Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Saying that comparing images has NO degree of accuracy is idiotic, as far as I'm concerned....so I'm not putting much stock into what LT says, until he can demonstrate, with images,exactly what he's talking about.

Well sweetie, be careful of what you ask for because you may in fact get it.( cant post pics and links yet due to a low post count so you will just have to accept the text version)

So, sit down, put on your thinking cap because school is in session and you are going to, as many before you, learn from the master.

1) we must first start out by establishing the authority, source and accreditation of the information to be presented. That authority is the BOK, standards and criteria set forth from the ASPRS. ( The American Society for Photogrammetry & Remote Sensing )

2) We must define the objective of the training. To demonstrate why in this specific circumstance that an accurate correlation between these 2 specific pictures ( and any similar) is not possible with any degree of accuracy.


Now we will begin.

A) for ANY comparison of any group of pictures to be done, 2 things must be present.

1) One CANNOT compare any 2 "things" unless both are broken down into common frames of reference so both pictures must be able to be converted to the same scale and same measurement criteria be used. ( cant compare an apple to an alternator in terms of nutritional value)

2) The pictures themselves MUST be able to be properly analyzed to obtain 1 above.

A picture is not an object, it is a captured representation of an object. ( big difference there) so there are 2 hurdles that must be overcome or the attempt to compare them. They are:

The properties of a "picture" must be captured and compensated for ( focal length of the lense, internal measurements of the camera, the focus of the target, angular distortion and the like)

Within the picture itself, there must be 2 known dimensions to create the X and Y axes so Z can be defined. ( basic geometry and trig to calculate cartesian coordinates so 3 D datapoints can be obtained so the targets can be mapped in order to measure them)

In this case, the cameras and their internals are unknown and neither picture contains known dimensions.

(Example- you take a picture of a ruler some distance from the camera. you know the ruler is 12". You take a picture of an egg. you want to compare the 2. To do so, you must be able to grid both [ like the old viewmasters] and place them in relative plane according to their positioning. You must also be able to bring both into scale equally so the 12" from the picture of the ruler is the same scale as where the egg sits. In order to do that, you must be able to triangulate the targets from the point the image is captured on the film inside the camera to the 2 reference points and place them in the same grid used to correlate both sets of measurements in the same scale)

So, in conclusion, since NONE of the REQUIRED information is available to ACCURATELY do the math- the comparison CANNOT be done ACCURATELY.

Thats why we use high end metric cameras and software to do this. Not the garden variety digitals. ( we use Nexvue and Photomodeler software)

Now, to the "poor man's" Photogrammetry

Picture software such as Photoshop, Corel and others also allow for "scaling" and comparing pictures. ( many will take these measurements and plug them into metric software and come up with dimensions)

This method WILL give the user a DEGREE ( which cannot be defined as its relative) of accuracy which is more than adequate for those in the photography industry but woefully short for measurements where accuracy is crucial.

The flaw in accuracy with the above is the fact that the picture software can only measure the picture as a whole and not the subjects in a picture. ( cant break one out from the other)

The problem present here is that "Patty" cannot be accurately defined in terms of dimension. ( estimates of her height range from about 5-8 to 7 ft depending on who you ask)

So if you take BH's known size- he falls between the upper and lower "guestimated" range of her size. The difference is mere inches. If the film subject COULD be measured, the question could be answered.( accurately) You can argue with relative sizing- you cannot argue with math.

Theres your class for the day. Now you know what I'm talking about ( and know I know what I'm talking about)

Also, just FYI, after 40+ years, IF the PGF COULD be accurately measured ( with the equations that derived the measurements so they could be independantly reviewed for accuracy and validity) it ALREADY would have been.
 
OK, here we go again, one more time...

If arms lenghts are evidence for Patty not being a costume, then these two pics below must show real gorillas. And with resolutions way better than PGF.
the_gorilla.jpg

mipc_ray_and_snowflake.jpg

And since it must work both ways, these two creatures must also be real...
gorosaurus1.jpg

program-art-barney.gif


BTW, where are Barney's costume seams? Inhuman proportions, finger movement, no costume parts seams... The evidences point towards a real dinosaur!

One must add to the fact that PGF images themselves are not suitable for accurate measurements the fact that costumes can effectively distort and conceal human proportions.

In other words, even if the measurements were accurate, long arms -even with moving fingers- would not be good reliable evidence that Patty was other than a costume worn by some bloke. This situation would change only if at least one of the conditions below were acomplished:
1. The film's quality was much better and no possible costume flaws were seen;
2. The film showed Patty doing something really hard to replicate with a costume;
3. PGF's background was not as fishy as it is;
4. There were aditional reliable evidence that bigfeet existed and looked like Patty. Heck, even the unreliable available data can not support Patty-looking bigfeet, unless hairy and bipedal are the criteria.

Of course, these facts will be, again, ignored by some...
 
So I'll pose the question directly to you Atomic. Does the BBC figure appear to you to have proportions that are in the same range as the PGF? A simple yes or no will suffice.

In terms of body proportions? No. It seems to me that the guy in the BBC suit has longer legs than Patty, so that'd throw everything out of whack comparison-wise.

In terms of arm proportions? Maybe, but I can't say for sure since I don't have any pictures of the mime's arms in different positions. As you can see in these pictures, a simple swing position can make an arm look shorter or longer. If you haven't looked at them all ready, you definitely should.
 
If arms lenghts are evidence for Patty not being a costume, then these two pics below must show real gorillas. And with resolutions way better than PGF.
[qimg]http://i34.photobucket.com/albums/d150/AVCN/the_gorilla.jpg[/qimg]
BTW, where are Barney's costume seams? Inhuman proportions, finger movement, no costume parts seams... The evidences point towards a real dinosaur!

Now you've gone from the sublime to the rediculous! The very top photo of the Gorilla shows to good effect the very kind of arm extensions that produce an exaggarated long forearm. Patty manages the longish arms apparantly without resorting to those types of extensions. Suit wearer had arms to fill the suit arms well enough to maintain a propotion. Barney? well I've always hated that sucker from day one. But let's at least try and keep photo references confined to mammals at least.
 
In terms of body proportions? No. It seems to me that the guy in the BBC suit has longer legs than Patty, so that'd throw everything out of whack comparison-wise.

In terms of arm proportions? Maybe, but I can't say for sure since I don't have any pictures of the mime's arms in different positions. As you can see in these pictures, a simple swing position can make an arm look shorter or longer. If you haven't looked at them all ready, you definitely should.

Looked the photos over. While the top photo demonstrates a shortening of the arm in the mid swing the full back swing shows a classic Patty pose with long arm. Since there are but a limited number of frames in that PGF that show Patty's arm fully extended in a back swing the reference pohtos of other arm examples need to be posed as those in the PGF. Of the closer posed recreation/example photos available, namely yhe Morris recreation and the BBC both come up looking short. But I'll state once again that this indicated to me that a suitably long arm was inside the PGF suit.

I think the autopilot response that everything about the PGF indicates a hoax is a flawed argument. Credit must me given where credit its due. My stand is a human in a suit was filmed by another human that wielded a camera and the result is the PGF. The entire thing is a hoax but those things that look credible and are credible within the hoax need to be recgonized.
 
Actually, there are some frames in the PGF where the subject is pretty much standing up straight, and the ' long looking arm ' effect vanishes..

You can take my word for it, or dig them out yourself ...
 
Last edited:
You're wrong again, Greg.
Here is another image of Patty...with lines drawn through her eyes, and chin...

Some time ago, I asked Sweaty to give me numbers that show "Patty/Bunny's" arms were too long. He loves to post a lot of pics with lines but never gives us any numbers. When I posted my analysis of one frame, he stated he would get back to me. He never did. So I disappear for vacation and now I see that he is back with same line draws he grabbed from somewhere on the web. Again, I ask for his analysis of this image:

Bunny.jpg

I realize there can be errors here but if the footprints were 14.5" then the arm can not be too long since it is only about 33" long (My arm is roughly 34" in length and I am 6'4"). Feel free to give a counteranalysis or an explanation. I don't want to see lines drawn on blurry images. I would love to see measurements that mean something. Tick...Tock...The world wonders.
 
I think that Sweaty has been asked more than once to show that Patty's arms are "inhumanly" long.

AFAIK, Sweaty never showed this, and it cannot be shown with any certainty.

It's just something that has been said so often, it's taken for granted that it's true.
 
LTC

The bottom photo showing the palm is one of the more intriquing frames in the entire film. I don't know exactly how big the hand is but by any measure its big. If there' any one thing that gives me pause to consider that we're seeing a flesh and blood image and not a suit being propelled by a flesh and blood person its that image of the left hand. There's been lots of speculation about camera distortion and blur but the left palm appears once again a little later in the film and even thought its at a greater distance it still maintains the sense of massive flesh that is evident in the frame you posted.
 
Crowlogic said:
Now you've gone from the sublime to the rediculous! The very top photo of the Gorilla shows to good effect the very kind of arm extensions that produce an exaggerated long forearm. Patty manages the longish arms apparently without resorting to those types of extensions.
At PGF, Patty's arms are never positioned like the arms of the gorilla at the pic in question. When stretched, the effect is barely visible (if it can be seen at all). One must also note that Patty's forearms do not seem to be as long as the arms of both gorilla costumes. Do not forget to note the different detail levels. So, the extensions, if there were any, were not so long and their effects, such as weird wrist locations, less observable. But maybe the feature pointed by GT/CS, that bulge at the wrist is a sign of the extension. Maybe. Without the costume’s blueprints it is hard to say.

Crowlogic said:
Suit wearer had arms to fill the suit arms well enough to maintain a propotion.
Crow, you think the actor's arms proportions were kept in the pics from Barney and the Gorosaur? Costumes can be made with arms longer or shorter than the arms of the “bloke” inside. The proportions can be defined by the costume and not by who wears it.

What we see at PGF does not have enough details to set a definite answer on the exact method used to create the arms. Personally I stay with small forearms extensions (Patty’s arms do not seem to be as long as some PGF defenders say) because it is easier to build them than to find a guy whose arms will completely fill the suit’s arms. Maybe Astrophotographer is right and it is just a question of perspective and her arms are within the range of human forearms. If he’s right, then you are right, no extensions were used.

Remember, main point of the pictures posted is to demonstrate how human proportions can be altered by costumes, even cheesy costumes. Even if it was possible to obtain accurate measurements from PGF, long arms -even with moving fingers- and inhuman proportions would not be good reliable evidence that Patty was not a bloke in a gorilla bigfoot suit. There’s nothing at PGF which could not be made with vintage costume building techniques. Even some of the things Patty’s defenders say are there –and don’t seem to actually be there.
Crowlogic said:
Barney? well I've always hated that sucker from day one. But let's at least try and keep photo references confined to mammals at least.
Why? If the objective is to demonstrate how costumes can change human proportions and that seams may not be easy to find even without hair to cover them and at higher resolutions, then it does not matter if the costume represents a reptile, amphibian or anything else. Once again the objective is to show the weaknesses of the arguments based on the (alleged) inhuman proportions, (alleged) lack of seams and the “no Hollywood tech could build it” line strawman.

So, where are the seams at the Barney costume? There’s no long shaggy hair to cover them. If I can’t see Barney’s seams, why should I expect to see all the costume seams at PGF? If human proportions are altered at Barney, why should I consider possible inhuman proportions in Patty are evidence its no a costume?

OK, here's another crappy gorilla suit to enjoy us... I think a similar costume could have been built (either from scratch or by bashing other costumes' parts together) quickly and easily by professional costume makers, within the budget available to P & G. Imagine it with a mask like that from the Star Trek anthropoid (as suggested by Dfoot) and female breasts hanging low on the chest. If filmed under PGF's conditions, it would do the trick, I think. BTW, it’s from King Kong X Godzilla (1962, low budget), and the gorilla costume had moving fingers. It has many features which quite often are pointed as evidence that Patty is a real Bigfoot.
What a small head! Surely the human head won't fit... Check also the shoulders, the long arms and the short hair.
kkg20kong20costume.jpg

Only at certain positions, and movements, create a tell tale mark of the wrist extensions, like in this pic. Move the wrist or the hand and a weird joint location appears.
kkg20kong20on20FIRE.jpg

No wonder Patty does nothing but just swing her arms while walking... Anything else could betray the costume even more.
The long arms can be better seen at this pic. Note that there's no sign of a forearm or wrist extension.
kkg20stop20motion20pair201.jpg

Note that the seam between the head piece and the shoulders is easy to see only at the first pic and that its not unlike a line which can be seen in Patty at some PGF frames. Check also the forehead. Some would say a human head would not fit inside. Oh, a cheesy reptilian kaiju costume with inhuman proportions! Sorry, I just love them. Can't help posting pics of them. Its an addiction.
 
It's no catchers mitt, it's an oven mitt. Someone's Grandma somewhere has a Dynel covered Oven mitt hanging from her cast-iron stove.
 
It's seems pretty obviously distorted in the 3rd frame to me.

I'd say that it's true size and odd look is more accurately reflected in the middle frame.

Can you supply us with the dynamics of the elements at work creating the distortion? Why should this frame be any more distorted than any other frame? There are frames that come directly beforeit and directly after it that aren't suspected as being distorted. I discovered the frame while viewing the MK Davis stabilized gif. As that series of frames plays the hand comes and retreats from view in a cohesive manner. Could it be that this one frame presents the skeptic with an impressive detail of the hand that requires special dispensation of distortion in order to explain its appearance? Its worth taking note that in the most visable frame the hand is hardly moving as the pendulum movement of the arm has just stopped its upswing and is beginning its downswing. The pimary movement going on is Pattys forward movement which is captured quite nicely by the camera. This s after a motion picture and was shot using motion picture equipment.

For me its just a whle lot easier to go with it being a really big massive hand in keeping with big massive object. Can still be a suit.
 
If the hand were massive, it would be visible more. A larger hand would show up better on the film, even when it is moving. There are times where Patty's arms appear to end abruptly in stumps. No hand apparent at all.

Keep in mind that Patty herself pretty much disappears into motion blur in some frames.

A smaller hand is more likely to disappear in motion blur, except when near the ends of the swings where it slows down and stops briefly.

There is no indication of massive hands at all in the PGF, save for a couple of frames.

For the most part, Patty's hands appear properly sized.

I would expect to be able to distinguish fingers in the middle frame, though. The appearance is quite odd for what should be a fairly normal looking primate hand.

As for the bottom frame, IIRC, the hand does not appear that way in the frames just before and just after that frame. So, it's most likely distortion from any of several sources.
 
Can you supply us with the dynamics of the elements at work creating the distortion? Why should this frame be any more distorted than any other frame? There are frames that come directly beforeit and directly after it that aren't suspected as being distorted. I discovered the frame while viewing the MK Davis stabilized gif. As that series of frames plays the hand comes and retreats from view in a cohesive manner. Could it be that this one frame presents the skeptic with an impressive detail of the hand that requires special dispensation of distortion in order to explain its appearance? Its worth taking note that in the most visable frame the hand is hardly moving as the pendulum movement of the arm has just stopped its upswing and is beginning its downswing. The pimary movement going on is Pattys forward movement which is captured quite nicely by the camera. This s after a motion picture and was shot using motion picture equipment.

For me its just a whle lot easier to go with it being a really big massive hand in keeping with big massive object. Can still be a suit.

I can help you out with that Crow ( to a point)

The problem lies in the speed of the film as each frame went thru versus the speed the object was moving in real time. ( think stop motion animation movies or the Enterprise "stretch" when going to warp)

In stop motion you have a series of single pictures bundled together- you get uniformity of FOV and stuff but they always look "jerky" and never have the "swish" of an animate object moving under power.

In a "movie" per say- each frame captures that single second of whats ever there. If it catches it in a movement faster than the camera speed- the image will be distorted/stretched on the film in that frame. ( they come together when the film is played at normal speed and you dont "see" it)

So you have 2 points of destabilization.

1) from the film subject's relative speed of movement in relation to film speed per second.

2) the additional distortion from the camera moving

( Think Einstein's observer principle for how fast things look and are moving relative to a camera)

So, you could have distortion in a frame and not in the next or you could have part of a frame with no distortion and part with ( all depending on whats happening)

Imagine you standing there being filmed and someone throws a baseball in front of you. Depending on the camera speed- if you did a frame by frame- "you" would be clear but the ball would probably be blurred.

I'm not a photog guy but in some of our work, we have to deal with this for moving parts and such- the concepts are the same.
 
Can you supply us with the dynamics of the elements at work creating the distortion? Why should this frame be any more distorted than any other frame?
Why would this frame be anymore distorted than any other frame ?

hernia2.gif


PGF proponents and Bill Munns dismiss those lumps on the left leg as some kind of distortion, and they are much more clear that your giant paw ..

Do you think those lumps look like real leg muscles, positioned where they should be ?
 
What Longtabber said above- it all boils down to shutter speed and the velocity of the object which is being photographed.

You can see it by yourself. Get a camera (yep, a digital cam will do) wich enables you to change shutter speed. Take a pic of a moving object at say, 1/250s. Now decrease shutter speed to say, 1/30s and take another pic of the moving object. Compare results.

During a time intervall of 1/250s, a moving object (provided its velocity is constant) will imprint a shorter image track in the film (or the camera's chip) than at a 1/30s interval. At the slower shutter speed the object will be blurred and distorted (stretched) along its movement direction. That's why sports photography always use high shutter speed and sensitivity above ISO 1000.

Take a pic at say, 1/100 of a slow-moving object. Now take a pic of a fast-moving object with the same shutter speed. Compare results. The faster object will be blurred and distorted (stretched) along its movement direction.

Another clear demonstration of this fact are night shots of moving cars (where the head and tail lights become traces) and fireworks.
Here are two examples:
5_6_1.jpg

Can't remember the exposure time I used, but it must have been something between 15 or 30 seconds. EXIF file will not help since I may pasted the image over another JPEG file.
bocaosmall.jpg

During this one I kept the shutter open while the person was walking towards (don't ask for how long, it was a loooooooooong time ago). During this time, the flame's path was imprinted at the slide film (yep, 35mm slide ISO 64, I told you it was a long time ago). When the person whas close to the cam, I covered the lenses to avoid a transparent "ghost image" -note that there's a gap between the hard hat's flame and the "fire track". I asked the person to kneel, uncovered the lenses and manually shot the flash.

OK, the explanation was too long and quite possibly could be shorter, but I think now you have a better idea of the possible distortions due to movement at PGF.
 
Last edited:
Crowlogic wrote:
For me its just a whle lot easier to go with it being a really big massive hand in keeping with big massive object.


Patty's left hand also has that strange "catcher's mitt" distortion in an earlier set of frames.
It begins approximately 7 frames into this animated-gif, by M.K. Davis...when her hand passes in front of a dark piece of wood...

http://www.bigfootencounters.com/files/mk_davis_pgf.gif


I'll post a short animated-gif of it later, when I have access to my regular computer again.
For now, to get a good look at her hand (in a still-frame).....while the animated-gif is running, hit the IE 'refresh' button and then the 'stop' button when Patty's hand is in front of the wood.


I've never noticed this before....but it looks to me like it's most likely a 'glow' caused by overexposure due to a very light-colored palm.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom