Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Diogenes;

"When can we expect the book, Bill ?"

Don't have a clue. I'd want to do a lot more research and tests on materials and film resolution issues filming the materials (the Part 11 notes) and haven't got any funding lined up yet.

:)

Bill
 
AMM:

Given you are one of the more rational voices on this forum, can you help me understand why my opinions seem to provoke the reactions you were reminded of? I'd welcome a second opinion.

Seems to me, the theme of this forum is "a place to discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly and lively way"

Is "are you crazy" or "WTF" friendly?

And I'm still trying to understand why things posted elsewhere are of such concern here, as if either the other forum had no right to exist, or I had no right to express myself there.

Just curious. I'm still trying to figure out the mentality here.

:)

Bill
 
If I may add my grain of salt, I think the WTF comes from the frustration that you posit you have no prejudiced position and are inquiring the pgf neutrally using your knowledge (or at least you don't say you are a believer), but on the other hand you refuse to acknowledge even a low probability that this could be a hoax (like "3 guys could not have pulled it off" and I pass many other). The frustration probably comes from the fact that AGAIN one which tout himself as an expert will be used as an argument by believer, but the argument of the expert aren't really based on mucho evidence , if any, and from my POV is biased even if don't want to admit it.

*shrug* my expertise in biology tells me anyway all those discussion and expertise you offer, is nothing in comparison to other damning fact (no bones, no corpse, no blood, no sqat, no DNA, *nothing* since PGF and patty was one-of-a-kind... Would not that make you DOUBT a little bit in your own "expertise" that this cannot be a costume ? Apparently not).

I expect the WTF will be dropped (they are against forum rule as far as I know).
 
Aepervius:

"If I may add my grain of salt, I think the WTF comes from the frustration that you posit you have no prejudiced position and are inquiring the pgf neutrally using your knowledge (or at least you don't say you are a believer), but on the other hand you refuse to acknowledge even a low probability that this could be a hoax (like "3 guys could not have pulled it off" and I pass many other). The frustration probably comes from the fact that AGAIN one which tout himself as an expert will be used as an argument by believer, but the argument of the expert aren't really based on mucho evidence , if any, and from my POV is biased even if don't want to admit it.

*shrug* my expertise in biology tells me anyway all those discussion and expertise you offer, is nothing in comparison to other damning fact (no bones, no corpse, no blood, no sqat, no DNA, *nothing* since PGF and patty was one-of-a-kind... Would not that make you DOUBT a little bit in your own "expertise" that this cannot be a costume ? Apparently not).


I expect the WTF will be dropped (they are against forum rule as far as I know)."

Thank you for your very well reasoned note. I'll see if i can respond with similar reasoning.

"you posit you have no prejudiced position "

Well. I do not have any true absolute opinion on whether "patty" is real. I have said repeatedly, what's in the film mystifies me. And that is truly my frame of mind in this matter. It seems that others simply refuse to accept that as true, and I don't know what more I can say to get the point across.

Is "I'm mystified" a prejudiced position?

"but on the other hand you refuse to acknowledge even a low probability that this could be a hoax "


Then why do I keep saying, "If it's a suit"? I've probably said that a hunderd times or more, in all my postings. I even calculated a list of issues and their probability or improbability, in a way very structured and reasoned format.

But logically, if there are two essential options, "A" Patty's real, and "B" Patty's a hoax done with a suit, and I say I'm mystified or I'm undecided, doesn't that acknowledge both options are still being considered? That's what it means to me.

"The frustration probably comes from the fact that AGAIN one which tout himself as an expert will be used as an argument by believer,"


But if the statements of an "expert", like Dfoot, are used as an argument by skeptics, is that OKAY?

And why do you elevate my opinion above that of Chris Walas or Stan Winston (both who have Academty Awards, and I don't). Why not just tell "the believers" the ones with the Oscars say Patty's a suit.

Every Professional in the makeup field, when asked about this issue, offers an opinion, and that opinion feeds people who believe along the line of the opinion. I've seen "the list" of over a dozen Makeup people who are described as believing Patty's a fake. These dozen opinions feed the skeptical proponent's mind, don't they?

"from my POV is biased even if don't want to admit it."

Do you know the difference between a perspective view and an orthographic view? (Not being demeaning to you here, I honestly don't know if you are familiar with these terms)

A perspective view has one fixed point from which things are perceived, in relation to that one point. An orthographic view is instead a perception independent of a specific point of view (although it may have a general direction of view). Humans all perceive the world from their "perspective", and any perspective can conceivably be argued as a "bias" by someone taking another point of view.

So the remark of another person's bias is of itself, merely an opinion, unless you wish to acknowledge every person is biased, by virtue of their perspective.

"to other damning fact (no bones, no corpse, no blood, no sqat, no DNA, "

Don't you mean, to other damning "absense" of facts?
Not playing semantics here, and don't want to rely on that tired cliche "absense of facts is not proof of absense". Just reads to me that you left out a word.

let's look first at the essence of this concern of yours.

Do you know if I have expressed any specific remarks about the "no bones, no corpse, no blood, no sqat, no DNA," so you actually know my opinion of this particular issue. Did you know that the absense of such is actually one of the strongest reasons for my being mystified? I struggle continually with the issue of why such haven't been found and verified. But that is the larger "Is Bigfoot real" issue, not the "is Patty a suit" issue. So your remark in this portion seems to merge the two, when I thought the "Patty" issue was only a subset of the larger issue, because BF could be real even if Patty were proven to be a hoax.

I also wonder why would blood or scat or DNA be a "Patty" issue?

"Would not that make you DOUBT a little bit in your own "expertise" that this cannot be a costume ? Apparently not)."

Again, I fail to see how blood, scat, or DNA issues would impact on my investigation of whether or not Patty is suit? The issues I see as helping determine if Patty is a suit are issues of furcloth materials and their motion dynamics, the practicalities of seams and their placement, and such.

And the practicalities of how a suit is made, worn, filmed, and attended to during its use are all considerations I take into consideration, based on my experience working with them.

I've said I agree with John Chambers' reported statement that if patty's a suit, she's a better one than he could do. Isn't that an acknowledgement that it could be a costume?



Bill
 
Bill Munn, since we are on definition, Do you know what "inference" is ? How about this :
* there are only two possibilities. This is a real animal or a guy in costume.
* if this is a guy in costume, then this was a hoax. Either Patterson was hoaxed or he was the hoaxer
* the history of the con job patterson did hint at the probability he was hoaxed is low (if this was an hoax). But this is beside the point.
* now let us see, what is the probability that a giant bipedial primate could exists in the US. This is where the bone and blood comes in play. Anybody will agreee that the probability is relatively low in absence of biological evidence (any professional biologist at least, which you would surely agree knows a bit more on this than us). The only point hinting at the existence of a biological unknown entity would be the pgf. A Single point without any biological artifacts (only a film).
* Therefore the probability of the pgf being an hoax weight heavily against the probability of it being a live animal without prior biological artifact.
* You say you have difficulty thinking this could be a hoax. One can therefore infer you assign a zero, or nearly zero probability of it being a hoax. Compare with the previous statement. Rince and repeat.

QED.

Additionally you make the error of thinking that if you CANNOT think of a cheap technic used for it to be a costume in the 60th then it cannot be a costume. This is quite an error, (a fallacy I would dare say) because as said before there could be a wide pan of knowledge on such costume type you might be missing (or are you telling us you have omniscience on costume technic ?). You are trying to prove something by proving a negative. The only way to go would be to prove a positive. Either prove that this is a real animal or prove this is a costume. With trying to prove "this is not a costume" you are only fooling two people : yourself and the BF community.
 
Last edited:
Aepervius:

"Bill Munn, since we are on definition, Do you "inference" ? How about this :
* there are only two possibilities. This is a real animal or a guy in costume.
* if this is a guy in costume, then this was a hoax. Either Patterson was hoaxed or he was the hoaxer
* the history of the con job patterson did hint at the probability he was hoaxed is low (if this was an hoax). But this is beside the point.
* now let us see, what is the probability that a giant bipedial primate could exists in the US. This is where the bone and blood comes in play. Anybody will agreee that the probability is relatively low in absence of biological evidence (any professional biologist at least, which you would surely agree knows a bit more on this than us). The only point hinting at the existence of a biological unknown entity would be the pgf. A Single point without any biological artifacts (only a film).
* Therefore the probability of the pgf being an hoax weight heavily against the probability of it being a live animal without prior biological artifact.
* You say you have difficulty thinking this could be a hoax. One can therefore infer you assign a zero, or nearly zero probability of it being a hoax. Compare with the previous statement. Rince and repeat.

QED.

Additionally you make the error of thinking that if you CANNOT think of a cheap technic used for it to be a costume in the 60th then it cannot be a costume. This is quite an error, (a fallacy I would dare say) because as said before there could be a wide pan of knowledge on such costume type you might be missing (or are you telling us you have omniscience on costume technic ?). You are trying to prove something by proving a negative. The only way to go would be to prove a positive. Either prove that this is a real animal or prove this is a costume. With trying to prove "this is not a costume" you are only fooling two people : yourself and the BF community."


Interesting that you posted the above logic structure qa, because I was working on the following at the same time:


Just looking at the PG film issue, in a basic logic diagram:

step one:

a. Real creature
b. person in a suit

Step Two:
If (b) is correct:

a. Roger, Bob, and a third person faked the film
b. Roger faked Bob or vice verse
c. Somebody faked both Roger and Bob

Step Three:
If (a) is correct,

a. Did the three do it all by themselves?
b. Did they do it with some outside help preparing the suit?
c. Did they have professional help, both in preparation and on the filming event?

All I've ever said is, if Step one is proven to be a suit, and Step Two is proven to be Roger, Bob, and a third person faked the film, then I tend to think the Step Three option that makes the most sense to me, based on what I see in the film and my experience making suits and films, is "C" (they had professional help both preparing the suit and at the filming.)

And if "C" is true, I would expect that there may have been some evidence of such in the ground, because that extra person activity would be hard to completely hide from others who later examine the site.


Now comparing yours and mine:

"* there are only two possibilities. This is a real animal or a guy in costume."

We agree.

"* if this is a guy in costume, then this was a hoax. Either Patterson was hoaxed or he was the hoaxer"

We agree.

"* now let us see, what is the probability that a giant bipedial primate could exists in the US"

Don't know how to calculate odds of this, to assign a number to the probability, but as i understand biology and wildlife studies, the prospects of an unknown species existing but escaping detection from scientific confirmation would vary inversely with A. Its size (bigger less likely), B. It's habitat (less likely the more humans enter or explore the habitat) and C. The extent people are searching for it (the more people are searching and not finding it, the less likely it is). So we have three "Less likelys" in a row.


"* Therefore the probability of the pgf being an hoax weight heavily against the probability of it being a live animal without prior biological artifact."

Your reasoning weakens here, because while with BF in general, the above probability is calculated, based on the absense of anything to validate the cryptid. So your reasoning is based on absense of things, reasonably suggesting or inferring rarity or non-existance.

But the PGF is existant and there is something on that film. Fact. And that something has enough visual information to determine some factual particulars of the film figure. Example, it can be determined to be a bipedal walking figure, with apparent breast-like shapes on the front torso, etc.

There are enough frames of the film to compare light patterns across the body from frame to frame, and a full motion sequence to evaluate the physiological actions of walking, turning the head, etc.

So there is something, and that something can be evaluated, to some extent.

Now, the counter logic which you omitted is this. Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

What is the probability every one(100%) is a Hoax? I's say low.


"Additionally you make the error of thinking that if you CANNOT think of a cheap technic used for it to be a costume in the 60th then it cannot be a costume."

If a material (such as standard furcloth), is mechanically capable of pliable flexing and bending, but mechanically incapable of elongation, then when I see a mechanical motion which does not bend or flex based on the mechanical dynamics I know are the physical limits of a furcloth, I can say with some reasonable certainty that what I'm seeing isn't furcloth.

I believe we went around on the "trying to prove a negative" befor, and seems we never reached an understanding then, so I'll just say I argued this before and what I said then still stands as my point of view.

"* You say you have difficulty thinking this could be a hoax. One can therefore infer you assign a zero, or nearly zero probability of it being a hoax. "

One is "inferring" incorrectly. One's inference is actually one's own misunderstanding, thinking the world is pure yes/no/black/white, when i see multiple shades of grey. But I long ago gave up worrying if others "infer" their own misconceptions from my words or actions, because it is the inevitable result of existing.


Bill
 
"You have trouble imagining a hoax scenario? WTF?"

Yes, I do. If there was one, what i see on film took more than a performer and two guys to pull off.

OK. You are just another guy on the Internet saying that they have trouble with the PGF being a hoax. But wait, you're not just another guy because you are a professional costume designer. You give an expert opinion that this was not done by only three people at the film site. Your unstated proclamation is this: If you are going to believe that the PGF is a hoax, then you better get comfortable with the fact that more than three people were present and working at the film site.

"This guy is confessing to wearing the suit for only a few minutes, "

You don't get into and out of such a suit in a few minutes. Cheap suits, yes, but if patty's a suit, she's not a cheap or amateur one.

Look, here it is, straight up. I say what I think and believe, as do you. We see things differently. Live with it.

The confessing mime says he was offered $1000 to play the role of Bigfoot. He says it only took a few minutes after he had the costume on. He says Patterson and Gimlin helped him put on the costume. The day was "hot", and it was really hot being inside the suit. But it was only a few minutes and the physical effort was limited to walking across sand with only one single requested "turn to look" action. He says that near the end of his pre-determined walking pathway he jumped into a big hole (cavity created by an uprooted tree) and hollered out to "get this thing off me". He talks about wearing the hot and stinky suit and wanting to get out of it. Bob Heironimus might actually agree with you. No way could a "regular guy" perform in that furry black suit on that hot sunny day for more than a few minutes without some kind of break for cooling off.

This guy could be lying on multiple levels. Maybe he wasn't in the suit after all and the whole confession thing is a hoax. Or maybe he was in the suit and the bit about the stinky-hot-jump-in-the-hole is just some bullcrap that he is compelled to tack on for whatever reason.

Maybe there wasn't any support crew. Maybe there wasn't a suit to need one? Keep an open mind.

My mind is fully open to the PGF being a hoax. Your declaration that this would require a professional production crew seems funny to me. The whole Bigfoot belief thing is very funny. Opening the mind to accept a perpetually undocumented and undocumentable wild hairy ape is very funny. You want to make this whole thing a serious interest and concern. That is funny too.

I could easily switch from "WTF?" to "LOL". It's all the same expression. Bill, we are talking about Bigfoot in a skeptical forum. This Bigfoot thing is funny as anything could be. Your efforts to legitimize the topic as a genuine mystery stated by a genuine costume expert is only resulting in more humor. Requests for a necessary "open mind" is just more funny stuff stacked on top of a funny foundation.

Bigfoot is funny because some people want to try to deal with it in a serious fashion. That's funny too. Bill, you can't say anything anymore without increasing the humor factor. The more serious you try to be, the more funny it gets. It's so funny now that I don't even care about proper grammer and sentence structure. Rope-a-dope slapstick fun. This thread should be archived on 16mm film with lots of scratches. Future generations can laugh their asses off with the Bigfoot topic. Funny. Very funny.

LOL!
 
WP"

"Your unstated proclamation is this: If you are going to believe that the PGF is a hoax, then you better get comfortable with the fact that more than three people were present and working at the film site."

It's you who are suggesting elevating my opinion to fact. If you'd just keep saying "well, you are entitled to your opinion, but that's all it is, an opinion", maybe people would get the point, that it is my opinion.

"But wait, you're not just another guy because you are a professional costume designer."

So are Stan Winston and Chris Walas. Are you chastizing either of them for giving their opinions on the PGF? Are you worried that someone will think their opinions are "fact" because of their professional standing? I don't recall any concern or outrage from their remarks. Or is it only when someone who has some professional credentuals and offers an opinion conflicting with your belief that you whine about how that opinion might be perceived by others as fact? A good critical thinker applies a fundamental principle of logic across the board, so if a professional costume designer's opinion is in a special or restricted class as compared to a non-professional's opinion, fine. Apply that rule to Chris, Stan, and even Dfoot as you apply that rule to me.

"This guy could be lying on multiple levels. Maybe he wasn't in the suit after all and the whole confession thing is a hoax. Or maybe he was in the suit and the bit about the stinky-hot-jump-in-the-hole is just some bullcrap that he is compelled to tack on for whatever reason. "

So why does my remark of not appraising his ability to endure a suit provoke such a concerned response from you. I agree, Bob H could be lying on multiple levels. We agree. Done deal. Thank you.

"The more serious you try to be, the more funny it gets. "

Your opinion, and I respect your right to express it.

:)

Bill

added:

"Bigfoot is funny because some people want to try to deal with it in a serious fashion. That's funny too. Bill, you can't say anything anymore without increasing the humor factor. "

So, my singular opinion has the potential to change the whole level of "funny"? Must be a very influential opinion.

Maybe that's why it bugs you so much? Just a thought.

:)
 
Last edited:
Bill Munns said:
Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

What is the probability every one(100%) is a Hoax? I's say low.

You are completely leaving out the other potential factors for a report of BIGFOOT.
A. Person saw something and thought they saw a Bigfoot
B. Person completely fabricated the story for any number of reasons.
C. Person hallucinated that they saw a bigfoot

You are also leaving out the fact that these reports are investigated by enthusiasts, not investigators. How many investigations have led to any verifiable evidence?

While you may not admit that you are a Bigfoot enthusiast using your expertise in costumes to create waves within the bigfoot community, the fact that you have the same acceptance of the weak-evidence-pool as some of the other Bigfoot enthusiasts tells me otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Drew:

"While you may not admit that you are a Bigfoot enthusiast using your expertise in costumes to create waves within the bigfoot community, the fact that you have the same acceptance of the weak-evidence-pool as some of the other Bigfoot enthusiasts tells me otherwise."

Just curious, Drew, what "weak evidence" have I accepted? I rely on my industry experience and my understanding of materials and processes, and my own analysis of the PGfim data to form my judgments.

Calling your bluf here, Drew.

:)

Bill

Had to add this:

"You are completely leaving out the other potential factors for a report of BIGFOOT.
A. Person saw something and thought they saw a Bigfoot
B. Person completely fabricated the story for any number of reasons.
C. Person hallucinated that they saw a bigfoot

You are also leaving out the fact that these reports are investigated by enthusiasts, not investigators. How many investigations have led to any verifiable evidence?"


Okay, Let's do it this way:

A. Cryptid species explanation
or
B. Non-cryptid species explanation (which includes your list and mine, and any other which somebody thinks about later)

Can you say that 100% of incidents are in the "B" category, reliably confirmed? If not, you cannot take the "A" category out of consideration. And I did not refer to investigations that lead to a confirmation of a cryptid explanation. I referred to investigations leading to a non-cryptid explanation.

And the making waves thing is interesting. We all make waves by our very existance. Some waves may be bigger and more far reaching than others, but we all do make them. So is your concern:

A. That anybody is making waves?
b. That I specifically am making waves?
c. That I am making waves going in the opposite direction as your waves?
d. that you are getting seasick?
e. other.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me, the theme of this forum is "a place to discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly and lively way"

Yes.

Is "are you crazy" or "WTF" friendly?

No. But I must admit I can sometimes understand the confusion that leads to them.

And I'm still trying to understand why things posted elsewhere are of such concern here, as if either the other forum had no right to exist, or I had no right to express myself there.

Well, this is the PGF thread, so it's only natural that we'd discuss any new or particularly interesting developments related to the film.

I think the suspicions based on you posting on the BFF are pretty odd, but my not having a problem with it is based on me having experience similar to yours. I hung around on crypto boards when I randomly decided to check into cryptozoology-related stuff each year long before stumbling across the JREF. But I also realize that not everyone had similar experiences, so I can see why they're not seeing it the way I am.

I don't know if you've ever seen "They Live," so here's a link to the fight scene. Roddy Piper really wants the other guy to put on the glasses so he can see something important, but the other guy doesn't want to. This causes a great amount of frusteration between the two and this inevitably leads to a fight. I think that's what is going on here, only replace the glasses with research on factors directly related to (but not shown on) the film.

I feel kinda disappointed when you'll comment on something about the PGF and miss an important detail that doing some research outside what's seen on the film would've given you. One example is your comments about the lack of prints from the support crew you'd expect from a hoax explanation for the PGF and not realize that there was heavy, flood-causing rain hours after the filming (but before Patterson and Gimlin went back home) that would easily destroy any such tracks. I doubt they planned for that, though. William Parcher's comment about crew tracks being written off as the work of others looking at the tracks after Patterson had left is a valid explanation for how such evidence could be left and "spun" to a hoaxer's favor. I can provide examples of hoaxers giving even wilder explanations after they've been busted (and still managed to get away with it).

I think this is frustrating to others because various people here have tried to help you by directing you towards such information and yet you don't. I know the reason for you not doing that, but I hope the above example will make you rethink that (seeing as how it'd probably help you avoid more incidents like this).

And for some random quotes I felt compelled to respond to:

But if the statements of an "expert", like Dfoot, are used as an argument by skeptics, is that OKAY?

To be fair, Dfoot objects to being called an "expert." Well, that, and people here have disagreed with various aspects of his theories. Also, references to comments by Walas and Winston are brought up only as counterbalances to "someone from Hollywood says it can't be a suit", which actually predate the skeptical arguments.

And why do you elevate my opinion above that of Chris Walas or Stan Winston (both who have Academty Awards, and I don't). Why not just tell "the believers" the ones with the Oscars say Patty's a suit.

We try to avoid appeals to authority (that's not to say it doesn't happen sometimes, though).

Now, the counter logic which you omitted is this. Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

That's actually not an unreasonable explanation for Bigfoot. If you want, I can repost links to articles detailing cases in which staggeringly large amounts of reports on something turned out to be 100% incorrect. Since I have a link handy, here's a comment regarding feet that helped (but was only one of many points) knock me "off the fence" and onto the skeptical side of things when it came to Bigfoot.

I have some input on your recent comments concerning Roger Patterson's artistic abilities, but those'll have to wait for another post. I really, REALLY need to get some sleep...
 
AMM:

Thank you for your post, and your reasoning.

Allow me to comment on one specific section:

"I feel kinda disappointed when you'll comment on something about the PGF and miss an important detail that doing some research outside what's seen on the film would've given you. One example is your comments about the lack of prints from the support crew you'd expect from a hoax explanation for the PGF and not realize that there was heavy, flood-causing rain hours after the filming (but before Patterson and Gimlin went back home) that would easily destroy any such tracks. I doubt they planned for that, though. William Parcher's comment about crew tracks being written off as the work of others looking at the tracks after Patterson had left is a valid explanation for how such evidence could be left and "spun" to a hoaxer's favor. "

This is the kind of straightforward and calm explanation I would expect as a response, but nobody other than you seems capable of providing.

It sets a stage for a further discussion of the specific issue (footprints at the filming site).

Maybe we can explore this specific issue further together.

"I think this is frustrating to others because various people here have tried to help you by directing you towards such information and yet you don't. "

I've been trying now for 4 months to direct people to basic material issues and information, and they don't seem to be getting it either. The frustration cuts both ways. I'm frankly astonished at how much of what I write is missed by others.

But again, thank you for your well reasoned response.

Bill

ps:

"I feel kinda disappointed when you'll comment on something about the PGF and miss an important detail that doing some research outside what's seen on the film would've given you."

I would welcome a list of any specific issues or details you feel I have missed, which may be relevent to or should factor into my own studies and notes.
 
Last edited:
AMM:

Following up from the last post, I invite you to join me is trying to resolve the item you mentioned as follows:

"One example is your comments about the lack of prints from the support crew you'd expect from a hoax explanation for the PGF and not realize that there was heavy, flood-causing rain hours after the filming (but before Patterson and Gimlin went back home) that would easily destroy any such tracks."

From my observations of people here, they don't seem to be able to resolve much of anything, and more effort is directed at simply trying to put others down. Maybe the problem is they learn what they see, and they see others doing just that.

So What I propose to you is that you and I take this one issue you have mentioned (the footprints and the site) and we, together, see if we can discuss this one focused issue and arrive at a conclusion we both would confidently sign off on. And I will post that conclusion over in the thread with my notes that brought up the footprints on site issue, so the cleared up statement is there as well.

I propose we have this dialogue here, on line, so others interested can follow it (and obviously comment as they like), but you and I will keep our focus on our dialogue, and the construction of an understanding about this issue. If others can contribute facts and ideas in a cooperative way, we may quote them as well (attributed, of course).

We will respectfully quote and then answer every question the other asks, as fairly as we can, and we will never get into any silly semantics games or nit picky quibbles. We really will try to understand the true intent of the other's expressed ideas.

We will build on the things we agree on, and continue to discuss any points we disagree on. And we will see if we can reach a conclusion we both feel fairly reflects the important facts or considerations of the issue.

Hopefully, if others see us cooperating to achieve a mutual understanding, they may actually feel confident to try it with other issues, either with me or with other forum participants.

If this works for you, here's the starting point:

As you appear to know more about the issues of the filming site and footprints there, would you describe to me what you know or understand to be the facts and conditions of the matter. Specifically:

1. Can you describe what you know about the footprints found, human and "patty"?
2. Can you describe what you know about the weather, environment and timeline?
3. Can you describe the reported actions of people to investigate the site on the filming day or in days after?
In each case, you may describe your response in a simple paragraph, (more if you like) and in your own words, as you understand the matter, a generalized basic summary really.

And then let me respond with equal good faith, commenting on your remarks, and we will try to construct an understanding of the issue.

Bill
 
Bill, a couple of comments:

1. Please understand that one can understand your explanations and arguments but still disagree with your conclusions. This is what is happening here. This is what quite often happens when a bigfoot proponent exposes his/her arguments here. I don't think people here ignore your qualifications. We just do not agree with your analysis and conclusions. Reminding us of your qualifications may be interpreted as argument on authority, and what we discuss are the evidences and the reasonings. More than once, at this and other threads I, as well as many other posters could have used the weight of our qualifications, and we choose not to do so. Yes, it may be frustrating sometimes. You must also understand that a number of arguments you raised here, such as the footprints left by the hoaxers, have already been discussed here a couple of times with other posters. If you feel tired of exposing your points, please note that we are also tired of exposing ours. Not to mention that quite often we've been faced with very rude and offensive attitudes from a number of posters. This creates wear and frustration and causes reactions that may not be very friendly, but certainly are lively...

Regardless of how hot and cumbersome the Patty costume could be, those folks would have been, in my opinion, able to perform using it. I've seen people without special preparations use for hours carnival costumes which were at least as hot and cumbersome as a Patty costume would be. I think PGF's resolution is not enough to detect the costume flaws you described. I think pareidolia and biased onservations can effectively account for many if not all of the features pointed by proponents as evidence of Patty's nature as a bigfoot. I think Patty moves like a man. I think one or two people are enough to help pulling the hoax (wearing the suit, shooting, etc.). I think the tracks left by the hoaxers during the filming can remain undetected and/or- even without the rain. Don't take the following as an offense. Regardless of your qualifications, I haven't seen in your work any evidences capable of changing my mind regarding Patty's nature. Its about the the quality of the data, its about the quality of the evidence; its not about your qualifications. The same is valid for Meldrum and Krantz.

2. The "if 99.9% of the sightings are explained by hoaxes/misidentification this still leaves 0.1% of sightings of real bigfeet" line. We discussed this more than once. Frankly, its a very weak line. Its the "bigfoot living in the gaps".
You wrote
Can you say that 100% of incidents are in the "B" category, reliably confirmed?
Of course not, specially because there are missing pieces of information which, if available could either expose the incident as a hoax or a misidentification (or a real bigfoot, of course). If one can not really rule out the possibility of a real bigfoot, one must not forget that there are no reliable evidences to back the case of their existence, evidence which, if bigfeet were real creatures, one would expect to have. Sure, it is possible that a very unlikely chain of events and circunstances avoided these evidence of surfacing untill the time of writing. But this is... Well, unlikely. And gets more unlikely at each tick of the clock. This unlikely, implausible gap where bigfeet may live becomes smaller and smaller. Too small to host a population of giant apes scattered across North America. Oh, and note that if one can not really rule out the possibility of a real bigfoot, one can not rule out the possibility of their inexistence. And so far inexistence seems more likely in my opinion.
Aniway, I find interesting to see you advancing towards an approach not solely based on an analysis of if Patty as a suit is possible or not. I think the subject must be evaluated through more angles.
 
Correa:

Thank you for your well reasoned and calmly explained post.

"Reminding us of your qualifications may be interpreted as argument on authority, and what we discuss are the evidences and the reasonings. "

My experience is the basis for my own judgment, so I must rely on it for my own analysis. If I mention it, the mention simply is to identify the basis of the opinion (saying "I have done it", as opposed to "I read about it" or "I heard somebody say it", or the like). It simply qualifies the basis of the opinion or remark.

"If you feel tired of exposing your points, please note that we are also tired of exposing ours. "

Point well taken. This is why my post above your, to AMM, was intended to see if we can consolidate the information of one specific issue to a conclusion which could be referenced in a more concise way, so people new to a discussion can more easily find what has been discussed and settled.

"Regardless of your qualifications, I haven't seen in your work any evidences capable of changing my mind regarding Patty's nature. Its about the the quality of the data, its about the quality of the evidence; its not about your qualifications."

I respect your differing perspective, and would support your effort to make up your own mind, based on the evidence you examine.

"Of course not, specially because there are missing pieces of information which, if available could either expose the incident as a hoax or a misidentification (or a real bigfoot, of course). If one can not really rule out the possibility of a real bigfoot, one must not forget that there are no reliable evidences to back the case of their existence, evidence which, if bigfeet were real creatures, one would expect to have. "

My point is simply that while the probability of a cryptid primate existing undetected is very low, the prospect of every incident being explained by hoax or other non-cryptid circumstances (given the number, geographic locations around the country, and the timeframe, throughout the last 100 years, maybe longer if Indian folklore is counted) is also low, although I do not know how to assign any weight to compare probabilities in a numerical manner. So I am mystified by the prospect that clearly a phonemenon exists, and has existed for the last century, and both potential explanations are seemingly improbable.

You are, of course, entitled to your opinion of which may be more improbable, as anyone in this forum is similarly entitled, as am I. My opinion is both options are highly improbable, thus the "mystified" status.



Bill
 
Bill Munns said:
Just curious, Drew, what "weak evidence" have I accepted? I rely on my industry experience and my understanding of materials and processes, and my own analysis of the PGfim data to form my judgments.

Calling your bluf here, Drew.

By Accepting this as counter-logic (It's the same acceptance of weak evidence that many Bigfooters subscribe to)
Bill Munns said:
Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

I can't prove every single one of them false, but, they have yet to prove one of them to be real.
 
Drew;

"By Accepting this as counter-logic (It's the same acceptance of weak evidence that many Bigfooters subscribe to)

Originally Posted by Bill Munns
Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities? "

I can't prove every single one of them false, but, they have yet to prove one of them to be real."


Drew, what evidence am I accepting? I am acknowledging there are things unknown or unproven, lacking evidence to arrive at a conclusion.

What "counter logic"?

Bill
 
I guess I should have put counter-logic in quotes. By accepting the Bigfooter argument that 'if only one is correct' then you are accepting a weak argument, based on weak evidenciary standards.

Bill Munns said:
Now, the counter logic which you omitted is this. Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

What is the probability every one(100%) is a Hoax? I's say low.

If you think the probability that every report is (Non-Cryptid in nature) is low, than you are accepting that some of these reports are (Cryptid in nature), therefore accepting weak evidence. Since not one of them has ever been proven to be true.
 
Last edited:
Drew;

"I guess I should have put counter-logic in quotes. By accepting the Bigfooter argument that 'if only one is correct' then you are accepting a weak argument, based on weak evidenciary standards.


Originally Posted by Bill Munns
Now, the counter logic which you omitted is this. Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?

What is the probability every one(100%) is a Hoax? I's say low.

"If you think the probability that every report is (Non-Cryptid in nature) is low, than you are accepting that some of these reports are (Cryptid in nature), therefore accepting weak evidence. Since not one of them has ever been proven to be true."

Drew:
what are you talking about? Where am I doing the following: "By accepting the Bigfooter argument that 'if only one is correct' then you are accepting a weak argument, based on weak evidenciary standards."


How many times do I have to state so you get it that I have not accepted either argument or condition as proven and conclusive. the cryptid/non-cryptid debate is inconclusive by the lack of proven evidence overall.

Once again, I will ask you, what evidence am I accepting?

Bill
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom