Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I simply don't know what Bill or anyone expects to get from being "Footers last hope". There certainly isn't going to be a financial reward. I'd rather take a grand to Vegas and roll the dice for an afternoon with the expectations of getting a positive cash return than hitch my star to Bigfoot as a means of making money. I'd say that even the biggest buck makers in footery are pretty much a small change affair. Then if you yourself don't believe in Bigfoot yet set youself up as a savior to the Footers then all you have is the adoration of a bunch of people that you yourself know are fools. A kind of what's to be gained by being Lord of the Flies?
 
Snip...

GT:

"Come on Lock, you know that BM has convinced the 'footer's that he is their last salvation and he's milking it for all he can, and as their savior he can define words any way he wants!

The lights may be on, but nobody's home, if you think "savior" or "salvation" has even a remote connection to what I'm doing.

What is it with you guys and these silly religious analogies?

You are giving skepticism a bad rep, pulling such delusional fantesies out of thin air.

Bill

Really? Have you not read your own site?

No, probably not. That would explain the spelling and grammar errors.
 
Really? Have you not read your own site?

No, probably not. That would explain the spelling and grammar errors.
This would be another issue as far as credibility. Added with the obvious bias (misrepresenting skeptics to advance his own opinion/views, for example), the site has little appeal.

The site also lacks any significant, and no scientific, discussion on the PG film. Rather, the site just offerers opinion...which is fine, but really does not merit further discussion unless it is overhauled.

QED
 
GT:

"Really? Have you not read your own site?

No, probably not. That would explain the spelling and grammar errors. "


Yes, I misspell some words, and try to correct them.

It's a work in progress.

Bill
 
Notice in this gif, how the front of the shoulder (around the collarbone, below the green arrow)moves, and has absolutely no effect on the breast itself.

Bill would this be an example of two sections of costume moving independently of each other? It seems that, if the beast was real, the pulling of the upper section would have some affect on a muscled being's breast.
 
The foot we see exposed is a very square affair and exibits none of the finesse in toe taper that the other Bluff Creek prints exibit. In fact Patty's foot in that photo looks far more like one of these square things Wallace was doing. That said I don't think an accurate measurement of the foot attached to Patty can be determined because we don't have a reliable photo or cast of that foot.

Then are you stating that the casts are probably fake and that "patty/bunny" had odd shaped feet (I believe there is another frame showing toes)? Does this mean that "patty/bunny" never left a single footprint but other bigfeet (possible the slaughtered ones?) did? Is it possibly a flaw in the suit that makes it look square or is it film resolution issues? I used the 14.5" value because that is what everyone states were the size of the footprints left by "patty/bunny".

Of course, we can also look at the possibility that "if" it is bob H, the foot size would not be much more than 13-15" or he could not really walk successfully at the speeds shown in the film. I am not sure of his shoe size but my guess is it probably was a 10-13 range. I recall him being something like 6'1" tall.
 
Then are you stating that the casts are probably fake and that "patty/bunny" had odd shaped feet (I believe there is another frame showing toes)? Does this mean that "patty/bunny" never left a single footprint but other bigfeet (possible the slaughtered ones?) did? Is it possibly a flaw in the suit that makes it look square or is it film resolution issues? I used the 14.5" value because that is what everyone states were the size of the footprints left by "patty/bunny".

Of course, we can also look at the possibility that "if" it is bob H, the foot size would not be much more than 13-15" or he could not really walk successfully at the speeds shown in the film. I am not sure of his shoe size but my guess is it probably was a 10-13 range. I recall him being something like 6'1" tall.

Where there not several set of tracks at Bluff Creek? The block shapped foot we see may be the result of blur or the often cited camera distortion. Does it appear to you that the "thing" we see as the sole of Patty's foot look anything like any of the proported casts that came from Bluff Creek. Since both proponents of the film and opponents of same have to rely on the same source, the film itself, in the interests of unbiased reportage certain disclaimers may be usefull. For instance a factual statment such as the foot as shown on the creature is very likely subject to blur and distortion therefore a true estimate of its size is not possible. As for the toes that are sometimes seen it has been suggestd by members of this forum that the frame showing toes on the block foot frame is a doctored frame.
 
Notice in this gif, how the front of the shoulder (around the collarbone, below the green arrow)moves, and has absolutely no effect on the breast itself.

Bill would this be an example of two sections of costume moving independently of each other? It seems that, if the beast was real, the pulling of the upper section would have some affect on a muscled being's breast.
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1970548760cb2a55c4.gif[/qimg]

Drew, while the skin can obviously seen pulling where you've arrowed a carefull eximinaton will show that the skin continues to pull over the breast itself. While the breast itself does not seem to move by bounce and jiggle there is skin/tissue pull present on the breast itself. More importantly above the arrow you've posted there is a dark line near the base of the head that could be a seam.
 
Crowlogic wrote:
I think the points being argued against Sweaty's position should be demonstrated using the same photographs that Sweaty is using.

I've said it before its easy to say Patty can't me lined up with Bob H but when a person does indeed demonstrate that an alignment can be done if you feel it can't show us with the same photos.


Well said, Crow. ;) That's the right way of approaching this issue. Demonstrating something you're proposing carries more weight than simply proposing it with words alone.


That principle applies to Astro, Longtabber, myself....and everybody else who wants to propose something concerning the evidence.


If Astro sees an error in my comparisons, then let him show everyone exactly what the error is, so we can all learn, and get a better idea of what the truth of the matter actually is.
 
Crow, the "blockfoot" is less likely to be distorted, though. At that point, it's relatively still from the camera's point of view.

This is the reason we see "toes" in the "perfectfoot" frame. The foot is fairly square to the lens and hardly moving at all at that point.

If I thought Patty was a real creature, my explanation for "blockfoot" would be mud. Patty went through some mud. We can see this in several shots of tracks. Her foot and toes are covered with mud, making them appear that odd way in the "blockfoot" frame.
 
Last edited:
Drew, while the skin can obviously seen pulling where you've arrowed a carefull eximinaton will show that the skin continues to pull over the breast itself. While the breast itself does not seem to move by bounce and jiggle there is skin/tissue pull present on the breast itself. More importantly above the arrow you've posted there is a dark line near the base of the head that could be a seam.

I would say the breast does move slightly, but independently.

The motions do not look connected to me.

However, I think if I grant that the motions are connected, I get a whole different problem. If the breast moves that easily, well, then it ought to move that easily...
 
You seem to feel that Sweaty's argument is valid simply because he aligned two points of two photographs that have the subjects in two different positions. It is an invalid comparison and I have demonstrated this.


In this comparison (not mine)....Bob Erronious still comes up short in the Arm Department...

BobPatty2a.jpg




....and Bob and Patty are in extremely similar positions.

In this comparison, Bob seems to be scaled just slightly smaller than he should be...but that error is not nearly enough to account for the shortage in his arm length.
 
If Astro sees an error in my comparisons, then let him show everyone exactly what the error is, so we can all learn, and get a better idea of what the truth of the matter actually is.

Oh my....do we have to use small words as well so you can understand? I have "shown" how angles of the shoulders can affect the positions of hands relative to feet. You dismissed it because it does not show "bunny/patty". I identified all sorts of flaws and asked you to measure them yourself. You refused to do so because you don't know how to or chose not to do so. The truth of the matter is, you can not make the comparisions because the two images are not in the exact same pose (for goodness sake, just compare the wrist angles for starters) and Bob H. is not in a suit (which would extend his hand anywhere between 1-6" depending on the size of the "glove" on the suit). The missing 6" between the two lines can easily be accounted for through numerous reasons (angles of the wrist, shoulder, arm, glove size, etc) you chose to ignore.
Face it, your analysis was flawed. Longtabber clearly stated the problems but you ignored his objections as well. If you want to keep drawing with crayons, feel free to do so. However, any professional photographic analyst will tell you the same things already stated here.
 
In this comparison (not mine)....Bob Erronious still comes up short in the Arm Department...

Right off the bat:

1) the scaling appears off as you noted.
2) Bunny/patty is twisted more away from the camera
3) Bob's arm is at an obviously different angle (48 degrees from vertical vice 27 degrees from vertical for patty/bunny) as SHOWN by your yellow lines.
4) the wrist is again at a different angle (even though you blurred it with your crayons).
5) Bunny/patty is leaning over more (63 degrees from vertical) than Bob (39 degrees from vertical) as SHOWN by your blue lines.
6) The shoulders again appear to be leaning towards the right more than Bob.

I could do the calculations for you to show you how much a change the 24 degree (edit 6.8 deg)stoop of bunny/patty can add to apparent arm length. I could also do this with 21 degree (edit 6.4 deg)difference between Patty/bunny's arm angle and Bob's arm. However, I am not going to waste the time and effort. You would just say it is "irrelevant" because you believe your crayon lines are the final word on this.

Edit: I made an error with the angles as they are obviously not as large. My mistake in using a different program. It was only measuring X direction change and not angle change. The corrections are:

3) Bob's arm is at an obviously different angle (23.5 degrees from vertical vice 17.1 degrees from vertical for patty/bunny) as SHOWN by your yellow lines.
5) Bunny/patty is leaning over more (21.4 degrees from vertical) than Bob (16.3 degrees from vertical) as SHOWN by your blue lines.
 
Last edited:
In this comparison, Bob seems to be scaled just slightly smaller than he should be...but that error is not nearly enough to account for the shortage in his arm length.
This is a flawed conclusion. Why isn't "Bob" scaled correctly? What is the basis for the scale used? How "out of scale" is "Bob" suppose to be?
 
Crowlogic wrote:



Well said, Crow. ;) That's the right way of approaching this issue. Demonstrating something you're proposing carries more weight than simply proposing it with words alone.


That principle applies to Astro, Longtabber, myself....and everybody else who wants to propose something concerning the evidence.


If Astro sees an error in my comparisons, then let him show everyone exactly what the error is, so we can all learn, and get a better idea of what the truth of the matter actually is.

What we have here is nothing more than an exercise in denial ( the other river in Egypt)

See, what I told you regarding how the process works IS "the way" and math is a universal constant.

"scaling" properly cannot be done properly ( relative to the objects in the films) because the objects cannot be dimensioned properly. Thus no accurate comparison by simply scaling pictures is possible regardless of who does it.

Thats not an "opinion"
 
"scaling" properly cannot be done properly ( relative to the objects in the films) because the objects cannot be dimensioned properly. Thus no accurate comparison by simply scaling pictures is possible regardless of who does it.

Thats not an "opinion"
Ding ding ding...we have a winner! Exactly, as there is no valid reference any scaling is subjective and non-credible.

You'd think folks like say Bill Munns (being a self proclaimed expert) would recognize this. Rather, it seems, they hing a huge part of their argument/claim showing "scaled" comparisons that are simply baseless.
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
Bob's arm is at an obviously different angle (48 degrees from vertical vice 27 degrees from vertical for patty/bunny) as SHOWN by your yellow lines.


I mentioned in my post that that comparison was not mine, Astro.

I didn't draw those crayon lines. I borrowed the image from the BFF, a few years ago.


Anyway....you can think whatever you like about it....but the fact still remains, in every comparison of Bob and Patty, Patty's fingertips come closer to the feet than Bob's do.
Maybe that's because of a hand-extension on Patty....but as far as I know, Bob has never said that the suit he supposedly wore had hand extensions.....let alone remote-controlled ones.
 
I scaled Bob up so his arm appears as long as Patty's. and superimposed his semi transparant image over Patty. I suppose he's BIG BOB now. It takes a heap of upscalling to give him arms as long as Patty's. The second photo is if we're going to allow for a 50% error factor because of all the various issues that have been posed concerning we're still left with a Bob too big to be Patty.



 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom