Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

It's not an excuse, it's a reality.

Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?

But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.

Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.

There's clearly a continuum of provocative behavior. At one end, speech may even justify a violent response. For example, if you told somebody you were going to stab him with a knife you have in your pocket, it might be considered legitimate self-defense for him to attack you first. However, the kind of speech at issue here is so far removed from being reasonably perceived as provocative that I find it disturbing to see it described as such.

There is a slippery slope here. If hosting an event for religiously offensive artwork can be deemed provocative of violence, then so can drawing an offensive picture and displaying it intentionally. So can drawing an offensive picture and displaying it accidently. So can drawing an offensive picture and not displaying it. So can drawing an offensive picture accidently. And so on. We might find ourselves walking on eggshells, constantly worried about accidentally offending the sensibilities of extremist Muslims. This is not just a hypothetical. There was a story a few years ago about a British teacher in Africa who got into serious trouble for allowing her kindergarten students to name a stuffed bear Mohammad.

By hosting such events, people like Geller are doing all of us a favor. She not only acts as a lightning rod, drawing potentially fatal Jihadist attention away from the rest of us, but she helps to acclimatize the extremists to the reality that the rest of the world will not abide by their arbitrary rules. The more "provocations" the Jihadists are forced to accept, simply through overwhelming numbers, the sooner they'll give up their (hopefully) impractical goal of forcing everybody to respect their beliefs through intimidation.
 
This crap is only going to get more frequent.
And by "crap" I mean attacks by self styled mujahedin.
 
You mean my wife? I suppose she did. She also gave me that coy smile and kissed my neck. But if you want to say she "asked for it," I suppose that's accurate enough. Her actions were designed to elicit a certain response from me. They did.

And did you rape her?

Because if you didn't, well, your actions weren't equivalent to the jihadis' actions in any way, shape, or form.

I'm guessing you didn't rape her, and that you're just making stupid arguments for an indefensible position.
 
And did you rape her?

Because if you didn't, well, your actions weren't equivalent to the jihadis' actions in any way, shape, or form.

I'm guessing you didn't rape her, and that you're just making stupid arguments for an indefensible position.

[IMGW=440]http://i.imgur.com/o9VKbxL.gif?gifm[/IMGW]
 
Last edited:
This crap is only going to get more frequent.
And by "crap" I mean attacks by self styled mujahedin.

Only thing is,its not self styled. Its what the Koran,the hadiths and the clerics ram into the minds first of children,then adults. Your average terrorist is not a poor illiterate but a educated middle classer. Its the religion that's poison. If you think I'm wrong look closely at the Muslim worlds overwhelming response to Islamic terror.
 
For a few this has got to be the only subject on this forum where victim blaming is acceptable.

There is a whole industry of security experts that give advice on navigating places safely. Their advice isn't fun. It certainly doesn't include going out or being defiant. It is a perfectly acceptable framework for examining a situation.
 
For a few this has got to be the only subject on this forum where victim blaming is acceptable.

I agree,if this was about most types of violence,say domestic,no one would say anything to mitigate the perpetrators. They certainly would not say they brought it on themselves.
 
By hosting such events, people like Geller are doing all of us a favor. She not only acts as a lightning rod, drawing potentially fatal Jihadist attention away from the rest of us, but she helps to acclimatize the extremists to the reality that the rest of the world will not abide by their arbitrary rules. The more "provocations" the Jihadists are forced to accept, simply through overwhelming numbers, the sooner they'll give up their (hopefully) impractical goal of forcing everybody to respect their beliefs through intimidation.

I don't see any hint that eventually, they'll be acclimatized and give up.

Why should they? Insults about the Prophet are deeply insulting to them, infuriating, and those who turn to violence believe that this is what God wants them to do. What matters efficacy?

Furthermore, the more events such as these are publicized, the more likely that some Muslims will become angry enough to buy into the extremist dogma.

No, I think that Geller's program deeply hurts our interests. Just as Geller confuses the Islamic extremist with the average believer, the average Muslim may come to believe that Geller's highly visible rhetoric represents general Western opinions, and that this really is a battle between the West and Islam.
 
I don't see any hint that eventually, they'll be acclimatized and give up.

Why should they? Insults about the Prophet are deeply insulting to them, infuriating, and those who turn to violence believe that this is what God wants them to do. What matters efficacy?

Furthermore, the more events such as these are publicized, the more likely that some Muslims will become angry enough to buy into the extremist dogma.

No, I think that Geller's program deeply hurts our interests. Just as Geller confuses the Islamic extremist with the average believer, the average Muslim may come to believe that Geller's highly visible rhetoric represents general Western opinions, and that this really is a battle between the West and Islam.

The average believer.If you think the average Muslim is pro free speech,pro democracy and is for equal rights AND anti extremist terror, I assure you,your wrong.
 
Only thing is,its not self styled. Its what the Koran,the hadiths and the clerics ram into the minds first of children,then adults. Your average terrorist is not a poor illiterate but a educated middle classer. Its the religion that's poison. If you think I'm wrong look closely at the Muslim worlds overwhelming response to Islamic terror.

And yet.
I believe the masses in a lot of Islamic countries are undereducated and are stuck with very biased news sources.
I wouldn't expect the average Muslim in upper Egypt for example to have all the facts.
I also don't think that it's fair to blame Joe Muslim for failing to march in defiance of terrorism.
But then at the end of the day it will be perception that has the final word, as always. And the idea of the religion of Islam being hijacked by its extremists is decades old now so it is becoming an issue.
 
Last edited:
There is a whole industry of security experts that give advice on navigating places safely. Their advice isn't fun. It certainly doesn't include going out or being defiant. It is a perfectly acceptable framework for examining a situation.

You're right.
If a religious group is offended by what we post here on this forum and initiates a DDOS attack, shutting down ISF, we pretty much asked for it to happen. (Said none of you after it happened)
 
Last edited:
Violent extremists can't be "acclimated" like that. That's part of what makes them violent extremists.

But the problem is violent extremists, and not your "average believer". Before this event, Muslims in the area were telling each other to ignore Geller and not even dignify her event with a reaction. Despite Texas having one of the largest Muslim populations in the US, about 500,000, none of them attacked the event or even held a protest of any kind outside. The shooters had to come from two states away, from Arizona.

The difficulty is, what do you do about that problem? Even if every single one of half a million Muslims in the area decides to completely ignore Geller and her little hatefest (and they did), how do you deal with two random ******** from somewhere else entirely deciding to take a jihadi road trip like that?
 
And yet.
I believe the masses in a lot of Islamic countries are undereducated and are stuck with very biased news sources.
I wouldn't expect the average Muslim in upper Egypt for example to have all the facts.
I also don't think that it's fair to blame Joe Muslim for failing to march in defiance of terrorism.
But then at the end of the day it will be perception that has the final word, as always. And the idea of the religion of Islam being hijacked by its extremists is decades old now so it is becoming an issue.

My point is that education and social comfort and economic advantage does not seem to be a barrier where Islamic terrorism is concerned. And the Muslim community as a whole is exclusive of terrorism. A train is blown up in Spain and instead of completely condemning the horror they slip in things like "ah but George bush" or "Balkan killings" to excuse the killers. Mass mobs loudly celebrate any terror attack openly. They are never countered from within the Muslim community.
Every Muslim I have personally met says that Islam means peace in one breath,then by saying something excusing terrorism,derogatory to women or homophobic shows that Islam is incompatible with common human decency.
We also know for a fact,and can prove for a fact,that Islam(and all religion) is untrue. Yep they kill and persecute for nothing.
 
You're right.
If a religious group is offended by what we post here on this forum and initiates a DDOS attack, shutting down ISF, we pretty much asked for it to happen. (Said none of you after it happened)

If our objective is to maintain our website up and running its not the best strategy.

Yes you asked for it to happen. Either you take that risk or you don't. Wishes won't get rid of the risk.
 
My point is that education and social comfort and economic advantage does not seem to be a barrier where Islamic terrorism is concerned. And the Muslim community as a whole is exclusive of terrorism. A train is blown up in Spain and instead of completely condemning the horror they slip in things like "ah but George bush" or "Balkan killings" to excuse the killers. Mass mobs loudly celebrate any terror attack openly. They are never countered from within the Muslim community.
Every Muslim I have personally met says that Islam means peace in one breath,then by saying something excusing terrorism,derogatory to women or homophobic shows that Islam is incompatible with common human decency.
We also know for a fact,and can prove for a fact,that Islam(and all religion) is untrue. Yep they kill and persecute for nothing.

Gotta be careful using they.
 
Contributory negligence does not apply to defiance that provokes violence. There is no negligence. The volokh conspiracy did a good piece on that about an abuse case that held something similar.

Since I'm not a lawyer, how does what you say here square with "fighting words?" Do I contribute to my own punched nose if I call the large Mexican a "filthy wetback?"
 
Violent extremists can't be "acclimated" like that. That's part of what makes them violent extremists.

Yes they can. We're not talking about "senseless" violence like a drunken barfight that escalates to a shooting, or a deranged loner who shoots up a school or a post office. This is violence with a purpose. The purpose is to intimidate people to respect the rules of a particular religion. If it doesn't work, or, in fact, if it has the opposite effect of causing even greater disrespect, then the perfectly rational (albeit evil from my perspective) extremists behind the violence will move on to more practical goals.

The thing that really annoyed me about the Benghazi incident was the blame put on the "offensive" Youtube video. Sure, the video was promoted by jihadists in the Islamic world in order to stir up outrage, but the fact is, it was all pretext, and everybody (especially Hillary Clinton) should have known that. There are literally thousands of Youtube videos showing the Koran being burned or defaced or flushed down the toilet. There are probably millions of videos showing things that are deeply offensive to Muslims. Are extremists attacking Google and trying to get them to take those videos down? No, because it would be like trying to knock down a brick wall with your head. It's a hopeless goal, and they don't even try.
 
Have you actually seen any of the "insulting cartoons" that were drawn at the event?

Did the attackers see any of the cartoons?

I saw them, they were very mild, even bordering on editorial. I don't know if the attackers saw them or not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom