Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
IIRC, Dfoot already convincingly addressed the flexing fingers question with an animation of his own.

I've seen Dfoot's flexing hand. But we have to remember to think 1967 here. I don't think that Patterson could have afforded a mechanical hand even if one had been available back then, which it more likely than not wasn't. So it comes back to long armed mime that moved hands a bit during the filming.
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:



This effectively rebukes Bob's claim of being the guy-in-the-suit...

If Bob really was Patty....then his eyes were lined-up with Patty's eyes, and his feet were lined-up with Patty's feet. But in this comparison, when the eyes and the feet are matched-up, Bob's arms are too short....


....and could not have been directly responsible for this....




Here's another comparison....for good measure...:)...


Sorry for the bad news, boys....but you all can go right on pretending Bob was Patty, if it makes you feel better! ;)

Hate to spoil your all too brief "victory" but the comparisons you posted are the worst of JUNK science, meaningless and wouldnt hold water against any REAL cross examination.

The difference is between BF "forensic science" and REAL forensic science. ( those 2 are LIGHT YEARS apart) I've posted long detailed descriptions on the other forum ( for your reading) and despite the weeping and wailing, they still stand- they will here too. I'm going to give you the short text version and you can search/read the detailed ones on the BFF for more depth

First- my qualifications.- I/we ( I'm the owner) are an Engineering firm with a Civil division and a Mechanical division and do about every form of metrology on earth including photogrametry and we use it frequently for R&D,Design,Cartography, CNC machining,Back Engineering and Surveying. We can stamp and certify.

Now to the inherent problems with your comparison. ( and you arent the first to make similar arguments)

1) to be able to take pictures with verifiable accuracy for critical measurements- one must have a stereo camera or an ISO "metric camera" because the cameras internals must be known so measurements can be derived- none of these pictures were made with such devices.

2) pristine originals must be used for the measurements- not copies of copies ( distortion creeps in)- theres no way to know about the BH pictures but the original PGF seems to have vanished. That alone would get the comparisons laughed out of any legitimate validation.

3) Without 1 above, the correct dimensions from lens to subject with known measurements in all 3 planes must be known with a fixed benchmark. ( reasonably accurate can be done with regular cameras IF the measurements are known- in this case, there are ZERO accurate references to compare from)

I could write a short thesis on this but those are the main parts. In the end, all you have presented is a "looks like" comparison based on visual acquity with no valid metrics or common references to base a comparison on.

Since there are no known measurements, the cameras were not proper and the originals not available, no one can make an accurate comparison between those pictures with any degree of accuracy.

Sorry, but thats reality
 
He remains stuck right there, and brings up the same gif about once a month, give or take.
:jaw-dropp Sweet Fancy Moses! I might need to consult a lunar chart and cross-reference posting times but could Sweaty be...:scared: ...a werewoo!?:yikes:

I can see it now...

Heavy brown and grey clouds part in the night sky outside the window of a man happily at home on the internet reading about the April 2008 discovery in Ireland of the Greater White-toothed Shrew (Crocidura russula), native to North Africa and Europe, and it's possible effects on endemic Eurasian Pygmy Shrew population(Sorex minutus). Suddenly and without warning the man lurches over with a scream of excrutiating pain. Sweat pours from his stricken and tormented face as it twists and contorts and he frantically clutches for anything to hold on to. His body spasms and he falls from his seat howling. His howling in pain turns to hyperventilation which then turns to an odd and unsettling high-pitched giggle. The man rises with Nick Nolte mugshot-esque hair, his jaw jutted forward baring his lower teeth, and his wild and fevered eyes crossed and looking upward to the space between his eyebrows as he breathes heavily...

...He awakens the next morning to find himself on the floor with a Graham Hancock book for a pillow, surrounded by DVD copies of MonsterQuest, a protractor in his hand, and his computer table covered in printouts of Patterson/Gimlin film stills, Martian surface images, and pencil crayons. He gives his keyboard a tap and the screen comes up displaying some notification of banning from a Bigfoot enthusiast forum.

His private hell continues.
 
Since there are no known measurements, the cameras were not proper and the originals not available, no one can make an accurate comparison between those pictures with any degree of accuracy.

Sorry, but thats reality
Welcome to the JREF, LONGTABBER. I'm familiar with your handle from the BFF (though I don't post there). This is IMO the best place for PGF discussion and people who enjoy the Bigfoot myth and it's enthusiasts. Hope you enjoy it.
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:



This effectively rebukes Bob's claim of being the guy-in-the-suit...

If Bob really was Patty....then his eyes were lined-up with Patty's eyes, and his feet were lined-up with Patty's feet. But in this comparison, when the eyes and the feet are matched-up, Bob's arms are too short....

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/Patty1lined1.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/Bob1lined1.jpg[/qimg]


....and could not have been directly responsible for this....


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/handmove2ag.gif[/qimg]


Here's another comparison....for good measure...:)...


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty7a.jpg[/qimg][qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/BobH4.jpg[/qimg]


Sorry for the bad news, boys....but you all can go right on pretending Bob was Patty, if it makes you feel better! ;)

Wow, I can't believe you guys let this slide. How far away was patty? How far away was Bob? You can zoom in and out on either picture and put blue lines anywhere you want and make them match or mismatch at will. Unless you have a tape measure to show the distance from the camera and the same equipment, comparisons like this mean absolutely nothing. Plus Bob's hand is clearly further up the back swing than patty's so naturally the blue line would be a smidgen higher.


By the way, just pointing this out, I'll go back to lurking now. So no, I probably won't reply to whatever faulted argument or challenge you will reply to me.
 
Starthinker- We have done that before, this is not Groundbreaking Research you are seeing from Sweaty. When Sweaty answers GT's arm band question, and completes the promised 'head in the helmet' research. Then that will require rebuttal, but this old stuff we kind of let pass, which leads to reactions such as yours.
 


The problem with this illustration is that the animation has been touched up. Specifically in the hand which is the very thing under question. If nothing else Sweaty's untouched gif is less molested and truer to the actual film. Trying to make wrist rotation appearing as finger flexing reminds me of the photo of Rosemary Woods (Nixon's secretary) where she's shown at her desk in that ghastly contourted position unsuccessfully demonstrating how she proportedly accidently hit the erase button on the recorder that so conviently wipped a bunch of incriminating evidence against Nixon during Watergate.

So if we're seriously expected to believe a touched up gif that's been created to discredit flexing fingers it's going to take some sort demonstration/illustration of the PGF wrist/arm actually rotating. If that can't be demonstrated then we're left with the far simpler and easier to comprehend finger flexing. Rember if the fingers flex its not the end of the world. It just means that the fingers flex. Its far more likely that there was a nice long arm with a real moving hand in a nice big fur glove than a non mobile hand extension. If we're going to go with a hand extension then somebody better come up with convincing illustrations of Pattys arm proportions showing extensions. As it stands now her arms are proportionate.
 
Crowlogic said:
I've seen Dfoot's flexing hand. But we have to remember to think 1967 here. I don't think that Patterson could have afforded a mechanical hand even if one had been available back then, which it more likely than not wasn't. So it comes back to long armed mime that moved hands a bit during the filming.
There's no need for a long-armed guy to obtain the effect.

The easiest way to achieve the effect was demonstrated by Tube somewhere along this very thread -he even posted some pics of it. Just don't wear the glove all the way down and move your fingers. Easy and very cost-effective, its all it takes to create the range of movement that may be displayed by Patty's fingers. The method of choice, I would say, especially when I consider PGF's lenght, resolution and the possible movement range. Anything else would be overkill.

The same effect, as another poster noted, could also be obtained (even if unintentionally) by attaching at the tip of a stick gloves with floppy fingers. Swing the arms and the fingers may move. Maybe its what actually happened.

Regarding the 60's FX costume tech and mechanical props, please allow me to make a couple of comments.

Moving mechanical hands were available well before the 60s. This is from decades before the PGF:
popmechanics.jpg

Several vintage gorilla costumes had long arms with moving fingers.
If you accept Patterson had professional help to build/modify the costume (or rented one), mechanical hands would be a viable option.

Cheap toys back in the late 60s (or early 70s) had moving fingers.
claw1.jpg

Building a similar mechanism (with or without professional costume makers help) would not be, I think, such a challenge. So, a scracthbuilt simple mechanism would also be another viable option.

The last two methods are required for long forearm extensions. For smaller forearm lenght increases, the glove method is all it takes (specially when you consider the films lenght, resolution and range of -possibly seen- movement); anything else would be overkill.

And, once again, despite what some try to say...
Patty's (possibly) moving its fingers are not evidence supporting the Patty is a real bigfoot claim.
 
Yes I've seen Tubes had show. Not convincing. Its fine to post photos of things like the Robot hand etc. But this in 1967 we're talking about. I was alive in 1967 and I know first hand what was available in the way of gadgets and toys. It was the middle of the 20th century for gods sake practically the stone age!

But let's consider for a moment Roger Patterson is building a super hoax monkey suit and knows he needs movable hands to make it convincing so on top of the heroic undertaking of making the suit he also contraps at least one robot remote hand so the world can see his creature has real live moving hands. OH COME ON NOW!! Footers have been called on the carpet for less than trying to rationalize a flexing hand as a side effect of arm/wrist twist.

So unless some proponent of twist comes forward and produces a mapping of the twist on actual PGF I'm sticking with someone's fingers moved but I doubt it was Bob H's.
 
Wow, I can't believe you guys let this slide. How far away was patty? How far away was Bob? You can zoom in and out on either picture and put blue lines anywhere you want and make them match or mismatch at will. Unless you have a tape measure to show the distance from the camera and the same equipment, comparisons like this mean absolutely nothing. Plus Bob's hand is clearly further up the back swing than patty's so naturally the blue line would be a smidgen higher.


By the way, just pointing this out, I'll go back to lurking now. So no, I probably won't reply to whatever faulted argument or challenge you will reply to me.

I didnt miss it
 
Yes I've seen Tubes had show. Not convincing. Its fine to post photos of things like the Robot hand etc. But this in 1967 we're talking about. I was alive in 1967 and I know first hand what was available in the way of gadgets and toys. It was the middle of the 20th century for gods sake practically the stone age!

But let's consider for a moment Roger Patterson is building a super hoax monkey suit and knows he needs movable hands to make it convincing so on top of the heroic undertaking of making the suit he also contraps at least one robot remote hand so the world can see his creature has real live moving hands. OH COME ON NOW!! Footers have been called on the carpet for less than trying to rationalize a flexing hand as a side effect of arm/wrist twist.

Gloves were widely available in 1967. IIRC, Tube used only a glove.

Also, IIRC, no fingers are ever visible in the PGF.

The hand turn illusion was already discussed to death and demonstrated very nicely. It's entirely possible that the hand bending is an illusion, just as it's possible that the hand actually bends. There is no way to say for sure. There is no reason to rank one possibility above any others, such as noise in the images, or the fur of the suit blocking part of the hand in a frame. The PGF we have been allowed to see is simply too poor in quality and resolution.

Also remember that Sweaty's animation skips images to achieve the end result.
 
Do you see twisting of the wrist in the gif? I don't.

The fact that sweaty's .gif is made from two nonconsecutive frames might have something to do with that. This links to what are (supposedly) the frames in between.

I hardly imagine Patterson instructing his mime to rotate his hand/arm in just the right way so as to provide viewers 40 years later the illousion of hand movement.

I suspect that anyone arguing for the illusion explanation would say that its appearance in the film is merely a "happy accident" rather than something that was planned. Similarly, I seem to recall someone suggesting that a film artifact seen in another .gif that made other objects in the film appear to shift could've made the fingers seem to flex, so it's not like the rotation illusion was the only explanation offered up here.

Frankly, the whole finger flexing issue is a moot point, seeing how easy it is to create the illusion of long arms without any complicated extensions:

In this, Dfoot demonstrates how the position of one's arm during a "swing" can create the illusion of greater/shorter length.

Here's a gloved version of Dfoot's "notice the arms" comparison, which I feel matches up better with the BBC publicity photo.

Here's Dfoot's gorilla glove animation. No special mechanical parts or anything, it's just a standard gorilla glove.

0:47 of this video has someone with their arms in a position like Patty's. (Mildly NSFW)

This is a large version of the picture I had found of someone imitating the Patty walk for a contest.

Here is a picture of tube imitating Patty's walk and has his arms in a similar position/look longer.

More on "long arms."
 
Last edited:
I feel that the best way to determine whether or not the PGF is real is to look at the circumstances surrounding the film rather than by looking at what's on the film.

Take, for example, the alien autopsy video. If you were discussing it with someone who refused to discount the idea that the anatomical errors seen in the film could be due to differences in extraterrestrial anatomy, you could convince them by making them look at this link about Roswell and this link that answers the "if it was just a downed weather balloon, how come nobody else mistook one for a crashed flying saucer?" (which I liken to a distance cousin of the "all the sightings can't be misidentifications, hoaxes, and hallucinations" argument, which itself is rebutted here) question, it is clear that it's extremely unlikely that an alien spacecraft crashed in Roswell and that it was merely a downed weather balloon. As a result, the alien autopsy video has to be a hoax (since there was no crashed spaceship to recover bodies from).

As I touched on here, there are some very big problems with the PGF timeline: Hpw could the footprints survive the flood-causing rain if they were made when Patterson and Gimlin said they were? How come the accounts of the time the film was sent conflict? How could Patterson have the film developed over the weekend when he was using a type of film that could only be developed by Kodak facilities? Furthermore, how could Patterson and Gimlin have done everything they claimed to have done in that timeline, given all the time it would take to go back and forth on horseback?

I think the answer is simple: Patterson and Gimlin hoaxed the film and the footprints at times different than the ones they gave to the public. The footprints were most likely made (or remade) sometime after the rain so that things wouldn't look suspicious if anyone investigated the filming site. Similarly, the film was probably made sometime before the claimed filming date so that there'd be more than enough time to get it developed and edited.
 
Yes I've seen Tubes had show. Not convincing.
I consider it as a quite convincent demonstration about how easy it is to make a costume with long arms and moving fingers. What if he had used parts of a modified gorilla costume, filmed at PGF conditions?

Its fine to post photos of things like the Robot hand etc. But this in 1967 we're talking about. I was alive in 1967 and I know first hand what was available in the way of gadgets and toys. It was the middle of the 20th century for gods sake practically the stone age!
Crow, the robot hand I posted a pic of is actually nothing but a modified pair of pincers. Its actually very simple and was available at the time frame I mentioned (I was available back then also). The articulated gorilla hand (created decades before the PGF) allowed individual finger movement; while the toy hand did not. Potentially both methods could have been used to create moving fingers at the end of long arms. Both are overkill, I think.

But let's consider for a moment Roger Patterson is building a super hoax monkey suit and knows he needs movable hands to make it convincing so on top of the heroic undertaking of making the suit he also contraps at least one robot remote hand so the world can see his creature has real live moving hands. OH COME ON NOW!! Footers have been called on the carpet for less than trying to rationalize a flexing hand as a side effect of arm/wrist twist.
Who's saying it was a "super hoax monkey suit"?
Here's my position, in case I wasn't clear enough so far: The "moving fingers effect" was quite possibly, an accident. If the fingers moved, the movement was created by partially worn gloves, in the style Tube demonstrated, or by flexible gloves hold by a stick. This happened because Patterson wanted long arms for his bigfoot (not as long as a gorilla's).

The Patty costume was not, I think, above gorilla suits of those days when it comes to building techniques or quality. It only needed to be good enough to appear at a short shaky film, shot from a long distance, showing few details (only from the right side and the back); a film targeted to fool a number of people who already were inclined to belive the "Abominable Snowman of America" is real.

So unless some proponent of twist comes forward and produces a mapping of the twist on actual PGF I'm sticking with someone's fingers moved but I doubt it was Bob H's.
I have no idea regarding wo was inside the costume when the PGF was shot. For all I know it may have been Bob Hieronimus, Bob Gimlim or anyone else inside the gorilla bigfoot costume.

All I'm saying is that it does not take too much engineering or originally long arms to achieve -on purpose or not- finger movements such as those that may be recorded at PGF.
 
Good points Atomic .. ( Or do you prefer Mr. MysteryMonster ?)

If there is no Bigfoots ( which the evidence or lack thereof, indicates ), the subject of the film is a bloke in a suit..

The failure to understand how the suit was made or how it works, does not make the possibility that the subject of the film is a non-human North American primate, any more likely ..
 
Cheap toys back in the late 60s (or early 70s) had moving fingers.
[qimg]http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d150/AVCN/claw1.jpg[/qimg]
Building a similar mechanism (with or without professional costume makers help) would not be, I think, such a challenge. So, a scracthbuilt simple mechanism would also be another viable option.


Well rise to the occasion and whip up a mechicanal hand using 1967 materials and methods. I don't think it'd be all that easy.
 
Before this hand flex thing becomes a flame contest I'll state my position with regards to the hand arm question. When I see the film I see a subject with long (for a human but not out of the range) arms that have the proportions of a normal flesh and blood appendage with regards the position of the articulation points. For me this indicates that Bob H didn't wear the suit because his arms are on the short side for Patty. Because of the naturalistic proportions of the arm it make infinately more sense that there a human inside with long enough arm to make the creature suit work as a functioning unit. Virtually every illustration I've encountered where forearm and hand extensions have been used results in an unnatural proportion for an animal such as is claimed in the PGF.

Perhaps the Morris recreation would show the hands to better effect if the Morris recreaton was available in detail. Its not, or is it? I suppose that one explanation that supports the idea of "dead hands" is that a short armed mime operated the suit but said short arms never extended into the hands far enough to effect movement of the fingers. I prefer the idea of a mime that properly filled out the suit and could have operated the hands because the mimes fingers were inside the suit. Its a lot simpler than having to speculate on mechanicnal hands. Also everyone is 100% accurate that flexing fingers or not does not make or break it one way or the other. Silly arm extensions would of course put paid to the film.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom