Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Right. Could be that.

Or could be that your applications of game theory are all wet, that intentionally offending Muslims will increase the antagonism, encourage radicalization and serve no real purpose aside from losing the good will of the majority of Muslims.

I think you filled the numbers in your li'l game theory grid all wrong.

We could turn up the dial with bacon and pulled-pork sandwiches. Cooked over a bar-b-q fueled with Korans. Lots of room to generate rancor. What the anti-muslims need is a bit more creativity.
 
Since I'm not a lawyer, how does what you say here square with "fighting words?" Do I contribute to my own punched nose if I call the large Mexican a "filthy wetback?"

You are adding a component of mitigation where no one is suggesting that. There unfortunately is an unwritten code of that in law enforcement that is horrible. But that isn't the crowd on these forums.

Here is a more clear example of my thoughts. Suppose you were guaranteed punishment. Then the choice is not be the victim of a crime, or be a victim and the perpetrator gets death or life in prison. What do you prefer? That is the question security and risk experts are trying to address: not being the victim.
 
No kidding.

But it does.

So maybe don't do it? If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.

Seems pretty simple to me.

If a religious group were to DDOS attack us here and shut us down, would you think that the best thing to do would be to not offend religious groups, and delete posts, suspend, ban members who express opinions which might offend said group?
What if we became a target?
 
Violent extremists can't be "acclimated" like that. That's part of what makes them violent extremists.

But the problem is violent extremists, and not your "average believer". Before this event, Muslims in the area were telling each other to ignore Geller and not even dignify her event with a reaction. Despite Texas having one of the largest Muslim populations in the US, about 500,000, none of them attacked the event or even held a protest of any kind outside. The shooters had to come from two states away, from Arizona.

The difficulty is, what do you do about that problem? Even if every single one of half a million Muslims in the area decides to completely ignore Geller and her little hatefest (and they did), how do you deal with two random ******** from somewhere else entirely deciding to take a jihadi road trip like that?

I think it was handled fine by shooting them to death in the street.
 
No kidding.

But it does.

So maybe don't do it? If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.

Seems pretty simple to me.

Indeed: surrender to the demands of violent maniacs, and they won't hurt you. Very simple.

Nevertheless, no thanks.
 
If a religious group were to DDOS attack us here and shut us down, would you think that the best thing to do would be to not offend religious groups, and delete posts, suspend, ban members who express opinions which might offend said group?
What if we became a target?

If I were likely to get shot for posting on this forum, I wouldn't post on this forum. That is so regardless of the justification or lack of justification of the shooter. I am just as dead either way.
 
If a religious group were to DDOS attack us here and shut us down, would you think that the best thing to do would be to not offend religious groups, and delete posts, suspend, ban members who express opinions which might offend said group?
What if we became a target?

Then again if there was a religious group which was renowned for carrying out DDOS attacks, if we deliberately go out to provoke them (rather than just carrying out business as usual) then we shouldn't act shocked when the DDOS happens.

Likewise if I walk into a Rangers pub in green and white hoops and start singing nationalist songs I should not be shocked when I get the **** kicked out of me. That's not to say that the Rangers supporters aren't 100% in the wrong and that I should be able to do what I just did but maybe I should pause for reflection to see whether I absolutely needed to do it (and whether I also needed to put the members of the emergency services in danger to protect me and retrieve my beaten body from the pub).
 
No kidding.

But it does.

So maybe don't do it? If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.

Seems pretty simple to me.


There's another reason to do it. If you refrain from doing it because of a threat from people who insist you follow the strictures of their religion, then you have surrendered your rights to free speech.

Yes, I think that Geller and crew are a-holes, because they are known and demonstrated bigots. But I also fully support their right to do the Mohammed drawing thing. Because, believe it or not, they are defending my right to draw Mohammed if I see fit. Do I see fit to draw Mohammed? No. I have no immediate plans to do so. But I sure don't want to be in a position where I could not do it if I wanted to.
 
Then again if there was a religious group which was renowned for carrying out DDOS attacks, if we deliberately go out to provoke them (rather than just carrying out business as usual) then we shouldn't act shocked when the DDOS happens.

This is perhaps an experiment we could do with 4Chan.
 
I think it was handled fine by shooting them to death in the street.

A'isha's post is a good one and thought provoking.

However, I agree with your analysis as well. I'm not blood thirsty but there's a line being drawn.
 
And as a scientific thinker, I am surprised that you do not see the clear cause and effect on offer. We've seen the experiments done already. We have news reports of insulting artwork inciting attacks by extremists. How is it that we shouldn't expect a repeat of the experiment to yield similar results?

Do you not understand the difference between expecting a result and justifying the result?

We can expect that if you are Jewish, then Nazis will try to kill you. You are not therefore asking for it if you are or become Jewish.

Is it because there is a probabilistic relationship instead of a 100% correlation?

No, it's because the violent response, regardless of how predictable, is completely unjustified, and furthermore, because the action which prompted it is something which should be protected in any civilized society.

And, the people attacked make it their business to point out just how violent and reactionary Muslims are to things like images of the prophets. They absolutely are immersed in this idea. They are, in a sense, the very social scientists you'd consult if you wanted to know how Muslim extremists would respond to the event they held.

And they were right. So what's your point?

It is absolutely a clear case of eliciting a certain response to support an agenda.

Quite so. And?
 
There's another reason to do it. If you refrain from doing it because of a threat from people who insist you follow the strictures of their religion, then you have surrendered your rights to free speech.

Yes, I think that Geller and crew are a-holes, because they are known and demonstrated bigots. But I also fully support their right to do the Mohammed drawing thing. Because, believe it or not, they are defending my right to draw Mohammed if I see fit. Do I see fit to draw Mohammed? No. I have no immediate plans to do so. But I sure don't want to be in a position where I could not do it if I wanted to.

But could the same thing be done in a way which isn't so offensive ? Should people be encouraged to behave in ways which gets their message across in a way which isn't as offensive to other people ? I'm not suggesting that people be prevented from behaving offensively (unless it amounts to inciting violence) but that they be encouraged to behave in a less offensive way.
 
For a few this has got to be the only subject on this forum where victim blaming is acceptable.

I think we need a new term. I hear the word "victim" and I see an innocent person violated in some way.

These people got what they were looking for.

There must be some sort of distinction. There has to be.
 
Then again if there was a religious group which was renowned for carrying out DDOS attacks, if we deliberately go out to provoke them (rather than just carrying out business as usual) then we shouldn't act shocked when the DDOS happens.

Likewise if I walk into a Rangers pub in green and white hoops and start singing nationalist songs I should not be shocked when I get the **** kicked out of me. That's not to say that the Rangers supporters aren't 100% in the wrong and that I should be able to do what I just did but maybe I should pause for reflection to see whether I absolutely needed to do it (and whether I also needed to put the members of the emergency services in danger to protect me and retrieve my beaten body from the pub).

I don't think anyone is shocked.
Except maybe the two nutjobs, briefly, when their attack was shut down so quickly.
 
If a religious group were to DDOS attack us here and shut us down, would you think that the best thing to do would be to not offend religious groups, and delete posts, suspend, ban members who express opinions which might offend said group?
What if we became a target?

If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.
 
I think we need a new term. I hear the word "victim" and I see an innocent person violated in some way.

These people got what they were looking for.

There must be some sort of distinction. There has to be.

They were looking to stir the pot, not to have idiots pull up and try to shoot up the place.
 
There's another reason to do it. If you refrain from doing it because of a threat from people who insist you follow the strictures of their religion, then you have surrendered your rights to free speech.

Wrong.
I have made a choice.

I have chosen not to be an a-hole.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom