Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

We don't have to dance around it or be shy. We can say "kill them." Because that's the set up here. Incite violence and as a remedy, apply more violence.

Straw man. Again.

Ridiculing the ridiculous is not inciting violence. The entire responsibility for irrational violence rests on the irrationally violent.
 
On the other hand, I don't take cartooning seriously at all, and especially drawings depicting a long-dead guy I care nothing about. The imbalance here is stunningly obvious. To raise cartoon-Mohammed on some free speech pedestal harms free speech itself, turning it into a laughable toy ideal we pull out when convenient to whitewash asinine behavior.

It's a multiculturalism fail.

Sheer nonsense.

If we do not support freedom of expression for expressions that we dislike, even despise, then we do not truly support freedom of expression. We merely make ourselves petty demagogues.

Freedom is freedom to be stupid, to be hateful, to be offensive; otherwise it's not freedom; because everyone has their own ideas of what is stupid, hateful, or offensive. To the profoundly religious, the mere existence of this forum is hateful and offensive; and some are willing to commit violence over that perception. The mere existence of homosexuals is hateful and offensive to many; and some of those are willing to commit violence over that perception.

Does that mean we should shut down the forum and demand that all homosexuals should go back into the closet and stop being open about their sexuality? Should atheists pretend to be religious? After all, that would prevent the risk of harm to innocents, and it's their fault for inciting others to violence by being openly gay, or openly atheist.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.

This thread has been moving pretty quickly in the past 24 hours, so I apologize if you have already answered the following question. If you haven't, would you mind answering it here?

Do you condemn the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence as a hate group that needlessly incites violence?
 
No, but planning and locating a baseball game specifically to annoy them could be viewed as such.

I'm sorry, was the drawing event held in a mosque? Did it actually occur in Mecca, and not Texas? I must have missed those details.

We need to come to terms with the fact that, according to the beliefs of the extremists - the craziest of the crazy - there is no right way to draw Mohammad. There is no correct location in which it may occur. There is no proper class of people who may participate in the act. All this talk about where and how and why it was done is completely irrelevant.

If the following image is considered "too provocative," then there is something seriously wrong with our society.

bclPigp.png
 
Last edited:
Sheer nonsense.

If we do not support freedom of expression for expressions that we dislike, even despise, then we do not truly support freedom of expression. We merely make ourselves petty demagogues.

Freedom is freedom to be stupid, to be hateful, to be offensive; otherwise it's not freedom; because everyone has their own ideas of what is stupid, hateful, or offensive. To the profoundly religious, the mere existence of this forum is hateful and offensive; and some are willing to commit violence over that perception. The mere existence of homosexuals is hateful and offensive to many; and some of those are willing to commit violence over that perception.

Does that mean we should shut down the forum and demand that all homosexuals should go back into the closet and stop being open about their sexuality? Should atheists pretend to be religious? After all, that would prevent the risk of harm to innocents, and it's their fault for inciting others to violence by being openly gay, or openly atheist.

Yeah, the above. AND to emphasize... IF we were to knuckle under and submit to curtailment of freedom of speech, it just shows that violence works. That what might have been seen as core principles of modern liberty will be given up in the face of committed violence. That is a terrible message to send to extremists (not just islamists) and indeed to society in general.
 
Does anyone doubt there is a subset of Muslims who are willing to die to prevent or respond to insults to their prophet? The fact that it is a deeply certified cultural issue makes it different than mere affectation or manufactured outrage. They absolutely do take this seriously.

On the other hand, I don't take cartooning seriously at all, and especially drawings depicting a long-dead guy I care nothing about. The imbalance here is stunningly obvious. To raise cartoon-Mohammed on some free speech pedestal harms free speech itself, turning it into a laughable toy ideal we pull out when convenient to whitewash asinine behavior.

It's a multiculturalism fail.

tl;dr version: you simply don't believe in freedom of speech.
 
I'm sorry, was the drawing event held in a mosque? Did it actually occur in Mecca, and not Texas? I must have missed those details.

We need to come to terms with the fact that, according to the beliefs of the extremists - the craziest of the crazy - there is no right way to draw Mohammad. There is no correct location in which it may occur. There is no proper class of people who may participate in the act. All this talk about where and how and why it was done is completely irrelevant.

If the following image is considered "too provocative," then there is something seriously wrong with our society.

[qimg]http://i.imgur.com/bclPigp.png[/qimg]



Is that Mandy Patinkin from Homeland?

:)
 
Which means that those who are most prone to violence are the de facto rulers of your society. Do you insist that doctors and clinics should stop providing abortions, because of the risk to innocent bystanders in clinic bombings?

No, but I would want everyone involved to understand the risks they take and to make an informed choice about whether or not they are willing to take the risk.

We have no responsibility to bow to bigots and oppressors, just because they are more willing to use violent force. By that logic, India should still be ruled by the British; and people in general should never rise up against oppressive dictators. We should all just cower in our homes and pay the Dane as much as he wants to leave us alone.

If you think that holding a contest to draw pictures of Mohammed is resisting oppression and standing up to dictators, that would make the event seem noble and principled. I don't see it that way at all.

I see it as inciting violence and putting cops and security guards at risk in service of a hate-filled agenda against Muslims. But I agree with you that violence can certainly alter behavior. It's quite often an effective tool, used by police as well as criminals. I also think it shouldn't be the preferred method of solving disagreements.
 
If I were likely to get shot for posting on this forum, I wouldn't post on this forum. That is so regardless of the justification or lack of justification of the shooter. I am just as dead either way.

By that logic, the entire history of Civil Rights movements around the world are invalidated; as is every revolution against an oppressive government. Both of those frequently and inevitably result in death or harm to innocents. By your logic, even non-violent protests against injustice are a bad idea; because of the harm that fanatics or oppressors would cause.

Taking your premise to its logical conclusion, we should determine which worldview has the most violent and intolerant adherents, and then join that ourselves, accepting and living by its tenets. Only that way can we be truly safe from the fanatics.
 
This thread has been moving pretty quickly in the past 24 hours, so I apologize if you have already answered the following question. If you haven't, would you mind answering it here?

Do you condemn the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence as a hate group that needlessly incites violence?

I have no idea who that is. In general, I'm not going to condemn anyone. Unless, exposing hypocrisy counts as condemnation?
 
All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?

You're still trying the "false equivalence" thing? Let's just be honest and call it what it is,... a strawman.

You are arguing a point that no one has stated. Please highlight for me the posts where people have said "Hey, it's swell that these people shoot/kill people." No one is nominating these cruds for the Nobel Peace Prize. They are monomaniacal murderous bastards.
It is very possible, as I see many people trying to do so, to look at the murderous fanatics on the one side as murderous fanatics, yet still see that Geller and Wild are racist creeps and that particularly Geller is a bigot on a mission. She is absolutely free to say what she wants to say. She and her participants are absolutely free to draw cartoons of The Prophet, Baby Jeebus, Buddha, et al fornicating with donkeys. Have at it. I'll defend their rights, all the way.

But I'm equally free to say that they are rabble-rousing scum, because that's what I see in them.

NO ONE is arguing what you are claiming. And, one should note, NO ONE is playing the reverse Strawman on you. "Oh, so you support hateful racists, then... as long as they're lily white. I see." You want to argue that point for a while, or would you rather we dismiss it as the BS that I intended it to be when I wrote it.

You mean where you said:

"Meh? I'm not victim blaming. Geller wasn't a victim, nor was Wilder. They are just hateful individuals. Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. But it doesn't change the fact that Geller and Wilder are hateful bigoted miscreants."

To highlight: "Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. "

That sounds like equivalence to me.

And that ^^^^^ sounds like desperation to me. You so want to have an argument with someone who is saying the things you've been practicing for that you're inventing the argument where there is none. Do I have to say:

Isamic Terrorist Murders get a minus ten. Geller and Wilders and their ilk only get a minus 8. Geller and Wilders are better than Islamic Terrorist Murderers by two whole points. You hear, "not as bad as but still pretty bad" and you want to turn it into "So? Very close. Why do you love terrorists." Play that game with someone else.

Ooh, you changed it from:

"Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No."

To

"not as bad as but still pretty bad"

Your first statement only says that Pamela Geller isn't any worse than murderous scum. Your second statement says that she is slightly better.

Perhaps you should write more clearly?

Let's just reprint the whole conversation so the whole class can see the game we're playing. I asked you for examples of me or anyone saying what you're claiming in the first post above. You cherry-picked one line and responded with a quote which you have to read between the lines to come to the wrong conclusion about in order to find me or anyone making that argument.

Note the hilited parts:
1. I'll ask you again: Where is anyone making that sort of statement?
2. You ignored and snipped everything in my post other than the line you wanted to argue with. I hilited the part that you seem to have trouble understanding. You see... to me, and I assume to most people, "murderous bastards" are lower on my party list than "hateful bigots". What part of "monomaniacal murderous bastards" are you having trouble with? Perhaps we can help you.

Now you want to play True Skeptic Master of Pedantry. Neener neener neener you didn't say worse you said same as.... Please take that pedantry back to the playground.

Protip: If you have to wring an implicit meaning out of my posts, it might not be me who needs practice in writing, it may be your biases that need to be checked. And if you have to delete major portions because they pre-destroy the false argument you're trying to make, why one just might find that dishonest.
 
Last edited:
And you don't believe in being responsible for the consequences of speech.

If Geller is responsible for two dead terrorists, then she's a god-damn hero.

But I tend to think that the people responsible for their deaths are the terrorists themselves.
 
By that logic, the entire history of Civil Rights movements around the world are invalidated; as is every revolution against an oppressive government. Both of those frequently and inevitably result in death or harm to innocents. By your logic, even non-violent protests against injustice are a bad idea; because of the harm that fanatics or oppressors would cause.

Taking your premise to its logical conclusion, we should determine which worldview has the most violent and intolerant adherents, and then join that ourselves, accepting and living by its tenets. Only that way can we be truly safe from the fanatics.

Thankfully, we are not required to make that choice. But perhaps you live in a world chock-full of such choices between death and injustice. I don't envy you that and suggest you move to a more civilized part of the planet if possible. Look for a country where we do not go out of our way to cause offense, where getting along with each other has a higher value than rote idealism, where maturity and examination of possible consequences for actions hold sway, where people make responsible choices about what they do instead of trying to find someone to blame.
 
Here are a couple of reasons to continue the offence:

1) (Longer term) To show that “acting out” will not cause western society to cave in and accede to pre-Enlightenment restrictions on freedom of expression.

I certainly am not suggesting that we ought to bring back such restrictions, and I have trouble imagining a situation in which people conclude that we will bring them back unless we keep intentionally causing deep offense to Muslims.

So, (1) convinces me not even a little bit.

2) (Shorter term) If more people (say, most mainstream media) were to publish the cartoons then the jihadists would have to target everyone. There would be safety in numbers (any individual blasphemer would be likely to survive). As it is, there are only a few brave souls around the world, who can be picked off one by one (any individual blasphemer is likely to get attacked).

So, we should purposely encourage people to cause offense so that it will be safe to cause offense. And to hell with the otherwise decent Muslims who will feel deeply offended and targeted by such behavior, because, you know, it's all for the good in the long run.

Way back in post no. 136, I asked Caper if he would be willing to defend his actions to the many Muslims who would be deeply offended by willful and intentional attacks on the Prophet. Now, you've given a slightly different motive, but the question I posed there is approximately relevant with few changes. Have a gander at that post, please, and tell me if that's a reasonable sort of explanation you'd be willing to give.

A second issue I’d like to raise regards your comment (which I have seen a lot): “What it will do is alienate more Muslims, and encourage the belief that this is broadly a battle between Islam and the West.”.
If that is the case then these people are terrible citizens, who are abstaining from alienation and violence because of apathy rather than because they share any of the ideals of western civil society. I certainly hope that’s not true of many folks living in the west.

I can't understand this. If, indeed, the west makes a concerted effort to purposely and intentionally cause offense to Muslims, then that is a reason to have ill will to the west. If the west instead does not do this, then this reason doesn't exist. It's not a matter of apathy. It's a question of whether it is prudent, moral, decent to intentionally target Muslims and cause offense to them.

Some members of a minority that coexists peacefully in a society may, just may, come to wonder whether they are loyal to the society when it makes a concerted, deliberate effort to deeply offend them. We're not talking about latent hostility kept in check by apathy. We're talking about a plan that is certain to create hostility.
 
Muhammad sez:


:(

Offensive (depicting the prophet of Islam as a sad blue circle)? Probably to some. Worth killing this poster over? Possibly, to a very few (though no offense was meant; honestly, just a simple illustration, me thinking aloud, trying to work out where the lines are, what are the reasonable limits on free speech in a secular society).

Bill Clinton is a ***** moron.
George W Bush is a ***** moron.
The Buddha is a ***** moron.
Jesus Christ is a ***** moron.
Muhammad is a ***** moron.
Bugs Bunny is a ***** moron.
Yosemite Sam is a ***** moron.

I don't think any of those statements are true, essentially: very few of us, perhaps none of us, are perfect morons; otoh, very few of us, perhaps none of us, don't do or say 'moronic' - that is, very dumb - things sometimes. From what I've read or seen of them, each of the above in that sense was a moron sometimes; more tactfully put, all seven, to greater or lesser degrees, were human (or human-like), in their capacity for error.

However I might qualify those statements, I take it for granted there are people who will be offended by one or more of them. And yet, they all, from differing points-of-view, are fair statements to make I think, to allow for in the sometimes heated exchange of opinions that's the basis of good ol' secular democracy.

Barack Obama is a n-word.

Replace 'n-word' with the word it replaces, most publications will censor it. As is their right. A publication choosing not to repeat what it considers offensive is simply making an individual choice. As long as the government doesn't make it illegal to use racial epithets, there's no conflict with societal free speech. So not to worry.

Muhammad sez:


:(

This is free speech too. It's silly (though not pointless). It's potentially offensive. Again, any who are offended by this, I apologize. I'm just trying to illustrate something, maybe just to myself (i'm a bit slow, sometimes), as politely as possible. What? Good question. The absurdity of the ban on depictions of Muhammad, I guess. Does anyone really believe the above is worth killing someone over? If so -- I think you're taking yourself and your beliefs a little too seriously. Lighten up. You'll live longer. We all will. Peace = Islam?

Muhammad sez:


:mad:


:)
 
No, but I would want everyone involved to understand the risks they take and to make an informed choice about whether or not they are willing to take the risk.
And you don't believe in being responsible for the consequences of speech.

I have an understanding of the risks involved with being outside. I might get hit by a drunk driver. Does this somehow make me responsible if I get hit by a drunk driver?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom