Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Drew:

I really am going to try and reach an understanding with you, one last shot.
I do not accept "Bigfooter arguments" on face value, any more than I accept skeptic arguments on face value.

"Evidence" is something that may support a conclusion. If there are two basic options to explain something, and the evidence is weak or lacking to support one conclusion, that does not mean the other conclusion is automatically supported. It means "inconclusive", as in "not yet explained".

Your "counter-logic" seems to think there is only a cryptid/non-cryptid position, and you fail to acknowledge "inconclusive" or "undecided" as a middleground that favors neither side.

On the cryptid issue overall, I think there's reason to continue investigating the issue. I do not consider it "settled" either way. On the PG Film issue, I say again and again, I am mystified. That means "undecided" or "inconclusive".

You seem to think because I am not buying the evidence you choose to believe, I must be accepting the evidence of those on the other side. If so, you are wrong and are misunderstanding me.

Bill
 
If you are rejecting evidence of a hoax, then you are accepting evidence that the subject of the PGF is a non-human North American primate ...

There is much evidence that it is a hoax, the costume aside ..

If the subject is not a non-human North American primate, it is a man in a suit, whether you can figure out how it was done or not..
 
Diogenes:

"If you are rejecting evidence of a hoax, then you are accepting evidence that the subject of the PGF is a non-human North American primate ..."

Wrong. Undecided is an option. You may reject evidence as "inconclusive".

"There is much evidence that it is a hoax, the costume aside .. "

But no proven conclusion.

If the subject is not a non-human North American primate, it is a man in a suit, whether you can figure out how it was done or not.."

"IF"

well said.

Bill
 
I would welcome a list of any specific issues or details you feel I have missed, which may be relevent to or should factor into my own studies and notes.

Well, the stuff surrounding the filming that we'll be discussing later is probably the most important part. Looking into Patterson's connections to the entertainment industry and sleazy nature couldn't hurt, though. Hopefully the others can provide suggestions for you.

I also feel that it'd be wise to analyze the short-furred costumes used in The Lost World (the silent movie), King Kong Vs. Godzilla, The Bossburg "Cripplefoot" film, and the Harley Hoffman Bigfoot film. After all, it's possible that these known costumes have some of the same features that mystify you about Patty, which would definitely help your research. Like, say, if one of them shows signs of features that you had interpeted as requiring stretch furcloth (only the Hoffman figure might use that since it's modern) could tell you that something else is involved. Then again, maybe it's just a side effect of what William Parcher refers to as "peyote vision." I hope he reposts those stills he has that show the blinking eyes that Owen Caddy and Dr. Swindler claimed to see on the PGF are more likely to be a type of film artifact.

On Patterson's artistic abilities:

From my experience (and viewpoint), those arguments are worded that way as a response to those who try to paint Patterson as a talentless know-nothing. Both are extreme, but I side with the "Patterson could" possibility since I know that one should never, ever underestimate a potential hoaxer.

As for Patterson:

He could sculpt - Combined with casting knowledge, theoretically give him the ability to make masks.

He had the necessary skills to mold/sew saddles - Aspects of this could be applied to costume-making.

He could copy the artwork of others
I understand that he built special wagons without using blueprints - Just general "don't underestimate the guy" type stuff.

In short, it's better to say that we can't know for sure if he could've built a costume, but that it's not as unlikely as some would claim.

From my observations of people here, they don't seem to be able to resolve much of anything, and more effort is directed at simply trying to put others down.

Oh, they can. I've seen them do it plenty of times in the past. Hopefully now that you've shown to be more open to researching other aspects of the PGF besides the onscreen images, things'll calm down.

So What I propose to you is that you and I take this one issue you have mentioned (the footprints and the site) and we, together, see if we can discuss this one focused issue and arrive at a conclusion we both would confidently sign off on. And I will post that conclusion over in the thread with my notes that brought up the footprints on site issue, so the cleared up statement is there as well.

Sadly, I've got a lot on my plate right now, so I can't give this as much attention as I would like to. I can't give all the sources, but I'll plug in a few ones that I was able to find quickly. I sincerely hope that other posters chime in with sources, clarifications, and corrections to any possible errors on my part. I'll do my best to fill in more sources when I get the time:

Here's the basic, "rough draft" version of what I know about the filming of the PGF:

Patterson and Gimlin go to Bluff Creek to look at some tracks discovered there (supposedly depicting three different individuals) for Patterson's Bigfoot documentary. They get there, but the tracks have been reduced to muddy globs that can't be cast due to rain and exposure to the elements over a period of time. If I remember correctly, those tracks (some of which had been cast by others before Patterson and Gimlin showed up) seem to be ones of extremely questionable authenticity, as you can see in this lengthy and extremely informative look at the matter here (this section notes their history).

On October 20, 1967 at 1:00 or 3:00pm (I'm not sure of the exact time since it varies depending on the account; Judging from the film, it was sunny that day.), the "Patty filming incident" supposedly happens. There are some contradictions about some details of this in the various interviews, the most important one in the case of ground details is the one about the horses. Depending on the interview, here's what is claimed:

Patterson falls off his horse - Claimed by Roger Patterson

Patterson jumps off his horse - Claimed by Bob Gimlin

The horse falls on Patterson, hurting his foot and bending a stirrup - Roger Patterson (he apparently started showing a bent stirrup at events Gimlin and he spoke at since he got sick of Gimlin saying the horse didn't fall on him)

Both Patterson's and Gimlin's horses fall over

Afterwards, they claim to track Patty for 3 point something miles up a mountain. Then they return to the film site and cast what they felt were the two best tracks. The tracks were a few inches deep into the ground, with some apparently getting up to three and a half inches deep in softer soil. The tracks were apparently 14 or 14.5 inches, although I've found a reference to a 16 inch track. Later accounts have Bob Gimlin jumping off a stump in an attempt to make tracks as deep as Patty's They might've had to go back to their truck (the filming site is near a road) to get the casting materials first, though. Then they go to call some people (including a Canadian museum in an attempt to get tracking dogs) and to send out the film.

Dfoot once made this interesting note, which he will hopefully provide more information about:

DFoot said:
1) Gimlin said that AFTER he and Roger spent time with Hodgson they drove to the EUREKA POST OFFICE and air-mailed the film to DeAtley at 9 pm. PROBLEM? The post office was already closed.

2) Hodgson said that Roger told him they'd JUST GOTTEN BACK from the EUREKA POST OFFICE when he met them at 6:30 pm. They stayed there until they returned to their camp later that night. PROBLEM? That too doesn't fit with the things Patterson and Gimlin claimed went on prior to getting to the store. There simply wasn't enough time.

3) DeAtley always said he couldn't recall anything about the film, but one day he did give an explanation when told that the Post Office in Eureka would have been closed and neither Patterson's nor Gimlin's story matched reality. DeAtley then claimed his pilot had brought the film to him in his plane as he often ran such errands. PROBLEM? The pilot DeAtley used wasn't even in the USA all that year.

4) And finally, Bigfooters decided that the only thing to do is to claim that Gimlin couldn't tell the difference between the downtown Eureka Post Office and a local airport and so they must have had it specially flown from there. PROBLEM? Records show that NO PLANE flew anything to Washington at all that entire weekend.

Late at night/early next morning, it starts to rain heavily. Bob Gimlin tries to save some by covering them with cardboard. Seeing how soggy the cardboard gets, he opts to use tree bark.

The rain and flooding eventually gets so bad that they leave in fear that the road will be blocked and strand them there.

The next day, forest worker Lyle Laverty and his crew check out the site and takes some pictures of the tracks (both the covered and uncovered tracks).

Nine days later, Bob Titmus and his brother-in-law go to the site. He misses the tracks at first and then procedes to cast ten tracks. He claims that 10 tracks there showed signs of having been cast. This is odd, since Patterson claimed to have only done two. According to his map of the area, Patty looped around, went up a hill, and sat on a log to watch Patterson and Gimlin from above/behind. This contradicts Patterson and Gimlin's account of tracking Patty for several miles. He also noted that Patty's footprints seemed to start out of nowhere (There were no tracks that showed her entering the film site) and eventually vanished into pine needles. Titmus also claimed he could see Roger's prints from when he was filiming. To my knowledge, he didn't seem to make any reference to any impact of a fallen horse.

The thing is, Patterson and Gimlin had talked about how they barely made a dent in the soil while walking. How could such prints (especially unprotected ones) survive heavy rain? Furthermore, how could the unprotected Patty prints survive? Why weren't they reduced to "globs of mud" like the prints that brought Patterson and Gimlin there in the first place? How could that be when thet were at the mercy of rain heavy enough to threaten obstructing a road? To me, this makes it very likely that the originals were destroyed and that Patterson and Gimlin had to refake the tracks before leaving.

Roger Knights once came up with what he thought was an innocent explanation for the fact that the timeline for the October 20th filming didn't work and that the film was most likely filmed before when Patterson and Gimlin claimed it was. The problem with that explanation (as noted by William Parcher) is that Roger Patterson called for tracking dogs on the 20th (along with calls to toehrs saying he filmed Bigfoot that day). If the film is of a real creature and he filmed it before the 20th, we should expect him to ahve done that earlier. Furthermore, this would mean that Roger Patterson lied to countless people about what he was doing that day, which is extremely suspicious.

I should also note that Patty's tracks were never seen in the Bluff Creek area again after Patterson left.

I should also note that there are some issues with the "cast display footage." I find the possibility that the footage might be recycled from when Patterson dug some tracks into the ground in order to get footage of him casting tracks to be extremely compelling? Why? Because if that is the case, then it means the tracks he made before filming Patty match up exactly with Patty's feet. And if no instances of Patty's tracks can be found prior to the filming, I dare say that'd be smoking gun evidence that Patterson hoaxed it. The odds of him creating a footprint that matches up exactly to a real creature he'd film days later are very low.
 
....here is an out-take you arm-chair critics can toss in the soup & stir it with a stick...... sheriff Edson unwittingly ruled out a third person with Patterson & Gimlin. Did Greg Long interview Edson, nope!

-----------------------------------------

Page 72 – 4th paragraph:

When I got home that night I remembered to enter even this minor incident into my diary, though from long experience, I knew better than to volunteer any of this information to my men when they questioned me about my findings. I didn’t want to pique their curiosity so they’d all go tramping through that area like a lynch mob. And in case you are wondering, my new status as “Boss man” didn’t do a thing to prevent the guys from teasing me about my avid interest in this subject. I had been talked about too long by now not to expect to go on being the target of their jokes and pranks.

”Charlie Bigfoot rides again!” they’d laugh whenever I couldn’t contain my excitement over finding new evidence. “You want to know the real truth about Charlie’s search for Bigfoot?” one of the guys said one day while we were having lunch. “He just found out he was adopted, so now he’s looking all over creation to find his real Daddy!” ”Hell, I heard all our ancestors used to swing from trees,” said another guy, “but I sure didn’t know it was that recent.” “Now you’ve gotta admit, there is a resemblance, big and brutal-lookin’ as old Charlie Edson is…” “That may not be as funny as you guys think, I said, though I couldn’t help laughing along with them. “After I’ve collected all the information I need, it may turn out we are all close kin to Bigfoot. What would you guys say to that?” (Prophetic words for 1979?)

During the next two years, all of 1965 and ’66, my buddy Red Collier and I went on frequent tracking and backpacking trips together, but in all that time we didn’t see a trace of Bigfoot. No tracks, no sightings, no shrieking wails in the night and not even a hint of their unmistakable odor.

“I wonder if we’ve succeeded at last, Red.” I said one day when I was feeling particularly discouraged.

“How do you mean, ’succeeded?’ Charlie? We haven’t seen hide nor hair of those creatures in years.”

“Succeeded in chasing them clear out of the state of California,” I said. “That’s what I mean, Red. What with more and more logging activity going on and a lot more nosey tourists, it could be we have finally driven the Bigfeet out of our read forever…”

“Aw come on, Charlie, you don’t believe that. They’re just layin’ low, that’s all. They’ve done that before, you know. You told me yourself you didn’t see your first Bigfoot ‘till more than three years after you first saw their tracks. They’re just doing what they know how to do best, that’s all. You know, like those news reporters say on TV, they’re keeping a low profile.” ”Which has to be a pretty smart trick when you’re more than eight feet tall,” I said with a laugh, though I really didn’t feel too cheerful.

As the months wore on and we had no luck in finding new evidence, I really feared the creatures had given up the northern California area for good. I certainly couldn’t afford to leave my business and family and just go tracking them up into Oregon, Washington or Canada – locations where they were still being sighted. No, the truth was I could only make a career of hunting for Bigfoot as long as he remained in the area where I made my living. The prospect of tailing the creatures half way around the world just didn’t get in with my budget.

The summer of 1967 was a particularly dry one, so my men and I were called upon to do a lot of double duty fighting nearby forest fires in an effort to reinforce the manpower of the Forestry Service. By the time fall arrived, everybody was praying for rain or an early snow, whichever came first, as long as it was wet. As for me, I also threw in a few prayers for the Bigfeet. I prayed they would all escape the fires alive and that I’d be able to see another of the creatures soon.

In October of that year, I almost got my wish. But a couple of other guys beat me to it – a couple of horse breeders, cattlemen by the names of Bob Gimlin and Roger Patterson. Red and I happened to be scouting the Bluff Creek area up in Del Norte County the day those guys made that controversial film of a female Bigfoot on the run. I am sure if you have even the most vicarious interest in wildlife, you must have heard of that film by now. Hell, it was in all the papers, show on TV and in practically every country on earth.

As for whether or not Gimlin and Patterson shot film of a real Bigfoot or a man dressed up in a fur suit, it appears the jury is still out, weighting all the pros and cons. A lot of brilliant experts say yes, but there are a lot more who say “no way!”

Nobody asked me, but if they did, I would have to say, “Yes!” And not just out of loyalty to the Bigfoot either.

It wasn’t sheer coincidence that Red and I happened to be tracking in that area that day we accidentally saw Patterson and Gimlin go galloping past of on horseback. Of course, at the time we didn’t know who the hell those guys were or what they were up too. We only knew we didn’t care to get involved in any kind of social chitchat; not have to explain what we were doing in the area. We just squatted down and hid behind some underbrush until they rode past us. When we saw they were lugging a lot of equipment with them on a packhorse, I guess we just figured they were timber surveyors. Either that or gold miners as there had been a lot of prospecting for gold in that area in recent months.

It wasn’t until later that we found out it was only about a half hour after we spotted them that they must have spotted that female Bigfoot and gotten their historical 16mm film.

Now for the “coincidence.” We were in that precise area for a reason. Some hunters had reported seeing tracks in this vicinity only a few days earlier. And judging by the location they described when Red and I questioned them, it had to be right in the same general area where Patterson and his buddy had filmed their female. As I said, they got there first. But since I didn’t have a movie camera with me, I’m kind of glad they did, because controversial or not, I like to think at last somebody came up with what I fully believe to be “concrete evidence” that these creatures exist.

For one thing, the size of the tracks those hunters told me about jived with what Patterson and Gimlin found after the “star” of their film ran off. The prints were between fourteen and fifteen inches in length. Unquestionably female prints, since all the male tracks I had found were usually between seventeen and eighteen inches long. Also consensus had the height of the female as seven feet or thereabouts. That too, coincided with what Red and I had observed in the past; the females were generally between six and a half to seven feet tall, with the males averaging between eight and nine and a half feet tall.

As for the possibility that a third person had been with Patterson and Gimlin and had dressed up in a fur suit, both Red and I will swear we only saw two men ride past us that day, not three. And since we had been scouting that area for many hours before we saw those two guys on horseback, it’s not too likely that mysterious “third man” could have gone on ahead, since I presume he would have traveled on horseback too, and there was only one time that day when we heard or saw any horseback riders in the area; when we saw Patterson and Gimlin gallop past us.

Come to think of it, I sure wished I had known what those guys were up to when we saw them. Instead of hiding, I would have yelled out, “Take me along!”

And who knows, maybe that female was one of the same creatures I had seen before and chances are if she remembered me and I wasn’t as much of a stranger to her as the other two guys were, she might have hung around the area a little longer before taking off, resulting in a few more feet of film maybe and thus more evidence. Unfortunately, it didn’t happen that way.

Red and I got sidetracked in an effort to keep the secret routes and back roads that the tourists knew nothing about. That way we felt we had a better chance to do our tracking completely unobserved even though this usually involved our taking the longest way around rather than a short cut. That is how we got detoured up through Elk Valley and accidentally came upon some tracks we hadn’t counted on.

True, this was quite a way from our intended destination but as I mentioned, it had been two years since I had seen any sign of the Bigfoot. As a result, I got so carried away with excitement, you would think it was fifteen years earlier and I was getting my very first look at these tracks. This was also the first time I was just excited and not scared.

Red’s reaction was a little different. For the first thirty seconds or so, he seemed absolutely jubilant. Then when he saw how fresh the tracks were, he got very wary though first he tried to laugh it off by doing his “Lenny” imitation from Of Mice And Men “Which way did they go, George?”

Poor Red! I thought as I took out my tape measure and measured the seventeen and a half inch tracks, thinking they were very fresh indeed. The expression on his face looked as if part of him wanted to go on following those tracks while another part of him – his feet—would much prefer to backtrack in a hurry! “I’ll bet this guy is only about forty minutes ahead of us, Red” I said, “what’s your opinion?”

”Don’t panic, Charlie,” he said, panicking.

“Why should I panic? Do you realize how far a Bigfoot can go in forty minutes?”

Sure I do. But wouldn’t that depend on the direction he was headed?” I mean, even if we suddenly smelled one of them real close and we started running, how do we know we won’t run smack into it?”

“Who running,” I said…

”I think I smell one of them, Charlie. I didn’t want to tell you….”
---------------------------------------------------------------
End of except: Page 77 from “My Travels With Bigfoot, a true life odyssey” by Sheriff Charles “Charlie” Edson 1979-- Crescent Publications, Los Angeles, California

Edson, Charles W., Author, meticulous keeper of a diary, life time logger and Siskiyou County Sheriff in California; author of the 1979 “My Travels with Bigfoot, a true life Odyssey.” Edson first spotted a Sasquatch in 1955 while he was Sheriff in Siskiyou County. Edson continued searching for the creatures, personally spotting Roger Patterson and Bob Gimlin riding horse back just thirty minutes before the famous filming of a Sasquatch, October 20, 1967. He was out tracking Sasquatch footprints with logger friend Red Collier in the same area at the same time. At the time he thought they were gold prospectors.


Edson died October 11,1999, leaves widow Genevieve “Ruby” Edson and two sons. I will remember Charlie’s gentle wisdom and words of advice; he was truly a gentleman. …. Bobbie Short
 
....here is an out-take you arm-chair critics can toss in the soup & stir it with a stick...... sheriff Edson unwittingly ruled out a third person with Patterson & Gimlin. Did Greg Long interview Edson, nope!

Bob Heironimus does not claim to have been at Bluff Creek on October 20, 1967.

Besides that, "Charlie Bigfoot" sounds like just another Classic Bigfooter putting on the folk tales for others to enjoy.
 
Then again, maybe it's just a side effect of what William Parcher refers to as "peyote vision." I hope he reposts those stills he has that show the blinking eyes that Owen Caddy and Dr. Swindler claimed to see on the PGF are more likely to be a type of film artifact.

0f4f70a8.jpg
8401a6c8.jpg


Here's the basic, "rough draft" version of what I know about the filming of the PGF:

On October 20, 1967 at 1:00 or 3:00pm (I'm not sure of the exact time since it varies depending on the account; Judging from the film, it was sunny that day.), the "Patty filming incident" supposedly happens.

1:30pm seems to be the most common exact time reported by P&G.

The horse falls on Patterson, hurting his foot and bending a stirrup - Roger Patterson (he apparently started showing a bent stirrup at events Gimlin and he spoke at since he got sick of Gimlin saying the horse didn't fall on him).

Roger supposidly showed the bent stirrup to Al Hodgeson later that night. It would mean that Roger had to remove the bent stirrup from his saddle. How could Gimlin not take not of that, since they were together?

Afterwards, they claim to track Patty for 3 point something miles up a mountain. Then they return to the film site and cast what they felt were the two best tracks.

I believe Titmus claimed to see that three tracks had been cast. Patterson publicly presented only two.

They might've had to go back to their truck (the filming site is near a road) to get the casting materials first, though.

They did have to make a round-trip to the truck to get the plaster.

The next day, forest worker Lyle Laverty and his crew check out the site and takes some pictures of the tracks (both the covered and uncovered tracks).

It was actually three days later... on Monday the 23rd.

Nine days later, Bob Titmus and his brother-in-law go to the site.

Titmus was uncertain if he found the tracks nine or ten days after the filmed encounter. He was alone when he found and cast the ten tracks.

He misses the tracks at first and then procedes to cast ten tracks. He claims that 10 tracks there showed signs of having been cast. This is odd, since Patterson claimed to have only done two.

Again, I think Titmus says he saw that three tracks showed plaster residue.

According to his map of the area, Patty looped around, went up a hill, and sat on a log to watch Patterson and Gimlin from above/behind.

Not on a log. Titmus said she sat in ferns.

This contradicts Patterson and Gimlin's account of tracking Patty for several miles. He also noted that Patty's footprints seemed to start out of nowhere (There were no tracks that showed her entering the film site) and eventually vanished into pine needles.

No, it was P&G who lost her tracks on pine needles after following her sign for 3.5 miles. Titmus didn't lose her sign (as she moved away from the fern sit), but instead chooses not to follow it.

Titmus also claimed he could see Roger's prints from when he was filiming. To my knowledge, he didn't seem to make any reference to any impact of a fallen horse.

He also doesn't mention the array of Laverty crew bootprints which would have been "fresher" than those of Patterson.

Furthermore, how could the unprotected Patty prints survive? Why weren't they reduced to "globs of mud" like the prints that brought Patterson and Gimlin there in the first place? How could that be when thet were at the mercy of rain heavy enough to threaten obstructing a road? To me, this makes it very likely that the originals were destroyed and that Patterson and Gimlin had to refake the tracks before leaving.

I sorta agree. But I go with the Bob Heironimus version. Weeks before October 20th, he wears the suit for filming. Immediately afterwards he leaves for home (Yakima) with instructions to mail the film roll to DeAtley from Eureka(?). P&G stay behind at Bluff Creek. He says that P&G were to "make some fake tracks" at the film site right after he left. This is still weeks before October 20th. Then on the 20th (at this point the film is already developed and edited), P&G are back at Bluff Creek to prepare the fake trackway for the official announcement to the world. They pretend that they had filmed Patty that day, but instead it was weeks prior. They may or may not have done some additional filming on the 20th (such as the stomp test and/or the cast display scene, etc).

I should also note that Patty's tracks were never seen in the Bluff Creek area again after Patterson left.

Titmus did return to Bluff Creek later and of course he found Bigfoot tracks. No mention that these matched Patty. I don't think he ever went looking for BF tracks without finding any. I believe that Titmus was predominantly creating the tracks that he would "find". He may have been the most productive track hoaxer of all time.

I should also note that there are some issues with the "cast display footage." I find the possibility that the footage might be recycled from when Patterson dug some tracks into the ground in order to get footage of him casting tracks to be extremely compelling? Why? Because if that is the case, then it means the tracks he made before filming Patty match up exactly with Patty's feet. And if no instances of Patty's tracks can be found prior to the filming, I dare say that'd be smoking gun evidence that Patterson hoaxed it. The odds of him creating a footprint that matches up exactly to a real creature he'd film days later are very low.

Patterson may have designed the costume feet to sorta match his idea of Bigfoot feet. He could have used his previously-made fake footprints (in substrate) and plaster casts as models (molds?) for these costume feet. When a mime wears the suit, any decent impressions made by the fake feet could serve as "Bigfoot tracks". He could also add to or improve these tracks using tools (plaster or cement casts?) that match the costume feet. He could even bring the suit (or just the legs/feet) and tools back to Bluff Creek on the 20th and use it to make another (or improve what was left weeks earlier) trackway.

If the stride was genuinely much longer than a human stride, then the tracks were not created by a mime simply walking in the suit. This would require special fakery technique. Or, a real Bigfoot. :D
 
Last edited:
Correa:
My experience is the basis for my own judgment, so I must rely on it for my own analysis. If I mention it, the mention simply is to identify the basis of the opinion (saying "I have done it", as opposed to "I read about it" or "I heard somebody say it", or the like). It simply qualifies the basis of the opinion or remark.
As is mine, at least in part, since it is used to evalute information.
I have very few -and probably minor- problems with your explanations on how to build a bigfoot costume and what sort of flaws are to be expected. Here's where the experience or qualifications enter. From your professional experience you provided the data, the evidence, the evidence, in this case is composed by descriptions of costume building techniques and their telltale marks.

My disagreements with you start when you look for these flaws at PGF. At this point, I really don't think qualifications matter or should be used as an argument.

A similar situation happens in respect to how hard it would be the Patty performance and the traces left by the hoaxers.

Point well taken. This is why my post above your, to AMM, was intended to see if we can consolidate the information of one specific issue to a conclusion which could be referenced in a more concise way, so people new to a discussion can more easily find what has been discussed and settled.
Well, the information is around... Not organized, but it is around here. Somewhere. Of course a place showing the skeptic look towards Bigfoot would be nice to have. But sometimes I think people should use more the search function.

I respect your differing perspective, and would support your effort to make up your own mind, based on the evidence you examine.
My present position, again, was created by the evaluation of several lines of evidence. Once again I suggest that people must look from several angles.

Another interesting approach- why different people have different perceptions of Patty? Why I perceive “a bloke in a gorilla suit” while others see a real animal?

My point is simply that while the probability of a cryptid primate existing undetected is very low, the prospect of every incident being explained by hoax or other non-cryptid circumstances (given the number, geographic locations around the country, and the timeframe, throughout the last 100 years, maybe longer if Indian folklore is counted) is also low, although I do not know how to assign any weight to compare probabilities in a numerical manner. So I am mystified by the prospect that clearly a phonemenon exists, and has existed for the last century, and both potential explanations are seemingly improbable.

You are, of course, entitled to your opinion of which may be more improbable, as anyone in this forum is similarly entitled, as am I. My opinion is both options are highly improbable, thus the "mystified" status.
An analogy, quite often used, and quite often misunderstood by proponents:
For how long people have been seeing things that could be interpreted as lake monsters, ghosts, gnomes, etc.? Should I feel mystified by these reports? Is this an indication that there is something other than misidentifications, hallucinations, daydreams, false memories, hoaxes, etc. at the roots of these phenomena?
 
Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

I think it is true that there are at least 1000 incidents that are archived in various places. The BFRO has a big list. Most of these are encounter stories with no evidence (pictures, casts, etc).

It is very common for Bigfooters to say the same thing as you. How could every single one of those incidents be false (for whatever reasons)? If only one of them is true, then we have a Bigfoot in the woods. There are some problems with that reasoning. Correa just pointed out one of them.

Another problem is that although we can see and count the archived reports (let's call it 1000 for simplicity), we have missing data on the total number of reports submitted as Bigfoot encounters. I've read some posts by BFRO investigators that something like 90% of all submitted reports are rejected (never put on public view) because they are not worthy of documenting. This could be because they are obviously false (hoax or misidentification etc) and can be discarded out-of-hand.

What this means is that we cannot properly evaluate the number of people who are intentionally creating encounter story fiction. Would it not be interesting if we could know something like... 10,000 people have submitted BF-type reports, and only 1000 are worth documenting because those at least sound somewhat believeable.

All of a sudden we could possibly say, "Wow, lots of people are compelled to fake Bigfoot encounter stories and the remaining 1000 might only be the 'best' of the fakes."

Many thousands of fiction novels are written each year. Only some of them make the Best Sellers lists.
 
William Parcher said:
All of a sudden we could possibly say, "Wow, lots of people are compelled to fake Bigfoot encounter stories and the remaining 1000 might only be the 'best' of the fakes."
And also the best misidentifications, daydreams, hallucinations, false memories, etc...
 
Here's a little tidbit I don't think I've posted here before..
An excerpt from Patterson's own newsletter, writing how he tracked Patty for 3 miles .. and also recounting that his horse fell ..

newsltr.jpg
 
Last edited:
AMM:

Let me begin with the footprints on site issue we had discussed. I'm actually seeing a conclusion coming together quickly, from my perspective.

I have a few questions, which perhaps you, WP or others can answer:

1. Is Laverty's arrival on the scene "with crew" documented reasonably well (several people, not just him alone)?

2. Did Laverty have any knowledge that Patterson had (or would claim) to have filmed a creature making the footprints found?

My point being, if he came across footprints, I would not think he had any expectation a film showing the creature making the foorprints existed. And if not expecting any filming to have occured when a creature was present, he would not have any concern for any evidence of human activity on the site, other than observing evidence of human activity in relation to the footprints.
Any reports or evidence toward or against this idea?

Correa:

"My disagreements with you start when you look for these flaws at PGF. At this point, I really don't think qualifications matter or should be used as an argument. "

Well, I have two choices. I can say "I think . . . (with opinion added)" and no explanation of how I got to that opinion, or I can say "I think . . . (with opinion added) and then explain my experience which has shaped or influenced my opinion.

I prefer to explain how my opinion was formed or on what it is based, and that inevitably requires me to mention my experience at times.

The point of explaining how an opinion is formed is to allow others more options to test the opinion by their own investigation and research. An opinion without any explaination often leaves people simply wondering "where did that idea come from?"

Bill
 
Well, I have two choices. I can say "I think . . . (with opinion added)" and no explanation of how I got to that opinion, or I can say "I think . . . (with opinion added) and then explain my experience which has shaped or influenced my opinion.

I prefer to explain how my opinion was formed or on what it is based, and that inevitably requires me to mention my experience at times.

The point of explaining how an opinion is formed is to allow others more options to test the opinion by their own investigation and research. An opinion without any explaination often leaves people simply wondering "where did that idea come from?"

Bill
I understand your position. One of the things I am trying to say is that it can be easilly misinterpreted as an argument from authority. Not to mention that in some cases, the line separating both cases may be quite blurry. Note that at any moment there was a major questioning regarding the building methods and their telltale marks. Its quite clear from where it all came from.

Again, the disagreements are related to other topics.

An analogy: Suppose I am an engineer with 40 years of experience building bridges and we are discussing the possible causes of a collapse based on some footage. I can write about building methods and collapse causes and eventually reffer to my background. When we center our discussion on questioning if the footage has enough resolution to display features (say, corrosion marks) which would favor my idea or yours, my bridge-building background is not very relevant at this specific stage. This is my second point.

Of course, ideally the refferences should be towards publicated data, say, textbooks. Since as far as I know there are not too many books written on how to build gorilla suits, you must mention your experience... And it has a lot of weight.

However, on the other hand, I do think we all have the right to disagree with experts, within their field of expertise, when the data and or the analysis presented are found lacking. If we are wrong, then they will have no problem showing our mistakes. For example, I question Meldrum's and Krantz's conclusions, regardless of their qualifications because the problems I see at their analysis. This is my third point.

Well, I'm afraid we may be heading towards an OT digression. Maybe it would be better to focus at other issues we previously touched.
 
One substantial problem within the membership of this forum is the near total dissmissal of any and all expierence that a poster or posters may have concerning anything that is not swimming with the prevailing current. For instance during a certain period of my post graduate life I spent huge blocks of time in wilderness and semi wilderness not as a tourist, footer, hunter or lumberjack but as a trained observer dispatched to those areas to perform legitmate scientific work. The specifics of that work I've made no secret of. Yet I find it interesting that there are those that dismiss my observations concerning the environment I was working in because I was doing water research and not some other "accepted or forum scantioned" purpose for being where I was at the time.

By now there isn't any one cohesive story that can explain the PGF. Not William Parcher, not Atomic Mystery Monster, not Bob Gimlin, not Roger Patterson. The list of point counter point is impossibly too long convoluted and the trail is way too cold to ever nail the thing down. However people like Bill Munns and D'foot are the one's most likely within the confines of this and a few other web communities to produce working examples of the things we see on the PGF. Rather than turn thier efforts into a pissing contest why not support the effort. Isn't this place about truth.
 
Last edited:
Correa:

"I understand your position. One of the things I am trying to say is that it can be easilly misinterpreted as an argument from authority. "

We do agree here. That is why I try to explain my positions, with supporting facts, ideas, or examples. By giving the reader some basis to further research the issue, it empowers the listener to exercise some of their own logical authority or critical thinking, and make up their own mind.

As for being misintrepreted, to some extend that would seem to occur regardless of what a person perceived as an authority says. So I simply try in good faith to provide more information, so others can make up their minds.

"However, on the other hand, I do think we all have the right to disagree with experts, within their field of expertise, when the data and or the analysis presented are found lacking."

I support you here completely.

Perhaps this above isn't specifically On Topic for the PGF, but it is essential foundation for debating the PGF.

But I do welcome the discussion returning to PGF specifics, as you do.

Bill
 
One substantial problem within the membership of this forum is the near total dissmissal of any and all expierence that a poster or posters may have concerning anything that is not swimming with the prevailing current. For instance during a certain period of my post graduate life I spent huge blocks of time in wilderness and semi wilderness not as a tourist, footer, hunter or lumberjack but as a trained observer dispatched to those areas to perform legitmate scientific work. The specifics of that work I've made no secret of. Yet I find it interesting that there are those that dismiss my observations concerning the environment I was working in because I was doing water research and not some other "accepted or forum scantioned" purpose for being where I was at the time.

By now there isn't any one cohesive story that can explain the PGF. Not William Parcher, not Atomic Mystery Monster, not Bob Gimlin, not Roger Patterson. The list of point counter point is impossibly too long convoluted and the trail is way too cold to ever nail the thing down. However people like Bill Munns and D'foot are the one's most likely within the confines of this and a few other web communities to produce working examples of the things we see on the PGF. Rather than turn thier efforts into a pissing contest why not support the effort. Isn't this place about truth.
Crow, I think that perhaps you should reconsider some of those words of yours. We do not dismiss the experiences or positions of those who are "swimming against the tide". We dismiss unreliable information and flawed (or poorly based) reasonings/claims, regardless of their vectors.

The root of your "extinct bigfeet" claim/proposition are Native American myths and old reports, coupled with the fact that bigfeet-like species lived in the past at Africa and Asia. You feel this is enough to support a proposal- bigfeet are a real species. Your next step is to rely on your field observations (no bigfoot experience) and in the lack of (recent) good pieces of evidence to back a claim- the species was extinct. OK so far?

Now, here are the problems I see with your proposal (of course you have the right to disagree with me, but please forget your disagreements for the sake of this discussion):

1. Personally I do not consider what I presently know about Native American lore as being enough to back the previous existence of these creatures. I consider the old reports as being even more unreliabe.

2. I can not find a good reason to accept Native American lore and old reports but dismiss recent reports.

3. The lack of fossils of bigfeet-like creatures in North America or anywhere near the land bridge.

Note that none of the reasons above cited are actualy related to your field experiences. Note also that every now and then I, as well as other posters here, wrote that the many people who carry on field works would, by now, probably have found reliable evidence of these animals if they existed. Under this aspect, I feel it is incorrect to say your field experience was dismissed, because at least in part, we agree. Unless I got completely wrong your ideas.

Oh, and regarding the "pissing contest", well, I don't see how we turned the debate between Bill and Dfoot in such a thing. Its a debate, and you will find posts where we disagree with Bill and others where we disagree with Dfoot. Its an open forum, and I think we, while keeping civil and within the forum rules, can and should debate.
 
For instance during a certain period of my post graduate life I spent huge blocks of time in wilderness and semi wilderness not as a tourist, footer, hunter or lumberjack but as a trained observer dispatched to those areas to perform legitmate scientific work. The specifics of that work I've made no secret of. Yet I find it interesting that there are those that dismiss my observations concerning the environment I was working in because I was doing water research and not some other "accepted or forum scantioned" purpose for being where I was at the time.

Who is dismissing your environmental observations? Skeptics? Advocates? Both? Regardless, I can quickly think of at least two reasons for dismissing your observations:

1. you were working down east and not in the PNW, and;
2. you never observed a squatch.

RayG
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom