Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
My personal intentions for posting here.

1. I will monitor other posts that mention me and I may respond if I feel a response is appropriate.

2. I will generally reply to a question directed to me by name, if I feel the person asking is sincere and not just childishly annoying.

3. I will not do an analysis of other matters such as third party statements or postings, so if a person here asks me to comment about the statements or remarks of another person or group who is not present on the forum, I will generally decline to comment about such.

4. If I do any analysis of issues, films, reports or such, I will choose which and when, as my schedule permits. There are more issues and material than I can possibly review, so I will prioritize my time and effort, as is my right.

5. I do not plan to post any original notes or initiate any discussions. My activity here will simply be responsive to the activity of others. If people here do not talk about me, and do not ask me questions, I will not post, but merely read and review the forum posts from time to time.

6. Like every other forum member, I reserve the right to decide how much time and effort I can devote to this discussion.

Bill Munns
 
Aepervius:


"And I noted your evasion on questioning the salami tactic, and others stuff. "

I have never heard that exact phrase "salami tactic" before, and so I don't know what you are referring to, and prefer not to guess or infer. But I will revisit the source statements you attributed to that phrase.

LTC (I believe) said:
"Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit and that Patty walks like a human being. So your statement rings quite hollow."


(And I replied): Did I ever say Patty doesn't walk like a human being? Where are you inventing these falicies?

(Then you remarked) :Your forgot the part on Expert have given the opinion.... Patty is a suit, to conveniently focus on the second part of the sentence as if it was the essence of the statement. Isn't this the salami fallacy ?

Starting with LTC's statement, the first phrase:
"Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit. . ."

That is correct, as far as i know, that some people regarded as experts (including people in the makeup effects industry) have given such an opinion. There is no reason for me to comment on this because it wasn't a question. and i do not dispute that some experts do indeed have that opinion. And it was not referenced to anything I had said in the immediate prior posts, so I saw no point in concurring.

LTC then said: "and that Patty walks like a human being. "

I've never disputed this or endorsed any arguments to the contrary, so I would agree with the remark, but since I am not arguing to the contrary, and it proves nothing, the remark by LTC was irrelevent to the comments immediately proceeding that.

Then LTC said :"So your statement rings quite hollow."

So I wonder, which statements of mine ring hollow, because LTC does not reference any specific statement of mine to compare. He does not make a logical connect between his basic remarks and his attempt to compare my statements, because the first is very specific and the second is overly generalized.

Your appraisal of which part of his remark is "the essence of the statement" is opinion, of which you are entitled, of course. But my choice of response is equally what I am entitled to do.

But now, I have addressed the entirety of his remarks with my responses.

I do not dispute or disagree with the statement that other experts have the opinion Patty is a suit (it is apparently well documented that they do have that opinion), and I concur Patty walks in a generally humanistic fashion, based on my observation of the film.

So where's the "hollow statement" and is the "salami tactic" (whatever it is)still being claimed by you?

Bill
 
WP:

"Bill, is Bigfoot hiding in the forests, or in our minds?"

Sincerely, wish I could answer that question for us both, but I just don't know.

Bill
 
Bigfoot is hiding in the forests of our minds!

Hmmm this has the makings of a bad Gordon Lightfoot song!
 
Last edited:
WP said:
Bill, is Bigfoot hiding in the forests, or in our minds?

Bill Munns said:
Sincerely, wish I could answer that question for us both, but I just don't know.

At first I thought that your answer was some kind of total garbage coming from a person that has found a new hobby. Then I realized that I just don't know if you are full of crap. It's a kind of mystery that stands alongside the mystery of Bigfoot.

Does Bigfoot exist? Does Bill Munns actually know what the hell he seems to be talking about?

I stand in awe of these mysteries. Bigfoot may not exist, and Bill Munns may not be rational. I guess the reverse could be true. In that imaginary world, Bigfoot exists and you know what you are talking about.

But then I realize that nobody has proven that you are not a blowhard crapmeister who happens to work in Hollywood and now has a new Bigfoot hobby. Can you point to any other Hollywood professionals that would say that you are not kooky for thinking the way you do about Bigfoot? Can anyone vouch for your sensibilities within the context of Bigfoot?

I stand in awe of the growing list of mysteries. I wish I could tell both of us that you are not woo.
 
WP:

Time will tell, and perhaps lend clarity to all the mysteries, maybe even resolving them.

So let's just give it some time.

:)

Bill
 
Last edited:
I want to support a reasoned analysis of what's on the PG Film, based on what can be extracted or deduced from it, as compared to the hypothesis of what it is.
Should the fact that the only person who has ever made claim to being the man in the suit, friend of Patterson and Gimlin, who lives on the same street as Gimlin, is seen on the same film reel as Patty along with his horse (which Gimlin now admits was at Bluff Creek) have any bearing on a reasoned analysis of what's on the PGF?
 
Time will tell, and perhaps lend clarity to all the mysteries, maybe even resolving them.

So let's just give it some time.

LOL. Give it time? The PGF is over forty years old and nobody is any closer to determining if it is a guy in a suit or a real bigfoot than the day it was first shown. Are you so naive that you think your "notes" are going to resolve anything? Are you so naive that no matter what evidence is presented that it is a guy in a suit, that bigfoot proponents will ever accept it is a guy in a suit? I doubt any proponent would accept the bigfoot film as a hoax even if they found a signed statement from Patterson himself that admitted it was a hoax.

Let's look at the other side of the coin. The skeptics only ask for better evidence. Perhaps a body or more information to prove it is not a guy in a suit. Do that and we (I think I speak for most skeptics here) will start to or actually change our opinions. Unfortunately, skeptics keep seeing the same old foot/butt prints, blurry videos, and bigfoot stories. The same old subjective evidence that can be so easily misinterpreted or hoaxed that it bears no weight because the quality is so poor.

I continue to be amazed that bigfoot, like UFOs, is a reactionary "science" and not proactive at all. Lots of time and effort wasted on looking at old stories and the PGF with little to show for it. No wonder it is considered a myth by so many. Meanwhile, proponents of Bigfoot enjoy and relish in the mystery of it because as long as there is a mystery, they have a voice, can sell books and videos, and can be looked at as some form of expert on something. If you haven't figured it out, Bigfoot is about personal agendas and nothing more. Otherwise, Bigfoot would have been found long ago if it actually existed.

Feel free to wait but I doubt anything will change. You are not breaking any new ground here. You are following the same old pattern of others who have examined the film. Good luck in your efforts but I seriously doubt it will resolve anything. Let me know when you, or others, have found a body or have found something earth shattering in the film that thousands of people have missed.
 
Kitakaze;

"Should the fact that the only person who has ever made claim to being the man in the suit, friend of Patterson and Gimlin, who lives on the same street as Gimlin, is seen on the same film reel as Patty along with his horse (which Gimlin now admits was at Bluff Creek) have any bearing on a reasoned analysis of what's on the PGF?"

If I am trying to figure out if I see a suit, based on material dynamics and suit construction methods, no, that information does not have any bearing on my analysis. If you are trying to prove Bob H. is telling the truth, it might. Each question is different and thus uses different criteria for influencing factors.

Aepervius:

"LOL. Give it time? The PGF is over forty years old and nobody is any closer to determining if it is a guy in a suit or a real bigfoot than the day it was first shown."

You have erred in your intrepretation of the context that answer was given. My "give it time" was in response to the "mysteries" Mr. Parcher just expressed concern for today. Parcher's concerns are not 40 years old. They are 5 months old, the time since I began to post ideas in forums.

"Are you so naive that you think your "notes" are going to resolve anything? "

Maybe they will resolve something, maybe not. They're not done yet. We'll see what the future holds. As for my being naive, each person may make that appraisal, and if you choose to see me that way, I respect your right to your opinion. And I will continue to do as I wish, confident my efforts are worth my time.

Actually, I am now also studying the human communication issue in the internet age, and observing how people can fail to understand one another, despite engaging in dialogues. It's become a fascinating experience, and a very enlightening one thus far.

Bill
 
If I am trying to figure out if I see a suit, based on material dynamics and suit construction methods,
Why are you doing that?

Actually, I am now also studying the human communication issue in the internet age, and observing how people can fail to understand one another, despite engaging in dialogues. It's become a fascinating experience, and a very enlightening one thus far.

Bill
Really? What a renaissance man.

Bill Munns, I was curious what you think of this assessment of the BGF by the BFRO:



http://bfro.net/news/roundup/exped_whydo.asp

If you disagree or have issue with any part of that assessment, could you please detail the reasons why?

Kitakaze:

I am not interested in assisting people in challenging the accuracy of third party postings and documents, especially on other sites or when presented in only partial quote form out of context.
Bill
Fascinating. Did you observe yourself?
 
Kitakaze;

"Originally Posted by Bill Munns
If I am trying to figure out if I see a suit, based on material dynamics and suit construction methods,

"Why are you doing that? "

Because I have knowledge of the materials and processes.

Quote:
Actually, I am now also studying the human communication issue in the internet age, and observing how people can fail to understand one another, despite engaging in dialogues. It's become a fascinating experience, and a very enlightening one thus far.

Bill
Really? What a renaissance man.

Thank you. I've allways considered that description to be a high compliment.

Originally Posted by kitakaze
Bill Munns, I was curious what you think of this assessment of the BGF by the BFRO:



http://bfro.net/news/roundup/exped_whydo.asp

If you disagree or have issue with any part of that assessment, could you please detail the reasons why?
Originally Posted by Bill Munns
Kitakaze:

I am not interested in assisting people in challenging the accuracy of third party postings and documents, especially on other sites or when presented in only partial quote form out of context.
Bill
Fascinating. Did you observe yourself?

I try to, yes.

Bill
 
If I am trying to figure out if I see a suit, based on material dynamics and suit construction methods,...

Because I have knowledge of the materials and processes.
Yes, we all know that but why are you doing it? Why the PGF?

I try to, yes.

Bill
And did you observe anything of yourself in that case? Did you observe what made you interpret a simple query on any thoughts you might have on the BFRO's official assessment of the PGF and the possibility of a suit as directly relating to your experience as a request for help challenging the BFRO? Did you observe what made you comment that my post was a partial quote and out of context?

I know you like to consider yourself a renaissance man so I used the term. Tell me, in this study you are currently undertaking of communication in the internet age are you making and compiling detailed notes or was it just high brow way to say that you think it's interesting that people are not getting what you want them to think about you here?
 
Kitakaze:



Originally Posted by Bill Munns
If I am trying to figure out if I see a suit, based on material dynamics and suit construction methods,...

Because I have knowledge of the materials and processes.

"Yes, we all know that but why are you doing it? Why the PGF?"

Because it's the only photographic material with a clear enough picture to make such an analysis. Most other films, videos, stills, simply don't have enough reasonably clear frames to study a potential suit, unless the suit is a rather blatant hoax, which can be more easily evident even in stills.

So the PGF simply is the best evidence (regardless of how one might say it's poor image quality, it's still better than any other film/video). So that's why I study that one.

Quote:
I try to, yes.


"And did you observe anything of yourself in that case? Did you observe what made you interpret a simple query on any thoughts you might have on the BFRO's official assessment of the PGF and the possibility of a suit as directly relating to your experience as a request for help challenging the BFRO? Did you observe what made you comment that my post was a partial quote and out of context?

I know you like to consider yourself a renaissance man so I used the term. Tell me, in this study you are currently undertaking of communication in the internet age are you making and compiling detailed notes or was it just high brow way to say that you think it's interesting that people are not getting what you want them to think about you here?"


First paragraph above: How I see your post and my reaction, and how you see the same, are clearly two different perspectives or opinions. As for my observations, they are a work in progress. That's as much as i can say about that, because you and I clearly don't connect sometimes when we try to talk. Such is one of those times. I do not understand your point, and clearly see you don't get mine. Don't know why, but that's what it looks like to me.

On the second: I actually have started writing notes (just personal notes to myself now) and thoughts about my experience in the last 4 1/2 months, on both forums, and studying how google searches of my name reveal different links, and following those links to see what people put up on other websites. It's informal, primarily for my own education in human nature. I like to learn new things, and this is an new learning experience for me, so I want to get as much value from it as I can.

Bill


afterthought

Kitakaze:

I'm assuming you know of Akira Kurasawa's film classic, "Rashomon", because it's thematic concept is a classic. Several people observe an event, yet each one witnesses something differently.

That's the case of you, me, and the whole "what do you think about this BFRO material." You, I, LTC, and even Aepervius have tried to talk about your first post and my first reply, and we are just spinning our wheels here. You still don't see what I mean, I still don't see what you mean.

What say we give this one a rest, because I don't see any resolution.


Bill
 
Last edited:
Bill Munns
Because it's the only photographic material with a clear enough picture to make such an analysis.

Nonsense !

Over at BFF you proclaim :

Personally, I have not found anything in all the frames and film I've seen that shows any artificial folding, buckling, or other distortion of the fur around the neck and upper back torso. And with rigid furcloth, the option of the time, some significent and descernable folding or buckling should have occured in this film during or after the look back sequence.

What film are you looking at ?

Of course you haven't found it .. The resolution doesn't support the detail you claim you haven't found ..


Here is the best view we have of the head , neck and shoulders ..

neck.gif


There is no way, you or anyone can honestly claim there is not any artificial distortion of fur around the neck, because such detail is simply not available in the film ..

I suggest you are pandering to the believers ....
 
Last edited:
Have at it, this is a Henry May (bf2006) bit on this weekends Davis presentation at the 20th Annual Ohio Bigfoot Conference.


M.K. Davis

"M.K. described his ten+year journey in researching the P/G Movie, and is attempting to clear the name of Roger Patterson. He began by showing a panoramic view of the film, and moved on to an artifact which appeared to be a braid which shakes with the head. He says he is an observer, not an analyst, and he observes bangs and a topknot and ponytail on Patty which blows in the wind and indicates no sagittal crest. He also shows the back muscles evident as well as a comment about someone who thought the breasts were air sacs. M.K. also shows filtered images of the breasts which appear to show nipples. A writing on the film says American Bigfoot, which meant the copy used on National Geographic's Bigfoot special was a one-inch tape scan of the original, which they obtained from American National Enterprises. M.K. also showed the teeth pretty clearly and compared that shot to one David Hancock has, and the one Hancock has is massed over, almost deliberately, as is a shot showing a good deal of skin detail. The Hernia is also discussed, the one on her right leg as she steps down in Frame 352 and found to have a large concentric circle in it which could be a bullethole. It turns out there were also two other researchers in the area that day.M.K. discussed that Bob Gimlin and Bob Heironimus were better friends than Gimlin and Patterson. M.K. showed a frame where she appears to scrape her foot on the ground, almost as if she is attempting to hide it. A pool of water is shown which was dug out by a backhoe and appears to be red, like blood or something. It is unknown where the blood is from, since Patty does not appear to be injured. M.K. revealed that Patterson was actually filming from the hole with the red water in it, and this is why you sometimes see in the opening frames where Patty appears to be higher up. M.K. stated that Patterson did not have to die in vain, and that he is attempting to find closure and announced that it is over for him. He closed with a music video tribute to Patterson."




m
 
Diogenes:

"There is no way, you or anyone can honestly claim there is not any artificial distortion of fur around the neck, because such detail is simply not available in the film .."

I disagree.

:)

Bill
 
Diogenes:

"There is no way, you or anyone can honestly claim there is not any artificial distortion of fur around the neck, because such detail is simply not available in the film .."

I disagree.

:)

Bill

Unfortunatly your disagreement is neither supported by physic (the resolution of the pgf is known within a certain extent) nor by the multiple mistreatment the film had for all successive generation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom