Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're kidding, right ?

You have lined up the eyes on the Morris suit with Patty's chin ..

Keep em' coming Sweety ..

Umm ahhh errr Greg I don't know how to break this to you but that's not the Morris recreation. That's the BBC recreation. I always laugh a the BBC suit. It looks like a guy in hairy pajamas with legs too short. The Morris suit looks a little mor like Patty but still suffers somewhat with shortish arms.

BTW the photo that shows Bob H leaning against the Corvette displays that he's somewhat round shouldered. While this is neither here nor there it does indicate that it must've taken a heap of padding to get his shoulders beefed up to look like Patty's. I wonder if the actor that played Lurch in the old Adams Family could have filled the specs better than Bob H. THis is one reason why I like Dfoots Hollywood connections.
 
Last edited:
Has Bob Heironimus ever stated that the suit he allegedly wore had a mechanically-controlled hand in it?

It seems to me that if that was, in fact, the case...he would have mentioned it at some point in time.

I was not answering to your "Patty= real hands" but to crowlogic which was pretending such technics did not exists. Wrong. They did exists for a very long time, and 1957 is not stone age, they could very well manipulate scissor, leather, and a few small nylon rings and nylon cable, I think crowlogic do not realize that civilization and puppeteer technics were not born after 1957 with animatronics.

To you I would only answer, The bending of the hand is irrelevant to know whether patty is real or an animal.
 
Well, let me throw my version of Mr. Occam in the hat here just for discussions sake

Under the presumption this is a suit, I think it having any form of mechanical hand is unlikely because the hand does "nothing" ( one would believe that if such an extra was incorporated- you would see the hand "do" something otherwise its useless and whatever time and money expended for its incorporation was a complete waste)

One of the issues I have always had with the PGF (relative to effectively analyzing it) is that the film subject doesnt actually "do" anything other than walk and a look see.

If the film subject had performed complex motions such as squatting or using the hands/arms to perform a function demonstrating dexterity or strength there would be something to critically analyze.
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:

... one would believe that if such an extra was incorporated- you would see the hand "do" something, otherwise its useless and whatever time and money expended for its incorporation was a complete waste


Thank you very much LT, for supporting the logic behind my argument. :)


I think it having any form of mechanical hand is unlikely because the hand does "nothing"...



Here is Patty's hand....doing nothing...:boggled:..


handmove2ag.gif
 
Last edited:
Sweaty, you might want to check post 14583 at this thread and reconsider the "methodology" you use for photographic analysis as well as the conclusions you derive from them.

There you will find yet one more person telling you about the errors you are making.
 
I was not answering to your "Patty= real hands" but to crowlogic which was pretending such technics did not exists. Wrong. They did exists for a very long time, and 1957 is not stone age, they could very well manipulate scissor, leather, and a few small nylon rings and nylon cable, I think crowlogic do not realize that civilization and puppeteer technics were not born after 1957 with animatronics.

To you I would only answer, The bending of the hand is irrelevant to know whether patty is real or an animal.

Yes puppets and the like have existed for centuries. I'm saying that on top of everything else the suit maker (lets say Roger Patterson and keep it all in his little Yakima circle of cohorts) not only had to build the suit but also build a mechanical hand so his creation could have operating hands is a bridge to far. Pattys arms have excellent proportions with or without moving hands. The phony extension would have thrown those proportions hopeless and unrealistically off. Now if you can produce a PGF frame that shows Patty with an extended forearm than I'll entertain the idea of extension, working or otherwise. Beyond that the mechicanal hand idea is a joke and ony a fool will adhere to it.
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:
Thank you very much LT, for supporting the logic behind my argument. :)

Here is Patty's hand....doing nothing...:boggled:..

That depends on what your argument is specifically. Altho we agree on a single point, most of what I have seen utilized to support the other positions is fatally flawed at many levels.
 
Correa Neto wrote:
Sweaty, you might want to check post 14583 at this thread and reconsider the "methodology" you use for photographic analysis as well as the conclusions you derive from them.

I read LONGTABBER'S post, Correa.

Here is one statement from it....


Since there are no known measurements, the cameras were not proper and the originals not available, no one can make an accurate comparison between those pictures with any degree of accuracy.


Saying that comparing images has NO degree of accuracy is idiotic, as far as I'm concerned....so I'm not putting much stock into what LT says, until he can demonstrate, with images,exactly what he's talking about.
 
Why would he -or anyone else who says your analysis have several problems- need to images to demonstrate the flaws, Sweaty?

It does not take any images.

Take the BBC/Patty comparisson for example. The cameras were different, the subject-camera distances are unknown, the images passed through who-knows-how-many-and which image treatment processes, the subjects are at diferent viewing angles and positions, the images have poor resolution...

Honestly, you should reconsider whose position is idiotic.
 
You're kidding, right ?

You have lined up the eyes on the Morris suit with Patty's chin ..

Keep em' coming Sweety ..



You're wrong again, Greg.


Here is another image of Patty...with lines drawn through her eyes, and chin...

Patty9b.jpg



And here is the image you refered to:

Patty7a.jpg



In the image you refered to, I had drawn the blue line on Patty below the point where her head slopes backward. (I highlighted that key point with the white line.)

In the first image of Patty, above, the line at her chin, extended back, intersects a point below the top of the shoulder......and the line through her eyes, extended back, crosses just above her shoulder.....the same as in the side-view image of Patty.
 
Correa Neto wrote:
Why would he -or anyone else who says your analysis have several problems- need to images to demonstrate the flaws, Sweaty?


Because, if someone can't support their own claims, propositions, or statements....then what they're saying is nothing more than a 2-penny opinion. In effect, worthless. :)
 
Umm ahhh errr Greg I don't know how to break this to you but that's not the Morris recreation. That's the BBC recreation. I always laugh a the BBC suit. It looks like a guy in hairy pajamas with legs too short. The Morris suit looks a little mor like Patty but still suffers somewhat with shortish arms.

It should be noted that that was a preexisting costume and not intended as a recreation of Patty. Instead, it was used to show how a furry costume would look when shot from the same distance as Roger Patterson was when he filmed the PGF.

Hopefully when Dfoot comes back, he can repost that animated .gif of how the costume actually looked on that BBC show, instead of the close-up publicity photo that got used for the incredibly misleading "notice the arms" picture.

SweatyYeti said:
Well, to start with...it's the unusually loooooooooooooong arms of Patty, combined with bending-fingers, that makes Patty seem more like a real live wild creature than a Bobby-in-the-suit.

*cough*
 
776647aa1fe2955be.gif


Like the debunking of the "Lower Level Leg Lift" as a feature of an "inhuman gait" Dfoot's wordless debunking of the "inhumanly long arms" and "moving fingers" is definitive.

This thread, and JREF in general, seems to attract all sorts of fanatics, whose devotion to maintaining definitively disproved concepts seems to border on the religious. I have no doubt that Sweaty Yeti will continue to post his "moving fingers" gif, and I'm sure John Green still believes that the "inhumanly long arms" of the film subject "prove" it can't be a guy-in-a-suit.

Sweaty Yeti; you have lost the game. You have lost the game decisively. You have been "owned" by Dfoot. Your arguments are a joke, and your continued participation here is one of the reasons I rarely post here anymore.

Sorry, I'm going to go play table tennis now...
 
Last edited:
It should be noted that that was a preexisting costume and not intended as a recreation of Patty. Instead, it was used to show how a furry costume would look when shot from the same distance as Roger Patterson was when he filmed the PGF.

Pre existing, special fabrication, divine intervention the end result of that BBC thing is a really bad looking hairy primate. Yet it does serve a purpose by demonstration that the human that was inside of the BBC suit had arms far too short to be convincing as an apelike biped. Cameras and processing and angles and distance can be bantered about as much as you like but one look at that photo says short arms and long legs which is just the opposite of what is seen in the PGF. However and whatever is inside the PGF figure it manages to display long arms.

So I'll pose the question directly to you Atomic. Does the BBC figure appear to you to have proportions that are in the same range as the PGF? A simple yes or no will suffice.
 
LONGTABBER PE wrote:




Thank you very much LT, for supporting the logic behind my argument. :)






Here is Patty's hand....doing nothing...:boggled:..


[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/handmove2ag.gif[/qimg]

Show it all you want, it still is essentially nothing, or at least nothing much. It's a hand, possibly, but not definitively, flexing, or perhaps unflexing, as it swings, as might be expected from anything that dangles; all made less informative by the poor resolution of the film and the odd way that film at that limit of resolution handles boundaries.

Even if you decide it's a little something more than nothing, Longtabber's point is well taken, that if it's a costume, and if the costume makers had gone to the trouble of fabricating a complex hand, the little apparent motion shown here shows that they wasted their effort.
 
Sweaty didn't even think that the BBC guy and Patty might be different heights, and lining up two points (even if they were the right points) would be meaningless.
 
Sweaty continues to post two carefully chosen seperate frames, animated, that appear to show Patty's hand flexing a little bit, as if it means Patty's hand has the full functionality of his own. :D
 
Yes puppets and the like have existed for centuries. I'm saying that on top of everything else the suit maker (lets say Roger Patterson and keep it all in his little Yakima circle of cohorts) not only had to build the suit but also build a mechanical hand so his creation could have operating hands is a bridge to far. Pattys arms have excellent proportions with or without moving hands. The phony extension would have thrown those proportions hopeless and unrealistically off. Now if you can produce a PGF frame that shows Patty with an extended forearm than I'll entertain the idea of extension, working or otherwise. Beyond that the mechicanal hand idea is a joke and ony a fool will adhere to it.


I did not say it was a mechanical hand. I did say that YOUR statement that such tech did not exists in the 1967 and 1967 was practically stone age are both wrong. Heck in my own description on how I would do it, I would NOT use a mechanical hand, just some low tech cabling in a glove. No where at all I was saying that Patty indeed had a mechanical hand. That you persist in this argument starts to sound really strange. Why the heck use a mechanical hand when you can do it cheaper with an articulated pupetteer hand. This nearly sound like a misdirection to give the impression it was impossible to have a moving hand. Heck even a mechanical hand is not that hard, it is only machinated metal piece with some articulation. Even that was done in other material way before the 20th.

As for the pretension that the proportion of patty are inhuman or unrealistic comes from BF supporter. If you read the thread, you will see that some here think that the argument of Patty having unrealliticaly long arm is not falsifiable, and she looks pretty human, and even if she was not, there are possibility to extend and change the shape of people with costume.

The gist of this, is that the first trying to say patty could not ber human because she was not human shaped, were BF supporter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom