Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

If a religious group were to DDOS attack us here and shut us down, would you think that the best thing to do would be to not offend religious groups, and delete posts, suspend, ban members who express opinions which might offend said group?
What if we became a target?

I think that there is a moral distinction in the manner in which offense is caused.

Sometimes, one causes an offense as an unintended, though foreseeable, side effect of his actions. For instance, when we discuss Islam, we may well offend some Muslims, maybe even in ways we can foresee, but our intention is to discuss the issue, not to cause offense.

On the other hand, sometimes we cause offense intentionally, either because the offense is the end we desire (we just want to piss off somebody) or because it is a means to our end (we want to piss off someone so they react and others can see their reaction, or we want to piss off Muslims so they become used to the degradation and stop reacting).

I think that when the offense is itself the end pursued, the action is least defensible. Similarly, when causing offense is the means, it is less defensible than the case in which causing offense is a side effect of an otherwise unobjectionable act.

I don't know exactly what this competition was about, but my guess is that it was aiming for offense either as a means or an end, whereas examples involving this forum imagine the offense as a foreseeable side effect.

(These distinctions are commonly introduced in Catholic moral teachings as the doctrine of double effect, but one need not buy the context of their use in theology to conclude that there is a real moral difference to be considered here.)
 
I don't think you were arguing that, and my apologies if it seemed I implied that.

But at least one person (Caper) clearly suggested this strategy, and Sunmaster
suggested that the net effect of Geller's work may be positive, because Muslims will stop fighting back if someone continues to intentionally offend them.

The outrage is at least some what selective. They act out because it works. Large amounts of the mainstream media won't print the cartoons. There will not be a "life of brian" or "book of mormon" regarding islam.

Looking at it from a game theory perspective, the Islamist strategy is clearly being successful in eroding the west's free speech.
 
I don't think anyone is shocked.
Except maybe the two nutjobs, briefly, when their attack was shut down so quickly.

They were looking to stir the pot, not to have idiots pull up and try to shoot up the place.

Well which is it ?

Were they expecting an attack (and so weren't shocked) or were they just stirring the pot (in which case terrorists turning up and shooting the place up would come as a bit of a shock) ?

If they had grounds to expect that their (perfectly legal) actions would result in a terrorist attack, did they have the right to endanger the lives of the law enforcement officers who were there to protect them ?
 
Should a-holes have free speech rights, or not? Would those be the same rights that you expect for yourself?

Never, not one time in my history posting here have I ever advocated against someone's free speech rights. I'm simply saying folks have a CHOICE. They don't HAVE to provoke the worlds biggest hateful, ignorant morons. They can choose not to.

These people CHOSE to provoke militant islamic children and paid for it. Is there any way I can be more clear?

Don't be a dick.

It's THAT SIMPLE.
 
"If you insult Mahomet you have to expect that someone will try to kill you" is what the deep thinkers are telling us. It's also what the people who are trying(and succeeding) to kill people for insulting Mahomet are telling us. Is there anything else that should be capitulated preemptively? In some places refusing to wear a veil gets acid thrown in a woman's face. Maybe she should have just worn a veil right? I mean, she had to have known, right?
 
If I were likely to get shot for posting on this forum, I wouldn't post on this forum. That is so regardless of the justification or lack of justification of the shooter. I am just as dead either way.

Doesn't it depend upon how likely you are to get shot? What if it was 1 in 100,000? What if your probability of getting shot were inversely proportional to the number of people posting on the forum? Would you feel an obligation to post on the forum to make it safer for everybody else too? How would you respond to a post composed of nothing but a series of questions?
 
Yes, that's probably the question she had in mind. Good job. A real contribution to the discussion.

How else do you handle a couple of loons who drove from two states away and jump out of their car guns-a-blazin'? Tea?
 
The outrage is at least some what selective. They act out because it works. Large amounts of the mainstream media won't print the cartoons. There will not be a "life of brian" or "book of mormon" regarding islam.

Looking at it from a game theory perspective, the Islamist strategy is clearly being successful in eroding the west's free speech.

I'm not sure what you think game theory is, but it involves something more than talking about strategies and winning and losing.

In any case, yes, you're right that people are more sensitive when it comes to offending those who react with violence. But I think you're plainly wrong when you pretend that upping the ante will cause the violence to end. What it will do is alienate more Muslims, and encourage the belief that this is broadly a battle between Islam and the West.

Let me put it in game theoretic terms. If you increase the offense caused, then that's like letting the extremists pass go three times, collecting $200 each time.
 
Awhile back a Christian woman destroyed a Satanic Christmas display. Did that prove anything? If she had attempted to kill the creator of said work what would that prove?
 
Well which is it ?

Were they expecting an attack (and so weren't shocked) or were they just stirring the pot (in which case terrorists turning up and shooting the place up would come as a bit of a shock) ?

If they had grounds to expect that their (perfectly legal) actions would result in a terrorist attack, did they have the right to endanger the lives of the law enforcement officers who were there to protect them ?

It's hardly shocking anymore after so many Islamic Extremist attacks over free speech issues.

One can know that actions taken may produce a specific, illegal result but that's not on them.
If religious extremists decide baseball offends then and start bombing baseball games, are we to stop playing baseball? Would playing baseball then be seen as a deliberately provocative act?
Religious extremists deciding they don't like the way some folks use their right to free speech is no excuse to toss away freedom of speech.
It anything else for that matter.
 
How else do you handle a couple of loons who drove from two states away and jump out of their car guns-a-blazin'? Tea?

As A'isha has clarified, obviously, the problem is one of prevention, not what actions are reasonable once the bullets are flying.

Perhaps you honestly misread her point, but it seemed pretty obvious to me.
 
The outrage is at least some what selective. They act out because it works. Large amounts of the mainstream media won't print the cartoons. There will not be a "life of brian" or "book of mormon" regarding islam.

Looking at it from a game theory perspective, the Islamist strategy is clearly being successful in eroding the west's free speech.

I disagree. "Eroding" is too strong. Images of Mohammed weren't even a "thing" a couple of decades ago. They've only become worth drawing because of the reaction they get.

Not drawing Mohammed is equivalent to not using the n-word. We aren't suffering an erosion of our free speech because of it - we find other ways to say what we want. So too with the Mohammed pictures - there are other ways to express ideas and not drawing cartoons of Mohammed doesn't damage our overall free speech rights one bit.

I am not allowed to use profanity on this forum. I do not feel my ability to express myself is limited by this restriction. If images of Mohammed were prohibited here, I would have even less cause to object to that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom