Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
If he builds a bad crummy looking replica to prove the PGF is real then he's put himself in the unenviable position of having done a lousy job of his craft. Therefore he must build a replica that's going to withstand the every manner of analysis under every possible condition. So if he makes a bad replica he's made the PGF look good but he's made his talents look bad. .


That is the catch. I think that if he builds an exact replica, it WILL look 'bad crummy' because the Patty suit is 'Bad Crummy'. Thus he could exactly and expertly duplicate the Patty suit, and upon close inspection it would look crappy. I don't think the object of Bill Munns is to build a suit, but to recreate the film.
 
That is the catch. I think that if he builds an exact replica, it WILL look 'bad crummy' because the Patty suit is 'Bad Crummy'. Thus he could exactly and expertly duplicate the Patty suit, and upon close inspection it would look crappy. I don't think the object of Bill Munns is to build a suit, but to recreate the film.

First to recreate the film is to recreate the suit. The two elements are inseparable I tend to think that anyone commissioning a professional to recreate a suit/film would be doing so from a position of being a proponent and that the overall thrust of the enterprise would be to support the proponent position. It would take a great deal of integrity to undertake the commission and maintain a fully objective position and "call it like you see it" from start to finish.

That said I am in no way speculating on anyone's motives for seeking to make the replication. My impression of Bill Munns is that he has the skill set and desire to see for himself what comprises the figure we see on that film.
 
Rockinkt:

"As far as Bill Munns - it seems obvious to me that he is pandering to the believers in order to get himself a job building a replica suit.

The interest in his giganto replica as a model for bigfoot in the minds of Bigfooters obviously has caught his attention and my old spidey senses started tingling the moment he started his pedantic posts.

I challenge him here and now to state publicly that he will never accept a commission to build a replica "Patty" or suit or statue or model of a sasquatch/Bigfoot."


Thank you for verifying my impression that you are truly a cynical person wrapped up in your own intellectual agenda.

There is no current offer or negotiation for a commission, but if there were, I will accept a commission, grant, or investment to fund research work in this field, if I believe the research has potential to bring new data to the issue which benefits all interested persons in this investigation.

I have already outlined the basics of such a research plan, in my notes, part 11. It has to do with resolving the question of how much detail can reliably be extracted from the PG Film, which is much debated. It can only be accomplished with funding.

Bill
 
re: Crow Logics statement

I don't agree, I think recreating the film could be done with a crappy costume, with a crappy camera, with a shaky photog, or with a beautifully made costume, with a crappy camera and a shaky photog.
 
Last edited:
re: Crow Logics statement

I don't agree, I think recreating the film could be done with a crappy costume, with a crappy camera, with a shaky photog, or with a beautifully made costume, with a crappy camera and a shaky photog.

Well we've seen lots of crappy looking suits and there's no getting around the fact that they are crappy looking suits. The catch with the PGF is that its not 100% lousy. I suspect that a recreation effort would involve filming and digitally capturing the event as a shakey Pattersonesque job as well as a steady framing to compare with what can be seen and applied to the conditions of the PGF. In other words if a good (not great) suit looks great in steady film at the same distance from the subject then its bound to look perfect when filmed as Patterson did. There also the question of equipment. Patterson didn't use a crummy camera. In its day his camera was a very good piece of equipment and he used the best film in it.
He wielded it poorly more than anything else.
 
Bill Munns:
...It has to do with resolving the question of how much detail can reliably be extracted from the PG Film, which is much debated. It can only be accomplished with funding.
For the most part, that has been determined ..
http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/filmres.html

.... Cut out a paper circle with this diameter and it will approximate the smallest detail (optimistically) resolvable, in very rough terms about 2 inches on Patty's body. (Actual resolution, for the above-mentioned cautionary reasons is apt to be worse than that, possibly by half) Upon inspection of this juxtaposition, the resolution in these large pictures is virtually the same as the largest blobs like the nose and the ear projection, but anything below that level of detail ( 2 inches )does not contain information.....
..... Thus, finger or toe detail, that should lie in the vicinity of this 2" limit, does not show up crisply at all. Any conclusions based on supposed detail below the stated limit are largely a function of the imagination of the examiner .....


Seams, zippers,fur detail ( 2 inches or smaller ) cannot be resolved in this film regardless of the methods employed ..

So when someone claims there are no zippers or seams to be seen, they are simply confirming the obvious; that such detail cannot be resolved in this film ..

They are in no way, able to claim ( truthfully ) those features are not present on the subject ..
 
Last edited:
Diogenes:

The study I've described has not been done before, and thus may potentially yield new data. How the new data may impact on this issue can only be determined when the data exists and is studied.

Having real new data to study is more responsible than simply arguing about old data endlessly.

Bill
 
Bill,
You should link to your notes when you cite them. Then any newcomers could visit the BFF and read your positions on them.

Would you call your project an attempt to recreate the costume, or to recreate the film?
 
Bill Munns:
For the most part, that has been determined ..
http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/papers/filmres.html




Seams, zippers,fur detail ( 2 inches or smaller ) cannot be resolved in this film regardless of the methods employed ..

So when someone claims there are no zippers or seams to be seen, they are simply confirming the obvious; that such detail cannot be resolved in this film ..

They are in no way, able to claim ( truthfully ) those features are not present on the subject ..


Greg nobody is denying the films resoloution. In fact I'm a little embarrased by some of the things some professional imaging experts claim to see. But by having a reproduction that will both emulate the original in motion and format that can be compared with a clear stable (better?) camera technique a comparsion can then be made between the results of the two emulations. By being able to compare the way in which the details of the film degrade because of the limitations of the camera work and media it will be possible to determine better in what ways the PGF hides its own flaws and also a way of a kind of reverse engineering of the image quality of the original. For all we know a blatent seam that shows up as a vague line or shadow on the PGF may be able to be demonstrated for what it is by showing it in a clear steady state and how and what it transforms into because of the character of the way it was filmed.

Think of it like the Space Program where NASA has a full working model of the mission on the ground that can run simulations to trouble shoot problems occuring in the actual mission.
 
Having real new data to study is more responsible than simply arguing about old data endlessly.

Bill
I've got a better idea. It's new. It's vogue. It's art house. If interpretational works on dumpy thighs aren't getting the raised eyebrows of science, let's get experimental and follow some leads to getting some current bigfoot evidence. A Munns approved jaunt into Bigfoot Land should get the ball rolling.
 
Drew:

"Would you call your project an attempt to recreate the costume, or to recreate the film?"

Neither.

It is a plan to test with verifiable reference how much detail can be extracted from a filmed image at similar resolution/grain structure as the image in the PG Film, specifically using shapes and materials that might be found both on fur costumes and real mammals with varied hiar/fur characteristics.

Example would be a face mask, sculpted in two variations, one with a mouth, one without, and when filmed at actual 16mm size and resolution, can the mouth be determined on one mask? If we cannot see which mask has the mouth, then we can say with some assurance that a mouth cannot be determined in the PG film either.

Or, various seam types and costume fur patterns can be tested to see how they specifically appear under the PG film level of comparable resolution, with higher clarity reference imaging to verify the source appearance.

Any discussion or idea of recreating the full figure of "Patty", or recreating the film, should be set aside for now, because foundation studies should be done first, and we should see what they reveal.

Bill


added:

Kitakaze:

"I've got a better idea. It's new. It's vogue. It's art house. If interpretational works on dumpy thighs aren't getting the raised eyebrows of science, let's get experimental and follow some leads to getting some current bigfoot evidence. A Munns approved jaunt into Bigfoot Land should get the ball rolling."

If you ever think about becomming a professional sarcastic wit, don't quit your day job just yet.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Crowlogic:

"Greg nobody is denying the films resoloution. In fact I'm a little embarrased by some of the things some professional imaging experts claim to see. But by having a reproduction that will both emulate the original in motion and format that can be compared with a clear stable (better?) camera technique a comparsion can then be made between the results of the two emulations. By being able to compare the way in which the details of the film degrade because of the limitations of the camera work and media it will be possible to determine better in what ways the PGF hides its own flaws and also a way of a kind of reverse engineering of the image quality of the original. For all we know a blatent seam that shows up as a vague line or shadow on the PGF may be able to be demonstrated for what it is by showing it in a clear steady state and how and what it transforms into because of the character of the way it was filmed."

Thank you for contributing these thoughts. It's the best understanding of what I am actually proposing so far. Maybe others will "get it" through this second decription of the idea.

:)

Bill
 
Bill


added:

Kitakaze:

"I've got a better idea. It's new. It's vogue. It's art house. If interpretational works on dumpy thighs aren't getting the raised eyebrows of science, let's get experimental and follow some leads to getting some current bigfoot evidence. A Munns approved jaunt into Bigfoot Land should get the ball rolling."

If you ever think about becomming a professional sarcastic wit, don't quit your day job just yet.

Bill

Professional sarcastic wit? Well just when some rational discussion arrives in this hole where at least an idea is put on the table that may actually advance the issue to a reasonable conclusion the above remark to which Bill responded to has to get tossed in and suddenly it 7th grade again. Everyone knows about diaper butt, buldging thigh, mit hand, paddle foot and cap knees. But remember when they built the replica of the Wright Flyer. What for? There are Wright Flyers perserved we know what Wright Flyer is. But we didn't know how one flew and what it was like to fly one. So hense the replica told us things that the original couldn't.
 
Last edited:
Crowlogic:

"But remember when they built the replica of the Wright Flyer. What for? There are Wright Flyers perserved we know what Wright Flyer is. But we didn't know how one flew and what it was like to fly one. So hense the replica told us things that the original couldn't."

Thank you. A fine example of the general idea that a replica of some past event has real merit in understanding the original.

On a side note, does anyone find it curious that apparently, last weekend, M.K. Davis made some very interesting revelations about his studies of the PG Film, which could be debated here, and someone here even posted a note about that a few days ago, and yet no one here wishes to discuss the new news pertaining to one well established researcher's findings, preferring instead to try and make rules about what "Munns" can or cannot do.

Seems to show the mindset here, in a sad but unmistakable way.

Bill
 
On a side note, does anyone find it curious that apparently, last weekend, M.K. Davis made some very interesting revelations about his studies of the PG Film, which could be debated here, and someone here even posted a note about that a few days ago, and yet no one here wishes to discuss the new news pertaining to one well established researcher's findings, preferring instead to try and make rules about what "Munns" can or cannot do.

So far, all I have seen is a lot of conjecture on what MK Davis is supposedly releasing. No pics, no movies, no stills, no analysis that I can find. Exactly what is supposed to be discussed? Rumor? Speculation? If you have something to add, please do so.

As far as MK Davis being a "well established researcher", I am not sure what to make of that. From what I understand he is an astrophotographer of sorts but I have never seen his imagery anywhere. I have subscribed to Sky and Telescope and Astronomy since 1972 and I don't recall seeing his imagery anywhere (although I might have missed them). I did a quick search on the web but did not find any images of his there either. He may be good at manipulating imagery and maybe snapping a few pics of the night sky but I am not sure if he really spends a lot of his time doing astrophotography on the level implied.

MK has technical ability but what are his true qualifications? Is his area of expertise associated with film analysis or is he just a guy that is pretty good at photoshop and other image processing software?

I posted it once before and I will continue to post it again. Mr. William G. Hyzer is an expert on film analysis and he had words of caution for those who are "amateurs" in the field:

There is a certain commonality that exists between some statisticians and digital-image-processing aficionados:
'Tell me what you want them to hear and I will produce a statistic to support it."
"Explain to me what you want them to see and I will create an image to buttress that perception."
...digital image processing, even in primitive form, is a highly manipulative process capable of changing an image into something it isn't in order to highlight certain features and/or subdue others at the personal discretion of the operator...Tampering with these images for the intended purpose of revealing things that are not visually apparent in them is an exercise that can easily lead an overzealous photo analyst out of reality and into the realm of pseudo-science.
(William Hyzer responds, MUFON Journal, Oct 1992 P 15-16).

When I see MK Davis on the National Geographic channel program showing how he can confidently see bigfoot's eyebrow move in the PGF, I start to wonder exactly how objective he is in his work.
 
Well, I found the latest on MK Davis theory about the PGF. It is a whopper and I am simply amazed that such details can be extracted from the PGF. Are we really supposed to believe that there was a bigfoot massacre before the PGF was filmed?
Check it out:
http://www.cryptomundo.com/cryptozoo-news/bf-massacre/

If this is what MK Davis is doing, then my previous post concerning Mr. Hyzer's warning is very applicable.
 
Astrophotographer:

My only observation was simply that Mr. Davis has been involved far longer with the PG Film than I, and certainly more well known for his efforts, so all logic would seem that news of his activity would be expected to inspire more debate here in this thread than anything I have done recently.

Suffice to say, participants can post on any topic as they choose. It is simply revealing of their interests and agendas what they do post or remark about, and what they neglect or omit.

Bill
 
OMG! I've suspected MK had seen a little too much but this is rich. He's become Sean Connery in The Man Who Would be King or Marlon Brando in Apocalypse Now. He's lost it he's been consumed! That which he sought to illuminate has instead devoured him. Madness is tragic to wittness!
 
Astrophotographer:

My only observation was simply that Mr. Davis has been involved far longer with the PG Film than I, and certainly more well known for his efforts, so all logic would seem that news of his activity would be expected to inspire more debate here in this thread than anything I have done recently.

Bill
What about Mr.Davis activities do you feel are worthy of discussion ?

Why don't you get the ball rolling ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom