Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Apparently you are befuddled by this problem because it demonstrates your previous claim about the arm being too long is a false one. So much for not being afraid of the truth.

Just for reference, I brought this up some time back at post #13474. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3571927&postcount=13474
(Note: I had revised some of the numbers from my initial post. I changed the point I measured the shoulder to finger tips in that post are different than this one).

That was over three months ago and you promised to get back to it. Still waiting. Tick...Tock...The world wonders.


Instead of using numbers to compare arm-length ratios, I used images....aligning 2 known points on Bob H. and Patty...their eyes and the bottoms of their feet. If Bob H. was actually Patty, then his eyes had to line-up with Patty's eyes, and the same with the feet, also.

But in 2 different comparisons, using different views of Bob, his arms come up short of Patty's arms.

In addition to those, I also compared the arm length proportions of the "Chump" in the BBC suit.....and his relative arm length came up even shorter than Bob's did.

Now, there may be something to what LONGTABBER has been blabbering about, as far as possible errors in image comparisons....but isn't it funny that these errors always come out in favor of Patty's arms being longer than a human's arm. ;)


In your free time, Astro...feel free to show where the error is in those comparisons I posted...........if you can. :)
 
Instead of using numbers to compare arm-length ratios, I used images....aligning 2 known points on Bob H. and Patty...their eyes and the bottoms of their feet. If Bob H. was actually Patty, then his eyes had to line-up with Patty's eyes, and the same with the feet, also.

The problem with your comparison is the images have to be aligned exactly the same and positioned exactly the same and with the same exact scale. Any error will introduce false results. You disdain the use of math? How "unscientific" of you when examing the evidence. I do believe we had this discussion about subjective analysis several times. Apparently, you ignored it. Your method is highly subjective and based on how you want to present the imagery. The use of a proper reference (the foot) as a possible way of measuring the physical length of the arm is a more accurate way of trying to determine the arm length IMO. At least it takes some of the subjective nature away from values.

Now, there may be something to what LONGTABBER has been blabbering about...

Translation: Sweaty has no idea what he is talking about (hence it appears to be blabbering to him) and is therefore going to ignore the problems with what he is doing.


In your free time, Astro...feel free to show where the error is in those comparisons I posted...........if you can.

Gee, can I have a few hours? After all, you still haven't got back to me on my analysis (oh that's right you just implied you don't like "numbers" - i.e. math). As I stated, your measurements are highly subjective and open to interpretation. To me, it is better to make actual measurements and see how your claims stand up. Right now it seems that you are implying that "patty/bunny" had to have a smaller foot in order for the arm to be too long. Does that mean the 14.5" casts are fakes?

Btw, your comparison fails with Bob H on several points.

1. Patty/bunny is walking with the left shoulder up and the right shoulder down giving the false impression of the right arm being too long. Bob H. is seen walking/standing from a different angle with the shoulders square.

2. Bob H is seen from a different angle than patty/bunny in the comparison shots.

3. You can not see the bottom of patty/bunny's feet. You assume that you scaled that correctly since the feet are obscurred by terrain. We don't know if patty/bunny is in a hole or not.

4. Bob is not wearing a suit, which would add length to the arm. A large glove would extend his hand.

I could go on and probably will later.
 
Last edited:
There's enough of Bob H walking and posing both in the Morris recreation and street clothes. I've yet to see any photograph of Bob H where his arms look as long as Pattys and his height is in his legs. Now if Bob's the guy in the suit then we should be able to confirm some sort of corrolation between him and Patty. After all they did us the favor of the Morris recreation which is lame but has some servicable stills. Bob is good in the height department but he comes up short in the arms and long in the legs. I keep thinking of a fellow named Ivan Putksi who was a professional wrestler in the 70's. Although he was less than 6ft tall he was long and wide in the torso like Patty long in the arms and short in the legs. Human variation at its finest. Scale Ivan up a little and he would have filled the PGF suit well.
 
I knew it! I knew that it wouldn't be long before the typical attack dog mentaity that lurks just under the skin of this joint would come to the surface.
I couldn't agree more. And to think; Bill really hasn't been a member here all that long ..

Maybe he brought the attack dog mentality with him ...


To Bill ( and many other self styled experts ); skeptic = questioning my expertise ..

If you can't stand the heat ------------....
 
Last edited:
beed2b14.jpg
b2fcaa8d.jpg
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
As I stated, your measurements are highly subjective and open to interpretation.



Actually....the alignment points I used are objective, Astro. :)


Again.....

I used images....aligning 2 known points on Bob H. and Patty...their eyes and the bottoms of their feet. If Bob H. was actually Patty, then his eyes had to line-up with Patty's eyes, and the same with the feet, also.


The location of the eyes, and the feet, (on both Bob and Patty) are known within a high degree of precision.....and are determined by both subject's skeletal structures.....not padding in a suit.

It's a real shame that Bob's arm comes up a few inches short of Patty's (every time) when the 2 subjects are scaled appropriately so that their eyes and their feet match-up.....but that's just TOO FREAKIN' BAD for you, and the rest of the gang, my friend! :D
 
Last edited:
Crowlogic wrote:
Now if Bob's the guy in the suit then we should be able to confirm some sort of corrolation between him and Patty.
Bob is good in the height department but he comes up short in the arms and long in the legs.


Bob also comes up too short...or, too narrow, to be precise...in the 'chest width' department, Crow.

I've already posted a comparison of Bob and Patty's chest width, somewhere back in this thread...I believe. I'll try to re-post it tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
To all:

Thank you for your remarks about my new website.

It reflects the truth of my work, my thoughts and my feelings. Some people will understand and respect me. Others will not. Such is life, and I'm fine with that.

To those who want to criticize me, with talk of "mumbo jumbo" and similar dismissive remarks, I respect your right to express your opinion even if I disagree. Most of all, I respect this forum's basic intent, which is to allow people to express their thoughts in a candid form, and discuss varying points of view on a specific subject.

That said, to one and all, have a nice day.

:)

Bill
 
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/beed2b14.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/b2fcaa8d.jpg[/qimg]

Nicely plotted lines William. Perhaps there's something to work on from this. But in order for it to gain valid standing then the auto response of the film being of too poor a resolution to show this kind of detail will have to be suspended. And it it is given the dispensation then that same dispensation will need to be applied to the other things that others claim to see on either side of the issue.
 
Actually....the alignment points I used are objective, Astro.

But what about the other points. Are the angles of the shoulder identical? From what I can measure, I see Patty/Bunny's shoulders angled at 25 degrees from the horizontal and Bob H angled at 16 degrees. But wait...there is more. The hands are a different angles. The Patty/Bunny hand is angled at 50 degrees from horizontal, while Bob's hand is angled at roughly 30 degrees. Because the angles are different we can not consider this a valid comparison because the leaning to the right of Patty/Bunny and the different angles of the hand can produce a different result. Want some more? The angle of Patty's arm is at 71 degrees from the horizontal and Bob's is 68.

I can also point out that Bob's arm looks like it is not by his side and could be swung towards the camera, while Patty/Bunny's appears to be more perpendicular to the camera. This gives the foreshortening appearence of Bob's arm.

As for your second set of pics, this is not even close to a valid comparison because the two subjects are in two completely different poses.

In both cases of your line diagrams, the pixel difference between the two finger tips in the Y-direction is about 30 pixels, which looks like about 6 inches (based on the size of Bob H's hand). The angle difference in the hand in the first comparison is 20 degrees, which using a 6-inch hand as a reference adds roughly 1.5" to the vertical drop. This means we have to lower Bob's finger tip line about 7 pixels. Assuming the shoulders are roughly 15" across The drop of Patty would be about 2" more for Patty/Bunny than Bob. Lower Bob's fingertip line by another 10 pixels. This is a total of 17 pixels of the 30 difference you have in your line diagrams. If we assume Bob has a 33" long arm One can add another half-inch. Drop the line another 2 pixels. So, with just these three differences, we discover that we are only about 2" short of Patty/Bunny's finger tips. This does not take into account the possibility that Bob's arm swing was towards the camera, giving the impression of a short arm. It also does not take into account the size of a glove over Bob's hand. How much would that add? How far does Bob have to stick his hand into a suit glove to "wiggle fingers for you"? Based on my experiment with regular gloves, I think 1-2 inches of space between the finger tips and actual fingers will work.

Edit: Lastly, Bob H's fingers are not straight out and are curved. Could that result in a missing 1/2-1 inch?

So you see, there are variables at work here when you only use two points of reference. The rest is subjective because of the use of only two data points to position your images. This MK 48 ADCAP has done its work (Bonus points for anyone who can figure out that without google).

As for my analysis, I keep waiting and waiting and waiting...Tick...Tock....the world wonders.


.but that's just TOO FREAKIN' BAD for you, and the rest of the gang, my friend!

Sounds like somebody is getting a bit testy. I suggest you take a deep breath, get a measuring tool and a calculator, and look at the problems with what you are trying to do. You are ignoring variables that result in you getting the answer you desire. You have not shown that the arms are too long.
 
Last edited:
Yeah Crow, it's a shame. Guy hasn't been here long, won't discuss much and he's already giving me the finger. You'd think a qualified suit guy wouldn't resort to flipping people off.

The nerve...

Notice he didn't do it here...
 
Last edited:
This is what I think is the cause of the padding reveal. The blue is a thigh pad to give the impression of solid bulk or musculature. The red is the actual body of the mime.

07b0fc3c.gif


620f5655.jpg
 
Astrophotographer wrote:




Actually....the alignment points I used are objective, Astro. :)

Again.....
The location of the eyes, and the feet, (on both Bob and Patty) are known within a high degree of precision.....and are determined by both subject's skeletal structures.....not padding in a suit.

It's a real shame that Bob's arm comes up a few inches short of Patty's (every time) when the 2 subjects are scaled appropriately so that their eyes and their feet match-up.....but that's just TOO FREAKIN' BAD for you, and the rest of the gang, my friend! :D

You dont seem to get the point do you?

>>>Actually....the alignment points I used are objective,

No they are not and they will never be until you can qualify and quantify them on a 3 D interpolation using validated measurements of BOTH.

The proof in the pudding and test method is simple- show the actual measurements and how you derived them. Until you do/can, your argument is false by default.

>>>The location of the eyes, and the feet, (on both Bob and Patty) are known within a high degree of precision.....and are determined by both subject's skeletal structures.....not padding in a suit.


who determined this? What are the measurements and how was this verified for accuracy? ( also, where is Patty's skeleton for a comparative analysis?)

>>>It's a real shame that Bob's arm comes up a few inches short of Patty's (every time) when the 2 subjects are scaled appropriately so that their eyes and their feet match-up.....but that's just TOO FREAKIN' BAD for you, and the rest of the gang, my friend! :D[/QUOTE]


The "objects" arent scaled- the PICTURES are
 
Bill, Roger Patterson did a much better job of drawing Patty's nose (on the cover of his book) as compared to you. Of course, he did this before Patty showed up. The nose, mouth, jaw and chin are virtually identical.

fc590c86.gif
fbb92c40.jpg





Here you go CN...

92719891.jpg
 
More fun stuff...

Here we see the Morris "recreation" suit superimposed over Frame 352. Who knows if they are properly scaled to each other. If you assume that these are properly scaled, then you have very similar bulk. Bob H in a costume would appear to be about the same size and weight as Patty. LOL. :eye-poppi

e3606962.gif




Ms. Rock Hard Boobs goes for a little stroll across the sandbar...

0249340f.gif
 
I think the Morris recreation is too bulky or certain proportions are. For instance the thigh on the recreation seems wider on the MR. and the armfrom shoulder to elbo seems wider too. The MR for whatever reason dosn't have the same sense of muscle mass as the PGF. The MR looks more like a suit. They would have done much better if they had filmed it in the sunlight instead of the overc'shad they apparantly shot it in. The head dosn't look right and the face reminds me of someone with a fox tail wrapped around their jaw. Looks like Mr Morris couldn't make lightning strike twice even with the same cast. But you know haw it is reunions are never as good as the original.
 
I think the Morris recreation is too bulky or certain proportions are.

Isn't that a bit like saying... "When they put the guy who confessed into an approximate recreation suit, he appeared to be larger and heavier than Patty."?

If they are this similar in mass, then how could the Patty tracks end up being so deep that Gimlin couldn't replicate it even when jumping off a log (stomp test)?

BH is about 6' tall. The headpiece crest and the fake feet might add several inches to this. The total height of this costume, with him in it, could be something like 6' 3" - 6' 7".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom