Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

In the category "I never knew ..." I found this Wikipedia citation interesting:



The origins of the taboo against depicting Muhammad are vague. Islamists are often not very well-informed about where their taboos come from. I use the term "Islamist" as distinct from "Muslim," although it would be fair to call Iran an "Islamist" state, so it's easy to see that generalities also contain contradictions.

I'm one of those who think these incidents support the truism "Haters gonna hate" more than they support the actions and principles of most of the world's Muslims.

Imagine a contest to show how Mary can be both God's mother and the begetter of God's son. Imagine it showed images of Jesus f------ Mary. See the problem? Someone determined to cause offense causes offense. It doesn't make violence right, but it might add perspective. "C'mon, Mom, let's get it on!" says an amorous Jesus. I don't know if that would incite anyone to violence, but if the point is to spout offensive speech in order to preserve the right to offensive speech, I'd say yes, there is a chance this would incite violence among some populations of "Christians," and that such violence would reveal the true colors of some people who call themselves Christians.

I agree that "fighting words" exist, and that if avoidable, such "fighting words" could, arguably, be excluded from the doctrine of "free speech."

It's the "arguably" part, IMO, that defines "civilization." A civilized system doesn't grant offended parties license to fire upon an otherwise peaceable assembly. If offended Muslims start shooting, civil authorities are justified in slaying such offended Muslims. Whether any of this has much to do with the central tenets of Islam is, IMO, a completely different question.

Does anyone doubt there is a subset of Muslims who are willing to die to prevent or respond to insults to their prophet? The fact that it is a deeply certified cultural issue makes it different than mere affectation or manufactured outrage. They absolutely do take this seriously.

On the other hand, I don't take cartooning seriously at all, and especially drawings depicting a long-dead guy I care nothing about. The imbalance here is stunningly obvious. To raise cartoon-Mohammed on some free speech pedestal harms free speech itself, turning it into a laughable toy ideal we pull out when convenient to whitewash asinine behavior.

It's a multiculturalism fail.
 
Except that ISIS is claiming credit for it.

It's the comparison between Charlie Hebdo and the conference he's balking at, not the armed response (though there's obviously a difference in effect and I guess in firepower).
 
It's the comparison between Charlie Hebdo and the conference he's balking at, not the armed response (though there's obviously a difference in effect and I guess in firepower).

I dig.
I think they're essentially equivalent though in the "knew they were pushing the buttons of potentially violent religious zealots" column.
 
The group that staged the event is disgusting but they are without fault. Westboro Baptist Church is also disgusting but they are entitled to their horrible, disgusting, inciteful speech.

Yes, they are entitled to it. Just as I am entitled to jump off a bridge. But neither of us should be surprised when our actions don't turn out well.

The whole counter argument seems to be, "Well, radical Muslims shouldn't be violent!" Duh. And allergies shouldn't exist and farts should smell nicer...
 
I dig.
I think they're essentially equivalent though in the "knew they were pushing the buttons of potentially violent religious zealots" column.

I think reasonable folk can disagree, but that Charlie Hebdo's satire was not as explicitly bigoted and intentionally hurtful as Geller's crew. I think that Hebdo's cartoons aim to make a point, and that Geller's conference likely aimed to inflame and to rally the anti-Muslim crowd.

But maybe I'm a bit biased here, who can tell?
 
You're still trying the "false equivalence" thing? Let's just be honest and call it what it is,... a strawman.

.

You mean where you said:

"Meh? I'm not victim blaming. Geller wasn't a victim, nor was Wilder. They are just hateful individuals. Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. But it doesn't change the fact that Geller and Wilder are hateful bigoted miscreants."

To highlight: "Are they more hateful than the complete ********** who got themselves killed and who would have cheerfully killed anonymous individuals? No. "

That sounds like equivalence to me.
 
I think reasonable folk can disagree, but that Charlie Hebdo's satire was not as explicitly bigoted and intentionally hurtful as Geller's crew. I think that Hebdo's cartoons aim to make a point, and that Geller's conference likely aimed to inflame and to rally the anti-Muslim crowd.

But maybe I'm a bit biased here, who can tell?

No, for the most part I agree with what you're saying.
It's kind of hard though to "draw" a distinction between the two, iykwim.
Hebdo knew what they were printing was inflammatory.
 
Yes, they are entitled to it. Just as I am entitled to jump off a bridge. But neither of us should be surprised when our actions don't turn out well.
..

I don't think you are entitled to jump of a bridge.... at least not a high bridge.
 
The "he made me do it" excuse is absurd.

It's not an excuse, it's a reality.

Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?

But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.

Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.
 
She asked for it by dressing provocatively.

You mean my wife? I suppose she did. She also gave me that coy smile and kissed my neck. But if you want to say she "asked for it," I suppose that's accurate enough. Her actions were designed to elicit a certain response from me. They did.
 
Last edited:
Dear Lord.
Where's that list?

Plzf0bJ.jpg
 
It's not an excuse, it's a reality.

Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?

But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.

Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.

Contributory negligence does not apply to defiance that provokes violence. There is no negligence. The volokh conspiracy did a good piece on that about an abuse case that held something similar.
 
You're still trying the "false equivalence" thing? Let's just be honest and call it what it is,... a strawman.

You are arguing a point that no one has stated. Please highlight for me the posts where people have said "Hey, it's swell that these people shoot/kill people." No one is nominating these cruds for the Nobel Peace Prize.

Sheesh, talk about strawmen.

<snip>

But I'm equally free to say that they are rabble-rousing scum, because that's what I see in them.

Seems a bit off-topic here. There must be a thread on Geller or Wilders somewhere where it's more appropriate. For the record, I don't agree that they are scum, or rabble-rousing, let alone rabble-rousing scum. Have they said or written some things that I wouldn't want to defend? Probably. But I think for the most part they have been unfairly vilified.
 
For a few this has got to be the only subject on this forum where victim blaming is acceptable.
 
It's not an excuse, it's a reality.

Do you doubt that slinging a racist rant in an LA hangout for the Crips would be a dangerous thing to do? Couldn't we reasonably predict I'd get my butt whooped, or stabbed, or shot because of it?

But we can up it a level. If I were drawing insulting cartoons about Mexicans while in a prison where MS13 held sway, should I expect to peacefully serve my time and, if I did get shivved, then wonder how it could have happened? Are my actions, which could reasonably be foreseen to cause a violent response, merely "excuse making?" Hardly.

Victims often deserve some of the blame. It's called contributory negligenceWP, a principle firmly established in law.

Have you actually seen any of the "insulting cartoons" that were drawn at the event?

Did the attackers see any of the cartoons?
 
Last edited:
False equivalence. And nobody is defending the religiotards.

The issue here is that the whole exercise was desogned to provoke an pd in so doing the organiser(s) may have been putting the lives of innocents at risk.

It was only DRAWINGS. Let's be clear someone who gets that upset about drawings of a guy they have never met are to blame. If you try to hurt human beings over drawings you are completely 100%,utterly,tottaly,absolutely to blame. There is no reason or excuse for the reactions to drawings of a dead cult leader to be violence. To say the organisers behind this event or the artists have even 1% of the blame is excusing terrorism and victim blaming of the worst kind.
These nuts don't just want a stop to drawings,they want to end democracy itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom