Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good points Atomic .. ( Or do you prefer Mr. MysteryMonster ?)

Heh. Atomic's fine.

If there is no Bigfoots ( which the evidence or lack thereof, indicates ), the subject of the film is a bloke in a suit..

Good point, but I should note that even if you allow bigfoot into the equation, it's still more likely that the PGF is a hoax. Unless they found a bigfoot kind enough to redo its tracks and develop the film for them...
 
Patty didn't need to have functional hands and fingers.

Nowhere in the PGF do we see Patty's hands flex or move like a primate's hand.

We have one shaky example where one of Patty's hands appears to curve a little bit more for a brief moment.

That's it.

No need to talk about complex bending hands with moving fingers.

Nothing like that is in the PGF.

There aren't even any fingers visible in the PGF. Just the side of a hand, briefly.

The great apes use hand gestures, iirc.

Patty does nothing with her hands as far as I can tell.

Patty does nothing to warn others of the threat as far as I can tell.

Patty did not smell the humans approaching, or she would not have been there when they arrived, so she was surprised by them.

Yet she basically has no reaction at all other than to stroll away and look back.
 
Last edited:
Just a simple question here, but why didn't Patty just walk into the forest that was right next to her instead of walking all the way across a dry creek bed to get to the forest on the other side? Not an expert, but is it typical animal behavior to take the longest escape route possible versus the one right next to them?
 
Well rise to the occasion and whip up a mechicanal hand using 1967 materials and methods. I don't think it'd be all that easy.

It is relatively easy using a glove, a few fixed parts inside it, and a few long cable. All using method available *centuries* before 1967. It all depends how far you want it to be flexing, and how visible the cable can be. Think "puppet" on a cable with instead the thin cable going from the fake wrist to the fake tip of finer, then running all along the arm to the real finger. Draw one cable and a finger will bend. In 1967 there were already nylon cable thin enough not to be easily visible. Ergo it is relatively easy. The biggest pain is making sure the cable slide easily enough and the finger slide back once you release the cable.
 
Just a simple question here, but why didn't Patty just walk into the forest that was right next to her instead of walking all the way across a dry creek bed to get to the forest on the other side? Not an expert, but is it typical animal behavior to take the longest escape route possible versus the one right next to them?

This is a good question, and one that I have asked on the Bigfoot Forums a few times. I have never gotten a good answer. The one that seems to jump out is the 'Broken Wing' Scenario. This is when the Footers say that there were baby Bigfeets in the area, and Patty was deliberately leading Bob and Rog away from the babies.

Of course there is no evidence to support this theory, but that is the answer I recieved...
 
It is relatively easy using a glove, a few fixed parts inside it, and a few long cable. All using method available *centuries* before 1967. It all depends how far you want it to be flexing, and how visible the cable can be. Think "puppet" on a cable with instead the thin cable going from the fake wrist to the fake tip of finer, then running all along the arm to the real finger. Draw one cable and a finger will bend. In 1967 there were already nylon cable thin enough not to be easily visible. Ergo it is relatively easy. The biggest pain is making sure the cable slide easily enough and the finger slide back once you release the cable.



Has Bob Heironimus ever stated that the suit he allegedly wore had a mechanically-controlled hand in it?

It seems to me that if that was, in fact, the case...he would have mentioned it at some point in time.
 
The broken wing scenario is all they can come up with to explain why Patty doesn't run for cover when surprised by the threat of two humans.

Well, they had one more over the years. Patty was sick and not behaving properly. She was not able to run away.

Patty does not actually demonstrate any sign of encouraging Roger and Bob to chase her, though. They don't actually chase her, and she does nothing about that. She does not, for example, slow down to let them get closer to encourage them to chase her.

Patty does not make a warning call, either. If there are other bigfoots nearby, Patty did not warn them of the threat.

If Patty was sick, not behaving properly, and not able to run away, then Roger and Bob should have easily caught her on horseback when they trailed her for 3 miles.
 
Last edited:
Has Bob Heironimus ever stated that the suit he allegedly wore had a mechanically-controlled hand in it?

What does Patty do that would require such a hand? A slight flexing of the palm would not require anything but an ordinary costume glove, and that's all we apparently see, a slight flex of the palm.
 
Well rise to the occasion and whip up a mechicanal hand using 1967 materials and methods. I don't think it'd be all that easy.
Crow, other posters already made it. But here's one possible take: Check that picture of a gorilla's mechanical hand. Its made of aluminum and dates from the 30's or 40's. Instead of five independent wires or springs, one for each finger, a single wire or spring moving all fingers at once. Not unlike a pincer. And the spring will make the fingers move back to their original positions.

But again, its overkill. There's no need, I think, for this. As I wrote before:

The "moving fingers effect" was quite possibly, an accident. If the fingers moved, the movement was created by partially worn gloves, in the style Tube demonstrated, or by flexible gloves hold by a stick. This happened because Patterson wanted long arms for his bigfoot (not as long as a gorilla's).

I think its easier to build simple arm extensions than to find someone with long arms.

But why am I talking about a mechanical hand with moving fingers? Simple. I don't buy the idea that Patty was a sophisticated costume. I don't buy the idea that it required techniques wich were not available back in the 60's. In my opinion, costume-building techniques from the late 60s and before, would be more than enough to create Patty or a costume wich would perform better than Patty under the circunstances of PGF. So, underestimating the techniques and expertise available back then is not a good idea.

Before this hand flex thing becomes a flame contest ...snip...
I see no reason for this to happen. I have no intention of turning this in to one.
 
Last edited:
I don't even see why the hand movement is an issue.

There is no evidence that movement is even evident in the film
 
How many times have we done the ' finger bend ' analysis ?

LTC8K6 says all there is to say above ..

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3828219&postcount=14602

And once again I ask Sweaty..


So what, if the fingers bend ?

Please explain how this would tilt the evidence toward a non-human North American primate, and away from a bloke in a suit ?

How many times have we asked you that Sweaty ?


Remind us what your answer was ...
 
This is a good question, and one that I have asked on the Bigfoot Forums a few times. I have never gotten a good answer. The one that seems to jump out is the 'Broken Wing' Scenario. This is when the Footers say that there were baby Bigfeets in the area, and Patty was deliberately leading Bob and Rog away from the babies.

Of course there is no evidence to support this theory, but that is the answer I recieved...

In other words, they'll pretty much jump to any other conclusion if it helps them ignore the obvious one. :) I've read maybe half of this thread, and that became pretty apparent around page 3.
 
Diogenes wrote:
So what, if the fingers bend ?

Please explain how this would tilt the evidence toward a non-human North American primate, and away from a bloke in a suit ?


I explained why Patty's fingers bending greatly reduces the likelihood that Bob H. was in the "suit", in my post #14565.

Feel free to re-read it as many times as you like until you can understand what my reasoning was....and is. :)
 
Last edited:
Since nobody answered it.....I'll ask the question again.....


Has Bob Heironimus ever stated that the suit he allegedly wore had a mechanically-controlled hand in it?
 
Has BH ever mentioned whether or not his fingers were all the way in the gloves? I think his hands fell short of the gloves and the gloves were more or less just hanging on the sleeves. No extenders used. Just empty gloves.
 
Last edited:
I explained why Patty's fingers bending greatly reduces the likelihood that Bob H. was in the "suit", in my post #14565.

Feel free to re-read it as many times as you like until you can understand what my reasoning was....and is. :)
That still doesn't answer the question " So what, if the fingers bend ? "

How do bending fingers reduce the likelihood of a hoax ?
 
Bigfoot babies? Oh that was that idiot who got the idea from an "old indian". But lets not forget the new and improved nonsense about the bigfoot masacare. Seems MK Davis claims Bob Gimlin went on a shooting spree and wasted 4 or 5 of Patty's kin. Then Roger came in with a backhoe and covered the whole mess up. Heck flexing fingers are small potatoes compared to the latest gossip.
 
That still doesn't answer the question " So what, if the fingers bend ? "

How do bending fingers reduce the likelihood of a hoax ?


Well, to start with...it's the unusually loooooooooooooong arms of Patty, combined with bending-fingers, that makes Patty seem more like a real live wild creature than a Bobby-in-the-suit.

Why......here's yet another example of Patty's unusually looooooooooooong arms...:).
Again, lining-up the eyes and the feet...


Patty7AG.gif
BBCjoke2.jpg




....Patty wins again. The human's arm pulls-up several inches too short.

Since Patty's arms are obviously longer than a typical human's arms (proportionally speaking), the question then becomes...
"How do the fingers bend? Is there a hand extension, with remote-controlled fingers causing it?"

Here are 3 reasons why a remote-controlled hand extension would be an unlikely explanation...

1) A hand extension would cause Patty's upper/lower arm proportion to be out-of-whack....but it isn't.

2) Patty's fingers are NOT seen bending in the part of the film where Roger steadies the camera and Patty looks back. That would be the part of the film where Bob should have used the "extras package" (remo-hand) that Roger went through all the trouble to build into the suit.
But.......strangely.......the fingers do not bend at all in that very steady part of the film.

3) Bob H., as far as I know, has never mentioned anything about a remote-controlled hand extension in his "suit".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom