Actually....the alignment points I used are objective, Astro.
But what about the other points. Are the angles of the shoulder identical? From what I can measure, I see Patty/Bunny's shoulders angled at 25 degrees from the horizontal and Bob H angled at 16 degrees. But wait...there is more. The hands are a different angles. The Patty/Bunny hand is angled at 50 degrees from horizontal, while Bob's hand is angled at roughly 30 degrees. Because the angles are different we can not consider this a valid comparison because the leaning to the right of Patty/Bunny and the different angles of the hand can produce a different result. Want some more? The angle of Patty's arm is at 71 degrees from the horizontal and Bob's is 68.
I can also point out that Bob's arm looks like it is not by his side and could be swung towards the camera, while Patty/Bunny's appears to be more perpendicular to the camera. This gives the foreshortening appearence of Bob's arm.
As for your second set of pics, this is not even close to a valid comparison because the two subjects are in two completely different poses.
In both cases of your line diagrams, the pixel difference between the two finger tips in the Y-direction is about 30 pixels, which looks like about 6 inches (based on the size of Bob H's hand). The angle difference in the hand in the first comparison is 20 degrees, which using a 6-inch hand as a reference adds roughly 1.5" to the vertical drop. This means we have to lower Bob's finger tip line about 7 pixels. Assuming the shoulders are roughly 15" across The drop of Patty would be about 2" more for Patty/Bunny than Bob. Lower Bob's fingertip line by another 10 pixels. This is a total of 17 pixels of the 30 difference you have in your line diagrams. If we assume Bob has a 33" long arm One can add another half-inch. Drop the line another 2 pixels. So, with just these three differences, we discover that we are only about 2" short of Patty/Bunny's finger tips. This does not take into account the possibility that Bob's arm swing was towards the camera, giving the impression of a short arm. It also does not take into account the size of a glove over Bob's hand. How much would that add? How far does Bob have to stick his hand into a suit glove to "wiggle fingers for you"? Based on my experiment with regular gloves, I think 1-2 inches of space between the finger tips and actual fingers will work.
Edit: Lastly, Bob H's fingers are not straight out and are curved. Could that result in a missing 1/2-1 inch?
So you see, there are variables at work here when you only use two points of reference. The rest is subjective because of the use of only two data points to position your images. This MK 48 ADCAP has done its work (Bonus points for anyone who can figure out that without google).
As for my analysis, I keep waiting and waiting and waiting...Tick...Tock....the world wonders.
.but that's just TOO FREAKIN' BAD for you, and the rest of the gang, my friend!
Sounds like somebody is getting a bit testy. I suggest you take a deep breath, get a measuring tool and a calculator, and look at the problems with what you are trying to do. You are ignoring variables that result in you getting the answer you desire. You have not shown that the arms are too long.