Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

And uou decided to ignore the rest.

You edited while I was responding, but I'll respond: what if the sluttily-dressed, slutty slut drives home drunk and drugged after the gang-rape? Innocents are now in play. Your move.
 
False equivalence.

Right, a better example might be: if bloomberg funded another anti-gun publicity stunt, trying to show that gun owners were trigger happy killers and then some enraged gun owner tried to shoot him.

Would anyone defend the shooter as being no worse than bloomberg? That they were both just childish? Or that Bloomberg had only himself to blame? I doubt it (and hope not).

Somehow there seems to be a double standard. Too many people can't quite bring themselves to support free speech which they disagree with... Which means they font support free speech at all.
 
Does this also apply to slutty sluts who dress slutty and then drink too much and do too much drugs at frat parties with drunk, drugged up, horny frat boys and get gang-raped? She was obviously asking for it. If she whines, its childish.

If you're willing to concede that there is little mental difference between the group that pulled this stunt, and slutty horny teens, I'll concede that we agree on who the bad guys here are.
 
But this wasn't what it was, was it?

I am not in any way defending religiotards who believe that their paradoxical god, who is all powerful, needs brainless dolts to ensure his safety and also ensure that his feelings are not hurt.

However, this stunt seems to ha e been designed to provoke a reaction and probably placed quite a few innocents at risk.

The fact it received the reaction it did tells you everything you need to know.
 
Ofcourse it's free...so are the results...invariably violence in this case. Look, I am not denying that religious fundamentalism...particularly Islamic fundamentalism is a big issue. Atleast with Hindu fundamentalism, it is llargely localised and people outside India haven't had to experience it.

The issue of fundamentalism has to be addressed in a more sane manner. I think one way is for the Islamic moderates to stop pussyfooting and whining about how they cannot be held collectively responsible for the actions of terrorists. The fact is that their dithering and claiming the "no true scotsman" fallacy actually feeds the problem.
But really, what was the agenda of the organisers behind this little exercise?
 
Last edited:
If you're willing to concede that there is little mental difference between the group that pulled this stunt, and slutty horny teens, I'll concede that we agree on who the bad guys here are.

The group that staged the event is disgusting but they are without fault. Westboro Baptist Church is also disgusting but they are entitled to their horrible, disgusting, inciteful speech.
 
So we can make caricatures of Jesus and the pope but not of muhammed? Because we think there will be violence?

The justification for the curtailment of ideas, satire, free expression... All in the name of being grown up (except it's not, it's cowardly and, by burying ones head in the sand and avoiding the bigger picture, rather childish).

This stunt was none of those things though. It was designed to get this response.

Satire is there to make you think.

What these morons did makes others ACT out. It just happens that they found even bigger idiots who like to kill when their delicate sensibilities are harmed.
 
My issue is that the people who pulled the stunt had no thought for the safety of ordinary people. The terrorists can claim martyrdom and their virgins if they manage to kill a few,and the organisers can use the opportunity to wail and gnash their teeth at all the evil muslims. Win Win for both primary participants.

Everyone else loses.
 
A statement of the obvious perhaps? (Given that her free speech group had just been shot at)
You might want to read up on Pamela Geller before drawing any more conclusions. She's quite the piece of work. If you thought Fred Phelps was all about free speech you might have had a point.

Pamela Geller: The Looniest Blogger Ever
About Obama she says:
Back in the early 80’s, there were only two reasons to travel to Pakistan. Jihad or drugs. I think he went for the drugs and came back with jihad. (He did, after all, change his name to Barack Hussein Obama from Barry Soetoro, upon his return from that trip).

Obama is the love child of Malcolm X
Barack Hussein Obama Jr Malcolm X Barack Hussein Obama Sr. Barack Hussein Obama Sr., Tom Mboya, and Philip Ochieng, all share common physical features of the Kenyan Luo tribe: Modest stature under six feet, round faces, small chins, wide set eyes, slanted back foreheads, and retracted hairlines…none of these features are shared by Malcolm X and Barack Hussein Obama Jr.

Why isn’t CNN pursuing the nude pornographic photos of Obama’s mom…I never ran the pics, as it was unseemly and wasn’t relevant. But this assault on Palin is too disgusting. It’s time to tell the ugly truth about the enemy in the White House and his whores in the media.

You couldn't make this loony stuff up.


Now I'm not saying Geller has no right to spew hate. If we're going to allow the Westboro Baptists she has every right to spew the same. And certainly people who went to the event didn't do anything wrong just for going.

People who support her nonsense though, really need watching as much as other terrorists do. Apparently Anders Breivik was a fan of hers.

If Muslims are responsible for Islamic terrorism, are Muslim-bashers responsible for the massacre in Norway?
In a manifesto posted online, the admitted killer, Anders Behring Breivik, praised Geller. He cited her blog, Atlas Shrugs, and the writings of her friends, allies, and collaborators—Robert Spencer, Jihad Watch, Islam Watch, and Front Page magazine—more than 250 times. And he echoed their tactics, tarring peaceful Muslims with the crimes of violent Muslims.
 
You might want to read up on Pamela Geller before drawing any more conclusions. She's quite the piece of work. If you thought Fred Phelps was all about free speech you might have had a point.

Pamela Geller: The Looniest Blogger Ever
About Obama she says:


Obama is the love child of Malcolm X




You couldn't make this loony stuff up.


Now I'm not saying Geller has no right to spew hate. If we're going to allow the Westboro Baptists she has every right to spew the same. And certainly people who went to the event didn't do anything wrong just for going.

People who support her nonsense though, really need watching as much as other terrorists do. Apparently Anders Breivik was a fan of hers.

If Muslims are responsible for Islamic terrorism, are Muslim-bashers responsible for the massacre in Norway?

All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?
 
Which leads me to think that they wanted this to happen. No concrete evidence, and solely based on the character of those involved. I will willingly concede if this is not the case. And on that assumption, the stunt pulled was irresponsible. Cause for reckless endangerment?

P.S. Sorry for the irritating typos...not touch screen savvy.
 
Last edited:
This stunt was none of those things though. It was designed to get this response.

Satire is there to make you think.

What these morons did makes others ACT out. It just happens that they found even bigger idiots who like to kill when their delicate sensibilities are harmed.

Nobody MAKES them do anything. That's 100% on the scum with their fingers on the trigger.
 
All this hand wringing over Pamela gellers speech. None over the maniacs who thought they were justified in killing people over cartoons. Are you sure you're focusing on what is important?

Erm...they are utter pigs and got what they deserved. But what can be more important than the safety of ordinary people who just happened to be around. Do you think the calousness about their safety so that the organisers can vent their bile and actually gloat that "they had it coming" was justified?
 
Erm...they are utter pigs and got what they deserved. But what can be more important than the safety of ordinary people who just happened to be around. Do you think the calousness about their safety so that the organisers can vent their bile and actually gloat that "they had it coming" was justified?

She had the foresight to hire extensive, competent security.
 
My issue is that the people who pulled the stunt had no thought for the safety of ordinary people. The terrorists can claim martyrdom and their virgins if they manage to kill a few,and the organisers can use the opportunity to wail and gnash their teeth at all the evil muslims. Win Win for both primary participants.

Everyone else loses.

What a strange point of view. So nobody is allowed to upset overzealous religious idiots in case an innocent bystander might get hurt?

How about this guy? I guess in your estimation he should never venture outside in case some radical muslim freak decides to gun him down with innocent people present.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXzladhscMQ

How about opening a gay bar in a muslim neighbourhood, is that okay or would that be too dangerous as well?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom