Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
You tell me ...

Why don't you critique the evidence I have presented, and tell me what is wrong with it ?

P.S.

Nice dodge on holding me to a higher level of accountability than you do Bill Munns ..
 
Last edited:
You tell me ...

Why don't you critique the evidence I have presented, and tell me what is wrong with it ?

P.S.

Nice dodge on holding me to a higher level of accountability than you do Bill Munns ..

Not a dodge. But a repeating detail carries more weight than a "one off." For instance there is a frame of Patty's face where her appearance is entirely different from every other frame in the film. Since the overwhelming number of frames show a face that retains a characteristic look the one anomalous frame is just that anomalous.

If the leg skin compression and slackening appears in a majority of frames than there's a stronger foundation for the case being presented.
 
Patty isn't on camera all that long, and her extremities are often obscured and/or blurry.

Don't forget the catcher's mitt hands.

The thing about the catcher mitt hands is that they appear at least twice. Once is shortly after frame 352 and the other is about mid way between frame 352 and the end. When the inner hand is visible it has a certain appearance of a large fleshy thick fingered hand regardless of when its seen. Its been speculated that the hand appears so large due to camera distortion but during the best frames when its seen nothing else is undergoing distortion. Whatever the hands are I accept what is seen as accurately showing the hands as they were.

As for Patty not being on camera very long well that works both for and against both sides of the argument. How can you argue that you see a seam or a telltale suit detail when she's not in view long enough and how can you argue that there is no seam or tell tale suit detail because she isn't on the camera long enough.

Once again that's why the people expiermenting with suits are the people to best answer and produce the things we think we see or don't see.
 
Here is another animated-gif, showing what Greg's saying is a suit folding-up.
I slowed-down the frames in question...


Pattywalk55A.gif



Here is Greg's version again...


waderline.gif



One observation of mine, concerning this detail....is that if this shrinking area is actually a padded-leg compressing, then in addition to the suit material folding under, or compressing...the padding underneath would also be compressing. As a result of relatively stiff (compared to soft flesh) padding being compressed, we should be seeing the padding bulging outward in some other direction...either forward or backward.
But, in the longer animated-gif I posted, we don't see the thigh bulging anywhere, at all, during those frames.

To me it looks more like the movement of Patty's hair and soft flesh.
 
Last edited:
What about the wrist band that becomes obvious when 'The Big Hairy's' right arm is fully extended.

By the way, I am now referring to Sasquatch, Bigfoot, Yeti, Yowii, etc... as 'The Big Hairy' it covers it all.
 
..... and how can you argue that there is no seam or tell tale suit detail because she isn't on the camera long enough.
Precisely ..
Why haven't you called Mr. Munns to task for concluding no seams are present ?

You have responded to very few of his posts at all, yet when I make a post about any observation, you are all over me ...

You are clearly biased, while feigning objectivity..

I wonder why Mr. Munns hasn't called you a hypocrite ...
 
Precisely ..
Why haven't you called Mr. Munns to task for concluding no seams are present ?

You have responded to very few of his posts at all, yet when I make a post about any observation, you are all over me ...

You are clearly biased, while feigning objectivity..

I wonder why Mr. Munns hasn't called you a hypocrite ...

Am I under under any kind of obligation to "attack" Bill Munns? The rest of the attack dogs here seem to be doing a pretty good job already. You don't need me to attack Bill Munns.
 
Where did I suggest you attack him ?

You are avoiding the point, as you so often do .

Why your failure to question his conclusions or observations the way you do mine ?

You're just another Bleever, Crow...
 
Diogenes wrote:

You are clearly biased, while feigning objectivity..


Being 'biased' is simply a result of being a human being, Greg.
We all have our feelings toward the idea of a species of early human, or ape-man, still existing somewhere in the world today.

As for me, personally, I'd LOVE :D to see an ape-man. Therefore, I'm rooting for Bigfoot's existence....AAAAAAAAAAALL the way!! :D
I truly hope that there's at least a few of them out there....somewhere. :)

There you have it, Greg....my true feelings on the subject....exposed for ALL the world to 'see'. :blush:


But, despite people having their own feelings and biases towards the subject, Greg....people also have the ability to THINK.
Again, in my case, I'm quite capable of thinking clearly enough for my intellect to overide my feelings when it comes to analysing the evidence for Bigfoot.

In my previous post I gave a specific reason why I think that Patty's leg movements appear to be more like a real animal's, rather than a padded suit.
My reasoning was not based on simply "I want it to be real".



In fact, Greg, what's much worse than having a personal bias, is having a total lack of interest in the truth.....which you have shown to be the case with you, many times over.

Suggesting that there was no lift in the MD Video was just one example of your blatant lack of interest in the truth.

Suggesting that Roger Patterson may not have been the person who actually shot the PG film is another clear example of your true motivation for posting on these boards. It's not to try to help clear up the picture concerning Bigfoot....it's to try to 'muddy the waters' as much as you can.
 
Crow, keep in mind that a hand at the end of a swinging arm is probably moving faster than any other part of Patty when considering camera distortion.

You certainly aren't under any obligation to attack Munns, but you are under a general fairness obligation.
 
I don't need to question anyone whether or not its a man/woman/person in a suit. I am of the opinion that we're seeing a suit. The thrust of the investigation intrests me in learning how the suit was arrived at and what were the materials and what allowed the entire thing to come together as the whole we know as the PGF. Now if a believer ultimately proves that its a suit well that's fine. In fact a believer proving/concluding that its a suit is going to carry a lot more weight than a skeptic proving its a suit.

The film is what the film is. Its going to take more than the film to determine what it is that's seen on it.
 
Its going to take more than the film to determine what it is that's seen on it.

There isn't anything more than the film, though. In fact, there is actually less, since we don't have the whole film or films made by RP related to Patty.

People like to claim there are footprints and casts, but it's really impossible to say that any prints or casts are related to Patty.
 
As far as Bill Munns - it seems obvious to me that he is pandering to the believers in order to get himself a job building a replica suit.

The interest in his giganto replica as a model for bigfoot in the minds of Bigfooters obviously has caught his attention and my old spidey senses started tingling the moment he started his pedantic posts.

I challenge him here and now to state publicly that he will never accept a commission to build a replica "Patty" or suit or statue or model of a sasquatch/Bigfoot.
 
As far as Bill Munns - it seems obvious to me that he is pandering to the believers in order to get himself a job building a replica suit.

The interest in his giganto replica as a model for bigfoot in the minds of Bigfooters obviously has caught his attention and my old spidey senses started tingling the moment he started his pedantic posts.

I challenge him here and now to state publicly that he will never accept a commission to build a replica "Patty" or suit or statue or model of a sasquatch/Bigfoot.


Rock... That's absurd. Let's hope that there is a commission to have Bill Munns build a working replica that is put through the rigors of replication the conditions that the PGF was filmed under.

Now consider this. Bill is caught between a rock and a hard place by accepting a commission to replicate the PGF subject. If he builds a bad crummy looking replica to prove the PGF is real then he's put himself in the unenviable position of having done a lousy job of his craft. Therefore he must build a replica that's going to withstand the every manner of analysis under every possible condition. So if he makes a bad replica he's made the PGF look good but he's made his talents look bad. If he builds a bullet proof replica that withstands the closest of scrutiny then he'll be accused of having gone overboard in creating the replica. That is to say he'll be accused of cheating with modern method and materials or the like. And if he builds a replica that sort of passes as well as the PGF then he's proven that yes the PGF is a human in a suit or at least within the realm of it being a human in a suit.

Both sides of this thing need to encourage Bill Munns and Dfoot. They're at least working up a sweat and getting thier hands dirty while the rest of us are simply running off at the mouth no matter how many qoutes and internet info bites we post to support our positions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom