Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bill Munns, can I ask you something please? Does that PGF look to you like a Grade A Film?? Thank you.



I Am He
 
Bigfoot is a dream, fantasy, and hobby. Bigfootery is a social pursuit that does not require an actual biological creature to support it. All that is necessary is an ideation and desire to participate in drama. The Bigfooter understands the situation and chooses to take the role. One does not have to truly believe in order to pretend to believe. This is human nature and we do it all the time for things other than Bigfoot.

Reading and enjoying a good novel usually requires some suspension of critical thinking and skepticism. Otherwise, one cannot get past the fact that the characters are fictitious, the events did not actually occur, and in a specific context... the author is a liar. Why read something that you know damn well isn't true? Well, because it brings a kind of pleasure.

Bigfoot skepticism and voyeurism of the argument (300,000+ views worth) is pretty much as ridiculous as the initial proposed premise (Bigfoot exists). This is something like skepticism that Harry Potter or the Easter Bunny exists. You mean somebody actually talks about believing in these? No, but they are doing it with Bigfoot. Wow, I'll get some popcorn and watch the debate. This should be an interesting way to relieve the boredom of life. We are born with brains/minds that seem overkill (over capacity) for the requirements of living a life. Food, water and relative security should be enough. Bacteria accomplish this without even having a brain. But we seem so different and the Bigfooter is only using the brain that they were born with. Skeptics do the same, and unless both of them open their mouths to speak... there is no fundamental difference between the two.

Prior to 1958, there were no photos, films or plaster track casts representing Bigfoot. Cameras, plaster and guns (get a specimen) existed for a long time prior to this. Yet, there were devoted believers who had nothing more than stories presented by other people. It was a belief based upon believing the stories of others. Anecdote was all the world had to offer an early Bigfooter.

The PGF of 1967 represents the very first film footage of a Bigfoot. Interestingly, it remains the most referenced and supported evidence for the creature. If Patterson had lived to confess (voluntarily or otherwise) or if it were proven to be fake (against his contrary claim), that title might have been forced to switch to the Freeman video or some other recorded footage. Maybe modern Bigfootery could still exist without any footage, just like it did prior to 1967. The most common position for a Bigfooter is to proclaim the PGF subject as authentic and all others since then to be hoaxes or too poor to make any determination.

Bigfootery and this huge thread only exist because some people find it interesting to believe in Bigfoot. We don't have this sort of thing for the Easter Bunny because people haven't taken up the social hobby of claiming that (unconfirmed) rabbits are truly laying colored eggs.
 
"Bill Munns, can I ask you something please? Does that PGF look to you like a Grade A Film?? Thank you.

I Am He"


No.
 
I Am He:

I realized my previous answer might not have been real clear as to which of your questions I was answering, so to clarify,

No, I do not think the PG film looks like a grade A film.

Bill
 
I Am He:

I realized my previous answer might not have been real clear as to which of your questions I was answering, so to clarify,

No, I do not think the PG film looks like a grade A film.

Bill
Then could please tell me why you think that
the people involved with costume makeup would be involved, and not say cameramen and soundmen also? Thank you.



I Am He
 
Then could please tell me why you think that
the people involved with costume makeup would be involved, and not say cameramen and soundmen also? Thank you.



I Am He

I Am He, I suppose now the question is whether or not you think the PGF is a grade A film. If you're unsure of what a grade A film looks like view a copy of let's say Gone With The Wind and compare the PGF with the image quality of it. If Gone With The Wind is grade A then the PGF is somewhere around grade G. Or to put it another way the PGF is around the same quality as the WWII newsreel footage we've been watching for the pas 60 years. Actually much of the WWII newsreel footage is of better quality than the PGF. Its also a little known fact that all US WWII film footage was shot in color. However most of it was released in B&W because of the governments concern at the time that color war footage would be too graphic for the public consumption.
 
I am He:

"Then could please tell me why you think that
the people involved with costume makeup would be involved, and not say cameramen and soundmen also? Thank you."


I'm not making any judgment on whether other people on a crew were or were not involved, if it was a hoax. I'm simply expressing the opinion that, based on what I see in the film, and what i know about costume suits, if the figure in the film is indeed a fur suit, it appears to be a professional quality job, which would have required the skill and efforts of a professional makeup artist /suit builder.

You can imagine other crew people if you like. I choose not to speculate about that.


Bill
 
Bigfoot is a dream, fantasy, and hobby. Bigfootery is a social pursuit that does not require an actual biological creature to support it. All that is necessary is an ideation and desire to participate in drama. The Bigfooter understands the situation and chooses to take the role. One does not have to truly believe in order to pretend to believe. This is human nature and we do it all the time for things other than Bigfoot.

Reading and enjoying a good novel usually requires some suspension of critical thinking and skepticism. Otherwise, one cannot get past the fact that the characters are fictitious, the events did not actually occur, and in a specific context... the author is a liar. Why read something that you know damn well isn't true? Well, because it brings a kind of pleasure.

Bigfoot skepticism and voyeurism of the argument (300,000+ views worth) is pretty much as ridiculous as the initial proposed premise (Bigfoot exists). This is something like skepticism that Harry Potter or the Easter Bunny exists. You mean somebody actually talks about believing in these? No, but they are doing it with Bigfoot. Wow, I'll get some popcorn and watch the debate. This should be an interesting way to relieve the boredom of life. We are born with brains/minds that seem overkill (over capacity) for the requirements of living a life. Food, water and relative security should be enough. Bacteria accomplish this without even having a brain. But we seem so different and the Bigfooter is only using the brain that they were born with. Skeptics do the same, and unless both of them open their mouths to speak... there is no fundamental difference between the two.

Prior to 1958, there were no photos, films or plaster track casts representing Bigfoot. Cameras, plaster and guns (get a specimen) existed for a long time prior to this. Yet, there were devoted believers who had nothing more than stories presented by other people. It was a belief based upon believing the stories of others. Anecdote was all the world had to offer an early Bigfooter.

The PGF of 1967 represents the very first film footage of a Bigfoot. Interestingly, it remains the most referenced and supported evidence for the creature. If Patterson had lived to confess (voluntarily or otherwise) or if it were proven to be fake (against his contrary claim), that title might have been forced to switch to the Freeman video or some other recorded footage. Maybe modern Bigfootery could still exist without any footage, just like it did prior to 1967. The most common position for a Bigfooter is to proclaim the PGF subject as authentic and all others since then to be hoaxes or too poor to make any determination.

Bigfootery and this huge thread only exist because some people find it interesting to believe in Bigfoot. We don't have this sort of thing for the Easter Bunny because people haven't taken up the social hobby of claiming that (unconfirmed) rabbits are truly laying colored eggs.


The Earth is immensely bigger than your mind, William. :)

Accordingly, there will continue to be many rational, intelligent, and open-minded people having no problem at all giving Bigfoot's existence some degree of likelihood.

It is, in fact, a harmless pursuit...and a very intriguing mystery.
 
Last edited:
The Earth is immensely bigger than your mind, William. :)

Accordingly, there will continue to be many rational, intelligent, and open-minded people having no problem at all giving Bigfoot's existence some degree of likelihood.

Those same people will have no problem assigning "some degree of likelihood" to a rabbit laying colored eggs. The world is too big for that number to be zero, especially since we already have platypuses waddling around.

It is, in fact, a harmless pursuit...and a very intriguing mystery.

It's hard to disagree that Bigfootery is harmless. Bigfoot skepticism is also harmless. But the no-harm factor can get stretched when Bigfooters often refer to science and government as being short-sighted or unwilling to look closely at what is right in front of their eyes. You hear this a lot. It gets mixed in with another fairly common claim of conspiracies to conceal the existence of Bigfoot. For that one the theme is that GOV already knows about Bigfoot but doesn't want THE PEOPLE to know. The potential harm lies in enforcing or reinforcing a belief that the GOV is an enemy of the curious naturalist. It sure would be nice to know that we have a bipedal ape running around in North America. The GOV is hiding things and does not want the populace to know it really does exist. Or the forestry industry is involved in a cover-up. Sweaty, you've heard this stuff before.

Another possible harm is when Bigfoot is presented to children. Teachers and role models can have a profound effect on how young minds evaluate their environment and choose to act. Coleman and others have brought Bigfoot into classrooms. Then there was the lady philosopher and others who have misquoted Jane Goodall and propped her up for their own agenda. Harmful? Who knows, but Goodall made a move to delete a reference to Bigfoot in her Wikipedia biography. You heard that too.
 
Bill Munns, your name is popping up in Bigfooter forums outside of the BFF. It's exactly as was predicted by JREF Bigfoot skeptics. Your disclaimer (fine print) is not working to prevent them from directly associating you and your ongoing pursuit with showing that Patty is not a guy in a suit. Hot damn. A Hollywood costume pro is taking our side.

Saying that you are not taking any side does not help. They are counting you among the Bigfooter ranks.
 
PS: If you enter your name in a Google search a whole lotta BIGFOOT stuff shows up.

Then there is this unfortunate rant...

How many extras played zombies in ROTLD - do you recall?

No idea. Probably 25 extras were out there during the 1st few weeks of shooting. We did all the location stuff first. And everyone either had mud on their face or had those crappy Bill Munns masks. It’s a shame that Kenny Myers wasn’t hired before him, since Bill Stout had such wonderful designs for different zombies.

Was the makeup by Bill Munns as bad as Dan says they were?

No - it was worse. No one liked the makeup he did. It wasn’t even like…real makeup. The masks he made were unfilmable. Put it this way: your average junior high reader of Fangoria can do better - 1000 times better. You know what they were like? They were as thin as rubber gloves, painted brown, with eyeholes cut out. Munns wanted to put a bald cap and attach hair to it to make a mohawk. I was like, no shave my head and give me a real mohawk!
 
WP:

If other people want to talk about my notes or efforts, there's not much I can do to stop them. Just as I can't stop you from dragging up that silly rant by a nobody who likes to discredit my work on one old film 24 years ago.

My career, like my notes, are in the public forum of discussion, and I've learned to live with it.

You may as well learn to live with it too. The notes exist. and likely will never be erased, given the intrigue of the internet.

As for the film, ROLD represents about 1% of my total career thus far, so even if you choose to believe that petty rant, and deem my work on that film a total failure, that means I was successful only 99% of my career. I can live with that.

And you, being the steely eyed skeptic that you are, might consider that the writer of that criticism may have had an ulterior motive to discredit me. Or do you believe him to be the paragon of truth and rational description, simply because he is criticizing me?

Given you posted a picture of my Gigantopithecus model in the forum, you are obviously aware of my actual work. Does the quoted description of my work in that film seem to be the same quality of work you see in the Gignatopithicus model? Or do you only see what satisfies your agenda?

A true skeptic would say maybe he is the one who is wrong, or has a motive to distort the facts in a negative and biased way. And if you were a responsible skeptic, you would investigate the issue further before simply quoting him as if he were proven right.

Bill
 
If other people want to talk about my notes or efforts, there's not much I can do to stop them.

Your notes are interesting regardless of what "side" the reader is on. My point was that they are being taken as evidence that Patty is a real Bigfoot. This is not simply a discussion of your notes. It is an assumption of your conclusion. The Bigfooters assume that you are taking a slow ride towards authenticity. He sticks a disclaimer in there, but they "know" why you are doing it. They can smell Bigfooter on your breath.

Just as I can't stop you from dragging up that silly rant by a nobody who likes to discredit my work on one old film 24 years ago.

Bill, it's Google that drags it up, not me. Any Bill Munns fan that enters your name in a search will find (drag up) the same thing.

My career, like my notes, are in the public forum of discussion, and I've learned to live with it.

Good. Google has made Bigfoot your Siamese twin.

You may as well learn to live with it too. The notes exist. and likely will never be erased, given the intrigue of the internet.

Whether you like it or not, your notes have caused Bigfooters to count you as one of them.

As for the film, ROLD represents about 1% of my total career thus far, so even if you choose to believe that petty rant, and deem my work on that film a total failure, that means I was successful only 99% of my career. I can live with that.

I have no opinions on that rant, and don't really even care. It's there in a Google search and that is fact, not opinion.

And you, being the steely eyed skeptic that you are, might consider that the writer of that criticism may have had an ulterior motive to discredit me. Or do you believe him to be the paragon of truth and rational description, simply because he is criticizing me?

Damn, you really want to lay beliefs on me. When you entered this forum you said that I was making assumptions about you. Now you are doing this for me. I would not credit the Munns rant guy as a "paragon of truth" any more than I would do the same for Internet critics of Dfoot.

Given you posted a picture of my Gigantopithecus model in the forum, you are obviously aware of my actual work. Does the quoted description of my work in that film seem to be the same quality of work you see in the Gignatopithicus model? Or do you only see what satisfies your agenda?

Bill, the Giganto model is awesome. I love it. It is almost inconsequential to mention that we both know it might not look like the actual extinct creature. Does it matter in a bigger context? You are in the business of bringing fantasy to the big screen. People eat that stuff up and Hollywood creates the candy that everyone loves. Right now you are sorta working on Bigfoot, or more specifically Patty. You are making candy for the Bigfoot believers.

My agenda? I wear it on my sleeve. I'm here to make fun of Bigfoot believers and to try to make it entertaining and informative. I'm not alone here.
Edited by chillzero: 
Editing out start of derail. This is not Thunderdome, and there are some rules.

A true skeptic would say maybe he is the one who is wrong, or has a motive to distort the facts in a negative and biased way. And if you were a responsible skeptic, you would investigate the issue further before simply quoting him as if he were proven right.

Ah, the hypothetical "true skeptic" definition. I see Bigfooters bring that up with regularity. Usually they have somebody in mind that is skeptical and also gives great latitude for fantasy. Responsible skeptics aren't like me.

Edited by chillzero: 
Snip
I'm only saying that Bigfoot doesn't exist. You have a problem with that? Is the PGF causing you to lose sleep? Are you expecting or hoping that I will agree that Patty is a mystery? Homey don't play that.
Edited by chillzero: 
Snip
I'm Patty is not a suit, right? Parcher is toast.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another funky BFF thread about the PGF.

Remember November said:
Fact: neither Patterson nor Gimlin have confessed to hoaxing the film.

Oh? Howard Heironimus (Bob's brother) says that Roger Patterson told him that he made the Patty suit from "red horsehide". Is that a confession? Well... is it?

Maybe the next "fact" to be posted in that thread will state that the Heironimus brothers are liars. Fact seekers need to decide who is a liar and who is not, right? LOL.
 
Bill Munns said:
As for the film, ROLD represents about 1% of my total career thus far, so even if you choose to believe that petty rant, and deem my work on that film a total failure

That may be so, but it's an extremely popular movie and as a result, many people watch and comment about it. I don't know if you've seen/listened to some of the special features (some of which are carry-overs from the first DVD version of ROTLD) on the special edition DVD of "Return of the Living Dead," but your work takes a beating in one of the featurettes and both of the commentaries from various members of the cast and crew. As a result, that rant isn't going to be the only time your work on the film will be looked upon in a negative light online (as William Parcher was trying to point out).

Personally, I don't know how much of the complaints with your work are due to miscommunication issues, so I've avoided directly discussing the issue here until now(well, that, and it could distract people from discussing the PGF). I should note that I can't recall any complaints about the quality of the Tarman costume, so it's not like every single aspect of your work on the film was criticized.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom