Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn't that a bit like saying... "When they put the guy who confessed into an approximate recreation suit, he appeared to be larger and heavier than Patty."?

If they are this similar in mass, then how could the Patty tracks end up being so deep that Gimlin couldn't replicate it even when jumping off a log (stomp test)?

BH is about 6' tall. The headpiece crest and the fake feet might add several inches to this. The total height of this costume, with him in it, could be something like 6' 3" - 6' 7".

William two things: Bob H regardless of whether its back in 1967 or 2003? isn't naturally as bulky/massive appearing as the MR or Patty. Maybe he grown a bigger gut but his legs and arms are not as big as MR/Patty. In other words the MR may indeed present us with a bulky creature but its padding not flesh and blood. Morris overplumped our lad in the recreation. I think he got the head too pointed too.

The Patterson mask compared to Patty as you're showing it does overlay nicely. What then does do to Dfoot's position that Patty's face came from the studio of Wah and was featured in the Star Trek episode? It seems unlikely that Patterson caught the attention of Hollywood with his drawing and Hollywood jumpped on it and made a mask for thier own purposes. Then that mask finding its way onto the hoax of the artist that drew up the drawing tha made the mask.
 
But what about the other points. Are the angles of the shoulder identical? From what I can measure, I see Patty/Bunny's shoulders angled at 25 degrees from the horizontal and Bob H angled at 16 degrees. But wait...there is more. The hands are a different angles. The Patty/Bunny hand is angled at 50 degrees from horizontal, while Bob's hand is angled at roughly 30 degrees. Because the angles are different we can not consider this a valid comparison because the leaning to the right of Patty/Bunny and the different angles of the hand can produce a different result. Want some more? The angle of Patty's arm is at 71 degrees from the horizontal and Bob's is 68.

I can also point out that Bob's arm looks like it is not by his side and could be swung towards the camera, while Patty/Bunny's appears to be more perpendicular to the camera. This gives the foreshortening appearence of Bob's arm.

Much of Sweaty's "objective" analysis and other line drawings seem to be based on the unstated assumption that bigfoot is a two-dimensional creature.

I guess Historian was wrong after all.
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
But what about the other points.
Are the angles of the shoulder identical? From what I can measure, I see Patty/Bunny's shoulders angled at 25 degrees from the horizontal and Bob H angled at 16 degrees.

But wait...there is more.


But wait....you have nothing to begin with. ;)


If you watch this short clip of the PG film, you'll notice that Patty does not lean her body to the right, angling her right shoulder down lower than her left....

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/files/mk_davis_pgf.gif

Your "25 degree shoulder angle" is irrelevant, and meaningless, Astro.


Once again......

The location of the eyes, and the feet, (on both Bob and Patty) are known within a high degree of precision.....and are determined by both subject's skeletal structures.....not padding in a suit.


In addition to that....the location of the shoulders, butt, and elbows (intermediate points)....are irrelevant in the comparisons I put together.

I chose the eyes for one comparison point because of a simple FACTOID :rolleyes:.....we know that if there was a human being inside of Patty, that that person was looking out through Patty's eyes.

Therefore, aligning Bob's eyes with Patty's eyes produces a very accurate scaling between the two....and, as a result, a very accurate comparison of where their fingertips are located, between the 2 skeletal alignment points.
And Bob's fingertips are not in alignment with Patty's fingertips, no matter how you slice or dice it, Astro. :)
(But, I do admire your effort to make Bobby Erronious fit properly into Patty's bod.)


Oh....one more thing....in those comparisons, did you happen to notice that Bobby's forehead is just a tad larger than Patty's??...

Patty1lined1.jpg
Bob1lined1.jpg
 
Last edited:
If you watch this short clip of the PG film, you'll notice that Patty does not lean her body to the right, angling her right shoulder down lower than her left.

Your "25 degree shoulder angle" is irrelevant, and meaningless, Astro.

Sorry but you have proved nothing. Show me where there isn't a difference in the shouder angles.

You choose to ignore it because it demonstrates that your claim is false. You also choose to ignore all the other factors I stated. You might as well have said "I really don't know what I am doing but I am going to act that way."

But wait, Sweaty basically says that here!

In addition to that....the location of the shoulders, butt, and elbows (intermediate points)....are irrelevant in the comparisons I put together.

I think not. For a true and valid comparison to be done, everything has to line up. You aren't even close here and I think you know it. Specifically, the shoulders, which determine where the arm extends to have to be the same. To suggest the angle of the shoulders has nothing to do with where the arm extends to demonstrates you have a lack of understanding of human anatomy. For instance, this golfer's right hand is lower than his left hand because he has his shoulders at an angle. As the shoulders rotate, the hand positions relative to the feet and head change (which are stationary and the same two reference points you chose).Therefore, it does matter on where the shoulders and other parts of the body are located.

pg56.jpg


I chose the eyes for one comparison point because of a simple FACTOID :rolleyes:.....we know that if there was a human being inside of Patty, that that person was looking out through Patty's eyes.


So. It is inadequate. Other points also have to match. It is not an accurate match contrary to what you claim. Again, get out a ruler and a calculator. Give us some measurements for once.



And Bob's fingertips are not in alignment with Patty's fingertips, no matter how you slice or dice it, Astro. :)
(But, I do admire your effort to make Bobby Erronious fit properly into Patty's bod.)

That is your subjective opinion. You have not accounted for the problems with shoulder, hand, and arm alignment in the images. Until you can demonstrate they are aligned, then your claim and analysis is a false one. You seem to have a problem grasping this.


Oh....one more thing....in those comparisons, did you happen to notice that Bobby's head is just a tad larger than Patty's??

Another false claim. In the first two images, Patty/Bunny's head is 60 pixels in width and Bob's is 53. The height is about the same (both are roughly 58 pixels) but Bob is wearing a cap in that image. I did not even have to measure to Patty/Bunny's crown (which measures around 65 pixels). Therefore, it is not "larger" as you claim. I did not even have to use an ADCAP here. That dingy sinks on its own because of the holes in it.

BTW, I still haven't seen you explain the image I posted here two days ago and described over three months ago. Tick...tock...the world continues to wonder.
 
Last edited:
Bill,

Here's a little something I wrote that I feel is a balanced (but far from comprehensive) summarization of your work regarding on the PGF that I think would've gone over much better here than what you wrote here:

"There has been plenty of confusion and misunderstandings regarding my intetions and position on the Patterson-Gimlin film, which I hope to clarify: I'm doing this to see whether or not I could find any 100% obvious signs of the film's subject being a costume or not, using my own personal knowledge creature suit effects. As odd as it may sound, I'm not doing this as a full-fledged investigation into whether or not the film is a hoax, as that would involve checking into other details regarding the filming and I'm only focusing on costume-related stuff. For all I know, I could declare it to be one way (like, say, that it isn't a guy in a suit) and have the outside details I didn't look at show it to be the opposite. Also, there's a very real possibility that the film's quality of resolution is too poor to make any sort of accurate judgement of what's seen in the film, other than it is hairy and humanoid. As a result of that, I would like to do some experiments in the future to see whether or not one can actually see some of the claimed details can actually been seen at the film's level of resolution. If it turns out that such details really can't be seen, then I might take a look at the other details surrounding the film (especially since I have been pointed towards some information that I had never heard before).

I understand that some people out there think that if a special effects artist is mystified by something, this automatically means it's real because it's unlikely for a hoax to fool a knowledgeable person. They are flat-out incorrect. Not only am I not infallible, but there's the matter of the "Surgeon's Photograph" of the Loch Ness Monster. It was regarded as a mystery by many for decades and, well, we all know how that one turned out...

Finally, I should I have some problems with both explanations for what's seen on film (that it is a real creature or that's it's a guy in a suit) and as a result, I have chosen neither "side." My notes are an incomplete work-in-progress (not unlike my website at the moment) and are online so that I may "bounce" my ideas off others (and vice versa)."

------

Personally, I spent far more time looking at the behind-the-scenes pictures than the Bigfoot stuff at your new website. But, since I know the Bigfoot stuff is what's going to be discussed here the most, here are some random comments based on what I read of it:

-I feel that people at the JREF who argue "...aggressively against anyone who appears to support the authenticity of the PG Film or the reality of the figure seen in it" comes from the fact that the believers tend to keep repeating the same old stuff that's been covered in the past and it gets tiresome fairly quickly. Believe it or not, this behavior is actually quite common among internet forums. I know from past exerience that some people at cryptozoology.com get annoyed if someone brings up a cryptid that has been debunked in the past (the Loveland Frog and Canvey Island Creatures come to mind) instead of using the search function to make sure the topic hasn't been covered before. Come to think of it, there are occasional posts from other posters at the JREF who seem a bit annoyed that the PGF is still being discussed by the skeptics in this thread.

-I noticed that you expressed some skepticism towards "how reliable [the JREF skeptics'] basic suspicion is" and how "...[you] wonder how reliable their facts are." Do you have any particular sources that you're skeptical of? Maybe we can go over this point by point like we did with the whole tracks issue.

-I feel it's safe to say that all the other skeptics here don't think that all life forms on Earth have been discovered. In fact, I think that most people in the world have the same view. You can say what you want, but I personally feel that particular viewpoint is too obvious/common to make note of.

-If you keep (for lack of a better term) railing against skeptics on your website, people are probably going to get the idea (despite your kind comments about longtabber and myself) that you are not a skeptic and therefore are a believer. This will only lead to more misinterpretation of your work and I doubt that you want that. As for the thinly-veiled middle finger bit, I understand you're upset about how some people here treat you, but writing stuff like that will only make it worse for you crediblity-wise.

-I can't say I agree with the bank analogy as there is no reason for the hypothetical skeptics to pay attention to the behavior of bank employees and the like, let along think there's any reason to investigate a possible robbery. Now, a claim like "Roger Patterson filmed a real, live Bigfoot" is an extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary proof, which requires an in-depth look at the filming and the events leading up to it, especially since we know that a person in a costume can create a similar-looking "creature." And, as I noted earlier in my "Alien Autopsy" example, looking at the events surrounding footage can help determine whether or not something is a hoax if a viewer can't come to a conclusion about whether or not the filmed scenario is real.
 
Correa Neto:

The second pic, due to the weird form of the wrist is quite possibly from the "long arms" version.
I guess that when they needed more hand dexterity, they used the "normal arms" version.

I agree with you on both of these points. As it turns out, Toho chose to do the same "1 long arm suit and 1 normal arm suit" thing for the film "King Kong Escapes." The "long arm" suit from that movie was later reused for an appearance on the superhero series "Ike! Greenman." From what I've heard, they forgot to bring along the extension devices for filming, so this resulted in the actor flapping the long, empty arms at Greenman during the fight scenes. Similarly, our friend Gorosaurus turned up on the show "Ike! Godman," but the suit was looking much worse for wear (source).

Crowlogic:

Morris overplumped our lad in the recreation. I think he got the head too pointed too.

I agree that Morris didn't do a very good job in trying to recreate what was seen in the PGF. If I recall William Parcher's comments on the matter correctly, Morris claims that he was asked to build it at the last minute during his busy season for selling Halloween goods. I think he also said that he didn't have access to certain materials that he used in the 60's either. Since I feel that Mr. Morris is probably lying about selling Patterson a suit (based on his admitting to lying about making elephant costumes for free publicity in a book of his), I don't know if I should believe his seemingly credible story or not. But, I'll give credit where it's due, he nailed how Patty's feet look (Look up my "notice the feet" post for more on this).

If you watch this video, you can see some better, close-up views of the mask and costume. The commonly seen picture of Bob H. in the suit looks like it's a scan of a newspaper picture (or a picture printed in a cheap magazine), which could effect/distort the details shown on the suit. I recall that mangler did a rather amazing-looking comparison of what the Morris suit would look like if seen from a certain angle. Hopefully he'll repost it.

LTC8K6:

He thinks "we" started out believing the PGF is a hoax. While that may be true for a few, anyone who follows the threads knows that it is far from true for several of us.

I agree, the idea that all of the skeptics here started out with the conclusion that the film is a hoax is flat-out wrong. As a child, I held the nonstandard belief that the film's subject was "just there" and that nothing leapt out at me about it being an obvious hoax or an obvious fake. I also feel the need to point out that, way back at the beginning of this thread, Diogenes once chided someone for saying that the film was a hoax simply because they felt that Patty looked like a person in a suit.

Munns thinks the back story of the PGF cannot help him determine if it's a suit!

Well, technically, a hoax scenario could involve something that didn't require a suit (since some consider full-body makeup jobs to be a type of suit, I'll lump it in with a traditional costume), like an extremely hairy person or trained ape with either prosthetic or sugerical modifications (I swear, I've actually heard that as an explanation). However, I feel that the suit explanation is the most likely since it's the simplest and considerable easier to conceal from others (and is for more likely) than the non-suit explanations and that the film's backstory points to a hoax. And since the mostly likely hoax explanation is a suit...

Special bonus videos:

A montage of gorilla (and one Bigfoot-looking critter) suit scenes from the movie "It Came From Hollywood" can be seen here and if you watch the end credits for said film here, you'll see a list of all the films that the movie used stock footage from.
 
AMM:

Thank you for taking the time both to look through the site and to write up the above comments. As I have come to expect from you, you do think things through well and see things with unusual clarity.

As far as "re-writing" my statement, you actually wrote it quite well, but ultimately, I must be consistant in expressing my thoughts with my own choice of words and expression. So I concur with a lot of what you said, but I still must ultimately say it my way.

So I'll simply repeat, the site reflects me, the truth of how I think and what I feel, and I will let others judge me, good or bad, based on what I have posted on that site, and will update occasionally in the future. I am seeing a far bigger picture than this forum, and so my information and expressed ideas are not toward this forum or its members alone. You could say my whole experience with the online community is a work in progress.

Bill
 
There's enough of Bob H walking and posing both in the Morris recreation and street clothes. I've yet to see any photograph of Bob H where his arms look as long as Pattys and his height is in his legs. Now if Bob's the guy in the suit then we should be able to confirm some sort of corrolation between him and Patty. After all they did us the favor of the Morris recreation which is lame but has some servicable stills. Bob is good in the height department but he comes up short in the arms and long in the legs. I keep thinking of a fellow named Ivan Putksi who was a professional wrestler in the 70's. Although he was less than 6ft tall he was long and wide in the torso like Patty long in the arms and short in the legs. Human variation at its finest. Scale Ivan up a little and he would have filled the PGF suit well.

Pattys arms have excellent proportions with or without moving hands. The phony extension would have thrown those proportions hopeless and unrealistically off. Now if you can produce a PGF frame that shows Patty with an extended forearm than I'll entertain the idea of extension, working or otherwise. Beyond that the mechicanal hand idea is a joke and ony a fool will adhere to it.

So which is it crow ? Do the arm looks LONGER and out of proportion, or are they in proportion ?
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
For instance, this golfer's right hand is lower than his left hand because he has his shoulders at an angle. As the shoulders rotate, the hand positions relative to the feet and head change (which are stationary and the same two reference points you chose).


FYI, Astro....in that comparison I made, Bob H. is imitating himself (supposedly) as Patty.....not playing golf.

His arm is hanging straight against his side...supposedly the same way that it was as he was walking as Patty.


Of course people can twist and move their bodies in ways that can change the apparant lengths and proportions of their limbs.....but that wasn't what I was refering to. I was refering to possible padding on the top of Patty's shoulders.


I don't have the time to continue this discussion with you, Astro....you're steering it right down Idiot Lane. :boggled:


Originally Posted by SweatyYeti

And Bob's fingertips are not in alignment with Patty's fingertips, no matter how you slice or dice it, Astro. :)
(But, I do admire your effort to make Bobby Erronious fit properly into Patty's bod.)



That is your subjective opinion.



The length between the tips of Bob's fingers and his feet is (significantly) greater than the length between the same 2 points on Patty.
If you can't see that, Astro, then you're hopeless.
 
Last edited:
So which is it crow ? Do the arm looks LONGER and out of proportion, or are they in proportion ?

Patty's arm are on the long side. Long without the appearance of a forearm extension. If we allow that the so called catcher mit hand that I claim to see and everyone else writes off as camera/film anomoly then a human with good arm length could be filling the Patty arm and have a little bit of dead air space at the end of the fingers but enough to allow some of the finger flex seen in that oft posted gif. However since by most recconing the mit is nothing but a film gremlin than I'm out of ideas as to why Patty's arms are long and nicely proportioned.

While we're at it its been mentioned that at times Patty's hands appear as stubb like affairs. Hmmm could the stub like frames be because the fists were clenched. If so then we're back to considering moving fingers.
 
FYI, Astro....in that comparison I made, Bob H. is imitating himself (supposedly) as Patty.....not playing golf.

As always, you miss what I was trying to demonstrate. You claimed that the position of the shoulders did not matter in where the arm dropped. I demonstrated it did. Now you are trying to steer away from your obviously flawed statement and analysis.

His arm is hanging straight against his side...supposedly the same way that it was as he was walking as Patty.

Can you demonstrate that it is in the exact same position? It isn't. I have already stated the two pictures are seen from different angles, the slope of the shoulders is different, the arm angle is different, and the wrist angle is different. This could easily account for most of why the arm in the cherry picked image of Patty/Bunny looks longer than the image of Bob walking. You just fail to see it.


Of course people can twist and move their bodies in ways that can change the apparant lengths and proportions of their limbs.....but that wasn't what I was refering to. I was refering to possible padding on the top of Patty's shoulders.

So what does padding at the top of the shoulders have to do with the arm position? Are you suggesting that the shoulder drop has something to do with padding in a suit? Does this mean you think that Patty/Bunny is some person in a suit? Sounds like it. All padding aside, your claim was that the shoulders had no relevance in the comparison you made. This is a false statement because the position of the shoulders will change the position of the end of the hand. If you can't see that, then you truly are lost.


I don't have the time to continue this discussion with you, Astro....you're steering it right down Idiot Lane.

Hmmmm.....Abandoning the sinking ship? Remember this is your "analysis" and you have done a poor job of defending it. I ask for numbers, you give us lines on two images that do not match. The problem with you is that you fail to see the argument and when it shows your reasoning is flawed, you resort to name-calling.


The length between the tips of Bob's fingers and his feet is (significantly) greater than the length between the same 2 points on Patty.
If you can't see that, Astro, then you're hopeless.

Define "significantly". How much longer? Can the positioning of the shoulders, the tilt of the wrist, curl of the fingers, angle of the arm, etc. have an effect on this measurement. Yes it can and it could account for the difference. The problem is you can't understand this or refuse to accept this as a possibility.

Still waiting for you to explain my image. I have demonstrated yours to be truly flawed. Feel free to show that mine is as well. I can think of a few arguments against it but they do not skew the results too much. Tick...Tock...The world wonders.
 
OK folks, check this one out:
tn_snowman.jpg

A better resolution pic can be found at
http://www.tohokingdom.com/kaiju/images/snowman.htm
Its from the 1955 "Half Human: The Story of the Abominable Snowman" film. Check the face, compare with Patterson drawings. Both drunk from the same source and it was not a real bigfoot or yeti, but the "cavemen" renderings available back in the 50's. Check also hair lenght- short, not long and shaggy.

That costume, I think, is at least equal to (and possibly even better) than Patty. A similar costume could have been relatively quickly built or assembled by costume makers -Morris included- for Patterson. This thig would fit within the hoaxer's budget.

Thanks to AMM by presenting a linkie to a Toho site I wasn't aware of!
 
As always, you miss what I was trying to demonstrate. You claimed that the position of the shoulders did not matter in where the arm dropped. I demonstrated it did. Now you are trying to steer away from your obviously flawed statement and analysis.

Astro since we have photos of Bob H in a number of circumstances and we have Patty it makes a lot more sense to use direct evidence from Patty and Bob H for effecting corrolations (if any) between the two. The golfer isn't Patty or Bob and its not in a pose or dynamic of either the PGF or Bob strutting his stuff in street clothes. You presented a nice apple to munch on but we need to be munching and crunching the oranges within the PGF and its participants.
 
Last edited:
Tick...Tock...The world wonders.

Actually, most of the world doesn't give a crap either way, and most of the people on this board (who know Sweaty's game) are not expecting an answer, so in essence, it is just you wondering.

Disclaimer: Astro, I know you are really not expecting an answer, I just wanted to illustrate the futility of waiting for a direct answer from Sweaty.


After reading Bill Munns' website, I have come to the conclusion that he has reached a conclusion regarding Patty, but is attempting to obscure this fact, by saying things like:

Bill Munns said:
* My analysis of the film is a work in progress
* I am specifically looking at the film, from my experience as a movie creature maker, trying to see if there is any way to determine if what is seen in the film is a real creature or a human in a suit. That's it.
* I am still exploring which will determine how much data can be extracted from the film, and then better determine if a suit can be conclusively proved or disproved.


But his attempt to obscure is betrayed by his "Summary of Issues I am confident about".

Bill Munns said:
1. If it is a suit, it's definitely not a "cheap suit", as often stated by people trying to just dismiss the whole matter and intimidate those who disagree. If it is a suit, it represents elements of sophistication far beyond the norm for the time.

2. The "Roger could make the suit because he's a... (Fill in your favorite noun, artist, saddlemaker, con man, or whatever)" idea is not supported by anything I've seen in 6 months of study. This idea is mere skeptical wishful thinking.

3. If the film is a hoaxed event with a human in a suit, I assume that professionals must have been involved in making the suit and working with it during the filming event, and any explanation that a hoaxed film event was done by three guys (including the one wearing the supposed suit) when none had any documented professional level filmmaking experience, such an explanation I would regard as delusional fantesy.

Interestingly, the people who claim there is a suit and a hoax still reject all three above ideas with fierce denials because they have already reached their conclusion and their forgone conclusion requires the following three conditions to be true (1. It's a cheap suit, 2. Roger made/modified it, 3. Roger, Bob G. and Bob H. filmed it with no help). So they have already accepted a conclusion and fight to discredit anyone who offers opinions that do not support their foregone conclusion of how the proported hoax occured.

If you are confident about the above, how can you possibly think that Patty was not a real Unclassified, Hairy, Bipedal, Breaststroking, Babysitting, Gigantic Beast which wandered the Woods of the PNW?

Here is a section in which he accomplishes two things, 1. He once again points out that he knows nothing about the players in the film, and can't judge the merits of the skeptical position about them. and 2. Makes a play to get sympathy by complaining about his treatment. (thus allowing him to judge the skeptical position on the characters based on that treatment alone)


Bill Munns said:
]I have no direct knowledge of the people involved in the PG Film story, so I can't test the merit of the skeptical suspicion about them. But I do have a reference point to guage the merit of their suspicion, skeptical logic, and thinking skills quite reliably, and that reference is how they treat me.

Your percieved poor treatment, should not influence whether or not you think you can judge skeptical position on the characters in the PGF story is valid or not. You claim that you doubt the stories about them, because of how you are treated? In fact you shouldn't even worry about the characters at all, if you truly believe the following.
Bill Munns said:
I am specifically looking at the film... That's it

I would go so far as to say, that I think Bill Munns is a classic Patty believer, he even makes a play at the classic 'close-minded-skeptic' argument here:
Bill Munns said:
I doubt they can understand any truth which does not suit their preconcieved agenda and their bias. They have started with a conclusion, that the film is a hoax, bigfoot does not exist, and and no facts to the contrary will be allowed to clutter their mind or tarnish their foregone conclusions.
All quotes copied from www.billmunnscreaturegallery.com spelling left as is.
 
Last edited:
OK folks, check this one out:
[qimg]http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d150/AVCN/tn_snowman.jpg[/qimg]
A better resolution pic can be found at
http://www.tohokingdom.com/kaiju/images/snowman.htm
Its from the 1955 "Half Human: The Story of the Abominable Snowman" film. Check the face, compare with Patterson drawings. Both drunk from the same source and it was not a real bigfoot or yeti, but the "cavemen" renderings available back in the 50's. Check also hair lenght- short, not long and shaggy.

That costume, I think, is at least equal to (and possibly even better) than Patty. A similar costume could have been relatively quickly built or assembled by costume makers -Morris included- for Patterson. This thig would fit within the hoaxer's budget.

Thanks to AMM by presenting a linkie to a Toho site I wasn't aware of!

Can you say for certain that the costume could have been quickly and easily cranked out by hoaxer or professional? In certain of my own professional endevours clients are often stunned when given the bill or estimate of what a seemingly quick and easy operation might entail. The only people I'll trust to comment on the easiness of costume making here is Bill Munns and Dfoot. Now if you've constructed hairsuit costumes yourself and can furnish figures on the time it took to make then by all means fire away. However you're on a slippery slope if you casually remark that something must have been quick and easy to make.

That said the its a decent looking apeman. I'm still waiting for Parcher to respond back in on how the Patterson drawing works so well on Patty yet the wah mask is claimed to be the Patty face.
 
That said the its a decent looking apeman. I'm still waiting for Parcher to respond back in on how the Patterson drawing works so well on Patty yet the wah mask is claimed to be the Patty face.

I think Correa's implication is that the film caveman, Patterson's drawing, and probably Dfoot's mask all have the same inspiration -- the 1950s' stereotype of what a caveman ought to look like.
 
Here is Frank Frazetta's "Neanderthal" illustration. It was on the cover of Creepy Magazine in 1967. This seems to be a somewhat typical rendition (using skulls and skeletons as guides) that artists of that era used, though Frazetta adds sinister drama.

The brow ridge, nose and heavy jaw in this illustration is similar to Roger's Bigfoot drawing, that Wah mask, and Patty herself. All look more like "wild bipedal hominoids" rather than "apes".

247a618b79eec785c55c701e1fe503c8.jpeg
 
Astro since we have photos of Bob H in a number of circumstances and we have Patty it makes a lot more sense to use direct evidence from Patty and Bob H for effecting corrolations (if any) between the two. The golfer isn't Patty or Bob and its not in a pose or dynamic of either the PGF or Bob strutting his stuff in street clothes. You presented a nice apple to munch on but we need to be munching and crunching the oranges within the PGF and its participants.

I guess I have not made myself clear on the golfer image or maybe you don't understand. It is to demonstrate that hand position can change when the slope of the shoulders change even though the head and feet are at the same position. This invalidates the methodology chosen by Sweaty because it does not take into account other factors (besides the positions of the shoulders) that would raise or lower the hand position relative to the head and feet. This is also why I stated earlier that in comparison images, the subjects need to be in the exact same pose for the comparison to be valid. In the case of the PGF, none of the images show Bob and Patty/Bunny both in the same pose.
 
Last edited:
As always, you miss what I was trying to demonstrate. You claimed that the position of the shoulders did not matter in where the arm dropped. I demonstrated it did.


You demonstrated nothing that had anything to do with the comparison images I posted, or anything relevant to the meaning of what I've said in my posts, Astro.

Here is an excerpt from one of my posts yesterday...concerning the shoulders...

The location of the eyes, and the feet, (on both Bob and Patty) are known within a high degree of precision.....and are determined by both subject's skeletal structures.....not padding in a suit.

In addition to that....the location of the shoulders, butt, and elbows (intermediate points)....are irrelevant in the comparisons I put together.


In making reference to the "location of the shoulders", I was refering to the length from the fingers to the tops of the shoulders....a length that can easily be changed by padding.
Your posting of a picture of a golfer (refering to someone bending and twisting their body) is simply picking on a technicality, and doesn't have any relevance to the comparison images I posted....in which Bob has the same basic posture as Patty, imitaing himself as he allegedly walked as Patty.

Even though there may be slight differences in some of the body/limb angles in those images....the bottom line is still the same.....in every comparison, with Bob and the BBC Chump.....Patty's arms reach closer to the feet than the other subject's arms do. (when the subject's bodies are scaled by lining-up the eyes.)


Now you are trying to steer away from your obviously flawed statement and analysis.


No.....as I stated earlier...I'm hopping off the Idiot Train that you're driving, Astro. That's all.
If, at some point you have something to add to the comparisons of Bob and Patty, please feel free to post it.

So far, I haven't seen anything from you which shows Bob's fingertips matching up to Patty's, as far as the distance from the tips of their fingers to the tips of their toes (feet, actually.).

Bob comes up short.....like it or not. :D
 
Actually, most of the world doesn't give a crap either way, and most of the people on this board (who know Sweaty's game) are not expecting an answer, so in essence, it is just you wondering.

Disclaimer: Astro, I know you are really not expecting an answer, I just wanted to illustrate the futility of waiting for a direct answer from Sweaty.

Actually, it is a historical reference. I like military history (having spent 22+ years in the Navy). The reference is to the Battle of Leyte Gulf. Halsey had taken the Japanese bait and went north to sink their carriers (which really were not a significant threat since most of their planes were lost in the battle of Phillipine sea). Meanwhile, the Japanese battleships had changed course in the night and snuck through the unguarded straits (the one Halsey was supposed to guard) and were now shooting up some small "jeep carriers" and threatening the Leyte landings. Nimitz sent out a message which stated "Where is task force 34? The world wonders". Task force 34 contained fast battleships, which everyone assumed was guarding the straits. Halsey had them with his carriers. "The world wonders" was never meant to be part of the message. It was padding that was part of the security measures in place and was supposed to be removed. Somehow, Halsey got the message with "the world wonders" attached. Needless to say, Halsey was upset that Nimitz would say such a thing in a radio message. I thought it appropriate to use here.

BTW, "dogfights" on the History channel did a superb job recreating the battle of samar. What could have been a defeat by a superior foe turned into one of the greatest feats of heroism that I have ever seen by a few naval officers. They definitely lived up to John Paul Jones statement of "give me a fast ship for I intend to go in harm's way".

End of history lesson and back to Bunny's exploits.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom