Seems to me, the theme of this forum is "a place to discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly and lively way"
Yes.
Is "are you crazy" or "WTF" friendly?
No. But I must admit I can sometimes understand the confusion that leads to them.
And I'm still trying to understand why things posted elsewhere are of such concern here, as if either the other forum had no right to exist, or I had no right to express myself there.
Well, this is the PGF thread, so it's only natural that we'd discuss any new or particularly interesting developments related to the film.
I think the suspicions based on you posting on the BFF are pretty odd, but my not having a problem with it is based on me having experience similar to yours. I hung around on crypto boards when I randomly decided to check into cryptozoology-related stuff each year long before stumbling across the JREF. But I also realize that not everyone had similar experiences, so I can see why they're not seeing it the way I am.
I don't know if you've ever seen "They Live," so
here's a link to the fight scene. Roddy Piper really wants the other guy to put on the glasses so he can see something important, but the other guy doesn't want to. This causes a great amount of frusteration between the two and this inevitably leads to a fight. I think that's what is going on here, only replace the glasses with research on factors directly related to (but not shown on) the film.
I feel kinda disappointed when you'll comment on something about the PGF and miss an important detail that doing some research outside what's seen on the film would've given you. One example is your comments about the lack of prints from the support crew you'd expect from a hoax explanation for the PGF and not realize that there was heavy, flood-causing rain hours after the filming (but before Patterson and Gimlin went back home) that would easily destroy any such tracks. I doubt they planned for that, though. William Parcher's comment about crew tracks being written off as the work of others looking at the tracks after Patterson had left is a valid explanation for how such evidence could be left and "spun" to a hoaxer's favor. I can provide examples of hoaxers giving even wilder explanations after they've been busted (and still managed to get away with it).
I think this is frustrating to others because various people here have tried to help you by directing you towards such information and yet you don't. I know the reason for you not doing that, but I hope the above example will make you rethink that (seeing as how it'd probably help you avoid more incidents like this).
And for some random quotes I felt compelled to respond to:
But if the statements of an "expert", like Dfoot, are used as an argument by skeptics, is that OKAY?
To be fair, Dfoot objects to being called an "expert." Well, that, and people here have disagreed with various aspects of his theories. Also, references to comments by Walas and Winston are brought up only as counterbalances to "someone from Hollywood says it can't be a suit", which actually predate the skeptical arguments.
And why do you elevate my opinion above that of Chris Walas or Stan Winston (both who have Academty Awards, and I don't). Why not just tell "the believers" the ones with the Oscars say Patty's a suit.
We try to avoid appeals to authority (that's not to say it doesn't happen sometimes, though).
Now, the counter logic which you omitted is this. Given there have been a number of sightings, and a number of footprints observed, cast, etc, and such, going back the last century or more, and cross all America, can you say categorically every single one of those is a hoax? because if there were (a hypothetical number here) 1000 incidents, and 999 are hoaxes, but one of them is real, then the cryptid phenonenon is real. Can you say categorically that you have investigated virtually every sighting and footprint occurance and determined that 100% of them are a hoax or expalined by known biological entities?
That's actually not an unreasonable explanation for Bigfoot. If you want, I can repost links to articles detailing cases in which staggeringly large amounts of reports on something turned out to be 100% incorrect. Since I have a link handy,
here's a comment regarding feet that helped (but was only one of many points) knock me "off the fence" and onto the skeptical side of things when it came to Bigfoot.
I have some input on your recent comments concerning Roger Patterson's artistic abilities, but those'll have to wait for another post. I really, REALLY need to get some sleep...