hit by a drunk driver. Does this somehow make me responsible if I get hit by a drunk driver?

If you choose to go outside instead of staying inside, you are choosing one set of risks over another. You are making a choice. You cannot control (for the sake of argument) the actions of others, only your own actions.

I cannot distinguish the relative risk in your hypothetical, so the choice isn't clear. But to the extent that you adopt some risky behavior, you are responsible for the choice you made. Providing, of course, you understood the probable consequences.

This is well established in law and insurance. People are generally held accountable for the choices they make. In fact, it's the reason the drunk driver gets prosecuted when he runs you down, even though he claims it was an accident. We say he is responsible for the choices he made and contributed to the accident through those choices.

If we are going to remove responsibility and agency from one party, we should remove it from all parties. This is the "but I was abused as a child" defense. Interestingly, Tsarnaev's defense at his terrorist trial relied on a version of this. The idea was that, in his culture, a younger brother has to follow the dictates of an older brother - a defense which tries to remove the element of choice and hence, responsibility.
 
There is a whole industry of security experts that give advice on navigating places safely. Their advice isn't fun. It certainly doesn't include going out or being defiant. It is a perfectly acceptable framework for examining a situation.

So the sluttily-dressed slutty slut who gets gang-raped at the frat party after too much drink and drug needs to change her behavior.
 
<snip>

I can't understand this. If, indeed, the west makes a concerted effort to purposely and intentionally cause offense to Muslims, then that is a reason to have ill will to the west. If the west instead does not do this, then this reason doesn't exist. It's not a matter of apathy. It's a question of whether it is prudent, moral, decent to intentionally target Muslims and cause offense to them.

Some members of a minority that coexists peacefully in a society may, just may, come to wonder whether they are loyal to the society when it makes a concerted, deliberate effort to deeply offend them. We're not talking about latent hostility kept in check by apathy. We're talking about a plan that is certain to create hostility.

You must have a pretty low opinion of moderate Muslims to think that they're going to be so deeply offended by efforts that are clearly intended to stand up to intimidation by violent Jihadists. So deeply offended in fact that they would sympathize with the violent Jihadists over those who defend free speech.

I wonder if you've managed to recognize the myriad ways in which the left intentionally insults and offends religious Christians in this country. If you do recognize them, do you speak out against those insults, or do you in fact celebrate them? And, by and large, what has been the response of the people who were offended? Have them become more militant? Do they hate liberals more? Or, rather, in the case of, say, gay rights or secularism in schools, does it acclimatize them to a new reality?
 
Not drawing Mohammed is equivalent to not using the n-word.

No, it's not. That word has a long history of association with violence against and oppression of a specific racial/ethnic minority. It is inherently a term of degradation. That said, there should be no official proscription of its use. Refusal to use it is to acknowledge the historical associations and cultural context, as a general rule, not fear of violence from that community.

Drawing pictures of Mohammed, by contrast, has no such history or cultural context. It is no different than creating caricatures and cartoons of Jesus, the Buddha, Krishna, Ba'ha'u'lla, or Donald Trump. In fact, the proscription against images of The Prophet is not even universal within the wider context of Islam.

I am not allowed to use profanity on this forum. I do not feel my ability to express myself is limited by this restriction. If images of Mohammed were prohibited here, I would have even less cause to object to that.

This is such a false equivalency I'm surprised you even brought it up. The proscription against profanity has nothing to do with limits on expression, since there is nothing that can be expressed with profanity that cannot be expressed similarly without it. The limit exists simply because that is the only way to ensure that the forum is accessible from schools and other institutions that limit profanity. The same cannot be said for depictions of Mohammed, since depictions make a statement that cannot be effectively made any other way: to wit, rejection of a specific limitation on freedom of expression imposed by adherents of a particular religion upon others who are not adherents of that religion.

If the fanatics did not insist on violently imposing their beliefs on others, then depictions of Mohammed would be a non-issue, regardless of how many others it offends. It is precisely because some people are prone to violence over said depictions that doing so is a useful exercise in freedom of expression.
 
And you don't believe in being responsible for the consequences of speech.
There is no way of always being able to tell what speech will be offensive to any given individual.
Our society, and laws, allow speech that is offensive to any one individual, or groups of individuals. The law PROTECTS that speech, and when anyone attempts to suppress that speech, the government, and people in general, MUST punish those who so attempt. Otherwise the law is useless.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

To paraphrase H.L Mencken, the problem with fighting for freedom is that you end up defending a lot of really unpleasant people; because oppression is always targeted at those sorts of people first, and oppression needs to be stopped early if it is going to be stopped at all.

Do you think that Neo-Nazis have no right to express their views? What about Nation of Islam? Black Panthers? Fundamentalist Christians? Madalyn Murray O'Hair and American Atheists? Black Lives Matter?

As very many others have said, if you are only in favour of freedom of speech for speech you agree with, then you are not in favour of freedom of speech.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.

I'd like to say that this is beneath you, but at this point I'm not sure anything is.
 
You must have a pretty low opinion of moderate Muslims to think that they're going to be so deeply offended by efforts that are clearly intended to stand up to intimidation by violent Jihadists. So deeply offended in fact that they would sympathize with the violent Jihadists over those who defend free speech.

I tend to think that religious beliefs can cut pretty deeply, and if one believes that offense against the Prophet is a horrible deed and an attack on those of faith, then, yes, I can imagine Muslims being further marginalized, and more likely to view the west with hostility. And I think it would be very difficult to explain that this isn't really an attack on Islam, and they should get over it.

I wonder if you've managed to recognize the myriad ways in which the left intentionally insults and offends religious Christians in this country. If you do recognize them, do you speak out against those insults, or do you in fact celebrate them?

I do neither.

I don't speak out against them in part because I don't think that Christians are reasonably concerned about marginalization in this society. I think that Muslims are.

And, by and large, what has been the response of the people who were offended? Have them become more militant? Do they hate liberals more? Or, rather, in the case of, say, gay rights or secularism in schools, does it acclimatize them to a new reality?

Hard to say, really, but seems to me that small-scale, homegrown attacks are on the rise. I think that's an indication that this strategy is not working so far, but maybe it's a long term thing.
 
So you didn't read my post? :rolleyes:

I read your post, but it was irrelevant to my point.

Yes, Geller is a bad person.

But "whoop-di-do" is not an appropriate response to correction. You can dispute the correction, you can defend the error as insignificant. But you should not react as if the allegation of error itself is something inconsequential.
 
If you choose to go outside instead of staying inside, you are choosing one set of risks over another. You are making a choice. You cannot control (for the sake of argument) the actions of others, only your own actions.

I cannot distinguish the relative risk in your hypothetical, so the choice isn't clear. But to the extent that you adopt some risky behavior, you are responsible for the choice you made. Providing, of course, you understood the probable consequences.

This is well established in law and insurance. People are generally held accountable for the choices they make. In fact, it's the reason the drunk driver gets prosecuted when he runs you down, even though he claims it was an accident. We say he is responsible for the choices he made and contributed to the accident through those choices.

If we are going to remove responsibility and agency from one party, we should remove it from all parties. This is the "but I was abused as a child" defense. Interestingly, Tsarnaev's defense at his terrorist trial relied on a version of this. The idea was that, in his culture, a younger brother has to follow the dictates of an older brother - a defense which tries to remove the element of choice and hence, responsibility.

Why is the responsibility of my speech proportional to the actions of other people?
 
Not unless you knew the guy was drunk and ran infront of the vehicle he/she was driving.

How is that the slightest bit analogous to what occurred here? Do you think all these people wanted a gunfight? Did they metaphorically jump in front of the bullets of people from two states away? I participated in the very first International Draw Mohammad Day. Do you think I want to get shot?
 
Except that other Muslims are often killed by extremists as well as unbelievers.

So we all need to acceded to the most violent and intolerant form of Islam, then we'll be safe from the extremists.

Or (not aimed at you), we could accept that no amount of capitulation will make us entirely safe, stop believing in this illusion of complete safety, and accept - as many others fighting for freedom have accepted - that life and the exercise of freedom has risks which cannot be completely negated.

There is no way to ever be completely safe from extremists as long as they exist. Worse, the more we capitulate to violence extremists, the more other irrational actors will see that violence is an effective tacit to obtain their desires. What we will see is not a decrease in violence and risk; but an increase, as more and more competing extremist groups resort to violence to enforce their worldview on the rest of us.

The point is to not cower in fear of irrational fanatics, because in the long run that does not make us more save, but less. We need to accept the fact that life and freedom has risks, and do our best to improve the world and lessen the risks to the degree that we can without capitulating to the irrational.

That's not to say that we should always go out of our way to offend the irrational. Obvious, we need to pick our battles, choosing the most effective time and tactics to fight irrationality. But cowering in the face of violence is never a useful tactic.
 
If you think that holding a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed is resisting oppression and standing up to dictators, that would make the event seem noble and principled. I don't see it that way at all.
So it's a good thing I don't think that.

What I do think is that it can be in the right context; but otherwise the "nobility" of such an act is completely and utterly irrelevant. All that matters is the freedom to commit such an act. It's not inherently a "noble and principled" thing to do, but it's a simple human thing to do, and the more we are allowed to do simple, human things that do not harm others, the more freedom we have, and the less power the extremists have.

Right now, by putting the blame on the victim for "inciting" by simply acting like normal humans exercising their freedom of expression; you are granting the extremists a substantial amount of power that they have not earned, and do not deserve. The nature of those humans or their worldview is completely and utterly irrelevant. Plenty of people find them offensive and hateful. I do not disagree. Plenty of people find openly GLBT people hateful and offensive, and those people form a substantial percentage of the population of this country. I strongly disagree with those people.

But how can I defend one, and deplore the other, without making myself either a hypocrite or demagogue?

I see it as inciting violence and putting cops and security guards at risk in service of a hate-filled agenda against Muslims.

Do you think the same thing about non-violent Civil Rights protests? About Gay Pride parades? About protests against the influence of religion in government? Anti-war protests? Protests against excessive police violence? Protests against female genital mutilation, "honor killings", and forced marriage? Protests against lese majeste laws? What makes these so different?

All of these things have been and still are met with violent reactions from extremists almost everywhere in the world. In some places, they are actively prohibited; and seen as having a hate-filled agenda. There is a reason that groups like the ACLU defend hate groups like the Neo-Nazis and Nation of Islam just as much as they do GLBTs and atheists. Or do you think that is wrong as well?
 
Remember that scene in Pleasantville where Jeff Daniels' character, the owner of the diner, paints a colorful mural and eventually one featuring a nude woman on the large window of his diner, out where the whole town can see it?

He does it in an environment where he knows it will cause a disturbance and generate anger and even violence, but he does it anyway as a way of taking a stand about his right to express himself and even as a deliberate attempt to shake people out of their unreasonable, backward views on such art.

Liberals loved that movie because it was railing against white bread 1950's America and it's Christianity and it's hangups about sex, women, etc. Those are villains liberals are comfortable with. Those are people liberals are comfortable with the idea of deliberately provoking and trying to openly mock and dislodge the antiquated views of.

Liberals, in other contexts, and certainly in the 60's and 70's in particular, could be found openly endorsing the notion of creating art for the express purpose of upsetting people, and they would be able to argue endlessly about how important it was to disrupt peoples' comfort zones with art, etc.

When the townsfolk in Pleasantville smash the window mural with bricks, the takeaway the liberal filmmakers wanted the liberal audience to have was that those doing violence against free expression were the bad guys, even if they were knowingly provoked by something right in their town square, shoved right in their faces. The fault was entirely on them for having those hang ups and those prejudices and being made uncomfortable by nudity and color and modern art. They deserved zero sympathy and their issues were to be mercilessly assailed and done away with, not tip-toed around or respected in any way.

Sure, it was just a movie, but it echoed a real process that took place in the US where liberals quite deliberately sought to inflame conservatives and their old fashioned, patriarchal, religious, stuck up, Christian, socially restrictive ways.

It sure doesn't take much for liberals to flip into total hypocrisy mode, does it? Just make the villains brown instead of white (even though they're an even more extreme version of what Christianity was in the 60's in the U.S., by far) and make the people doing the free expression and deliberate artistic provocation into white tea party types... and just sit back and watch the total hypocrisy flow.
 
Last edited:
Because they approve of The Sisters Of Perpetual Indulgence and are afraid of Moslems.
 
Some members of a minority that coexists peacefully in a society may, just may, come to wonder whether they are loyal to the society when it makes a concerted, deliberate effort to deeply offend them. We're not talking about latent hostility kept in check by apathy. We're talking about a plan that is certain to create hostility.

What if the loyal minority decides that it is "deeply offended" by the way the women of the majority decide to dress? What if the loyal minority decides that these women are deliberately dressing that way to antagonize them? What if certain members of that loyal minority decide to start throwing acid at improperly dressed woman, as punishment for "deeply offending" their religious sensibilities? Should those women be blamed for inciting violence?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom