Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

My point is that education and social comfort and economic advantage does not seem to be a barrier where Islamic terrorism is concerned.

In most Muslim countries, education and social comfort/economic advantage are not correlated. Because university education is free, there's not the same economic barrier to higher education like there is in places like the US. As a result, there are a large number of highly-educated young people, but no corresponding demand for the skills and education those people have (in Egypt, the unemployment rate for university graduates is ten times that of people who did not attend university), resulting in large numbers of unemployed (and therefore poor and disgruntled) well-educated young people. And when there are a lot of poor and dissatisfied people with no prospects for better opportunities causing a lot of social unrest, there are a lot of potential terrorist recruits.

And the Muslim community as a whole is exclusive of terrorism. A train is blown up in Spain and instead of completely condemning the horror they slip in things like "ah but George bush" or "Balkan killings" to excuse the killers.

http://theamericanmuslim.org/tam.ph...n-attack-on-anti-islam-event-in-texas/0020396

Mass mobs loudly celebrate any terror attack openly. They are never countered from within the Muslim community.

Tens of thousands of Pakistanis took to the streets of Karachi to support Malala Yousafzai and condemn the Taliban after she was shot, and Muslims in Portland were going to hold a rally to celebrate the death of Osama Bin Laden but canceled it after vandalism of a mosque in Maine made them concerned about similar reprisals against their community.
 
How can anyone call drawings of a dead child molester a"hate fest". That would be like getting upset over a drawing of jimmy savile.
 
Yes they can. We're not talking about "senseless" violence like a drunken barfight that escalates to a shooting, or a deranged loner who shoots up a school or a post office. This is violence with a purpose. The purpose is to intimidate people to respect the rules of a particular religion. If it doesn't work, or, in fact, if it has the opposite effect of causing even greater disrespect, then the perfectly rational (albeit evil from my perspective) extremists behind the violence will move on to more practical goals.

The thing that really annoyed me about the Benghazi incident was the blame put on the "offensive" Youtube video. Sure, the video was promoted by jihadists in the Islamic world in order to stir up outrage, but the fact is, it was all pretext, and everybody (especially Hillary Clinton) should have known that. There are literally thousands of Youtube videos showing the Koran being burned or defaced or flushed down the toilet. There are probably millions of videos showing things that are deeply offensive to Muslims. Are extremists attacking Google and trying to get them to take those videos down? No, because it would be like trying to knock down a brick wall with your head. It's a hopeless goal, and they don't even try.

If enough of the violent lunatics are killed before they can spawn, the reasonable will be left to reproduce. I think this is how it ends.
 
And did you rape her?

Because if you didn't, well, your actions weren't equivalent to the jihadis' actions in any way, shape, or form.

I'm guessing you didn't rape her, and that you're just making stupid arguments for an indefensible position.

And as a scientific thinker, I am surprised that you do not see the clear cause and effect on offer. We've seen the experiments done already. We have news reports of insulting artwork inciting attacks by extremists. How is it that we shouldn't expect a repeat of the experiment to yield similar results?

Is it because there is a probabilistic relationship instead of a 100% correlation? Is it because you think, as moral agents, human beings are not predictable? But surely, being moral agents, we can predict consistent morals and consistent reactions based on historical moral judgements.

And, the people attacked make it their business to point out just how violent and reactionary Muslims are to things like images of the prophets. They absolutely are immersed in this idea. They are, in a sense, the very social scientists you'd consult if you wanted to know how Muslim extremists would respond to the event they held.

It is absolutely a clear case of eliciting a certain response to support an agenda. If I want to show how crazy Christians can be, I'm not going to go and film a quiet talk with a theologian. No, that won't do. Instead, I'm going to film a crazy-Christian camp, and maybe even up the ante by exclaiming how much of a fraud Jesus was. I know I can incite a certain response because I know my enemy.
 
If enough of the violent lunatics are killed before they can spawn, the reasonable will be left to reproduce. I think this is how it ends.

Unless, of course, some persons are not radical because they are born to radicals, but rather become radicalized over time. Perhaps because, oh, I don't know, they see well-publicized examples of deeply offensive and insulting acts directed at their faith for the sole reason of acclimatizing them to the degradation.

I just don't understand how some people think the way to end the violence is to be intentionally offensive to a very large number of Muslims.
 
Unless, of course, some persons are not radical because they are born to radicals, but rather become radicalized over time. Perhaps because, oh, I don't know, they see well-publicized examples of deeply offensive and insulting acts directed at their faith for the sole reason of acclimatizing them to the degradation.

I just don't understand how some people think the way to end the violence is to be intentionally offensive to a very large number of Muslims.

Well to be fair, I don't think anyone is arguing that.
 
The difficulty is, what do you do about that problem? Even if every single one of half a million Muslims in the area decides to completely ignore Geller and her little hatefest (and they did), how do you deal with two random ******** from somewhere else entirely deciding to take a jihadi road trip like that?

Nuke all the Muslims from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.

Seriously, though, one of the most obvious and simplest things we can do is acknowledge the very important distinction between the Muslims who tolerate disagreement and those who react to disagreement with violence. I don't mean to sidetrack the topic here, but one of the most poisonous ideas in this discussion is the view that all Muslims are terrorists. Besides the fact that this is simply untrue, it hampers our ability to ask that tolerant Muslims criticize the dangerous ideas in Islam from within.

The prospect of validation versus scorn, particularly among one's peers, is a powerful driving force in the decision-making process. Fundamentalists may be above evidence and logic, but they are not above basic psychology.
 
If enough of the violent lunatics are killed before they can spawn, the reasonable will be left to reproduce. I think this is how it ends.

No, it's not a genetic thing, and the extremists are not irrational at all. It comes down to game theory, and we're not playing it right. Or rather most of us aren't playing it right, or don't want to play it right. Sugar might catch more flies than vinegar, but it's the wrong tool to use when the flies are trying to kill you.
 
Yes they can. We're not talking about "senseless" violence like a drunken barfight that escalates to a shooting, or a deranged loner who shoots up a school or a post office. This is violence with a purpose.

Yes, which is why I never said they were senseless or undirected, but fanatical.
 
No, it's not a genetic thing, and the extremists are not irrational at all. It comes down to game theory, and we're not playing it right. Or rather most of us aren't playing it right, or don't want to play it right. Sugar might catch more flies than vinegar, but it's the wrong tool to use when the flies are trying to kill you.

Can't argue against this.
I see a huge problem in Islamic extremism and no mechanism to correct it, which worries me but will worry our descendants more
 
Then why do you keep referring to them as "insulting" cartoons? How could the attackers have been "insulted?"

One is not supposed to draw the Prophet, and the act of doing so is broadly seen as offensive. My landlord for example is Muslim and couldn't give a rat's ass about such things though he may find it distasteful. Then there's the other end of that spectrum, the one with nutjobs who have "plans".
 
Unless, of course, some persons are not radical because they are born to radicals, but rather become radicalized over time. Perhaps because, oh, I don't know, they see well-publicized examples of deeply offensive and insulting acts directed at their faith for the sole reason of acclimatizing them to the degradation.

It doesn't matter. Such examples are always going to be available for Jihadist leaders to use as a pretext. They can even manufacture such examples themselves. There's absolutely no need for them to be real. What dissuades people from jihadist violence is the enhanced likelihood of negative consequences (e.g. discomfort, pain, humiliation and death). The Arab world, in particular, with its focus on honor and shame is particularly attuned to signals of weakness or strength. The culture celebrates and respects the strong horse and degrades, and even hates, the weak horse. Our problem is that we act like the weak horse too much.

I just don't understand how some people think the way to end the violence is to be intentionally offensive to a very large number of Muslims.

Probably because you haven't thought about it deeply enough.
 
Some folk don't seem to get it. Drawings of a guy who has been dead for 1400yrs should not cause violence. The reason why they were drawn,or who drew them are irrelevant. They are drawings-thats it-just drawings. Those that are upset over them are 100% to blame for there own moronic emotions and behaviour. Those that inflict violence over drawings are lower than fecal matter.
 
Then why do you keep referring to them as "insulting" cartoons? How could the attackers have been "insulted?"

I believe what they say - generally, not these specific attackers. I believe it because I understand that "insult" is subjective and the best way to see if the word applies is to see how the insulted acts/reacts.

I understand the n-word is insulting. It is not offensive to me. It is probably not universally offensive to blacks either. However, I believe that some black people are highly offended by it.

I have no inside information on the motivations of the attackers in this instance. I have been discussing it based on what seems to be the assumption in this thread that they were Muslims responding to the actions of this hate group. The group had publicized their intent to award a prize (I think $10,000) for the best cartoon depiction of Mohammed - to be judged and awarded at this event. But you are correct, I do not know what was going on in the attackers' heads.
 
It doesn't matter. Such examples are always going to be available for Jihadist leaders to use as a pretext. They can even manufacture such examples themselves. There's absolutely no need for them to be real. What dissuades people from jihadist violence is the enhanced likelihood of negative consequences (e.g. discomfort, pain, humiliation and death). The Arab world, in particular, with its focus on honor and shame is particularly attuned to signals of weakness or strength. The culture celebrates and respects the strong horse and degrades, and even hates, the weak horse. Our problem is that we act like the weak horse too much.



Probably because you haven't thought about it deeply enough.

Right. Could be that.

Or could be that your applications of game theory are all wet, that intentionally offending Muslims will increase the antagonism, encourage radicalization and serve no real purpose aside from losing the good will of the majority of Muslims.

I think you filled the numbers in your li'l game theory grid all wrong.
 
Some folk don't seem to get it. Drawings of a guy who has been dead for 1400yrs should not cause violence. The reason why they were drawn,or who drew them are irrelevant. They are drawings-thats it-just drawings. Those that are upset over them are 100% to blame for there own moronic emotions and behaviour. Those that inflict violence over drawings are lower than fecal matter.

No kidding.

But it does.

So maybe don't do it? If the ONLY reason you're doing it is to be an a-hole, maybe try not being an a-hole.

Seems pretty simple to me.
 
Some folk don't seem to get it. Drawings of a guy who has been dead for 1400yrs should not cause violence. The reason why they were drawn,or who drew them are irrelevant. They are drawings-thats it-just drawings. Those that are upset over them are 100% to blame for there own moronic emotions and behaviour. Those that inflict violence over drawings are lower than fecal matter.

There are two teams here. If one is responsible for their behavior, shouldn't the other also be responsible for theirs?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom