I would welcome a list of any specific issues or details you feel I have missed, which may be relevent to or should factor into my own studies and notes.
Well, the stuff surrounding the filming that we'll be discussing later is probably the most important part. Looking into Patterson's connections to the entertainment industry and sleazy nature couldn't hurt, though. Hopefully the others can provide suggestions for you.
I also feel that it'd be wise to analyze the short-furred costumes used in The Lost World (the silent movie), King Kong Vs. Godzilla, The Bossburg "Cripplefoot" film, and the Harley Hoffman Bigfoot film. After all, it's possible that these known costumes have some of the same features that mystify you about Patty, which would definitely help your research. Like, say, if one of them shows signs of features that you had interpeted as requiring stretch furcloth (only the Hoffman figure might use that since it's modern) could tell you that something else is involved. Then again, maybe it's just a side effect of what William Parcher refers to as "peyote vision." I hope he reposts those stills he has that show the blinking eyes that Owen Caddy and Dr. Swindler claimed to see on the PGF are more likely to be a type of film artifact.
On Patterson's artistic abilities:
From my experience (and viewpoint), those arguments are worded that way as a response to those who try to paint Patterson as a talentless know-nothing. Both are extreme, but I side with the "Patterson could" possibility since I know that one should never, ever underestimate a potential hoaxer.
As for Patterson:
He could sculpt - Combined with casting knowledge, theoretically give him the ability to make masks.
He had the necessary skills to mold/sew saddles - Aspects of this could be applied to costume-making.
He could copy the artwork of others
I understand that he built special wagons without using blueprints - Just general "don't underestimate the guy" type stuff.
In short, it's better to say that we can't know for sure if he could've built a costume, but that it's not as unlikely as some would claim.
From my observations of people here, they don't seem to be able to resolve much of anything, and more effort is directed at simply trying to put others down.
Oh, they can. I've seen them do it plenty of times in the past. Hopefully now that you've shown to be more open to researching other aspects of the PGF besides the onscreen images, things'll calm down.
So What I propose to you is that you and I take this one issue you have mentioned (the footprints and the site) and we, together, see if we can discuss this one focused issue and arrive at a conclusion we both would confidently sign off on. And I will post that conclusion over in the thread with my notes that brought up the footprints on site issue, so the cleared up statement is there as well.
Sadly, I've got a lot on my plate right now, so I can't give this as much attention as I would like to. I can't give all the sources, but I'll plug in a few ones that I was able to find quickly. I sincerely hope that other posters chime in with sources, clarifications, and corrections to any possible errors on my part. I'll do my best to fill in more sources when I get the time:
Here's the basic, "rough draft" version of what I know about the filming of the PGF:
Patterson and Gimlin go to Bluff Creek to look at some tracks discovered there (supposedly depicting three different individuals) for Patterson's Bigfoot documentary. They get there, but the tracks have been reduced to muddy globs that can't be cast due to rain and exposure to the elements over a period of time. If I remember correctly, those tracks (some of which had been cast by others before Patterson and Gimlin showed up) seem to be ones of extremely questionable authenticity, as you can see in this lengthy and extremely informative look at the matter
here (
this section notes their history).
On October 20, 1967 at 1:00 or 3:00pm (I'm not sure of the exact time since it varies depending on the account; Judging from the film, it was sunny that day.), the "Patty filming incident" supposedly happens. There are some contradictions about some details of this in the various interviews, the most important one in the case of ground details is the one about the horses. Depending on the interview, here's what is claimed:
Patterson falls off his horse - Claimed by Roger Patterson
Patterson jumps off his horse - Claimed by Bob Gimlin
The horse falls on Patterson, hurting his foot and bending a stirrup - Roger Patterson (he apparently started showing a bent stirrup at events Gimlin and he spoke at since he got sick of Gimlin saying the horse didn't fall on him)
Both Patterson's and Gimlin's horses fall over
Afterwards, they claim to track Patty for 3 point something miles up a mountain. Then they return to the film site and cast what they felt were the two best tracks. The tracks were a few inches deep into the ground, with some apparently getting up to three and a half inches deep in softer soil. The tracks were apparently 14 or 14.5 inches, although I've found
a reference to a 16 inch track. Later accounts have Bob Gimlin jumping off a stump in an attempt to make tracks as deep as Patty's They might've had to go back to their truck (the filming site is near a road) to get the casting materials first, though. Then they go to call some people (including a Canadian museum in an attempt to get tracking dogs) and to send out the film.
Dfoot once made this interesting note, which he will hopefully provide more information about:
DFoot said:
1) Gimlin said that AFTER he and Roger spent time with Hodgson they drove to the EUREKA POST OFFICE and air-mailed the film to DeAtley at 9 pm. PROBLEM? The post office was already closed.
2) Hodgson said that Roger told him they'd JUST GOTTEN BACK from the EUREKA POST OFFICE when he met them at 6:30 pm. They stayed there until they returned to their camp later that night. PROBLEM? That too doesn't fit with the things Patterson and Gimlin claimed went on prior to getting to the store. There simply wasn't enough time.
3) DeAtley always said he couldn't recall anything about the film, but one day he did give an explanation when told that the Post Office in Eureka would have been closed and neither Patterson's nor Gimlin's story matched reality. DeAtley then claimed his pilot had brought the film to him in his plane as he often ran such errands. PROBLEM? The pilot DeAtley used wasn't even in the USA all that year.
4) And finally, Bigfooters decided that the only thing to do is to claim that Gimlin couldn't tell the difference between the downtown Eureka Post Office and a local airport and so they must have had it specially flown from there. PROBLEM? Records show that NO PLANE flew anything to Washington at all that entire weekend.
Late at night/early next morning, it starts to rain heavily. Bob Gimlin tries to save some by covering them with cardboard. Seeing how soggy the cardboard gets, he opts to use tree bark.
The rain and flooding eventually gets so bad that they leave in fear that the road will be blocked and strand them there.
The next day, forest worker Lyle Laverty and his crew check out the site and takes some pictures of the tracks (both the covered and uncovered tracks).
Nine days later, Bob Titmus and his brother-in-law go to the site. He misses the tracks at first and then procedes to cast ten tracks. He claims that 10 tracks there showed signs of having been cast. This is odd, since Patterson claimed to have only done two. According to his map of the area, Patty looped around, went up a hill, and sat on a log to watch Patterson and Gimlin from above/behind. This contradicts Patterson and Gimlin's account of tracking Patty for several miles. He also noted that Patty's footprints seemed to start out of nowhere (There were no tracks that showed her entering the film site) and eventually vanished into pine needles. Titmus also claimed he could see Roger's prints from when he was filiming. To my knowledge, he didn't seem to make any reference to any impact of a fallen horse.
The thing is, Patterson and Gimlin had talked about how they barely made a dent in the soil while walking. How could such prints (especially unprotected ones) survive heavy rain? Furthermore, how could the unprotected Patty prints survive? Why weren't they reduced to "globs of mud" like the prints that brought Patterson and Gimlin there in the first place? How could that be when thet were at the mercy of rain heavy enough to threaten obstructing a road? To me, this makes it very likely that the originals were destroyed and that Patterson and Gimlin had to refake the tracks before leaving.
Roger Knights once came up with what he thought was an innocent explanation for the fact that the timeline for the October 20th filming didn't work and that the film was most likely filmed before when Patterson and Gimlin claimed it was. The problem with that explanation (as noted by William Parcher) is that Roger Patterson called for tracking dogs on the 20th (along with calls to toehrs saying he filmed Bigfoot that day). If the film is of a real creature and he filmed it before the 20th, we should expect him to ahve done that earlier. Furthermore, this would mean that Roger Patterson lied to countless people about what he was doing that day, which is extremely suspicious.
I should also note that Patty's tracks were never seen in the Bluff Creek area again after Patterson left.
I should also note that there are
some issues with the "cast display footage." I find the possibility that the footage might be recycled from when Patterson dug some tracks into the ground in order to get footage of him casting tracks to be extremely compelling? Why? Because if that is the case, then it means the tracks he made before filming Patty match up exactly with Patty's feet. And if no instances of Patty's tracks can be found prior to the filming, I dare say that'd be smoking gun evidence that Patterson hoaxed it. The odds of him creating a footprint that matches up exactly to a real creature he'd film days later are very low.