Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, you really are expecting an answer? That is the point. In the military sequence you quote, 'The World Wonders' was somewhat true, where in the case of the direct answer you are requesting from Sweaty, it is mostly untrue.
 
Last edited:
Your posting of a picture of a golfer (refering to someone bending and twisting their body) is simply picking on a technicality, and doesn't have any relevance to the comparison images I posted....in which Bob has the same basic posture as Patty, imitaing himself as he allegedly walked as Patty.

"Same basic posture" is not the same thing as the EXACT same posture as the images you posted. You keep missing the point of the golfer image. For such a comparison to be valid, the two images have to show the exact same posture because of the "technicality" that any change in hand, arm, shoulder, etc. position can alter the line at which the fingers end.

Even though there may be slight differences in some of the body/limb angles in those images....the bottom line is still the same.....in every comparison, with Bob and the BBC Chump.....Patty's arms reach closer to the feet than the other subject's arms do. (when the subject's bodies are scaled by lining-up the eyes.).

I am not sure how you bring the BBC recreation into this. I guess it is another red herring in order to divert attention away from your flawed analysis. However, you now admit there are differences in some of the body angles/positions. Can that make a difference? I think it does and have demonstrated how the angles can keep adding up based on the images you show. BTW, the image I posted from earlier in the PGF shows a normal length arm. Did Patty/Bunny's arm stretch after that?

No.....as I stated earlier...I'm hopping off the Idiot Train that you're driving, Astro. That's all.

It is your train. You were the one who wanted counteranalysis to prove you incorrect. I have effectively done so. You have yet to provide one good counterargument using actual measurements on the images you presented to suggest my objections are false.

If, at some point you have something to add to the comparisons of Bob and Patty, please feel free to post it.

I already have. You ignore them and now appear to be abandoning your torpedoed and sinking ship.

So far, I haven't seen anything from you which shows Bob's fingertips matching up to Patty's, as far as the distance from the tips of their fingers to the tips of their toes (feet, actually.).
Bob comes up short.....like it or not.

Actually, it is your comparison that comes up short. It is invalid because of the differences between the images/poses. I have shown but you are either incapable of understanding the problems I have noted and how those will change the drop of Bob's hand or your are not accepting the fact that there are issues with such a comparison.

I keep responding to your questions/requests. Why don't you try and answer mine?
 
So, you really are expecting an answer? That is the point. In the military sequence you quote, 'The World Wonders' was somewhat true, where in the case of the direct answer you are requesting from Sweaty, it is mostly untrue.

Nah...I know sweaty is not going to answer. He apparently lacks the firepower to effectively engage.
 
I guess I have not made myself clear on the golfer image or maybe you don't understand. It is to demonstrate that hand position can change when the slope of the shoulders change even though the head and feet are at the same position. This invalidates the methodology chosen by Sweaty because it does not take into account other factors (besides the positions of the shoulders) that would raise or lower the hand position relative to the head and feet. This is also why I stated earlier that in comparison images, the subjects need to be in the exact same pose for the comparison to be valid. In the case of the PGF, none of the images show Bob and Patty/Bunny both in the same pose.

And none of them show either Bob or Patty swinging a golf club. Yes I understand what you were illustrating. But the a million figures of posing for comparison will not substitute for determining what's going on in the PGF with regards to a proported character in the cast of PGF. I can easily see the forum attacking a proponent of the film if they were posting non subject illustrations as a means to prove an element of the PGF. I think there is a strong case for Sweaty's argument, at least he's using the film and characters as reference. Its too easy a way out just to say there's no way to make a corrolation between what's on the film and what's on the photos of the prime mime suspect. Sometimes you just gotta go with what's obviously in front of you. Or to put it another way as Dr. Ziggy told his daughter Anna, "Sometyimes a bannana is just a bannana."
 
I can easily see the forum attacking a proponent of the film if they were posting non subject illustrations as a means to prove an element of the PGF.

I doubt it. If it proves a point, then it is pertinent to the discussion. You seem to think the pictures I showed of a golfer have no point. That is a false conclusion. I used it because it was handy to demonstrate how the slope of the shoulders alter hand position because sweaty did not seem to understand it by calling the position of the shoulders irrelevant in his comparison.

I think there is a strong case for Sweaty's argument, at least he's using the film and characters as reference.

So you consider his comparison valid? If so, then you don't see the issues as well. You can not make a valid comparison in this case simply because the data is not the same. We do not see Bob H from the same angle, we do not have his arm at the same position, we do not have his wrist at the same position, and the shoulders are not at the same position. End result is that it is NOT a valid analysis and incapable of drawing the conclusion that Sweaty desires.
 
Can you say for certain that the costume could have been quickly and easily cranked out by hoaxer or professional?

Why quickly? Roger was working on a movie and books for quite a while, wasn't he?
He had plenty of time to come up with a suit. He had been studying bigfoot for 8 years and he had been filming the documentary itself for eight months.
 
Last edited:
I doubt it. If it proves a point, then it is pertinent to the discussion. You seem to think the pictures I showed of a golfer have no point. That is a false conclusion. I used it because it was handy to demonstrate how the slope of the shoulders alter hand position because sweaty did not seem to understand it by calling the position of the shoulders irrelevant in his comparison.



So you consider his comparison valid? If so, then you don't see the issues as well. You can not make a valid comparison in this case simply because the data is not the same. We do not see Bob H from the same angle, we do not have his arm at the same position, we do not have his wrist at the same position, and the shoulders are not at the same position. End result is that it is NOT a valid analysis and incapable of drawing the conclusion that Sweaty desires.

I think the points being argued against Sweaty's position should be demonstrated using the same photographs that Sweaty is using. You can't properly demonstrate a pine tree using a fig tree. I've said it before its easy to say Patty can't me lined up with Bob H but when a person does indeed demonstrate that an alignment can be done if you feel it can't show us with the same photos. A clinical perfect alignment isn't going to happen unless they get BoB H to pose in a well exceuted measured way. The data is not the same but if I was betting my life that the dissimilar nature of the data was going to be the thing that's saves my skin I'd be worried .
 
Why quickly? Roger was working on a movie and books for quite a while, wasn't he?
He had plenty of time to come up with a suit. He had been studying bigfoot for 8 years and he had been filming the documentary itself for eight months.

Why quickly? Because it was included by CN that a professional could have quickly made it. If it was a professional making the suit and the suit was cheap rest assured it would have had to have been done quickly. Don't you know time is money? So if the suit was in the making for years then only Roger and his inside circle made it. Have you ever written a book or made a media event such as movie, play or recording? It tends to consume time and resources. Just how many balls do you think Roger could keep in the air at one time? He was also earning a living of sorts while Bigfooting. Let's not forget his cancer which plagued him before the PGF and killed him not long after.
 
Drew:

Thank you for publicizing my website, and for your imaginative commentary.

You are so clueless as to what I'm saying or doing, that no reply seems to matter.

I do, however, appreciate your linking to the site, so others can read it for themselves and make up their own minds.

Best regards,

Bill
 
Correa Neto:

I'm glad you like the site. I agree with you about that suit. Awhile back, I found some other pictures of the snowman and was informed that two costumes were used for the snowman in that film, along with a rejected third suit that was used for some promotional materials. I've also referenced "Half Human" in cryptozoological discussions as an example of a great-looking pre-60's costume, proof that the creator of a fake can chose random, creative details for a suit that others might not think of (the random bald spot), and as an example of when someone made something good looking only to do a lesser version of a similar thing later (I've noticed that people praise the look of the Half Human suits, but hate the "King Kong vs. Godzilla" costumes. Personally, I've never minded the Kong costumes used in "King Kong vs. Godzilla.").

Crowlogic:

I agree with Drapier, William Parcher, et al. about similarities between the Star Trek mask and Patterson's drawing being due to them tapping similar sources of inspiration. Judging from the caveman-like nature (and style of dress/weaponry) of the creatures in that Star Trek episode, it seems obvious where they got their inspiration from. As for Patterson, his Bigfoot bust bears a resemblence to a bust of Homo erectus and, as noted in post #78 here, Patterson possessed a homemade scrapbook called "Prehistoric Giant Men."

If Patterson went to Wah & co. with a picture of the sort of costume he wanted, it's not unreasonable to think that they'd opt to modify a preexisting mask they possessed which had similar features.

Oh, and here are some more pictures of the Morris suit.

Drewbot:

If you are confident about the above, how can you possibly think that Patty was not a real Unclassified, Hairy, Bipedal, Breaststroking, Babysitting, Gigantic Beast which wandered the Woods of the PNW?

Well, technically, he's just confident that a hoax scenario wouldn't involve a "cheap" (but since everyone has their own personal view of what's "cheap" and what's "expensive," it can be difficult to reach a middle ground on that) suit and that professionals would have to be involved. Thanks to Greg Long (by the way of Dfoot), we know that Patterson definitely had $700 (in 60's dollars). The choice of wording in Mr. Munn's comment can cause confusion, like the bit about hoax supporters rejecting that idea, whereas I'm one and I don't rule out professional involvement or that someone other than Bob H. is in the suit.

Your brief reference the breasts raises a good point; the breasts seem to be unnaturally stuff and the illusion of movement seems to be due to the movement of the arm in the background at one point in the film. That alone could make someone decide that the film is a hoax. However, a popular response for this is playing the "unknown species" card, which could get some people stuck on the issue of whether or not the film is a not (precisely the sort fo thing I was alluding to when I discussed "Alien Autopsy" a few pages back), which can be remedied by looking outside the film.

Your percieved poor treatment, should not influence whether or not you think you can judge skeptical position on the characters in the PGF story is valid or not.

Although I can kinda see what he's getting at with that comment, I definitely agree with you.

Bill:

I'm glad you liked what I wrote; My offer still stands about going over the stuff you're skeptical of point-by-point when you're ready. A few things that immediately leapt out at me while reviewing your comments here (putting aside potential distorting factors such as "peyote vision" and the like):

-Look back sequence: I highly suggest obtaining a copy of the film "Watchers III." I have heard there is a sequence that involves a person in a monster costume looking back in a manner that's eerily similar to what's seen in the PGF can could aid in your analysis of how a costumed person would look/what flaws could be revealed. I once mistakenly commented here that the creature was hairless, but I have since come to understand that the "Watchers" are a type of hairy, reptilian monster. I also feel that the turning the upper body during the "look back" sequence could have limited the need for neck movements by the person in the suit.

If I remember correctly, using stretch furcloth would avoid showing the costume flaws you're familiar with in a look back sequence. The Patty suit could have been a ventilated stretch fabric costume created either for an aborted movie project or made by a professional just to see if they could do it. I have some examples of props created for a failed project turning up in other movies and I know that Rick Baker recycled some "just for the heck of it" masks (along with some gloves from "It's Alive" and a costume made for a Halloween show at Bob Burns' house) for the cantina scene in "Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope"), so it's not entirely unlikely.

Another possibility is that there was an error in the creation of ventilated stretch fabric for a movie that led to much more being created than was needed. This would leave plenty of material for the creation of a suit (especially if it would help recoup the cost). Alternately, someone in the industry could've bought the "overstock" and made a suit from that. A similar example is how the reason "Dr. Who" wore such a huge scarf is that the woman who knit it misread the specifications for it, but that the actor liked it and decided to use it anyway.

-Neck hackles: If not the result of some unintentional action (like brushing or moving the hair), the "hackles" could have been a creative lark done by someone involved with the film simply because they liked the way it looked. I mean, if someone can use a sheep's brain as a design concept for tentacled turtle-things (which I do not mean as an insult; you didn't come up with the idea and I actually like said idea), the imaginative possibilities are endless! Features on a potential costume matching up to something on/related to a real animal are not indicators of reality, as noted in these links.

-Could you please illustrate what you mean by a flattened cranial cap? Depending on what you mean, someone here might be able to offer up an example of a mask with such a feature. It's also important to remember that, even if it was found that a human head couldn't fit into Patty's head (assuming that distortion has been ruled out as a factor), there are costumes with false heads that can be worn by mimes.

In short, factors like the above comments are probably why the others here are so vocal about the need to look outside the film.
 
Drew:

Thank you for publicizing my website, and for your imaginative commentary.

You are so clueless as to what I'm saying or doing, that no reply seems to matter.

I do, however, appreciate your linking to the site, so others can read it for themselves and make up their own minds.

Best regards,

Bill
Speaking of your site....I found a error on the second page you might want to correct.

A skeptic is not "...dedicated to denouncing the "Footers" and proving them wrong".

As defined by Random House, a skeptic is "a person who questions the validity or authenticity of something purporting to be factual."

Oddly enough, I'd think "Footers" want the same thing...credible proof.

To date, the "Footer" community simply has none. No body, no indisputable photographic/video, no DNA, etc. but rather a collection of "evidence" that can be explained.

Anyway, best of luck correcting that error on your site.
 
Locknar:

"Speaking of your site....I found a error on the second page you might want to correct.

A skeptic is not "...dedicated to denouncing the "Footers" and proving them wrong".

As defined by Random House, a skeptic is "a person who questions the validity or authenticity of something purporting to be factual."



I agree with your quote from the dictionary, as a generalized definition of a skeptic (not within the context of a specific issue or debate). My comment was framed within the PG Film debate, in the observation of what skeptics did was based on what I have observed.

But I will look into a way to clarify it is my opinion, based on my observations.

Thank you.


AMM:

Interesting ideas. Will take me awhile to go through them.

Bill
 
I think the points being argued against Sweaty's position should be demonstrated using the same photographs that Sweaty is using.

Then you haven't been paying attention at all. You seem to feel that Sweaty's argument is valid simply because he aligned two points of two photographs that have the subjects in two different positions. It is an invalid comparison and I have demonstrated this.

If you like sweaty's argument so much, do you have any problems with figure I posted earlier demosntrating the armlength is not too long?
 
I agree with your quote from the dictionary, as a generalized definition of a skeptic (not within the context of a specific issue or debate). My comment was framed within the PG Film debate, in the observation of what skeptics did was based on what I have observed.

But I will look into a way to clarify it is my opinion, based on my observations.
I am not sure why opinion should play any part; "skeptic" is a defined word found in virtually any English Dictionary.

As an analogy, it would be paramount to me proclaiming to be a expert on space flight, and then define NASA as "Naval Aviation Systems Administration".

To inject opinion, and an inaccurate one at that, simply weakens your arguments and calls your credibility into question.

Why inaccurate? To claim that all skeptics are "Footer" denouncers is simply a false argument; that would the same as me proclaiming all "Footers" are bald.
 
Astro I went back 2 pages and saw a post you did with the foot vs arm scale ratio. The claim that the foot is 14.5" is untennable. We don't know if the prints measured and cast at Bluff Creek are indeed prints made by the Patty's foot. I have strong reservations about the print photos and casts. The foot we see exposed is a very square affair and exibits none of the finesse in toe taper that the other Bluff Creek prints exibit. In fact Patty's foot in that photo looks far more like one of these square things Wallace was doing. That said I don't think an accurate measurement of the foot attached to Patty can be determined because we don't have a reliable photo or cast of that foot.
 
I am not sure why opinion should play any part; "skeptic" is a defined word found in virtually any English Dictionary.

As an analogy, it would be paramount to me proclaiming to be a expert on space flight, and then define NASA as "Naval Aviation Systems Administration".

To inject opinion, and an inaccurate one at that, simply weakens your arguments and calls your credibility into question.

Why inaccurate? To claim that all skeptics are "Footer" denouncers is simply a false argument; that would the same as me proclaiming all "Footers" are bald.

Come on Lock, you know that BM has convinced the 'footers that he is their last salvation and he's milking it for all he can, and as their savior he can define words any way he wants!
 
Last edited:
Locknar;

"To inject opinion, and an inaccurate one at that, simply weakens your arguments and calls your credibility into question. "

Opinions are descriptions of a person's point of view. I'm entitled to mine, and in my opinion, "skeptics" in the PG film issue are consistantly denouncing "Footers". You are entitled to disagree, but your opinion is no more accurite than mine.

You are just getting caught up in petty semantics here, in my opinion.

:)




GT:

"Come on Lock, you know that BM has convinced the 'footer's that he is their last salvation and he's milking it for all he can, and as their savior he can define words any way he wants!

The lights may be on, but nobody's home, if you think "savior" or "salvation" has even a remote connection to what I'm doing.

What is it with you guys and these silly religious analogies?

You are giving skepticism a bad rep, pulling such delusional fantesies out of thin air.

Bill
 
Locknar;

"To inject opinion, and an inaccurate one at that, simply weakens your arguments and calls your credibility into question. "

Opinions are descriptions of a person's point of view. I'm entitled to mine, and in my opinion, "skeptics" in the PG film issue are consistantly denouncing "Footers". You are entitled to disagree, but your opinion is no more accurite than mine.

You are just getting caught up in petty semantics here, in my opinion.
I merely pointed out your definition of skeptic is wrong and not supported by those found in virtually any English Dictionary.

If you can not accept this, and use words properly (as defined), how do you expect anyone to take you/your BF work seriously?

Misrepresenting skeptics to advance your BF theories is disingenuous at best, intellectually dishonest at worst.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom