Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Drew:

"Bill- I always assumed that you saw a demand, and were attempting to supply a product to fill that demand. "

Well, hard as you may find this to believe, I saw a need, not a demand, and the need was for factual information about suits, from a person who built them, to hopefully bring some factual information to the debate.

Onviously, no good deed goes unpunished.

Bill
 
Wait a gosh darn minute! You mean all of the hard boiled critical thinking skeptics are trying to create the scenerio that Bill Munns is hatching a get rich scheme? As far as I know nobody has gotten rich from Bigfoot. Its maybe safe to say that Roger Patterson made the biggest bang for a buck than anybody else.

Has anybody stopped to consider that perhaps Bills explorations will confirm that a suit wearing human is what we see in the PGF? You're putting the cart before the horse without a finished recreation to even either embrace or pan. If anybody can make a recreation I'm sure Bill can. Also assuming this does indeen get made the world will have the chance to disect every nano bite of detail. And regardless of how it looks, be it good bad or indifferent there will be people on both sides who will condone or condemn what they see.

Actually Bill is doing you all a favor. Without somebody like Bill engaging in a project like this you guys aren't going to have an awful lot to live for. Hell this thread would have stayed dead as a doornail if there wasn't Bill Munns work to feed the furnace. You should thank him. Fire in the hole!
 
Wait a gosh darn minute! You mean all of the hard boiled critical thinking skeptics are trying to create the scenerio that Bill Munns is hatching a get rich scheme? As far as I know nobody has gotten rich from Bigfoot. Its maybe safe to say that Roger Patterson made the biggest bang for a buck than anybody else.

Has anybody stopped to consider that perhaps Bills explorations will confirm that a suit wearing human is what we see in the PGF? You're putting the cart before the horse without a finished recreation to even either embrace or pan. If anybody can make a recreation I'm sure Bill can. Also assuming this does indeen get made the world will have the chance to disect every nano bite of detail. And regardless of how it looks, be it good bad or indifferent there will be people on both sides who will condone or condemn what they see.

Actually Bill is doing you all a favor. Without somebody like Bill engaging in a project like this you guys aren't going to have an awful lot to live for. Hell this thread would have stayed dead as a doornail if there wasn't Bill Munns work to feed the furnace. You should thank him. Fire in the hole!

IMHO it's more of an ego thing than a money thing. He'll keep milking this thing as long as the bigfooters keep drooling over him. Another Meldrum is born.

Maybe this post will finally move this whole mess to AAH!
 
What a difference a few months can make:

Rockinkt, Jan. 10, 2008, My Notes part three, post #40

"Bill, I very much appreciate all the effort you have put into your analysis. I do not doubt your expertise - not do I think you are trying to pull the wool over anyone's eyes.
The fact that I question some of your assertions is in order to clear things up in my mind.
I am not trying to trick you ( I'm pretty certain I couldn't anyway).
Neither am I searching for a "gotcha"! - because you have put so many valid explanations forward that to think one or two disagreements will blow your whole work out of the water is silly.
So - please take my comments and questions as if we were discussing this over coffeee and - as you explained things - I just asked some questions or made comments to clear things up or to make counterpoints for further discussion. "



To this: Rockinkt, May 23, 2008, JREF Post #14202

"The fact that you are ignoring everything that makes this film an obvious hoax by concentrating only on the suit enables anybody to see your ultimate goal.

You can ignore the facts by sticking to one thing - the suit.
By doing that - the poor quality that a copy of a copy of a film gives, combined with the poor resolution, means that you (and anybody else) can see what they want with impunity.
You are purposely leaving yourself an out that may satisfy your own conscience - but it does not pass the odor test.

I am not cynical. I am an experienced former LEO that has spent a few years specializing in fraud cases. That enables me to see through what people like you are doing: Pandering to people's unfounded or unrealistic beliefs in exchange for a benefit to yourself.
That is far worse than being cynical.
What you are doing is just plain wrong."



And of course, yesterday, Post # 14177 where Rockinkt said:

"As far as Bill Munns - it seems obvious to me that he is pandering to the believers in order to get himself a job building a replica suit.

The interest in his giganto replica as a model for bigfoot in the minds of Bigfooters obviously has caught his attention and my old spidey senses started tingling the moment he started his pedantic posts."


Compare:

"not do I think you are trying to pull the wool over anyone's eyes."

"I am an experienced former LEO that has spent a few years specializing in fraud cases. That enables me to see through what people like you are doing"

"my old spidey senses started tingling the moment he started his pedantic posts."

"you have put so many valid explanations forward "


Maybe we have a case of identity theft here? Bi-polar disorder? Or was one of these postings simply not the true expressions of the person, making all his subsequent remarks equally suspect of deception?

Who do we believe, him, or him?

Bill

Bill - you are completely busted - and by the oldest trick in the book!:D

Really - I am just comparing your post to all the other nefarious schemers I busted in my career and I am laughing my tuckus off.:D:D

They all showed such bewilderment and surprise that I was originally lying to them and I was not their friend - ever.:jaw-dropp

They all tried to say it was proof that I was originally in agreement with what they were doing. :boggled:

Oh my - it is so funnny! I haven't had so much fun since I left the job! :D

The first thing that you have to understand Bill - is that pretending to believe and sympathize with a suspect is a standard tactic amongst well trained and experienced investigators.

Cha-ching!!! Did the nickel drop yet???

Pretending to be your friend is so old - you must have seen it a thousand times on TV and in the movies or read it in a book.

I just wanted you and everybody else to see that the "big sceptic" on the BFF was not going to interfere or doubt your word - thereby giving you a chance to show exactly what your game was.

See the big flashing "obvious" light yet? :rolleyes:

If I had come on strong in the beginning - you would have been much more careful in how you went about things.

So - you just kept on with your scheme and felt you were untouchable - making little errors that showed your true goal.

Darn it, Bill - you are just not the challenge I thought you would be! ;)
:D
 
Regardless of my personal feelings for another person on this forum, I will respond to a dignified post with a dignified reply.

Rockinkt responded to my quote:

"Fine, you see me as a fraud. Time will tell, and I will submit to that jury."

with the following post:



"Actually Bill, I'm glad you bring up the part about the jury. You see - I spent a long time preparing cases for juries and giving evidence in front of a jury. The biggest thing that impacts a jury is the accused very own words and actions. "

"You have left a very large and indefensible body of evidence to show that your scheme is NOT "a harmless form of recreation" - but a well developed scheme to scam a bunch of people who are looking for validation and hope out of their money.

You see, Bill - you are not dealing with average people on the BFF. After 3 years of posting there - I have seen the average people fall off one by one as they realized that this whole phenomenon is nothing more than smoke and mirrors. The preponderance of the people on that board are BELIEVERS looking for their holy grail.

The average person is by far in the minority on that board.
That is your downfall - if you are looking for absolution in the court of public opinion or the real courts.
The vast majority of average people DO NOT BELIEVE IN BIGFOOT!
Juries are made up of average people.

In a real court - the fact that the original P&G film is NOT available for analysis would make your case untenable from the start.
It would be thrown out of court.
No judge in his/her right mind would ever allow such nonsense as a copy of a copy of an unknown original allowed in their court as evidence. (Since the provenance of the original film is not available and under such a cloud - even that would be hard to have admitted as evidence - but that is another story)

So you see Bill, you have not got a leg to stand on - in the real world."


Regarding Rockinkt's response,

My remark was not pertaining to a trial of the PG Film, but rather a trial of my integrity and the fact that I am confident, with time, my true intentions will be obvious to all with an open mind and I will be respected for my integrity.

This quote, "You have left a very large and indefensible body of evidence to show that your scheme is NOT "a harmless form of recreation" - but a well developed scheme to scam a bunch of people who are looking for validation and hope out of their money." is false and will be proven so in time. If I have to wait for years before people finally see the truth of my intentions, so be it. I can wait. I'm patient.


There are "believers" of every persuasion and philosophy, and all different levels of sophistication and openmindedness. And there are cynics who can find fault or suspicious motive for virtually every act of human nature. No person can live bound by fears that some people may misunderstand them, and no person should ever wavier in something they feel has merit because others find suspicious motives lurking about.

That said, I am not suggesting taking the PG Film, or my work into a court of traditional law, because the fundamental elements are not specified. Is it a criminal or civil case? Who is the defendant and what are the charges or causes of action against same? How does the film stand as evidentuary ingredient and who introduces the film as evidence? Until such questions are answered, judgment of admissability is purely speculative, and inconclusive.

"So you see Bill, you have not got a leg to stand on - in the real world."[/

Finally, I have two very fine legs to stand on. One is my stated intention of research, to study materials for suits in relation to the image on the PG Film, and the second is my knowledge of the materials and processes, a body of informational material that so far, nobody has impeached the credibility of, despite approximately 47,000 views over all the note sets, in the past 4 1/2 months. However vigorously people have tried to impeach my character, nobody has refuted or impeached the truthful substance of my notes on materials and processes.


Crowlogic:

:)

More fire in the hole.

GT/CS

"He'll keep milking this thing as long as the bigfooters keep drooling over him."

Actually it's not drool, but venom, and the "bigfooters" are the passive ones, while the distinguished company here are dribbling their fluids.



TO ALL:

Just wanted to wish one and all a good night and thank you all for a fascinating day of exchanges. Like a good group therapy session, a lot of people really let down the guard and revealed their true selves.

I must say this whole forum is becoming an intriguing laboratory of human interaction, a mirror of contemporary culture. Enlightening, to say the least.

Bill


Rockinkt:

"They all showed such bewilderment and surprise that I was originally lying to them"

Thank you for admitting you are a liar, and simply intend to deceive people. The truth comes out now.

You are the admitted fraud.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Both sides of this thing need to encourage Bill Munns and Dfoot. They're at least working up a sweat and getting thier hands dirty while the rest of us are simply running off at the mouth no matter how many qoutes and internet info bites we post to support our positions.
Exactly how is Bill Munns getting his hands dirty?
log, I was hoping you could tell me how you think Bill Munns is getting his hands dirty, so to speak. Is a lot of typing getting your hands dirty?
 
You are not saying anything that I haven't heard said by any number of fraud artists justifying their scams.
I have complete confidence in my abilities. Unlike you - I have never been fired for incompetence in something I purport myself to be an expert in.

As far as your babbling statement about jursidiction - that is a bunch of crap designed to make you sound like the agrieved party and trying to make me look like some sort of fool or power usurping despot. Jurisdiction is red herring and you know it. What I stated has NOTHING to do with jurisdiction.
The fact of the matter is that I issued you a CHALLENGE - not an order.
Your crying and whining and lying about the challenge being more than it was - is just more proof that your conscience is not clear and you are trying the "poor, poor, little me" gambit.

Such a ruse doesn't fly with anybody who recognizes your obvious true intentions which are to exploit a bunch of people into paying you large sums of money to make a model that you convince them should be made according to your fabrications (an accurate description of your "specifications").
Sweet con - gotta hand it to you.

Too bad the truth cannot be told on the BFF.

I think you have him nailed dead to rights.
 
Drew:

"Bill- I always assumed that you saw a demand, and were attempting to supply a product to fill that demand. "

Well, hard as you may find this to believe, I saw a need, not a demand, and the need was for factual information about suits, from a person who built them, to hopefully bring some factual information to the debate.

Onviously, no good deed goes unpunished.

Bill

I think you are hoping that no bad deed will go unrewarded.

I guess you might as well con people about bigfoot, it seems to be a tradition.
 
Rockinkt:

"They all showed such bewilderment and surprise that I was originally lying to them"

Thank you for admitting you are a liar, and simply intend to deceive people. The truth comes out now.

You are the admitted fraud.

Bill

Actually Bill - you are the fraud and you proved it once again by by taking my quote out of context.
Boy, you are sure showing your true colors again.

You know my whole post was referring to the fact that it is a standard and accepted tactic to pretend to be on the side of the bad guys and pretend that you are trying to help or like them when you are actually intending to nail them to the wall.

Perfectly fine and happy to have done so many, many times to protect people from those scum who prey on the weakness of others.

That is why I did it to you.
And it worked.
So stop whining.
 
Last edited:
log, I was hoping you could tell me how you think Bill Munns is getting his hands dirty, so to speak. Is a lot of typing getting your hands dirty?

Hands on material approach. Same as Dfoot. Have you sampled any fake fur recently?
 
Bill - you are completely busted - and by the oldest trick in the book!:D

Really - I am just comparing your post to all the other nefarious schemers I busted in my career and I am laughing my tuckus off.:D:D

They all showed such bewilderment and surprise that I was originally lying to them and I was not their friend - ever.:jaw-dropp

They all tried to say it was proof that I was originally in agreement with what they were doing. :boggled:

Oh my - it is so funnny! I haven't had so much fun since I left the job! :D

The first thing that you have to understand Bill - is that pretending to believe and sympathize with a suspect is a standard tactic amongst well trained and experienced investigators.

Cha-ching!!! Did the nickel drop yet???

Pretending to be your friend is so old - you must have seen it a thousand times on TV and in the movies or read it in a book.

I just wanted you and everybody else to see that the "big sceptic" on the BFF was not going to interfere or doubt your word - thereby giving you a chance to show exactly what your game was.

See the big flashing "obvious" light yet? :rolleyes:

If I had come on strong in the beginning - you would have been much more careful in how you went about things.

So - you just kept on with your scheme and felt you were untouchable - making little errors that showed your true goal.

Darn it, Bill - you are just not the challenge I thought you would be! ;)
:D

"Every cop is a criminal" Rolling Stones Sympathy For The Devil 1968
 
Last edited:
Rock, welcome to JREF. I just saw your final departure post on BFF. I have no intention of joining that forum and can see why you decided to abandon it.
 
William I'm really not much of a crusader. You said yourself that your involvment in the Bigfoot issue amounts to a harmless form of recreation. If there was a bonified instance where Bigfootery did intentional harm or unintentional harm to somene for believeing I might be tempted mount my white steed grab a lance and go charging about proclaiming the evils of Bigfootery. It dosen't seem to lead people into ruin. Is there a case where anyone has ever ended up in dire straights and lamenting that if they haden't believed in Bigfoot they might have amounted to something?

Off the top of my head comes the name Rene Dahinden. Watch the CBC archives I posted for the melodramatic saga of a man who left his wife and children to chase a dream. Don't try talking about Dahinden without watching those old films first, and don't ask me for links before using the search function.

My entire capital expendature in Bigfoot amounts to about $25 worth of books and a small portion of some VCR tapes that I recorded some Bigfoot stories over a period of 30 years. I'll bet that I've spent more than $25 in electricity running my computer and reading and posting on this forum. But tell you what. Next time I'm in California I'll try and get an auidence with Nancy Regan and maybe she'll be willing to support a new just say no campaign on behalf of ridding the world of Bigfootery. Just to show you that my heart is in the right place I've even made a little symbol for the campaign. And what have you done for truth justice and the demonic way today?

I have spent no money on Bigfoot propaganda. The bit about "fight the rot" was tongue-in-cheek. I would never go to lengths to argue against Bigfootery. I limit my postings to this forum, and only go head-to-head with believers who wander into this place. I'm pretty sure I have lured a few BFF believer folks here by using my Parcher style criticism. I name names and go for the weapons. When Wild Bill Munns called me "the worst" (of the JREF gerbils) I cracked a smile. How could he not expect that sort of thing? We are talking about a creature that does not exist. Hello!
 
William yes there is Rene Dahinden. From what I've gathered about the man it seems that he was of the modality that if there haden't been a Bigfoot to chase he would have chased something else to the same end as his Bigfoot chase. A question worth considering is whether or not he was satisfied/happy with the decisions he made or was he bitter and dispondant over the life he chose to persue? Its a little like that Van Morrison song about the guy who cleans windows for a living and is happy doing it.

That said I wouldn't dream of spending the kids collage fund going on BFRO expeditions.

:boxedin:
 
Rockinkt:



(My quoting you) "They all showed such bewilderment and surprise that I was originally lying to them"

(My remarks to you) "Thank you for admitting you are a liar, and simply intend to deceive people. The truth comes out now.

You are the admitted fraud.

Bill "

(Your response) "Actually Bill - you are the fraud and you proved it once again by by taking my quote out of context.
Boy, you are sure showing your true colors again.

You know my whole post was referring to the fact that it is a standard and accepted tactic to pretend to be on the side of the bad guys and pretend that you are trying to help or like them when you are actually intending to nail them to the wall."




Comparing a persons remarks, past and present is a classic and respectful way of revealing deception such as yours, and your accusation of me as a fraud is contridicted by your own admitted deception.

The problem with your "standard tactic " of law enforcement is that you are not enforcing any law, just your delusional personal vendetta.

And as for "nailing me to the wall", you haven't got a nail and there isn't a wall. You have not offered anything even remotely qualifiable as "proof" of my intentions or any results of those intentions you accuse me of. You are just hurling lame accusations you are inventing.

You should feel very much at home here among your kind.

Bill
 
Last edited:
William I went to CBC archives and found a couple of things on Rene Dahinden but the video buffered a long time and didn't open so I'll hsve to go back. But I did a general search and picked up some history on him. I'm assuming there is an outright admission of failure and wasted effort by him somewhere but didn't read specifically that. Since he took up the search based on the word of a farmer and not on an outright report of significant stature I think that it was in him to latch onto something to encompase his entire being. Perhaps he would have chased UFO's or Lake Monsters if the Sasquatach question hadn't presented itself. Its more like he was seduced by the idea than of external coercion by profiteering forces. I can't help but think of J. Allen Hynek who started out as an official Government UFO debunker, then changed his stance and spent the rest of his life chasing the enigma. But in the end Hynek fell victim to huksters and died without bringing the UFO issue into the respectibility he himself thought it was worth. I'm willing to bet that both men in the end (Hynek did) became a target for others to take advantage of in order to advance a given agenda.
 
Dahinden's goal was to deliver a Bigfoot (called Sasqua/Sasquatch in Canada) dead or alive to the world. He always carried a gun and intended to use it. He said he would hunt the Sasquatch until he bagged one. His own death came first, but I don't think he outright said his devoted efforts amounted to a waste of time. That kind of admission would amount to saying he really should have been doing something else. He seemed to develop an angry hatred for skeptics and scientists which he called the "100% Boys".

His farmer boss near Calgary got him started by mentioning that the "hairy buggers" lived nearby. He soon found that there already were plenty of stories about encounters with these things. At that time there were no plaster casts, photos or films. All anyone had were stories. He believed them. Soon he began seeking funding for his hunts. I don't think anyone stepped forward. Rene wasn't seduced by profiteers because nobody was selling anything (goods or services) related to Sasquatch. That came later. He was seduced by the campfire encounter stories. Over 20 years later he still had no Sasquatch even after hunting for it relentlessly. In a non-CBC archive he said that he had seen 3000 tracks in six different sizes. He worked only to eat and look for the creature. His obsession caused him to leave his family, and his wife said he wanted to spend his money on the search instead of buying food for them.

Many Bigfooters who knew him say that he was a money-hungry jerk, or worse. They don't say he was wrong about Sasquatch being real.
 
Last edited:
Reminds me of Henri Mignet. Mignet was an amateur aviation buff and designed a home built contraption called the Flying Flea and sold plans to would be builders. The Flying Flea was all the rage in Europe for a while until a few people died in them. Seems the aircraft had an obscure yet serious design flaw that could send it hopeless out of control if the pilot put it into a certain flight attitude. Eventually the thing was grounded and the fault corrected but only after a right and proper analysis made by bonified aircraft engineers. But Minget persisted in hawking the device and traveled around Europe trying to keep his dream of an everyman airplane going. It cost him his home and his family and was in the end reduced to becoming a vagabond sleeping in hangers or sheltering under the wing of his obsession.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom