Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

"If you insult Mahomet you have to expect that someone will try to kill you" is what the deep thinkers are telling us. It's also what the people who are trying(and succeeding) to kill people for insulting Mahomet are telling us. Is there anything else that should be capitulated preemptively? In some places refusing to wear a veil gets acid thrown in a woman's face. Maybe she should have just worn a veil right? I mean, she had to have known, right?

I would like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting a long-dead, murderous pedophile. I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from insulting the long-dead, murderous pedophile doesn't really seem like the best strategy.
 
How else do you handle a couple of loons who drove from two states away and jump out of their car guns-a-blazin'? Tea?

Do you wait until they shoot a security guard and maybe even kill someone else before you attempt to deal with the problem? Or is the Wild West exchange-of-gunfire method your only proposed solution?
 
I was thinking more along the lines of dealing with them before they get to the "hopping out of the car with guns and opening fire" stage.

You can't. Most people don't need to be educated on the subject of mass murder is wrong. But there will always be some who just don't get that. Unless your idea is for everybody to be on their bestest behavior all the time, treading oh so very lightly as to not possibly offend anybody in any way. Where does that lead? Because it won't end with Mahomet cartoons.
 
Awhile back a Christian woman destroyed a Satanic Christmas display. Did that prove anything? If she had attempted to kill the creator of said work what would that prove?

But she didn't. And that's the point.
 
I would like to live in a world where I wouldn't expect to be targeted for violence for insulting a long-dead, murderous pedophile. I am even willing to give up a measure of personal safety to make that happen. How should I go about it? Refraining from insulting the long-dead, murderous pedophile doesn't really seem like the best strategy.

If you really want to jump that train, head to a big city street corner and become known for handing out images of the Prophet. It's becoming a lock that some nut will attack you. Might not make much news though unless you have a bunch of friends with you doing it as well.
Good luck soldier
 
Last edited:
As A'isha has clarified, obviously, the problem is one of prevention, not what actions are reasonable once the bullets are flying.

Perhaps you honestly misread her point, but it seemed pretty obvious to me.

Don't try to kill lots of people over an insult. Be the bigger man and walk away. I don't know what else you want, I ain't their daddy. Those are ideas that they should have taught years ago.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.
 
Awhile back a Christian woman destroyed a Satanic Christmas display. Did that prove anything? If she had attempted to kill the creator of said work what would that prove?

"That would prove that you don't have 1st amendment rights to offend Christians" - Some poorly formed logic.
 
The other thing about this story is how colossal a failure this attack was. For a couple of losers they seriously are losers. How to you gear up with body armor, well armed, with the element of surprise and fail so badly to one guy with a service pistol? That's incredible.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.

Huh?

We can make statements that offend Islam here.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.

Did you ever miss the target with that post.
 
You can't. Most people don't need to be educated on the subject of mass murder is wrong. But there will always be some who just don't get that. Unless your idea is for everybody to be on their bestest behavior all the time, treading oh so very lightly as to not possibly offend anybody in any way.

It's not.

Are those really the only two options you can come up with? "Trust everyone not to mass-murder", and "Hope that when they open fire you can shoot back fast enough to keep them from killing anyone"?

You do realize that the authorities currently investigate potential mass shootings and terrorist attacks in an effort to prevent them from happening, right?
 
Don't try to kill lots of people over an insult. Be the bigger man and walk away. I don't know what else you want, I ain't their daddy. Those are ideas that they should have taught years ago.

Yeah, okay. Nothing else to be said then. These things happen.
 
You can't.

Not exactly. It's more correct to say that we haven't figured out how to. This is another example of a "known wolf" attack. The guy was already on our radar as a threat, we just didn't know what to do about him. Completely out-of-the-blue attacks are indeed hard to prevent, but most of the recent terrorist attacks in the west involve people who had already shown danger signs before.
 
People are posting their support for the actions of a hate group on a forum where incivility can get you banned. These same posters willingly submit to restrictions on their language and the images they can post here.

Oh, the tasty irony. Come, let me lick your salty-sweet outrage tears.

What irony?

It is one thing to accept that speech restrictions on a private internet forum make for better discussion, and another to argue that hateful political speech should be restricted in the public sphere.

You seem to be conflating two quite distinct opinions.
 
That's just to keep people from getting jealous.

The four arms make me jealous. The possibilities for self-gratification boggle my noodle. (Which could be rephrased as "the possibilities for boggling my noodle!")
 
I disagree. "Eroding" is too strong. Images of Mohammed weren't even a "thing" a couple of decades ago. They've only become worth drawing because of the reaction they get.

Not drawing Mohammed is equivalent to not using the n-word. We aren't suffering an erosion of our free speech because of it - we find other ways to say what we want. So too with the Mohammed pictures - there are other ways to express ideas and not drawing cartoons of Mohammed doesn't damage our overall free speech rights one bit.

Regardless of your overall point, with which I disagree, I think that drawing a picture that may or may not look like Mohammed is quite different from using the n-word. Rather, I think it's equivalent to using the word "niggardly" or the word "boy" or the word "thug" or perhaps using the n-word in a non-offensive context, or in the privacy of one's own home. Almost all reasonable people (using my definition of "reasonable" I'll admit) would consider it an innocuous enough action per se and not invidious at all, except for the fact that there's this shockingly aberrant response from time to time.

I am not allowed to use profanity on this forum. I do not feel my ability to express myself is limited by this restriction. If images of Mohammed were prohibited here, I would have even less cause to object to that.

You wouldn't even object on grounds of consistency, if in fact other forms of material offensive to religion was allowed, and an exception was made only for Islam?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom