Bill,
Here's a little something I wrote that I feel is a balanced (but far from comprehensive) summarization of your work regarding on the PGF that I think would've gone over much better here than what you wrote
here:
"There has been plenty of confusion and misunderstandings regarding my intetions and position on the Patterson-Gimlin film, which I hope to clarify: I'm doing this to see whether or not I could find any 100% obvious signs of the film's subject being a costume or not, using my own personal knowledge creature suit effects. As odd as it may sound, I'm not doing this as a full-fledged investigation into whether or not the film is a hoax, as that would involve checking into other details regarding the filming and I'm only focusing on costume-related stuff. For all I know, I could declare it to be one way (like, say, that it isn't a guy in a suit) and have the outside details I didn't look at show it to be the opposite. Also, there's a very real possibility that the film's quality of resolution is too poor to make any sort of accurate judgement of what's seen in the film, other than it is hairy and humanoid. As a result of that, I would like to do some experiments in the future to see whether or not one can actually see some of the claimed details can actually been seen at the film's level of resolution. If it turns out that such details really can't be seen, then I might take a look at the other details surrounding the film (especially since I have been pointed towards some information that I had never heard before).
I understand that some people out there think that if a special effects artist is mystified by something, this automatically means it's real because it's unlikely for a hoax to fool a knowledgeable person. They are flat-out incorrect. Not only am I not infallible, but there's the matter of the "Surgeon's Photograph" of the Loch Ness Monster. It was regarded as a mystery by many for decades and, well, we all know how that one
turned out...
Finally, I should I have some problems with both explanations for what's seen on film (that it is a real creature or that's it's a guy in a suit) and as a result, I have chosen neither "side." My notes are an incomplete work-in-progress (not unlike my website at the moment) and are online so that I may "bounce" my ideas off others (and vice versa)."
------
Personally, I spent far more time looking at the behind-the-scenes pictures than the Bigfoot stuff at your new website. But, since I know the Bigfoot stuff is what's going to be discussed here the most, here are some random comments based on what I read of it:
-I feel that people at the JREF who argue "...aggressively against anyone who appears to support the authenticity of the PG Film or the reality of the figure seen in it" comes from the fact that the believers tend to keep repeating the same old stuff that's been covered in the past and it gets tiresome fairly quickly. Believe it or not, this behavior is actually quite common among internet forums. I know from past exerience that some people at cryptozoology.com get annoyed if someone brings up a cryptid that has been debunked in the past (the Loveland Frog and Canvey Island Creatures come to mind) instead of using the search function to make sure the topic hasn't been covered before. Come to think of it, there are occasional posts from other posters at the JREF who seem a bit annoyed that the PGF is still being discussed by the skeptics in this thread.
-I noticed that you expressed some skepticism towards "how reliable [the JREF skeptics'] basic suspicion is" and how "...[you] wonder how reliable their facts are." Do you have any particular sources that you're skeptical of? Maybe we can go over this point by point like we did with the whole tracks issue.
-I feel it's safe to say that all the other skeptics here don't think that all life forms on Earth have been discovered. In fact, I think that most people in the world have the same view. You can say what you want, but I personally feel that particular viewpoint is too obvious/common to make note of.
-If you keep (for lack of a better term) railing against skeptics on your website, people are probably going to get the idea (despite your kind comments about longtabber and myself) that you are not a skeptic and therefore are a believer. This will only lead to more misinterpretation of your work and I doubt that you want that. As for the thinly-veiled middle finger bit, I understand you're upset about how some people here treat you, but writing stuff like that will only make it worse for you crediblity-wise.
-I can't say I agree with the bank analogy as there is no reason for the hypothetical skeptics to pay attention to the behavior of bank employees and the like, let along think there's any reason to investigate a possible robbery. Now, a claim like "Roger Patterson filmed a real, live Bigfoot" is an extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary proof, which requires an in-depth look at the filming and the events leading up to it, especially since we know that a person in a costume can create a similar-looking "creature." And, as I noted earlier in my "Alien Autopsy" example, looking at the events surrounding footage can help determine whether or not something is a hoax if a viewer can't come to a conclusion about whether or not the filmed scenario is real.