Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyway....you can think whatever you like about it....but the fact still remains, in every comparison of Bob and Patty, Patty's fingertips come closer to the feet than Bob's do.

In every comparison you presented. These all use the same comparison image of Bob. Since you love "show and tell" and not math, let's take a look a different set of images.

Bobbunny1.jpg

Why isn't it out of whack as well? The difference you showed earlier equated to about a hand width. Why isn't Patty's hand touching the left side of the frame or extending well below the line? I am sure there might be "minor" "scaling" (in your sense of the word) issues. Based on what you have presented, the hand should be significantly below and to the left of Bob's hand. However, it isn't. There are still issues with this comparison. Bob is not quite tilted the same way towards the camera (this would move the arm towards the left if he turned more towards the camera) but this is all I really have to work with.

I don't like this comparison anymore than I enjoy looking at your crayon lines. However, you seem to think you have presented some earth shattering evidence, so I will play your game. Important to note is that Bob is wearing a suit this time and his left arm has a very similar angle to that of Bunny/Patty.
 
Last edited:
I scaled Bob up so his arm appears as long as Patty's. and superimposed his semi transparant image over Patty. I suppose he's BIG BOB now. It takes a heap of upscalling to give him arms as long as Patty's. The second photo is if we're going to allow for a 50% error factor because of all the various issues that have been posed concerning we're still left with a Bob too big to be Patty.

Crow, you just proved my point- you had to scale the PICTURE ( scaled by uniform ratio of EVERYTHING in the picture)- that throws everything out of whack.

Thats why ALL of these picture comparisons are NOT reliable. ( doesnt matter who does them)

No scaling proves/disproves or illustrates anything.

Nobody can analyze data they dont have.

This is all I have said from day one- it doesnt matter whether one is a pro PGF or an anti, these methods are USELESS to all sides.
 
This is all I have said from day one- it doesnt matter whether one is a pro PGF or an anti, these methods are USELESS to all sides.[/QUOTE]

I'm not 100% certain that scaling of known objects from different angles in similar pose or circumstance cannot produce useable information. The following photos are of a Polo Pony match and are taken minutes apart and at considerabley different distances and object speed. I can vouch for the photographer completely as to the details of the circumastance in which the photos were taken..

 
Nice work with the images, Crow. :)

In this one....

BobComp1.jpg



....one interesting thing of note, is that with Bob upscaled a bit, and his arm still shorter than Patty's, or maybe just barely the same length...his head is now definitely too large to fit inside Patty's cone-shaped head.

Poor Bob....he just can't seem to 'fit the bill', no matter how hard anybody tries to make him fit. :(
 
Bob as Bob dosn't do much to put him inside Patty. Bob as MR Patty does a good job of being Bob in the MR. Astro's post of Patty and MR scaled gives Bob arms that look OK. But overall the MR dosn't look right but that's not Bob's fault. The key to understanding Bob's arms filling either suit is to understand the length of the gloves. There needs to be a few inches added somewhere that keeps the proportions of the arm not looking like the typical costume arm extensions and ideally allow the fingers to move a little.

This photo was posted on BFF. I don't recall exactly what the purpose of it was demonstrating but it says a little about proportions. The man in the wind breaker is within reason of Patty's height. He's actually hunched a little lower in the shoulder so the top of his shoulder is somwhat lower than Patty's. Yet his arm in spite of the advantage of being in a deeper hunched position still comes up short at the finger tips to catach Patty's.
 
Last edited:
Even though I'm skeptical of Bob H...

Astro's post of Patty and MR scaled gives Bob arms that look OK. But overall the MR dosn't look right but that's not Bob's fault. The key to understanding Bob's arms filling either suit is to understand the length of the gloves. There needs to be a few inches added somewhere that keeps the proportions of the arm not looking like the typical costume arm extensions and ideally allow the fingers to move a little.

*cough*
 
I'm not 100% certain that scaling of known objects from different angles in similar pose or circumstance cannot produce useable information.

Now we are getting somewhere Crow. ( I know things tend to get lost in a blog, especially when the information is posted over 2 of them in multiple threads)

The key is as you wrote- usable information. As I said originally, one CAN get a degree of relative accuracy ( which cannot be defined) but not exact. ( and in this case the range is but a few inches)

Heres the next problem ( in addition to not being able to independantly measure each object to bring them in sync) The objects are 3 D ( they have height,width and depth)

a picture is 2 D- thus its been "flattened" ( distorted) so in addition to lacking information to scale the objects to measure them- the objects themselves are distorted and not a true representation of what they actually are. ( depending on their relative angles to the lense)

Its like making a map. A map ( flat paper) is a representation of a 3 D globe ( with elevations, depressions and such). So when you "iron" the globe flat to put on the paper- its automatically distorted. Thats why maps have conversion angles on them to account for the distortion when using GPS or a compass. ( or why some people say a picture makes them "look" fat- it actually does to a point)

So this effect can, depending on the angle to the lens of the object, can compress ( make smaller by pushing it into itself) or make it wider ( like a fun house mirror)

This effect becomes greater ( more pronounced) as distance between the object and the lens increases. ( same angle but from the apex out- the tangent lines move further apart)

So, in addition to the inability to dimension the objects independantly, you are dealing with 2 different levels of individual distortion that must be accounted for if one wants to compare the 2.

For example-( just pulling figures out of the air because actual measurements are unknown) if BH was 10 feet from the lens, his distortion factor might be 1%- if patty was 100feet, her distortion would be about 10% so you are still comparing an apple to a plum in terms of an orange. ( unlike your polo pictures where the players were reasonably close so their distortion would be almost insignificant and equal amongst the group)

See, what I'm telling you isnt my "opinion" ( as if one persons opinion regarding a guess means more than any others)- its a stone cold fact of physics and planar math and cant simply be "ignored" in favor of visual acquity( the eyes will play tricks on one- a yardstick never does)
 
I agree with your quote from the dictionary, as a generalized definition of a skeptic (not within the context of a specific issue or debate). My comment was framed within the PG Film debate, in the observation of what skeptics did was based on what I have observed.

But I will look into a way to clarify it is my opinion, based on my observations.

Thank you.

Bill,

Simply change the word from 'skeptic' into scoftic on your site. That should do the trick. This is what these people are. Their intentions are not to engage in critical debate but rather to scoff and pontificate.
 
Bill,

Simply change the word from 'skeptic' into scoftic on your site. That should do the trick. This is what these people are. Their intentions are not to engage in critical debate but rather to scoff and pontificate.

Are you referring to everyone on this site except you and BM when you use the term "these people"?
 
Bill,

Simply change the word from 'skeptic' into scoftic on your site. That should do the trick. This is what these people are. Their intentions are not to engage in critical debate but rather to scoff and pontificate.


What are your intentions? I haven't seen you on here in months if not a year.
 
Poor Bob....he just can't seem to 'fit the bill', no matter how hard anybody tries to make him fit. :(

Again he is ignoring what Longtabber wrote (as well as my comments about Bob not being in the same pose as Patty and seen from a different angle). Additionally, when I tried your "methodology" with Bob in the suit, he suddenly did "fit". You haven't explained that. You are also still trying to ignore the measurements I made of Bob's head being slightly smaller than that of Patty, which means his head probably would fit inside the suit. Once again, I suggest you get a measuring tool and a calculator. Your crayon lines provide no valid analysis at all.

BTW, if Bob's head can't fit into "patty/bunny's" head and his arms are too short, doesn't that make "patty/bunny" some kind of freakish bigfoot? It would have very long arms but a puny head. Is that what a real bigfoot looks like? I was under the impression that a large "bigfoot" would have proportionally bigger everything. Bigger feet, bigger arms, biggerhands, and subsequently a bigger head.
 
Are you referring to everyone on this site except you and BM when you use the term "these people"?

I would hope I'm not confused with being a scoftic. Longtabber is not a scoftic,Sweaty is by no means a scoftic. Not everyone here is a scoftic but there is a healthy population of them breeding here.
 
But obviously not any shorter than some long fingered gorilla gloves could make up for ...
Particularly since the fingers of the Windbreaker guy are curled more ....

Greg they would need to be really long gloves becuase not only is the man's arm showing up short its also posing at a lower angle which is allowing the end of the arm to extend further down. That much glove exentsion would put the glove in the range of looking disproportonate of the hand with the rest of the arm.
 
BTW, if Bob's head can't fit into "patty/bunny's" head and his arms are too short, doesn't that make "patty/bunny" some kind of freakish bigfoot? It would have very long arms but a puny head. Is that what a real bigfoot looks like? I was under the impression that a large "bigfoot" would have proportionally bigger everything. Bigger feet, bigger arms, biggerhands, and subsequently a bigger head.

Bigger head proportionate to a human? Not unless Patty/Bigfoot has a bigger brain.
I was thinking looking at your post of the MR recreation that the MR head seems bigger.
 
Last edited:
Bigger head proportionate to a human? Not unless Patty/Bigfoot has a bigger brain.
I was thinking looking at your post of the MR recreation that the MR head seems bigger.


Actually, I was thinking proportion to body size. Large animals have large heads but not necessarily bigger brains than humans. In this case, I believe Sweaty is saying that bigfoot has everything bigger but not a bigger head.

BTW, doesn't anyone have a ruler? If you can't figure out how to measure images with a software program (even MSPaint has a crude way of measuring things), then simply use a ruler on the screen. At least you can measure something. However, don't say things like "seems bigger" if you have no idea if it is bigger. When you measure the heads above the eyebrows they are about the same. The numbers vary depending where you start. In one instance Bob had a smaller head by a pixel or two. In another Bob's was the same size.

Of course, many of these measurements are flawed as pointed out be longtabber. The subjects are at varying distances from the camera and different cameras/lens systems are used. Additionally, as I continuously point out, the two subjects are not in the exact same pose. What I was trying to demonstrate with this "comparison" is that you can get the hands to line up if you get the right image using Sweaty's flawed methodology.

This brings up an interesting point. If it is a suit, wouldn't it have extremely large gloves on it to simulate Bigfoot being a large creature? After all, a "bigfoot" should have "bighands" as well. Wouldn't Patterson make the hand larger (adding an inch or two to the fingers)? Even though Bob could not reach the end of the fingertips, he certainly could wiggle the ends by moving his fingers (something like hockey gloves).
 
Notice in this gif, how the front of the shoulder (around the collarbone, below the green arrow)moves, and has absolutely no effect on the breast itself.

Bill would this be an example of two sections of costume moving independently of each other? It seems that, if the beast was real, the pulling of the upper section would have some affect on a muscled being's breast.

Not a primate expert, but those boobies are positioned awful low. They're almost sticking out from her stomach. They're rather firm too, compared to gorilla breasts.
 
Not a primate expert, but those boobies are positioned awful low. They're almost sticking out from her stomach. They're rather firm too, compared to gorilla breasts.

Now that would make for an interesting business card; International Primate Boobie Expert.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom