Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

You might want to read up on Pamela Geller before drawing any more conclusions. She's quite the piece of work. If you thought Fred Phelps was all about free speech you might have had a point.

Pamela Geller: The Looniest Blogger Ever
About Obama she says:

Obama is the love child of Malcolm X

You couldn't make this loony stuff up.

Just tracking this one story down, and no surprise, it's not what Geller believes:

The “Atlas says that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child” charge has gone viral among leftists and lizards. The only problem with it is that it is false. I am not the author of this post, and I posted it because the writer did a spectacular job documenting Obama’s many connections with the Far Left. The Malcolm X claim is one minor part of this story, and was of interest to me principally as part of the writer’s documentation that Stanley Ann Dunham could not have been where the Obama camp says she was at various times. I do not believe that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child, and never did — but there remain many, many unanswered questions about his early life and upbringing.

So, yeah, you could make this stuff up about Pam Geller, and in fact the lefttards like Wonkette, Gawker and Loonwatch did. I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!
 
Just tracking this one story down, and no surprise, it's not what Geller believes:

So, yeah, you could make this stuff up about Pam Geller, and in fact the lefttards like Wonkette, Gawker and Loonwatch did. I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!
OMG! Are you a Geller supporter? :eye-poppi :eek: :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp

Did they get the love child thing wrong? Whoop-ti-do! Or maybe not:
The only problem with it is that it is false. I am not the author of this post, and I posted it because the writer did a spectacular job documenting Obama’s many connections with the Far Left. The Malcolm X claim is one minor part of this story, and was of interest to me principally as part of the writer’s documentation that Stanley Ann Dunham could not have been where the Obama camp says she was at various times. I do not believe that Barack Obama is Malcolm X’s love child, and never did — but there remain many, many unanswered questions about his early life and upbringing.” - See more at: http://pamelageller.com/rebuttals-to-false-charges/#sthash.3th5s5Xy.dpuf

I'm pretty sure her blog speaks for itself. Have you read it?
http://pamelageller.com/categories/

So do, pray tell, let us know specifically where else you believe the woman was misunderstood or misrepresented. :rolleyes:

Oh wait, she has an answer to that:
http://pamelageller.com/rebuttals-to-false-charges/

I'm not impressed.
 
Last edited:
OMG! Are you a Geller supporter? :eye-poppi :eek: :jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp

Did they get the love child thing wrong? Whoop-ti-do! Or maybe not:


I'm pretty sure her blog speaks for itself. Have you read it?
http://pamelageller.com/categories/

So do, pray tell, let us know specifically where else you believe the woman was misunderstood or misrepresented. :rolleyes:

Oh wait, she has an answer to that:
http://pamelageller.com/rebuttals-to-false-charges/

I'm not impressed.

No surprise there. Confronted with the fact that one of the claims made against Geller was wrong (the only one I bothered to check), you naturally assume that all the rest of the claims must be right.

A skeptic, you are not.
 
No surprise there. Confronted with the fact that one of the claims made against Geller was wrong (the only one I bothered to check), you naturally assume that all the rest of the claims must be right.

A skeptic, you are not.
I see you didn't look at her actual blog. How not a skeptic you are.
 
All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?

You're still trying the "false equivalence" thing? Let's just be honest and call it what it is,... a strawman.

You are arguing a point that no one has stated. Please highlight for me the posts where people have said "Hey, it's swell that these people shoot/kill people." No one is nominating these cruds for the Nobel Peace Prize. They are monomaniacal murderous bastards.

It is very possible, as I see many people trying to do so, to look at the murderous fanatics on the one side as murderous fanatics, yet still see that Geller and Wild are racist creeps and that particularly Geller is a bigot on a mission. She is absolutely free to say what she wants to say. She and her participants are absolutely free to draw cartoons of The Prophet, Baby Jeebus, Buddha, et al fornicating with donkeys. Have at it. I'll defend their rights, all the way.

But I'm equally free to say that they are rabble-rousing scum, because that's what I see in them.

NO ONE is arguing what you are claiming. And, one should note, NO ONE is playing the reverse Strawman on you. "Oh, so you support hateful racists, then... as long as they're lily white. I see." You want to argue that point for a while, or would you rather we dismiss it as the BS that I intended it to be when I wrote it.
 
You can't do something designed to illicit a specific response from a group and then whine when they do it. That's childish.

Knowing something you're doing might happen because certain people are easily offended isn't the same thing as designing it to happen.
Come on.
 
Which suggests that she wanted what happened to have happened. And this would negate any possibility of collateral fatalities? I am thankful no one else was hurt, but it is a bit of a reach to feed your own ego isn't it?

Knowing something could happen isn't the same thing as wanting it to happen.
 
There seems to be a lot of victim blaming going on. An awful lot of "oh, she was asking for it, being all provocative, naughty naughty Pamela". A lot of people trying to say that both sides are as bad as each other.

I can see only one person who has come even close to saying that.

I can also see that Skeptic Ginger said nothing even suggesting that she felt the conference goers were morally on par with the shooters. All she said is that the conference organizer has expressed some really horrible views. And you complained that she didn't say the shooters were bad, too, and that she should talk more about them.

I think your trigger finger has gotten a little itchy.
 
So let's say I organize a squad of ax handle swinging good ol' boys and storm the stage the next time The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence put on one of their Gay Jesus beauty pageants. After beating them to death and firebombing the audience for good measure is anyone going to say "Well, they had to have known what they were doing was going to provoke a reaction."? Nope. And I'll tell you why. Because the literati and intelligentsia and twitter all agree with The Sisters. Why are Moslems getting the deference? Because those same people are afraid of them.

The literati and intelligentsia and twitter?
 
Yet you still say and do things which offend a great number of people.

Yes I do. I would certainly be more careful about it if I knew the offense I was causing rose to the level of inciting violence against me though. To ignore that consequence would be an error on my part.


Sorry, but your distortion of the case is far too blatant to ignore.

The more accurate analogy would be more like this:

"He called me names, and drew a bad picture of me, so I hit him."

"I have the right to call someone names and draw pictures of them, as long as I don't do anything to actually hurt them."

(added by Marplots) "Yes, you have that right. Now, unfortunately, I have to expel you. For you certainly understand there are consequences that flow from your actions? (end addition)

Are you able to see the difference there?

Yes, I see the difference. I added a line to improve it further.

This thread seems to be heavy on the freedoms bit, but light on the responsibility part.
 
Specifically, to make it clear that violence in the name of religion will not be tolerated, and eliminate all those who cannot express themselves through non-violent means as they become a threat, or reduce them to a state where they are unwilling to act on their violent urges.

We don't have to dance around it or be shy. We can say "kill them." Because that's the set up here. Incite violence and as a remedy, apply more violence.
 
That's right, if she didn't want to get raped she wouldn't have left the house dressed like a whore. Her refusing to wear a burqa means it's partly her responsibility.

You're quite good at slippery slopes, lazy inferences, and so on.

But actually trying to understand what your correspondent is seeing, fairly and carefully evaluating his ideas? Need a little work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom