Diogenes:
"I tell the judge and jury " ..there is another four minutes of film from the same reel, but they just need to forget about that .. " I assure them there is nothing of importance on the rest of the film .. They can take my word for it..."
Regardless of how suspicious you find this description of the film, suspicion does not rise to evidence. It simply proves film is not available for viewing. No evidentiary conclusion can be drawn that the missing film proves one side or the other.
For your pictures, you are using falsely altered versions of the film. Doesn't make for strong arguments for any truth.
"Real muscles don't look like that; but padding does.."
This is your opinion, not documented fact.You are entitled to your opinion, but your opinion is not fact. This statement fails as evidence. Your statement is argument, not proof. Big difference.
WP:
"The "major indicators" that Bigfoot is not a mythical creature don't pass legitimate inquiry and this is why Bigfoot is widely regarded as simply a legend."
This is simply an opinion held by some people, that it is a legend. The fact is it is an unknown or unexplained entity, which may be mere legend, may be biological fact, and may be humans with hypertrichosis. The only fact is that there is no conclusion as yet.
"Your notes are not sufficient evidence that Patty is a real creature (Bigfoot exists). "
Who said they were? I have never even once claimed that my notes were sufficient evidence that Bigfoot exists? My notes and my work are to see if the figure in the PG Film can be determined with some certainty to be a suit, or can a suit be excluded. That would leave either a unknown biological entity or a human female with hypertrichosis as potential explanations, and that is only if the suit could be fully discounted, and I have not even claimed that to any certainly.
"There is the strong potential to misunderstand the situation with the film".
Considering how all here misunderstand nearly everying I say and do, it doesn't surprize me that you see potential to misunderstand the situation of the film. The tragedy is how few people are actually trying to resolve minunderstandings.
"I uderstand your use of the term "challenge",
No, you do not understand. You didn't even read Rockinkt's truly patyhetic post where he challenged me to abide by rules he chose to invent for my life, career, and activity. It has nothing to do with challenging the film. I'm refusing to let a moron dictate my life.
You have concerns about the film. Fine. I do not dispute those concerns. I would love nothing more than for the full reel of the original footage to be released publicly and scanned by an reputable forensic service and the scanned data made available to all for study. But I have no way to make that happen. Do you? If not, then it simply remains one of many imperfect issues of this matter.
"Don't forget that the one minute of film (Patty walk) shows multiple indications of shutter stops and/or intentional editing. Patterson said he never stopped filming Patty once he had started the camera. The evidence shows something else going on. "
Nothing about starting or stopping the camera, if that is so, changes what I see on the film, or changes my analysis of materials that may be used to made a suit, and the motion of those materials while the suspected person wearing the suspected suit is moving in the picture.
Drew:
First, thank you for being civil.
"A. There is no existing/documented creature corresponding to the figure depicted in film, therefore the film is a hoax."
Sorry, Drew, but your basic statement is flawed by the simple reality of "there's a first time for everything", including a first sighting or evidence of any new species in the biological world. However small the odds, the possibility exists and the hoax is not conclusive on that basis.
"Now Bill, I know you are not attempting to overcome A, you are simply attempting to determine the feasability of a costume, as portrayed in the film, but, don't you feel that your skills will be used by Bigfootry to try and overcome Argument A? Which you must admit, a species has never been classified as existing, on the basis of 'The species in a photograph couldn't have been a costume therefore it must exist'."
People desperate to win an argument (on both sides of this issue, skeptic and advocate both) will grab anything spoken by any person who has some public presense that they feel advances their agenda to win, and so in that regard, you cannot expect me to be held to any standard that you do not apply to others. So what is the "rule" for people in the "creature/costume suit business"? Does the rule apply to any other makeup artist speaking an opinion of the film, or just me?
And while i do believe that you are trying to reach an understanding with me (certainly trying with more civilized reason and fairness that others here), I can't agree with your reworded statement:
""and those material processes are by far more reliable in their nature than your 'There is no existing/documented creature corresponding to the figure depicted in film, therefore the film is a hoax' argument ."
I would say instead "material processes, motion dynamics, and limitations of materials to bend, stretch or deform are more empirical and impartial to prejudice, more testable and thus more credible than arguments based on supisitions or circumstantial character, and should prevail in any proof."
Bill
added for Diogenes:
Diogenes:
In your post on the previous page Post #14186, you quoted this information about the film resolution:
"Quote:
.... Cut out a paper circle with this diameter and it will approximate the smallest detail (optimistically) resolvable, in very rough terms about 2 inches on Patty's body. (Actual resolution, for the above-mentioned cautionary reasons is apt to be worse than that, possibly by half) Upon inspection of this juxtaposition, the resolution in these large pictures is virtually the same as the largest blobs like the nose and the ear projection, but anything below that level of detail ( 2 inches )does not contain information.....
..... Thus, finger or toe detail, that should lie in the vicinity of this 2" limit, does not show up crisply at all. Any conclusions based on supposed detail below the stated limit are largely a function of the imagination of the examiner ..... "
Then, in your post today, #14209, you show a picture a the PG Figure with clearly designated eye and mouth/lips.
That whitish spot suggesting an eye is clearly less than 2: in diameter (the whole eye ball, fully exposed, would only be about 1 1/4" in diameter, ). The height of the lips is also well less than 2". So if the statement you quoted as part of your argument is true, than you have argued that the photo you now posted is showing detail beyond the resolution you claim the film can reveal. If the film can resolve greated detail than a 2" area, you should retract the remark as incorrect. If you stand by the quote about resolution, you should not use any photo which shows an enhanced resolution because by your specification, the photo is false and unreliable as compared to your earlier remark.
Also in your remark,
"Real muscles don't look like that; but padding does.."
You fail to consider hair patterns and light reflectance off of the varying patterns as a potential cause for the light dark patterns you see. It is a trird option you failed to consider.
Finally, in the matter of the Hollywood face mask you show, find a true clean profile photo of that mask, and superimpose it over a true clean profile image of "Patty", and see of it fits, and if so, where do the eyes of the mask align with the estimated eyes of Patty.
Only then would the comparison have merit to consider further.
Bill