sunmaster14
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2014
- Messages
- 10,017
It's not an excuse, it's a reality.
Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?
But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.
Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.
There's clearly a continuum of provocative behavior. At one end, speech may even justify a violent response. For example, if you told somebody you were going to stab him with a knife you have in your pocket, it might be considered legitimate self-defense for him to attack you first. However, the kind of speech at issue here is so far removed from being reasonably perceived as provocative that I find it disturbing to see it described as such.
There is a slippery slope here. If hosting an event for religiously offensive artwork can be deemed provocative of violence, then so can drawing an offensive picture and displaying it intentionally. So can drawing an offensive picture and displaying it accidently. So can drawing an offensive picture and not displaying it. So can drawing an offensive picture accidently. And so on. We might find ourselves walking on eggshells, constantly worried about accidentally offending the sensibilities of extremist Muslims. This is not just a hypothetical. There was a story a few years ago about a British teacher in Africa who got into serious trouble for allowing her kindergarten students to name a stuffed bear Mohammad.
By hosting such events, people like Geller are doing all of us a favor. She not only acts as a lightning rod, drawing potentially fatal Jihadist attention away from the rest of us, but she helps to acclimatize the extremists to the reality that the rest of the world will not abide by their arbitrary rules. The more "provocations" the Jihadists are forced to accept, simply through overwhelming numbers, the sooner they'll give up their (hopefully) impractical goal of forcing everybody to respect their beliefs through intimidation.