Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

It's hardly shocking anymore after so many Islamic Extremist attacks over free speech issues.

One can know that actions taken may produce a specific, illegal result but that's not on them.
If religious extremists decide baseball offends then and start bombing baseball games, are we to stop playing baseball? Would playing baseball then be seen as a deliberately provocative act?

No, but planning and locating a baseball game specifically to annoy them could be viewed as such.

Religious extremists deciding they don't like the way some folks use their right to free speech is no excuse to toss away freedom of speech.
It anything else for that matter.

If it's *that* important to make your point in that way and if you think it's worth risking your life, the lives of those who are obliged to protect you and the lives of bystanders in order for you to make your point in exactly the way you want then that's your right.

Personally I think that perhaps you should think of making the same point but in a different way. Of course it may not be possible, in which case carry on..
 
The other thing about this story is how colossal a failure this attack was. For a couple of losers they seriously are losers. How to you gear up with body armor, well armed, with the element of surprise and fail so badly to one guy with a service pistol? That's incredible.

Training matters. That's the scariest part about ISIS owning land: they can put together programs for guys like these and get them proficient in weapons and tactics. (And really the only "scary" part for the West)
 
You wouldn't even object on grounds of consistency, if in fact other forms of material offensive to religion was allowed, and an exception was made only for Islam?

Yes, I might on those grounds. That's a quite logical objection.
 
No, but planning and locating a baseball game specifically to annoy them could be viewed as such.



If it's *that* important to make your point in that way and if you think it's worth risking your life, the lives of those who are obliged to protect you and the lives of bystanders in order for you to make your point in exactly the way you want then that's your right.

Personally I think that perhaps you should think of making the same point but in a different way. Of course it may not be possible, in which case carry on..

This post has more than a whiff of personalization.
Be careful of offending me! :D
 
I'm not sure what you think game theory is, but it involves something more than talking about strategies and winning and losing.

In any case, yes, you're right that people are more sensitive when it comes to offending those who react with violence. But I think you're plainly wrong when you pretend that upping the ante will cause the violence to end. What it will do is alienate more Muslims, and encourage the belief that this is broadly a battle between Islam and the West.

Let me put it in game theoretic terms. If you increase the offense caused, then that's like letting the extremists pass go three times, collecting $200 each time.

Here are a couple of reasons to continue the offence:

1) (Longer term) To show that “acting out” will not cause western society to cave in and accede to pre-Enlightenment restrictions on freedom of expression.
2) (Shorter term) If more people (say, most mainstream media) were to publish the cartoons then the jihadists would have to target everyone. There would be safety in numbers (any individual blasphemer would be likely to survive). As it is, there are only a few brave souls around the world, who can be picked off one by one (any individual blasphemer is likely to get attacked).

A second issue I’d like to raise regards your comment (which I have seen a lot): “What it will do is alienate more Muslims, and encourage the belief that this is broadly a battle between Islam and the West.”.
If that is the case then these people are terrible citizens, who are abstaining from alienation and violence because of apathy rather than because they share any of the ideals of western civil society. I certainly hope that’s not true of many folks living in the west.
 
Training matters. That's the scariest part about ISIS owning land: they can put together programs for guys like these and get them proficient in weapons and tactics. (And really the only "scary" part for the West)

We can drone the **** out of them.

Which actually brings up the point that scares me: individual drone attacks are going to be a thing.
 
You mean where you said:

"Meh? I'm not victim blaming. Geller wasn't a victim, nor was Wilder. They are just hateful individuals. Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. But it doesn't change the fact that Geller and Wilder are hateful bigoted miscreants."

To highlight: "Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. "

That sounds like equivalence to me.

And that ^^^^^ sounds like desperation to me. You so want to have an argument with someone who is saying the things you've been practicing for that you're inventing the argument where there is none. Do I have to say:

Isamic Terrorist Murders get a minus ten. Geller and Wilders and their ilk only get a minus 8. Geller and Wilders are better than Islamic Terrorist Murderers by two whole points. You hear, "not as bad as but still pretty bad" and you want to turn it into "So? Very close. Why do you love terrorists." Play that game with someone else.
 
You edited while I was responding, but I'll respond: what if the sluttily-dressed, slutty slut drives home drunk and drugged after the gang-rape? Innocents are now in play. Your move.

Another false equivalence, since the event organizer were note engaging in deliberately reckless behaviour, violating both laws and common sense. In a civilized society composed of rational adults, no amount of "blasphemy", ridicule, or insult should ever be considered justification for violence. Unfortunately, there is a substantial minority of people who are not sufficiently rational and mature enough to acknowledge that. There is no society where driving impaired is ever rational or mature.
 
Erm...they are utter pigs and got what they deserved. But what can be more important than the safety of ordinary people who just happened to be around. Do you think the calousness about their safety so that the organisers can vent their bile and actually gloat that "they had it coming" was justified?

You know, if we all give in and become fundamentalist Muslims, then we will all be a lot safer from the fanatic Islamists.
 
Which suggests that she wanted what happened to have happened. And this would negate any possibility of collateral fatalities? I am thankful no one else was hurt, but it is a bit of a reach to feed your own ego isn't it?

Or perhaps she hired them as a precaution against a possible attack, having received numerous threats of harm in the past?

You know, like nearly all major politicians and public figures do.
 
You know, if we all give in and become fundamentalist Muslims, then we will all be a lot safer from the fanatic Islamists.

Except that other Muslims are often killed by extremists as well as unbelievers.
 
And that ^^^^^ sounds like desperation to me. You so want to have an argument with someone who is saying the things you've been practicing for that you're inventing the argument where there is none. Do I have to say:

Isamic Terrorist Murders get a minus ten. Geller and Wilders and their ilk only get a minus 8. Geller and Wilders are better than Islamic Terrorist Murderers by two whole points. You hear, "not as bad as but still pretty bad" and you want to turn it into "So? Very close. Why do you love terrorists." Play that game with someone else.

Ooh, you changed it from:

"Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No."

To

"not as bad as but still pretty bad"

Your first statement only says that Pamela Geller isn't any worse than murderous scum. Your second statement says that she is slightly better.

Perhaps you should write more clearly?
 
The other thing about this story is how colossal a failure this attack was. For a couple of losers they seriously are losers. How to you gear up with body armor, well armed, with the element of surprise and fail so badly to one guy with a service pistol? That's incredible.

I agree. It's stunning. Either that cop is one hell of a bad ass, or those two idiots did something to piss off Allah.

Another interesting thing to note is that because the gunmen were unsuccessful, the event isn't considered all that newsworthy. The original story of the attack appeared on page A14 of the NY Times, if the reference under the online article can be believed. Compare and contrast to the way the story would have been run and told and explored if the gunmen had been even half as successful as the Charlie Hebdo gunmen.

I'm not surprised. It's human nature to downplay or ignore events that merely had the potential to be extraordinarily dramatic but turned into a fizzle. But it's something to bear in mind. Just because this time the terrorists ended up being made to look like clowns doesn't mean they actually were clowns. Or that they had a low probability of success.
 
Except that other Muslims are often killed by extremists as well as unbelievers.

That's why it's important to become an extremist and start killing apostates, so that your own faith is deemed beyond reproach. Of course, if the probability of getting a drone missile up the ass becomes too high, you might want to switch sides again.
 
Nope, ideally I would want you to be ib court and facing charges. But if there is no other way, you and you ilk go down in a hail of bullets. However, if the sisters actually set this up, knowing you would be coming and will do what you do, then they also have to be charged with reckless endangerment.

So better that they all disband, stop being so flagrantly and openly gay, go back to being closeted and secretive about their sexual identity; and everything will be perfect and happy.

Sorry, but no. That is beyond cowardly. That is reprehensible blame-the-victim rhetoric. People have a right to be who they are, as long as they are not harming anyone else. The responsibility for any harm caused by violent bigots and intolerant fundamentalists rests solely and entirely on the violent bigots and intolerant fundamentalists. To say otherwise is vile victim-blaming.

People have a responsibility to respect the rights of others, all equally. Those who don't are the problem, not those who refused to be cowed and beaten down.

If a man puts a gun to your head, and demands that you choose a friend or family member for him to kill, with the proviso that if you refuse to choose a specific person, that he will kill them all, who has responsibility for the deaths? Do you accept responsibility, despite being under unreasonable duress? If so, that's stupid. The only threat is from the man with the gun. There's a name for the fallacy that you're committing, but I can't recall it off the top of my head.
 
And that ^^^^^ sounds like desperation to me. You so want to have an argument with someone who is saying the things you've been practicing for that you're inventing the argument where there is none. Do I have to say:

Isamic Terrorist Murders get a minus ten. Geller and Wilders and their ilk only get a minus 8. Geller and Wilders are better than Islamic Terrorist Murderers by two whole points. You hear, "not as bad as but still pretty bad" and you want to turn it into "So? Very close. Why do you love terrorists." Play that game with someone else.

Sheesh. Sounds pretty close to me. I guess it depends on what your scale is. I might agree with you if the scale runs from Charles Manson at -10.5 to Jessica Alba at -7.5.
 
Yes I do. I would certainly be more careful about it if I knew the offense I was causing rose to the level of inciting violence against me though. To ignore that consequence would be an error on my part.
Which means that those who are most prone to violence are the de facto rulers of your society. Do you insist that doctors and clinics should stop providing abortions, because of the risk to innocent bystanders in clinic bombings?

Yes, I see the difference. I added a line to improve it further.
So you support expelling someone for calling someone else names, just because his target was more willing to become violent? That's beyond cowardly.

This thread seems to be heavy on the freedoms bit, but light on the responsibility part.

We have no responsibility to bow to bigots and oppressors, just because they are more willing to use violent force. By that logic, India should still be ruled by the British; and people in general should never rise up against oppressive dictators. We should all just cower in our homes and pay the Dane as much as he wants to leave us alone.
 
I think that there is a moral distinction in the manner in which offense is caused.

Sometimes, one causes an offense as an unintended, though foreseeable, side effect of his actions. For instance, when we discuss Islam, we may well offend some Muslims, maybe even in ways we can foresee, but our intention is to discuss the issue, not to cause offense.

On the other hand, sometimes we cause offense intentionally, either because the offense is the end we desire (we just want to piss off somebody) or because it is a means to our end (we want to piss off someone so they react and others can see their reaction, or we want to piss off Muslims so they become used to the degradation and stop reacting).

I think that when the offense is itself the end pursued, the action is least defensible. Similarly, when causing offense is the means, it is less defensible than the case in which causing offense is a side effect of an otherwise unobjectionable act.

I don't know exactly what this competition was about, but my guess is that it was aiming for offense either as a means or an end, whereas examples involving this forum imagine the offense as a foreseeable side effect.

(These distinctions are commonly introduced in Catholic moral teachings as the doctrine of double effect, but one need not buy the context of their use in theology to conclude that there is a real moral difference to be considered here.)

I agree that there's a moral distinction in the manner in which the offense is caused, but I don't think it's clear cut. If someone tells you that your discussion offends them, and that they will kill you if you don't stop, you might decide to continue the discussion anyway. But even if you continue the discussion for the purpose of discussion, you are now intentionally giving offense. And the violent extremist doesn't care about your moral distinction. He only cares that you kept going after he told you to stop.

What's more, you may decide to continue the discussion not only for its own sake, but also as a form of protest against thugs who see threats of violence as a legitimate way to silence your speech.

If you see the extremism as especially pernicious or detrimental to society, you may decide to present instances of your discussion primarily as a public display of protest, to make people aware of the problem and encourage them to think about it more deeply and seriously.

All of this is, I think, legitimate in response to threats of violence as a means of silencing speech. And to the violent extremist, the nuances of moral distinction you make are meaningless. He was already prepared to kill you just because of the discussion for discussion's sake. Against a person like that, who would kill your speech by killing you, why shouldn't you protest by word and by deed? Why shouldn't you make your discussion--a legitimate act of free people everywhere--a public protest? And why shouldn't you intend to meet violent extremists with deadly force, if deadly force is what they bring to your protest?

I'm not saying you have to protest. I'm not saying you have to invite a violent confrontation with extremists, nor that you have to intend to win such a confrontation. I'm not saying it's cowardly to silence your discussion rather than trigger the ire of violent extremists. I'm not saying it's morally depraved to counsel cooperation with their demands.

What I am saying is that I don't see many options for civilized people, once violence is threatened as a way to suppress human rights. One option is to cooperate in suppressing your rights, and hope that this satisfies your oppressor. There are probably a lot of people in ISIS-controlled territory right now who are testing with their lives the benefits of cooperation and hope.

Another option is to fight, to protest, to bring to public light the conflict between you and your oppressor. This also has limitations. I'm not saying you should choose to fight, but rather that you should not condemn those who do. Discussion as a public protest against threats of violence is just as morally legitimate as discussion for its own sake, even if--especially if--there is a real risk of violence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom