Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
So in the matter of my previously stated opinion that some evidence at the filming site of a support crew might be expected, the reality is that the issues of the site, the rain, and the contamination in the days after, all create a condition where no human activity, arguing for or against the number of people involved in filming a hoax, can be determined by the ground area where the film was made."
Regarding the support crew issue in general. Are you aware of the filming logistics surrounding the docudrama The Missing Link?


John
 
Greg

.... Better yet ask a few professional wildlife photographers about how they deal with situations in the bush and filming animals exiting the scene.

.....
So, your argument, is that Patterson's behavior exhibits the skill of a professional wildlife photographer ?

Would a professional wildlife photographer have chased after their subject the way Patterson did at the beginning of the film ?
 
So, your argument, is that Patterson's behavior exhibits the skill of a professional wildlife photographer ?

Would a professional wildlife photographer have chased after their subject the way Patterson did at the beginning of the film ?

I'm simply suggesting that you've made a mountain out of a mole hill. So alright Greg yes you're right Roger Patterson's path at Bulff Creek makes sense only if the film was a staged event. He could have stood on his head, eaten his lunch, taken a dump and wipped his kiester while Bob H stood motionless behind the trees waiting for Roger to click the chalkboard and call for action.

Now you know the film is a hoax so why are you even bothering to waste electrons on the forums about it? The PGF has been whipped to death sorry its a case where we've killed something we loved but its dead. I realized how stupid it had all become and how nobody had a clue anymore what happened or how it happened. There were posts and photos concerning the so called "tent pole" pics which were no more than a couple of scrawny trees from the frames preceeding the creature footage. Yet miles of dialogue were expounded on it and it was nothing nothing at all! And so it was with Patterson holding the casts. Thousands of words have been written about where and when the photos were taken. And guess what they're not even photos per se they're frames from the second roll. Yet the know it all's never figuered that out yet they were able to postulate how they could have been filmed months or years before or after.

So go back and read what I've said about Roger Patterson's camera abilities I doubt you'll find me saying anything about "professional quality." Now if you want to take someone on don't take on Roger Patterson, he's dead let him rest. Take on Owen Caddy and his magic mouth and eye movements.
 
Crow,

Are you lost little boy ?

This thread is about the PGF ..

We are discussing the PGF ...

I'm simply suggesting that you've made a mountain out of a mole hill.

Why don't you run that by the congregation over at BFF ...

Is Mr. Munns and his 12 part series on Roger P's handiwork making a mountain out of a mole hill ?

I've barely got a surface disturbance compared to the effort he's put forth..


Why do you have such a problem with my observations ?

Why don't you really show your brass, and go over to BFF, and suggest in every one of Mr. Munn's threads that he is " making a mountain out of a mole hill "...
 
Crow,

Are you lost little boy ?

This thread is about the PGF ..

We are discussing the PGF ...



Why don't you run that by the congregation over at BFF ...

Is Mr. Munns and his 12 part series on Roger P's handiwork making a mountain out of a mole hill ?

I've barely got a surface disturbance compared to the effort he's put forth..


Why do you have such a problem with my observations ?

Why don't you really show your brass, and go over to BFF, and suggest in every one of Mr. Munn's threads that he is " making a mountain out of a mole hill "...

Bill Munns is attempting to recreate the object in the PGF and so is D'foot. Thier actions can't be compared with your focusing on a few seconds of camera play that by most observations carry no weight one way or the other. Once again if you believe the film is a hoax accept it and move on. How many Cub Souts does it take to bury a hoax anyway?
 
And so it was with Patterson holding the casts. Thousands of words have been written about where and when the photos were taken. And guess what they're not even photos per se they're frames from the second roll. Yet the know it all's never figuered that out yet they were able to postulate how they could have been filmed months or years before or after.

Your online personality is very strange. I have never been able to understand what you are doing in the forums. It seems directionless and almost never contains critical thinking. This is why you catch so much flak here.

How do you know the cast display scene is from "the second roll"? What is this second roll, and exactly what does it contain? Is it even possible that Patterson never installed another roll of film after he filmed Patty? Could the story be a bunch of lies?

The big significance of the cast display scene is that nobody seems capable of accurately placing this in space or time. It's partly because there is no proper forensic or custodial coherency to the various pieces of celluloid associated with P&G and the PGF. It's also because virtually everyone who has written about the history and "facts" surrounding the PGF is a proponent. That's a problem because these people tend to take the testimonies of P&G at face value. Inconsistencies are taken as common exaggeration, excitement, poor reporting or just flawed memory. When a proponent encounters problems like this, they can go ahead and try to explain it in a way that smooths things out and presents no smoking guns.

Proponents cannot show that the cast display scene was filmed after the Patty encounter. All they can do is explain that it must have been filmed afterwards because that is logical for a non-hoax scenario.
 
...snip...So I would conclude that evidence from the actual filming site simply does not exist to make any determination of how many humans were present on the day of the filming, or what their activities may have been, in relation to the subject being filmed....snip...
As AMM commented, if rain coupled with the activity of other people and the lack of data (say, a map of the tracks, humans' and Patty's) does not allow the determination of a possible hoaxing activity, then Titmus' report is useless. All the "Patty squatting at ferns" is suspect.

The same is also valid for most (probably all) stuff written about Patty's alleged tracks and footprints. One can not rule out the possibility that the tracks were not made by Patty, after all. The PGF may have been shot weeks before and the footprints "planted" anytime later. All we have to back the claim that Patty made the tracks are Patterson's and Gimlim's words. A very weak case, I would say.

This is important, Bill. If I understood your text correctly -consequences and extrapolations included- you agree with skeptics on this particular issue. And its not quote mining or misquoting.
 
Last edited:
JohnWS:

"Regarding the support crew issue in general. Are you aware of the filming logistics surrounding the docudrama The Missing Link?"

No, I'm not aware of any particulars of that filming.

Correa:

"As AMM commented, if rain coupled with the activity of other people and the lack of data (say, a map of the tracks, humans' and Patty's) does not allow the determination of a possible hoaxing activity, then Titmus' report is useless. All the "Patty squatting at ferns" is suspect."

my remarks don't pass judgment on the validity of Timus' report, other than to acknowledge that it has no evidence on the issue I was discussing. Everyhing about Patty's footprints is a seperate issue since evidence of them was cast. The validity of that evidence, I understand, is strongly disputed.

Bill
 
Your online personality is very strange. I have never been able to understand what you are doing in the forums. It seems directionless and almost never contains critical thinking. This is why you catch so much flak here.

How do you know the cast display scene is from "the second roll"? What is this second roll, and exactly what does it contain? Is it even possible that Patterson never installed another roll of film after he filmed Patty? Could the story be a bunch of lies?

The big significance of the cast display scene is that nobody seems capable of accurately placing this in space or time. It's partly because there is no proper forensic or custodial coherency to the various pieces of celluloid associated with P&G and the PGF. It's also because virtually everyone who has written about the history and "facts" surrounding the PGF is a proponent. That's a problem because these people tend to take the testimonies of P&G at face value. Inconsistencies are taken as common exaggeration, excitement, poor reporting or just flawed memory. When a proponent encounters problems like this, they can go ahead and try to explain it in a way that smooths things out and presents no smoking guns.

Proponents cannot show that the cast display scene was filmed after the Patty encounter. All they can do is explain that it must have been filmed afterwards because that is logical for a non-hoax scenario.

William how many more smoking guns does a skeptic/outright disbeliever need to kill the beast? Seems a lot of ammunition is still being fired but at what? Is it something like well on a scale of 1 to 10 its a full ten 100% fake. But its still not fake enough it needs to be an 11? Is it like Spinal Tap and the volume controls?

At some point it becomes as obsessively sad to beat the hoax to a pulp as it is for the Owen Caddys finding non existing mouth and eye movement as a means to prove its real. In a way I suspect nobody is really happy with either position they choose to inhabit.
 
William how many more smoking guns does a skeptic/outright disbeliever need to kill the beast? Seems a lot of ammunition is still being fired but at what? Is it something like well on a scale of 1 to 10 its a full ten 100% fake. But its still not fake enough it needs to be an 11? Is it like Spinal Tap and the volume controls?

At some point it becomes as obsessively sad to beat the hoax to a pulp as it is for the Owen Caddys finding non existing mouth and eye movement as a means to prove its real. In a way I suspect nobody is really happy with either position they choose to inhabit.

If people enjoy discussing the film, and if doing so does not harm you in any way, why do you care if they spend their time in that manner?
 
William how many more smoking guns does a skeptic/outright disbeliever need to kill the beast? Seems a lot of ammunition is still being fired but at what? Is it something like well on a scale of 1 to 10 its a full ten 100% fake. But its still not fake enough it needs to be an 11? Is it like Spinal Tap and the volume controls?

At some point it becomes as obsessively sad to beat the hoax to a pulp as it is for the Owen Caddys finding non existing mouth and eye movement as a means to prove its real. In a way I suspect nobody is really happy with either position they choose to inhabit.

This entire forum is based on skepticism of extraordinary claims. Have a look around at other topics. Proper skepticism involves critical thinking, rationality, reasoning and specialized knowledge. It could be considered an intellectual pursuit.

When proponents of these claims engage in dialogue with skeptics it becomes a form of debate. Patterns of defensive behavior and argumentative tactics emerge and distinct commonalities can be seen for proponents of almost any extraordinary claim.

You know that I regard both avid Bigfoot proponents and skeptics as a strange lot. I'm not sure if I could fully explain why I do this. To a certain extent it's entertaining for myself. It is easy to get bored with this, and that's one reason why I engage in "obsessive" research and documentation of things like Patterson's clothing throughout the filmed scenes and still photos. It gives me something to do and I think it has productive potential.

This forum has produced an amazing amount of facts and logical deductions concerning the PGF. Many of these things cannot be found anywhere else in print or on the web. Obviously, it is driven by skepticism and curiousity.

I could say a lot more, but you are not worth the keystrokes. :p
 
JohnWS:

"Regarding the support crew issue in general. Are you aware of the filming logistics surrounding the docudrama The Missing Link?"

No, I'm not aware of any particulars of that filming.

I think it's interesting in the context of an alleged hoax. I was a legitimate production that featured a creature suit but according to an interview with Rick Baker (Cinefex 46, May 1991) the production crew on location consisted of just three people. Husband and wife Carol & David Hughes (camera/sound) and noted ape impersonator Peter Elliott. Elliott both wore & maintained the suit during the shoot in Africa.

The suit was manufactured in Baker's shop but due to the crew limitations Baker taught Elliott to care for the suit. Baker does state he had some reservations about such a project, but I think it certainly suggests a 'support crew' is not a prerequisite for every such instance. Especially a hoax which I would speculate likely being done somewhat more 'on the fly' than a more 'regular' production.

The attached image shows it was not as bulky as the Patterson subject, but it certainly seems to hold up in close-up and features a detailed face as well as the hand-tied hair suit.

Missing-Link.jpg
 
Last edited:
About the rain and finally leaving Bluff Creek...

There are differing accounts of the timing of when Gimlin goes to cover the tracks and when P&G leave the area.

Chris Murphy's History of the PGF said:
By about midnight, it was raining heavily.

Back at the campsite, weather conditions had gone from bad to worse. Fearing a possible landslide on the Bluff Creek road, Patterson and Gimlin decided to get out of the area. They packed up and left for Yakima at about 4:00 a.m., October 21, 1967. They experienced great difficulties getting out of the area. The Bluff Creek road had caved away so they had to take the Onion Mountain route.


Bob Gimlin interviewed by John Green in 1992 said:
Gimlin: Around 5:30 a.m. or so it started raining and it was just a pouring down rain. I told Roger we better get up and do something about the tracks or they'd wash out, and he said no, it would stop raining after a while. I went ahead and got up, put the saddle on my horse, and decided I would ride up there while it was raining really hard and Roger says "ah it'll quit, don't ride up there." I said "no, I'm going to go ahead and ride on up there." I had gotten a couple of cardboard boxes from Mr. Hodgeson's to cover these tracks the night before. So when I went outside to get a couple of these boxes that were folded up out there, they were just soggy old pieces of cardboard. I disregarded taking those back up to the scene - so I rode back up there, pulled some bark off some trees and covered up the tracks as best I could and went back to camp.

By then we decided it wasn't going to quit raining. The little creek that was six or seven feet across was now ten or twelve feet across and four feet deep! We were on the side of the creek which had to be crossed with the truck to get out to the main road. I said "well I'm going to go ahead and cross the creek with the truck and get started out." And of course Roger thought it would stop raining and he suggested I leave him there and come back and pick him up.

These two accounts have significant time differences. Murphy mentions rain, but nothing about Gimlin returning to the site to cover tracks. He says they drove out of the area at 4:00am. In the November 1967 radio interview with P&G, there is no mention of rain, covering tracks, or the circumstances of their evacuating the area.

If Gimlin's 1992 recollection is accurate, I would estimate that they did not finally leave their camp before about 8:30am. Gimlin wakes at 5:30, decides to ride the (about) two miles to the site in what would be darkness and pouring rain, then pulls bark and decides which tracks to cover (I think I've read he covered three tracks), and then rides back to camp. In order to leave they had to pack up camp and load the horses - all in a pouring rain.

So, I'm curious where Murphy got the info that they made their final exit at 4:00am. Gimlin said he didn't even wake up until 5:30am.

Also, I'm curious if there are any witnesses or evidence (besides the testimony of Gimlin) that can attest to this tremendous rain happening at the film site area.
 
Thanks, mang. We can see that there was some rain in Eureka. It probably had to rain more than .38" in the vicinity of the film site to account for all the things Gimlin talked about. Maybe it didn't and instead he made up a bunch of stuff. That wouldn't be very surprising if he was involved in a hoax.

This is the famous print that Laverty photographed on Monday the 23rd. This one was said to be covered with bark. But Gimlin claims it poured rain before he even got to protect it. I can see dimple impressions around and within it. That suggests rain, but not a downpour before covering. The raised ridge (MTB) doesn't look like sand that has been pounded by rain. The whole print including the edges looks sharp and almost pristine.

Try making a distinct footprint in moist sand... then rain a bunch of water onto it. How much water? Enough to double the volume of Bluff Creek. I don't think you end up with something quite like this. It looks to me like this only received a drizzle...

067a7e3e.jpg
 
I haven't seen a reply so akward since Costanza pulled out the "The Jerk Store called... THEY'RE RUNNIN' OUT OF YOU!"

Drew I was just being a kinder gentler BITCH!! I mean sometimes it just isn't worth rummaging through the weapons locker looking for the C4 when there's just a couple of flies being uppity!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom