William Parcher
Show me the monkey!
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2005
- Messages
- 27,680
This is simply an opinion held by some people, that it is a legend.
That opinion exists because nobody has presented primary evidence that Bigfoot is not a myth. It would be the same thing for a claim of modern living Tyrannosaurs. No primary evidence presented for their modern existence, yet the claim that they no longer exist is simply an opinion.
The fact is it is an unknown or unexplained entity, which may be mere legend, may be biological fact, and may be humans with hypertrichosis. The only fact is that there is no conclusion as yet.
It's not even an entity in the absence of primary evidence. It's a social construct until such evidence is produced. If Bigfoot does not exist, then this evidence cannot be produced. Yet, this would not stop anyone from claiming the question has no conclusion.
Who said they were? I have never even once claimed that my notes were sufficient evidence that Bigfoot exists? My notes and my work are to see if the figure in the PG Film can be determined with some certainty to be a suit, or can a suit be excluded. That would leave either a unknown biological entity or a human female with hypertrichosis as potential explanations, and that is only if the suit could be fully discounted, and I have not even claimed that to any certainly.
Any possible conclusion or determination you would reach would simply be your opinion, right? Saying that there is no evidence of a suit is the same as someone else saying there is no evidence that Bigfoot exists. People and their opinions. How are these kinds of opinions converted to facts?
Considering how all here misunderstand nearly everying I say and do, it doesn't surprize me that you see potential to misunderstand the situation of the film. The tragedy is how few people are actually trying to resolve minunderstandings.
No, you do not understand. You didn't even read Rockinkt's truly patyhetic post where he challenged me to abide by rules he chose to invent for my life, career, and activity. It has nothing to do with challenging the film. I'm refusing to let a moron dictate my life.
In the past few days you have shown yourself to be evolving into a common form of Bigfooter. A strong and growing disdain for skeptics and a willingness to insult them.
I would love nothing more than for the full reel of the original footage to be released publicly and scanned by an reputable forensic service and the scanned data made available to all for study. But I have no way to make that happen. Do you? If not, then it simply remains one of many imperfect issues of this matter.
The original film roll was chopped up and can't be released no matter what anyone might want. That's exactly the kind of thing hoaxers need. But still, the absence of certain evidences is a kind of evidence in itself. Missing or destroyed evidence can be prominant in court cases. Not always because of what it could have contained, but because it is missing in a situation where that is critical. That the PGF roll never appeared in its original form is a terribly damaging fact in the debate about its authenticity. This is exactly the kind of thing one would expect in a filmed hoax scenario.
Nothing about starting or stopping the camera, if that is so, changes what I see on the film, or changes my analysis of materials that may be used to made a suit, and the motion of those materials while the suspected person wearing the suspected suit is moving in the picture.
If Patterson removed 5 seconds of celluloid when the mime stumbled, then rose to his feet revealing all sorts of suit flaws, you'd be right where you are now. The suit may have been constructed for nothing other than upright walking. Don't try grabbing anything either - the hands won't work for that.
If the debate was a trial and you were an expert witness (supporting authenticity), a cross-examiner would present the evidence that portions of her walk are not shown in the film and then get you to admit that those portions could have been intentionally removed. You would not have to say that if the film itself did not show these stops. There always remains the possibility that Patty was filmed before and/or after what has come to be recognized as the beginning and end of that walk scene.
