Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Diogenes:

"There is no way, you or anyone can honestly claim there is not any artificial distortion of fur around the neck, because such detail is simply not available in the film .."

I disagree.

:)

Bill
If you disagree, then you shouldn't have any problem providing us with visuals from the film that support your claim ..

Over at BFF you provided highly detailed drawings ( detail far beyond the resolution of the film ) of how a suit would be put together and why the seams would or would not show, but you provided no source material from the film as a direct comparison ..

Of course, you are entitled to your opinion, but your opinion, without evidence, is no more valid than someone claiming to have some Bigfoot blood on a nail ...
 
Diogenes wrote:
Here is the best view we have of the head , neck and shoulders ..


Not quite, Greg.


Here's the image you posted...

neck1.gif



And here is a much better quality image from the film....

Pattywalk2a.jpg



This is yet another good example of the grade of your "analysis", Greg......100% pure Garbage.
 
That is a cibachrome print .. Not frame from the film, where we can analyse the detail in motion..
And yes it shows the folds and seams much clearer ..
Particularly where the shoulders meet the neck...

Thank you ...


Have any more ?
 
Do the Cibachromes appear compressed vertically to anyone else?

Do the Cibachromes appear to show Patty with much longer fur than is visible in frames of the film?
Bill- Does the appearance of shaggy fur in the Cibachromes affect your belief that the Patty hair is short, and would not be able to cover seams, and thus the seams would be more visible?

Does anyone have more Cibachromes like Sweaty posted?

Bill- Have you seen the Cibachromes before?
 
Diogenes:

On the BFF, you are posting photos from the film and arguing that they reveal lines that indicate aspects of a suit, meaning the film has enough detail to pereive such details. And then here you say "such detail is simply not available in the film" when you criticize me.

Blatant hypocracy. The film has enough resolution to support your observations, but not enough detail to support mine.

I know you're trying to win your arguments, at all cost, truth or not, but when you are that obviously hypocritical, you win nothing.

Drew:

I have seen a few of the Cibachromes and the levels of detail are interesting, but the colors are also way off, so I don't know what copying/alteration may have been done. So I haven't made any judgment on them yet.

Bill
 
Diogenes:

On the BFF, you are posting photos from the film and arguing that they reveal lines that indicate aspects of a suit, meaning the film has enough detail to pereive such details. And then here you say "such detail is simply not available in the film" when you criticize me.

Blatant hypocracy. The film has enough resolution to support your observations, but not enough detail to support mine.

I know you're trying to win your arguments, at all cost, truth or not, but when you are that obviously hypocritical, you win nothing.



Bill

You have yet to show where in the film your observations are supported ...

You have only produced some high resolution drawings, and made claims that the features found in your drawings cannot be found in the film ..

You have produced no evidence that rules out seams..

I have not stated categorically that my observations are correct ..
I am pointing out what I believe could be seams ...
The headpiece could be sewn to the body with inch high cross stitches made with purple thread, and they would not show up in the film ..

I have produced evidence that shows parts of the outer covering and under-structure, interacting in a way that is indicative of a suit with padding underneath.
The best you can do is offer the tired old " It must be light and shadow " ..
On the other hand, light and shadow couldn't possibly be be causing you to fail to discern any features of a suit..

It's clear where the hypocrisy is ..


You keep saying you cannot see what would be folds of suit material,
but we can see that parts of the upper thigh, disappear into the pelvic area above ..

waderline.gif


Explain, using your expertise, how you can rule out suit behavior in what is being seen..
 
Diogenes:

You said:
" "such detail is simply not available in the film"

and then you procede to show and argue that the detail to see the fold you diagram in the hip appears like a suit fold.

Can't have it both ways.

retract the remark "such detail is simply not available in the film"

and admit the film does show enough detail to support what you perceive.

Then, confront Aepervius, who says,

"Unfortunatly your disagreement is neither supported by physic (the resolution of the pgf is known within a certain extent) nor by the multiple mistreatment the film had for all successive generation."

and tell him why he's wrong, because he's also trying to say the film resolution doesn't support the detail you are mentioning.

(Unless of course, he shares your hypocracy and thinks the film grain only obscures the details I see 9or see no evidence of) while being fully resolved enough in detail to support what indicators of suit aspects you see.

Finally,
you say:

Explain, using your expertise, how you can rule out suit behavior in what is being seen..

I explained it in detail in my notes, part 12, the hip seam issue. If you want to read them, you know where to find them.

People, this is getting so lame and nitpicky. To say you cannot see the forest for the trees, wouldn't do you justice. You cannot even see the tree because you have your eyes glued to one leaf.

Bill
 
Holy Crap Greg- I have never seen that before.

It's always been there, no one else has bothered to zero in on it..
The complete gif those frames are pulled from, is a gif that was Bob Zenor's avatar for a while ..

I love it !

It shows what appears to be the upper arm moving under a shoulder pad, the upper chest ( part of a shoulder pad apparatus ? ) moving independently of the lower chest, the torso twisting independently of the pelvis and that upper thigh disappearing into the diaper among other things ...

All indications of a suit, that is somehow escaping the expert eye of Mr. Munns ...
 
Last edited:
Diogenes:

"All indications of a suit, that is somehow escaping the expert eye of Mr. Munns ..."

All were considered, all analysed, and in my opinion, are not indications of a suit.

:)

Bill
 
Bill,
I have not claimed I can see detail you claim is not there..

You do not seem to understand what " you cannot rule out detail that is not supported by the resolution of the film " means ...


It means ( an example ), you cannot claim there are no zippers .. ( smaller than what is supported by the resolution of the film ..)

You can't rule out that there are one inch high letters spelling out " made in china " on Patty's cheek .. The resolution of the film cannot resolve one inch details.. etc. etc..


When you get this, you might understand more about what Aepervius and I are talking about when we talk about the resolution of the film ..


Obviously, when you don't' have an explanation for something that fits your conclusions, we are being nit picky ..

And, no, you haven't explained the disappearing material in the upper thigh area ..

Welcome to the Thunderdome ...
 
Diogenes;

You and I disagree on just about everything. That is obvious.

I remain confident that I have presented my ideas and arguments in a manner that represents my thinking on the issues. Others, including you and all the residents of Thunderdub can take them or leave them as they like.

:)

Bill
 
You're the expert ..

Explain why the shrinking area in the upper thigh cannot be accounted for with suit behavior..

I'm not saying it has to be ( suit behavior ), I'm asking how you can rule it out ...

Maybe a forum where evidence is required, is not your cup of tea ..:)
 
Diogenes:

"You're the expert .."

I'll take that at face value and assume you are a sincere person with rational judgment and fair appraisals of other persons. If you are not sincere, not rational, or not fair, please feel free to correct me.

"Explain why the shrinking area in the upper thigh cannot be accounted for with suit behavior.."

I have looked at ten different frames of the hip area and charted the shadow patterns in those ten frames. The shadow patterns, which may reasonably indicate some changes in the fur lay or underlying base structure positions, do vary across the ten frames examined. Those changes of pattern do not follow a form which man-made structures tend to show, because in suits, the underlying structure, or folds of furcloth, tend to form in lines and buckled curves which are consistant in shape as the suit moves. The patterns I observed in the ten frames, when viewed as a group, do not have a consistant pattern that man made objects and structures indicate. On that basis, I believe the hip shadow patterns, however odd they may be, do not indicate a suit or any folding of one part under another.

"I'm not saying it has to be ( suit behavior ), I'm asking how you can rule it out ..."

Noted above, and explained in more detail in the notes, part 12.

"Maybe a forum where evidence is required, is not your cup of tea .. "

Tea, no. Evidence, yes, I love it.

Problem is people assign different weight to what they perceive as evidence, and the classical disagreement is when one person sees something as evidence and another does not.

Ideally, some foundation of agreed relevence helps resolve that disagreement and lead people to a greater shared understanding.

Would you like to try and work with me to establish a shared foundation of relevence that may allow us to better agree on what material is credible evidence in this discussion?

Bill
__________________
 
Of course, none of this observed suit-like behavior is new to anyone but Bill Munns, apparently. The regulars here and elsewhere have been posting and talking about it for a long time.

The believers went so far as to claim the giant flapping thigh piece was a muscle pull! That of course, explained why Patty didn't run!

We've noticed the baggy pants legs, the strange calf behavior, the arm muscle rings, the rigid breasts, etc., etc.
 
Kitakaze:

In regard to your prior post about the BFRO and some comments of theirs about costumes, LTC has been kind enough to provide you with answers that should clear everything up for you.

He said:

"Of course, none of this observed suit-like behavior is new to anyone but Bill Munns, apparently. The regulars here and elsewhere have been posting and talking about it for a long time.

The believers went so far as to claim the giant flapping thigh piece was a muscle pull! That of course, explained why Patty didn't run!

We've noticed the baggy pants legs, the strange calf behavior, the arm muscle rings, the rigid breasts, etc., etc. "


Just trying to help you guys all get on the same page with your research.

Bill
 
The patterns I observed in the ten frames, when viewed as a group, do not have a consistant pattern that man made objects and structures indicate.
BS ..

Analyze these 5 frames...

waderline.gif


The area between to well defined structures - the top of the wader boots, and the bottom of the fur diaper - shrinks ..

The only logical explanation is that it is folding, or subducting into the fur diaper ..

Oh wait! There is at least one other logical explanation ..

Patty recently lost a lot of weight and she has all this loose skin, flapping around on her thighs ....
 
Does the effect show up in other frames? Something that apparanty loose with all that movement should be easily spotted elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom