Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. I'm sure Gimlin has a list of questions which are off the table, I'd like to see that, before considering my line of questioning.
2. Would Gimlin be subject to a lie detector? Is there any record of him subjecting to that?
C. Is there a given reason, by 'footers why BobH is considered the liar?, or is it the nature of his story itself which has branded him as one? Vice versa in regards to Gimlin?

Chances are that Gimlin taking a poly at this time ( 40+ years of reinforcement) would be unfruitful because its doubtful he would have physiological reactions after so many times recanting his version. ( based on my experience using them)

I learned this in my years investigating and building cases as a real investigator investigating real incidents using tested and true methods and proving them in real courts.

People will lie, they will do it with composure and with a straight face. You cannot base it soley in their life circumstances, reputation or anything else except the SITUATION at hand. ( what they have to gain or lose)

I have never seen or heard of BG ever being asked the "hard" questions, his account investigated for accuracy in any vigorous method or being challenged with any of the adverse stories or "questionable" circumstances.

Doesnt mean he is lying ( he may be on the up and up) but it DOES mean he has never been put to the acid test.

Same with BH. I have never seen where his account of wearing the suit has been FACTUALLY rebuked. ( nor has it been proven either) The reason he is accused of falsehood by the same general acceptance ( with nothing backing it up but personal opinion) is the same reason BG is given a ride for being honest. ( with nothing backing it up but personal opinion)

If BH is telling the truth, the PGF goes in the grave, dead and buried. ( and a lot of BF supporters with it)
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:
Same with BH. I have never seen where his account of wearing the suit has been FACTUALLY rebuked.


This effectively rebukes Bob's claim of being the guy-in-the-suit...

If Bob really was Patty....then his eyes were lined-up with Patty's eyes, and his feet were lined-up with Patty's feet. But in this comparison, when the eyes and the feet are matched-up, Bob's arms are too short....

Patty1lined1.jpg
Bob1lined1.jpg



....and could not have been directly responsible for this....


handmove2ag.gif



Here's another comparison....for good measure...:)...


Patty7a.jpg
BobH4.jpg



Sorry for the bad news, boys....but you all can go right on pretending Bob was Patty, if it makes you feel better! ;)
 
Last edited:
Sweaty the gif with showing the hand movement is claimed by some to be no more than a rotation of the hand into a different angle thus giving the illousion of flexing fingers. There was a post here showing a model hand supposedly demonstrating the effect. I was never convinced by that demonstration. The Patty gif is pretty effective as a true flexing of the fingers. Dosn't mean its not a suit but it takes more effort to discount flexing than it does to see it for what it is. I agree Bob H's arms look way too short to be Patty. But I've never believed Bob H wore the suit. Yet even when shown a comparison where you've lined up the pertenant elements of eyes and hands there will be those who will in knee jerk reaction claim Patty's arm aren't on the long side.

Back to the finger flex gif. There's not a snowballs chance in hell that Patty's hand/wrist is rotating and giving the illousion of flexing fingers. That's flexing boys and girls get over it!
 
Last edited:
Sweaty the gif with showing the hand movement is claimed by some to be no more than a rotation of the hand into a different angle thus giving the illousion of flexing fingers. There was a post here showing a model hand supposedly demonstrating the effect. I was never convinced by that demonstration. The Patty gif is pretty effective as a true flexing of the fingers. Dosn't mean its not a suit but it takes more effort to discount flexing than it does to see it for what it is. I agree Bob H's arms look way too short to be Patty. But I've never believed Bob H wore the suit. Yet even when shown a comparison where you've lined up the pertenant elements of eyes and hands there will be those who will in knee jerk reaction claim Patty's arm aren't on the long side.

Back to the finger flex gif. There's not a snowballs chance in hell that Patty's hand/wrist is rotating and giving the illousion of flexing fingers. That's flexing boys and girls get over it!

Wrong, wrong, wrong.

It's just twisting of the wrist. The fingers are always flexed but we can see that they are flexed only when they are viewed from the side. It's a fairly simple concept.
 
Sweaty the gif with showing the hand movement is claimed by some to be no more than a rotation of the hand into a different angle thus giving the illusion of flexing fingers.


Many months ago, I invented a saying just for that wacky explanation....(inspired by Johnny Cochran).....

"If the fingers bend...you must pretend". :covereyes


There was a post here showing a model hand supposedly demonstrating the effect. I was never convinced by that demonstration.


I'm glad to hear that, Crow.
Back when that 'doll-hand illusion' was presented, I showed why that was not what we're seeing with Patty. I think I posted my analysis of it in the "Simple Challenge" Bigfoot thread.

Basically...in the doll-hand illusion, when the fingers appear more bent, the palm of the hand appears wider.....but in Patty's case, when the fingers appear to be bent more, her palm is thinner, not wider......the exact opposite of the dollhand illusion.


Patty's fingers bend....pure and simple. :)



I agree Bob H's arms look way too short to be Patty. But I've never believed Bob H wore the suit. Yet even when shown a comparison where you've lined up the pertenant elements of eyes and hands there will be those who will in knee jerk reaction claim Patty's arm aren't on the long side.


They sure will...and they sure have!

Back to the finger flex gif. There's not a snowballs chance in hell that Patty's hand/wrist is rotating and giving the illousion of flexing fingers. That's flexing boys and girls get over it!

I'll second that, Crow! :)
 
Last edited:
Wrong, wrong, wrong.

It's just twisting of the wrist. The fingers are always flexed but we can see that they are flexed only when they are viewed from the side. It's a fairly simple concept.

Do you see twisting of the wrist in the gif? I don't. Now the big issue about those hands is whether or not they're real or simply fake extensions. So just for a moment has anyone figured out just how and why bother having a twisting fake hand. What good would that do have been? I hardly imagine Patterson instructing his mime to rotate his hand/arm in just the right way so as to provide viewers 40 years later the illousion of hand movement.

Also can you or anyone else indicate the twist moment of motion in the actual gif and how the twist of the phony hand was accomplished by the mime. Maybe Bill can shed some light here.

Is this hand (left showing palm) flexed straight or somewhere in between? The amount of flex in the gif is considerable and also if it was just a simple turning of the wrist the fingers would not get longer in what shows as the unflexd position.

 
Last edited:
The significant thing is, in those comparisons, is that the eyes and the bottom of the feet had to be matched-up if Bob was in the "suit"....and we know to a very high degree of accuracy where those are located in images of both Patty, and Bob.
So there's simply no other way to cut it....Bob's fingers are not Patty's fingers.
 
Last edited:
Crow:

"Also can you or anyone else indicate the twist moment of motion in the actual gif and how the twist of the phony hand was accomplished by the mime. Maybe Bill can shed some light here."

If the hand has fingers bent and the wrist is just twisting, the height of the fingertips should not change relative to the palm or any other reference point of the hand itself. The finger tips should simply move further away from the palm on the horizontal (to look more curled), and move closer to the palm (for looking more straight.).

I don't see either of those occuring, so I would be of the opinion the fingers are bending somewhat.

In theory, that could be accomplished with arm extensions on a suit, if you wanted to argue for a more professionally made suit. But the apparent elbow position is not the typical flaw of a suit with an arm extension. Arguing for a suit has the strongest argument if you specify the person wearing it has unusually long arms, longer than those of Bob H. as illustrated by Sweaty.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Bill

The only way I see a mime in a suit is a mime with very long arms at the long limit of human variation. This brings us to a deeper professional involvment than lore puts it. I failed to pay strict attention to the new POTA movie I just saw with regards to arm length. I was too busy focusing on facial details. Anybody have any input about the new POTA and arm length? Did they go cheap and just humanize the apes arm length?
 
Crow:

"Bill

The only way I see a mime in a suit is a mime with very long arms at the long limit of human variation. This brings us to a deeper professional involvment than lore puts it. I failed to pay strict attention to the new POTA movie I just saw with regards to arm length. I was too busy focusing on facial details. Anybody have any input about the new POTA and arm length? Did they go cheap and just humanize the apes arm length? "


As much as I recall, no arm extensions were used on the original POTA films, simply because of practical concerns (budget, convenience) plus the fact actors as apes had to handle things and arm extensions are really bad for any kind of handling things. So rather than commit to extended arms on all, and have horrible problems with ape actors handling weapons or horse reins (which no horse rider I know would agree to), and not wanting some arms long and others shorter, they just skipped it and asked the actors to slump their shoulders to lower their arms a bit.

Bill
 
RRRRRRRotate,

Rotate your rist, samething. Don't let light and shadow screw with your brain.


m

May need to click pic to animate...
 
Crow, we already spotted Sweaty the point that Patty's fingers do flex.

We were asked specifically by Sweaty to provide possible alternate explanations for Sweaty's animated gif of the fingers apparently flexing. So we thought of a few, and suggested them. Sweaty then tried to claim we had said these alternatives were what was actually happening. The hand rotation was just one possibility for what was observed.

One of the possibilities was always, "Patty's fingers are indeed flexing."

How this eliminates a suit is where Sweaty got stuck again.

He remains stuck right there, and brings up the same gif about once a month, give or take.
 
Crow, we already spotted Sweaty the point that Patty's fingers do flex.

We were asked specifically by Sweaty to provide possible alternate explanations for Sweaty's animated gif of the fingers apparently flexing. So we thought of a few, and suggested them. Sweaty then tried to claim we had said these alternatives were what was actually happening. The hand rotation was just one possibility for what was observed.

One of the possibilities was always, "Patty's fingers are indeed flexing."

How this eliminates a suit is where Sweaty got stuck again.

He remains stuck right there, and brings up the same gif about once a month, give or take.

And every time he posts the gif I point out the nice shiny straight-as-an-arrow wrist band which he pretends doesn't exist, every once a month or so. Just like clockwork.
 
Both gifs are fine but there seems a true lenghtening of the hand when the fingers are in the open position. A simple rotational illousion won't produce the lengthening. So mime needs nice long arms because as Bill Munns rightly notes the arm does not show the tell tale disproportanately long forearm that arm extensions produce.

This is where Dfoots Hollywood connections have potential. Mime with long arms needed to fill professionally made suit. Suit maker knows mime, suit is made to fit mime and Patty gets to be filmed with realistic arm proportions. Those pics above of Bob H. aligned with Patty have Bob comming up short in the arm department. The Morris recreation with Bob seems to indicate that the arms aren't actually as long as Pattys.
 
Here is a simple illustration of finger joints actually flexing, as compared to a bent finger group rotating so the forward most finger appears to be straighter because of the turn.

In one case, the finger tip moves only on the horizontal plane (rotation of hand), while in a real bend, it moves on both horizontal and vertical planes.

Chart attached.

forgot to mention the red bars indicate the changes of position from the point of view. Top group shows change only horizontal, bottom group has horizontal and vertical changes.

Bill

 
Last edited:
If the fingers bend why should we assume they are firm and must be manually bent? Who's to say they aren't flexible and don't open and close a little as BH walks?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom