Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mr. Munns, no one knows what Giganto looked like. For all anyone knows, your model is a horrible representation.

As far as it looking real in general? No, it doesn't look like a real creature at all, imo. It looks like a movie model.
 
Last edited:
I am He:

"Then could please tell me why you think that
the people involved with costume makeup would be involved, and not say cameramen and soundmen also? Thank you."

I'm not making any judgment on whether other people on a crew were or were not involved, if it was a hoax. I'm simply expressing the opinion that, based on what I see in the film, and what i know about costume suits, if the figure in the film is indeed a fur suit, it appears to be a professional quality job, which would have required the skill and efforts of a professional makeup artist /suit builder.

I'm sorry Bill, but I do not recall saying asking you to make any judgments or saying anything is a Hoax but if I did I cannot recall it. The only thing I remember asking you was that, why not other people would not have been involved IF it was a suit, besides Makeup People & Suit Makers. Would not they go hand and glove in any kind of production? I'm asking because you are using your professional side of looking at this, are you not?



You can imagine other crew people if you like.

Again, where did I say others were involved? Did I or did I not ask you a question?

I choose not to speculate about that. Bill

Did I ever ask you to Speculate?



I Am He
 
The Earth is immensely bigger than your mind, William. :)

Accordingly, there will continue to be many rational, intelligent, and open-minded people having no problem at all giving Bigfoot's existence some degree of likelihood.

It is, in fact, a harmless pursuit...and a very intriguing mystery.
Harmless?
In some cases, yes, in others, no.
There's a thread here, named "What's the harm?" or something like this. I suggest reading it. Here are a few aspects of bigfootery which are not harmless in my personal opinion (they are not in any particular order).

-Making money out of people selling false informations and hoaxes as if they were true is not harmless.
-Passing ahead biased, twisted and/or false informations and hoaxes as if they were true is not harmless.
-Doing bad science is not harmless.
-Using cryptozoology in attempts to support religious fundamentalism (creationism, for example) is not harmless.
-Twisting parts of someone else's cultural inheritage (myths, artwork, etc.) to shape them in to bigfoot "evidence".

Now, lets make a thought experiment. Lets suppose bigfeet are real and live in small numbers at some remote corner of the Pacific Northwest. Everytime a footer does any of the above acts, he/she contributes to discredit their existence. Their defenders are much more harmfull to them than those who think they are not real.

As a last note, the above-cited behavior can be found not only within bigfootery. It can also be found within UFOlogy, paranormal reasearch, astrology, "hidden archeology", etc. Its standard woo methodology.
 
I Am He:

"The only thing I remember asking you was that, why not other people would not have been involved IF it was a suit, besides Makeup People & Suit Makers. Would not they go hand and glove in any kind of production? "

Not necessarily.
 
As a last note, the above-cited behavior can be found not only within bigfootery. It can also be found within UFOlogy, paranormal reasearch, astrology, "hidden archeology", etc. Its standard woo methodology.
And just think of Sweaty's magical halycon world. Aren't you jealous? Bigfoot roams our dark and not always so wild places. UFO's are in the skies, in our atmosphere dodging our death beams. The ruins of mysterious alien civilizations and their artifacts lie about our planetary neighbour.

It's a Sweaty world.
 
Bill Munns, I was curious what you think of this assessment of the BGF by the BFRO:

Science, and the Costume


Hollywood costume makers cannot re-create the Patterson creature. Whenever they try it becomes apparent that the Patterson figure's skeletal and muscular anatomy is different from a human's skeletal and muscular anatomy.

Normally, the scientific method requires repeatability of an experiment to establish scientific proof. In this case the non-repeatability of the Patterson creature is evidence itself.

It should be a relatively simple matter to make a reasonably close match to the Patterson creature, if it were simply a human in a costume.

See the article about the BBC's all-out-effort to build a Patterson costume replica. Click here for that article.





Frame 72


Casts were made of the footprints left behind by the Patterson creature. The measurements of the footprint casts allow the height and mass of the figure to be calculated.

It was over seven (7) tall and weighed well over 800 pounds. It had proportionately longer arms and shorter legs than a human.

Close examination of the moving footage shows that it could not be a padded costume. Its super-sized muscles can be seen flexing as it moves.

Costume technology that can mimic flexing muscles was not invented until 20 years after the footage was obtained.

http://bfro.net/news/roundup/exped_whydo.asp

If you disagree or have issue with any part of that assessment, could you please detail the reasons why?

The piece then goes on to state:

There were many sensational false "confession" stories about the Patterson Footage over the past few decades. For more details about those, click here.

That link brings us here:

'Confessions' about the Patterson Footage:

http://bfro.net/NEWS/roundup/exped_whydo_pgf_confessions.asp

The Imposters Were All Debunked

None of the various men who claimed they were the "man in the costume" were able to build a vaguely similar costume to support their claim. Some of these men tried and failed to build an approximate replica, the rest never even tried.

Professional skeptical debunkers have tried and failed. The best funded and organized attempt (funded by the British Broadcasting Corporation) to make a replica of the Patterson costume unwittingly demonstrated some of the anatomical oddities involved.

Click here to see the best attempt at a matching costume.

The BBC's well-funded failure to make a reasonable approximation of this man-in-a-costume hoax, has become among the strongest scientific proof that it is not man in a costume.
BFRO, are you blatantly lying to me? Would you do such a thing to make bigfoot seem more legit? You tell me about imposters but I couldn't help but notice that you didn't mention a single specific one. Hey, you have expeditions can join, right?
 
Kitakaze:

I am not interested in assisting people in challenging the accuracy of third party postings and documents, especially on other sites or when presented in only partial quote form out of context. If you wish to pursue this, you should proceed without my assistance, and take your concerns directly to the forum where the original document or posting exists.

I would consider helping another researcher in an analysis of a matter, preferrably offline, as my time permits, and if I respected the integrity of that researcher.

Bill
 
It was presented in context, Mr. Munns. That's what the link is for, so you can see it in context. You don't quote the whole passage here. You grab what you consider the relevant bits, and post a link to the whole thing, so that if anyone has a concern, they have the whole item to look through.

I would consider helping another researcher in an analysis of a matter, preferrably offline, as my time permits, and if I respected the integrity of that researcher.

Well, that's a bit snooty-sounding innit?

Aren't we researchers, Mr. Munns?

I have certainly done a lot of research on Bigfoot in the last few years.

Oh, we don't have integrity! Well, that lets out a lot of people, Mr. Munns.

We can start with Roger Patterson's lack of it. :D
 
LTC:

I'll make it simpler for you.

"I am not interested in assisting people in challenging the accuracy of third party postings and documents,"
 
No need to make it simpler for little old me. You are already challenging the accuracy of several different parties' postings and documents. Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit and that Patty walks like a human being. So your statement rings quite hollow.

Basically, you don't want to discuss much at all here, imo.

You want to be able to make statements and not be challenged on them, imo.
You want to support the idea of bigfoot and claim that you aren't.

On to ignore you go.
 
Last edited:
LTC:

"You are already challenging the accuracy of several different parties' postings and documents."

As is everyone here, it seems to me.

If I do so, it is directly to the person, or in generalized ideas, not through a second person to criticize a third. Big difference.

"Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit and that Patty walks like a human being. So your statement rings quite hollow."

Did I ever say Patty doesn't walk like a human being? Where are you inventing these falicies?

"Basically, you don't want to discuss much at all here, imo."

Review my posts from page 306, and you'll see how much I have discussed.

"You want to be able to make statements and not be challenged on them, imo."

I'm challenged here on almost everything I say. And this started with you and me (on this page) because I said I preferred NOT to make statements, under some circumstances.

"You want to support the idea of bigfoot and claim that you aren't."

I want to support a reasoned analysis of what's on the PG Film, based on what can be extracted or deduced from it, as compared to the hypothesis of what it is.

"On to ignore you go. "

Clearly your perceptions and mine so far apart, we will never understand each other.

Bill
 
LTC:

"You are already challenging the accuracy of several different parties' postings and documents."

As is everyone here, it seems to me.

If I do so, it is directly to the person, or in generalized ideas, not through a second person to criticize a third. Big difference.

And why not ? If you have information and evidence leading to a critic of the third person's theory, you would not publish it and only report it directly to the 3rd person ? With that kind of reasonement, Einstein and other 19th century physicist would NEVER have been able to criticize Newton.

"Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit and that Patty walks like a human being. So your statement rings quite hollow."

Did I ever say Patty doesn't walk like a human being? Where are you inventing these falicies?

Your forgot the part on Expert have given the opinion.... Patty is a suit, to conveniently focus on the second part of the sentence as if it was the essence of the statement. Isn't this the salami fallacy ?


"You want to support the idea of bigfoot and claim that you aren't."

I want to support a reasoned analysis of what's on the PG Film, based on what can be extracted or deduced from it, as compared to the hypothesis of what it is.

IMHO I did not see any evidence based analysis up to now in this thread leading to the idea that patty might be anything but a suit. And I assign reasoned analysis quite a low value, as this is not philosophy 101, you need evidence to prove something. As you from the starts are trying to reason to conclude on a negative, I wish you good luck, but you won't bring anything to the debat, anything but mis-perception and misconception with usage of your "reasonement" by bigfoot enthusiast.

Perception from my corner of the world, is that you are a bigfoot supporter which do not want to admit it. I grant you 100% that perception can be and often are wrong. But then you will have to admit to yourself that sometimes perception can be right, and you not conscientiously might color your reasonment.

"On to ignore you go. "

Clearly your perceptions and mine so far apart, we will never understand each other.

Bill

I don't think it is "perception" which make him put you on ignore.
 
Kitakaze:

I am not interested in assisting people in challenging the accuracy of third party postings and documents, especially on other sites or when presented in only partial quote form out of context.

What an odd thing to say. I mean really bizarre. I'm going to chalk that up to your lack of experience with this form of communication and medium for presenting information and exchanging ideas. I'm asking you if you have any thoughts on the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization's official assessment of the PGF. Talking about me presenting only partial quotes out of context just makes no sense at all.

Think about that comment carefully, Munns. What would make it in context? And should I copy/paste the entire BFRO page entitled 'Bigfoot research in a nutshell'? I'm asking your opinion on that group's assessment, giving you the relevant information, and providing a link for you to check the source. Do you understand?

If you wish to pursue this, you should proceed without my assistance, and take your concerns directly to the forum where the original document or posting exists.

I would consider helping another researcher in an analysis of a matter, preferrably offline, as my time permits, and if I respected the integrity of that researcher.

Bill
You know, it almost rings rather arrogant, you presuming I'm asking you for assistance to what? Challenge the accuracy of third party postings and documents? Huh?? We're talking about the official statements of the BFRO, the group that presents themselves as the foremost authorities on all things bigfoot. Here's a hint - I put no stock in the accuracy of their broad and definitive statements regarding the PGF. You know, ones like these:

Hollywood costume makers cannot re-create the Patterson creature.

It should be a relatively simple matter to make a reasonably close match to the Patterson creature, if it were simply a human in a costume.

It was over seven (7) tall and weighed well over 800 pounds. It had proportionately longer arms and shorter legs than a human.

Costume technology that can mimic flexing muscles was not invented until 20 years after the footage was obtained.

See, Munns, you're presenting yourself as an expert. I've seen enough information regarding the PGF over the years and commentary by various manner of experts to have formed the opinion that the above quoted statements by the BFRO are wrong. In all the countless words you've written on the PGF for your fans at the BFF I don't recall any results from your musings that support those above statements. I'm asking you directly your opinion on them. Simple. Do you understand? Don't flatter yourself presuming I'm looking for your help to stick it to the BFRO.

BTW, your thinly veiled comments regarding giving that help you think you're being asked for being conditional to your respect of the integrity of the researcher was pretty crass. If you have something to say to me, spare the attempts at subtlety.
 
Thank you Aepervius.

I saw nothing in your message worthy of a response.



Kitakaze:


"BTW, your thinly veiled comments regarding giving that help you think you're being asked for being conditional to your respect of the integrity of the researcher was pretty crass. If you have something to say to me, spare the attempts at subtlety."

I don't find anything you say or do worthy of respect.
 
I don't find anything you say or do worthy of respect.
Fair enough. It isn't facetious when I say you should understand that your respect means nothing to me and seeking it is and should be irrelevant to the discussion at hand. My only thoughts for respect when I interact with you is to maintain the same civility and respect that is to be accorded to all members. To be sure, you have all the respect you can handle at the bigfoot enthusiast forum. Here we discuss the facts and if it is respect you look for than you'll find us wanting. Indeed, I find your avoidance of the very simple issues I raised regarding the BFRO's assessment of the PGF to be far more telling.
 
LTC - "Experts have given the opinion that Patty is a suit and that Patty walks like a human being. So your statement rings quite hollow."

Munns - Did I ever say Patty doesn't walk like a human being? Where are you inventing these falicies?
Your forgot the part on Expert have given the opinion.... Patty is a suit, to conveniently focus on the second part of the sentence as if it was the essence of the statement. Isn't this the salami fallacy ?
Noted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom