LONGTABBER PE
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2008
- Messages
- 1,528
Saying that comparing images has NO degree of accuracy is idiotic, as far as I'm concerned....so I'm not putting much stock into what LT says, until he can demonstrate, with images,exactly what he's talking about.
Well sweetie, be careful of what you ask for because you may in fact get it.( cant post pics and links yet due to a low post count so you will just have to accept the text version)
So, sit down, put on your thinking cap because school is in session and you are going to, as many before you, learn from the master.
1) we must first start out by establishing the authority, source and accreditation of the information to be presented. That authority is the BOK, standards and criteria set forth from the ASPRS. ( The American Society for Photogrammetry & Remote Sensing )
2) We must define the objective of the training. To demonstrate why in this specific circumstance that an accurate correlation between these 2 specific pictures ( and any similar) is not possible with any degree of accuracy.
Now we will begin.
A) for ANY comparison of any group of pictures to be done, 2 things must be present.
1) One CANNOT compare any 2 "things" unless both are broken down into common frames of reference so both pictures must be able to be converted to the same scale and same measurement criteria be used. ( cant compare an apple to an alternator in terms of nutritional value)
2) The pictures themselves MUST be able to be properly analyzed to obtain 1 above.
A picture is not an object, it is a captured representation of an object. ( big difference there) so there are 2 hurdles that must be overcome or the attempt to compare them. They are:
The properties of a "picture" must be captured and compensated for ( focal length of the lense, internal measurements of the camera, the focus of the target, angular distortion and the like)
Within the picture itself, there must be 2 known dimensions to create the X and Y axes so Z can be defined. ( basic geometry and trig to calculate cartesian coordinates so 3 D datapoints can be obtained so the targets can be mapped in order to measure them)
In this case, the cameras and their internals are unknown and neither picture contains known dimensions.
(Example- you take a picture of a ruler some distance from the camera. you know the ruler is 12". You take a picture of an egg. you want to compare the 2. To do so, you must be able to grid both [ like the old viewmasters] and place them in relative plane according to their positioning. You must also be able to bring both into scale equally so the 12" from the picture of the ruler is the same scale as where the egg sits. In order to do that, you must be able to triangulate the targets from the point the image is captured on the film inside the camera to the 2 reference points and place them in the same grid used to correlate both sets of measurements in the same scale)
So, in conclusion, since NONE of the REQUIRED information is available to ACCURATELY do the math- the comparison CANNOT be done ACCURATELY.
Thats why we use high end metric cameras and software to do this. Not the garden variety digitals. ( we use Nexvue and Photomodeler software)
Now, to the "poor man's" Photogrammetry
Picture software such as Photoshop, Corel and others also allow for "scaling" and comparing pictures. ( many will take these measurements and plug them into metric software and come up with dimensions)
This method WILL give the user a DEGREE ( which cannot be defined as its relative) of accuracy which is more than adequate for those in the photography industry but woefully short for measurements where accuracy is crucial.
The flaw in accuracy with the above is the fact that the picture software can only measure the picture as a whole and not the subjects in a picture. ( cant break one out from the other)
The problem present here is that "Patty" cannot be accurately defined in terms of dimension. ( estimates of her height range from about 5-8 to 7 ft depending on who you ask)
So if you take BH's known size- he falls between the upper and lower "guestimated" range of her size. The difference is mere inches. If the film subject COULD be measured, the question could be answered.( accurately) You can argue with relative sizing- you cannot argue with math.
Theres your class for the day. Now you know what I'm talking about ( and know I know what I'm talking about)
Also, just FYI, after 40+ years, IF the PGF COULD be accurately measured ( with the equations that derived the measurements so they could be independantly reviewed for accuracy and validity) it ALREADY would have been.



