Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

She had the foresight to hire extensive, competent security.

Which suggests that she wanted what happened to have happened. And this would negate any possibility of collateral fatalities? I am thankful no one else was hurt, but it is a bit of a reach to feed your own ego isn't it?
 
All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?
That the shooters were maniacs whose actions were wrong and to be condemned is not controversial. reading through this thread, I think everyone agrees with that. therefore, it's not a topic of debate. So not much more to post along that line.

The controversy on this thread is whether the group holding the cartoon contest's actions were good/bad/neutral and if they bear some responsibility for incitement. Since there is disagreement on those points, there are more words written about that than on what everyone agrees on: shooting people for making insulting cartoons is bad and unjustified.

Is it really that strange of a position to think that both parties were acting badly but that (obviously I hope) shooting people is the worse offence?

If I condemn the shooters, do I have to support the people making the cartoons?

If I say the people making the cartoons were being jerks, does it really follow that I think that the shooters were justified or that the shooting was no worse than the cartoons?
 
All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?

Do you really think that she has nothing against the attempted killers?

Or do you suppose instead that all reasonable persons understand that trying to kill those who merely offend you with drawings is a horrible act, and that since we are all in agreement on that point, best to discuss other points that may actually be in contention?

For the record, and just so you don't misinterpret me: I think you shouldn't kill someone for drawing pictures that offend you. Also, in case it comes up, the guys who flew the planes into buildings did a bad thing.
 
Do you really think that she has nothing against the attempted killers?

Or do you suppose instead that all reasonable persons understand that trying to kill those who merely offend you with drawings is a horrible act, and that since we are all in agreement on that point, best to discuss other points that may actually be in contention?

For the record, and just so you don't misinterpret me: I think you shouldn't kill someone for drawing pictures that offend you. Also, in case it comes up, the guys who flew the planes into buildings did a bad thing.

There seems to be a lot of victim blaming going on. An awful lot of "oh, she was asking for it, being all provocative, naughty naughty Pamela". A lot of people trying to say that both sides are as bad as each other.
 
Killing people for drawing pictures is bad. The solution therefore is to not draw pictures. Glad that's settled.
 
As for the topic at hand...it seems like a bunch of guys poking at a dangerous mad pit bull with a stick.

But a mad dog isn't really responsible for its actions though is it? And isn't it simply more merciful to put a mad dog down?

Which is kind of what happened.
 
Fair enough. But to play another game that seems to be standard here, let's lure the mad dog to a children's play pen on saturday afternoon and shoot it there.
 
So let's say I organize a squad of ax handle swinging good ol' boys and storm the stage the next time The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence put on one of their Gay Jesus beauty pageants. After beating them to death and firebombing the audience for good measure is anyone going to say "Well, they had to have known what they were doing was going to provoke a reaction."? Nope. And I'll tell you why. Because the literati and intelligentsia and twitter all agree with The Sisters. Why are Moslems getting the deference? Because those same people are afraid of them.
 
Fair enough. But to play another game that seems to be standard here, let's lure the mad dog to a children's play pen on saturday afternoon and shoot it there.

Mad dogs seem awfully fond of soft targets. Of course being mad they couldn't conceive of armed resistance. This is Texas not Paris. Though it probably would have ended the same in Paris, TX.
 
So let's say I organize a squad of ax handle swinging good ol' boys and storm the stage the next time The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence put on one of their Gay Jesus beauty pageants. After beating them to death and firebombing the audience for good measure is anyone going to say "Well, they had to have known what they were doing was going to provoke a reaction."? Nope. And I'll tell you why. Because the literati and intelligentsia and twitter all agree with The Sisters. Why are Moslems getting the deference? Because those same people are afraid of them.

Nope, ideally I would want you to be ib court and facing charges. But if there is no other way, you and you ilk go down in a hail of bullets. However, if the sisters actually set this up, knowing you would be coming and will do what you do, then they also have to be charged with reckless endangerment.
 
The Travis rule of A-holes:
A-holes are good at finding each other and creating much a-holery.
​
Outside of again confirming my rule I don't think there is much to take away from this incident.
 
Nope, ideally I would want you to be ib court and facing charges. But if there is no other way, you and you ilk go down in a hail of bullets. However, if the sisters actually set this up, knowing you would be coming and will do what you do, then they also have to be charged with reckless endangerment.

That's right, if she didn't want to get raped she wouldn't have left the house dressed like a whore. Her refusing to wear a burqa means it's partly her responsibility.
 
The Travis rule of A-holes:
A-holes are good at finding each other and creating much a-holery.
​
Outside of again confirming my rule I don't think there is much to take away from this incident.
Except to be glad the security police and any curious bystanders weren't killed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom