Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Correa:

"I understand your position. One of the things I am trying to say is that it can be easilly misinterpreted as an argument from authority. "

We do agree here. That is why I try to explain my positions, with supporting facts, ideas, or examples. By giving the reader some basis to further research the issue, it empowers the listener to exercise some of their own logical authority or critical thinking, and make up their own mind.

As for being misintrepreted, to some extend that would seem to occur regardless of what a person perceived as an authority says. So I simply try in good faith to provide more information, so others can make up their minds.
OK, but just keep in mind that misinterpretations may also be made by those whose opinions are more closely related to yours...

"However, on the other hand, I do think we all have the right to disagree with experts, within their field of expertise, when the data and or the analysis presented are found lacking."

I support you here completely.

Perhaps this above isn't specifically On Topic for the PGF, but it is essential foundation for debating the PGF.
Its essential for any debate, I belive. Experts are people. They can be wrong. I am an expert in my field, and more than once I was wrong. OK, that was my argument from authority.

But I do welcome the discussion returning to PGF specifics, as you do.

Bill
OK. There are plenty of specific (as well as not-so-specific) subjects. Here's some.
-What sort of traces one would expect three hoaxers (a camera operator, a costume helper and a performer) to have left? Could these traces be found (and propperly interpreted) later?
-Why different people have different perceptions of Patty? Why I perceive “a bloke in a gorilla suit” while others see a real animal?
-PGF resolution- what can be really seen? Can we really evaluate hair lenght and distribution, for example?
-What would it take to build and "animate" a "basic Patty", something which would do the job within PGF resolution?
-Costumes with short hairs and seams.
-[add preffered subject here]
 
Correo/Ray it was mentioned that because I was in the forest doing research regarding the effects of acid rain on lakes that somehow my observations concerning the rest of the environment and what was or wasn't present in it somehow is invalid. That was the point of my post.
 
Before I begin, I'd like to thank Diogenes and William Parcher for their contributions and corrections to my mostly from memory attempt at writing a timeline. I'd also like to correct a particualrly glaring mistake I had made:

He misses the tracks at first and then procedes to cast ten tracks. He claims that 10 tracks there showed signs of having been cast. This is odd, since Patterson claimed to have only done two.

Since I was so sleepy, I accidentally deleted the part where I wrote that I thought there were four tracks that showed signs of having been cast. This got mixed up with the part about Titmus casting ten tracks.
I'll look into the possibility that it was only three, though. While doing some looking through the forum archives, I found this picture by Roger Patterson that gave me a good chuckle. Why was it funny? Because Bigfoot is demonstrating midfoot flexation! I doubt this was intentional and think it's just a quirk of Patterson's artwork; just think of my humorous observation on it as a thank-you gift of sorts.

Let me begin with the footprints on site issue we had discussed. I'm actually seeing a conclusion coming together quickly, from my perspective.

I have a few questions, which perhaps you, WP or others can answer:

1. Is Laverty's arrival on the scene "with crew" documented reasonably well (several people, not just him alone)?

Apparently, he was with some crew members and later told District Ranger Walt Kurshman about the tracks, who supposedly visted the day after being told. I don't know if any of them were on horseback or not, though.

2. Did Laverty have any knowledge that Patterson had (or would claim) to have filmed a creature making the footprints found?

I'm not quite sure about this yet. Many references to Laverty makes it sound like he (and his crew) found them while doing their job, but I did find some references to him having learned of the filming. The first is in an uncited "Squatchopedia" entry and the second comes from this BFF thread.

I run into Forest Service people often that worked for the Six Rivers National Forest during that time and remember the hoopla very well. Everyone seemed to know where the event took place because "Louse Camp" was a local term. Word spread quickly after they came out...hence why Laverty and his crew went there three days later, and District Ranger Walt Kurshman went about a day after that.

Hummm...Laverty and his crew wouldn't because they were a timber crew marking timber (so they walk every where). Rangers, in the old days, always rode horses, but once roads went in, it was fairly uncommon...but I have no idea. I'll ask Walt next time I see him.

In this thread:

Actually Laverty had a marking crew with him (so four more or so people) plus the Ranger for the area, Walt Kurshman (who now resides in Sonora, California) went the following day to see the prints after the reports came in from Laverty.

I don't who Walt has told, but he's a pretty forthright person (but aging...he's 85). He knows Lyle and it was Lyle's report about the tracks that caused Walt to go look at the tracks.

I'm not entirely sure that had the timber crew was literally with Laverty when he found the tracks. The statement was "Laverty was out with a crew marking timber when he came across the prints." That infers to me that the crew (of four or more) was with him, but I actually do not know.

In a March 15, 2005 post at 04:27 PM, Yetifan quoted page 21 of "Bigfoot Times - "Bigfoot At Bluff Creek" by Daniel Perez:

Stationed at the nearby Notice Creek Camp when the film was made the crew saw the tracks and Laverty took six color slides of the prints. Laverty remember having been in the area years earlier and was familiar with Bigfoot stories from the region. When asked if the tracks appeared real, Laverty said, "oh boy...hard to say. I guess there was some skepticism because we had been up and down that same road all summer long and never saw anything...and then all of a sudden Mr. Patterson comes in for a couple of days and 'bang!' Yeah, I think there was some skepticism," but even Laverty, 170 pounds at the time, admitted his boot tracks came nowhere near the depth of the subject's footprints."

For what it's worth, Mr. Laverty said that he didn't see any tracks by the site on October 19th or 20th.

Happily, Mr. Laverty is alive and is serving as Assistant Secretary of the Interior for Fish and Wildlife and Parks, so it might be possible to contact him via e-mail. If necessary, I can try finding it so that these questions can be directed to him.

My point being, if he came across footprints, I would not think he had any expectation a film showing the creature making the foorprints existed. And if not expecting any filming to have occured when a creature was present, he would not have any concern for any evidence of human activity on the site, other than observing evidence of human activity in relation to the footprints.
Now that you mention it, there's a Laverty photograph which shows what appears to be a bootprint by one of the tracks. I have no idea if it was there when Laverty arrived or if he (or someone with him) made it, though. You can see some more Laverty pictures here.

Bob Titmus knew about the filming, but I don't know if he knew about Laverty visiting the site. According to this (it's buried in part 7), Titmus decided to visit the site after a showing of the film at a university. There's too much to repost here, but I'll note a few select quotes:

My first full day up near the end of Bluff Creek, I missed the tracks completely. I walked some 14 to 16 miles on Bluff Creek and the many feeder creeks coming into it and found nothing of any particular interest other than the fact that Roger and Bob's horse tracks were everywhere I went

It was not difficult to find the exact spot where Roger was standing when he was taking his pictures and he was in an excellent position.

Harry made several tests and observations, one of which was walking briskly beside the tracks to try to match their depth of up to an inch and a quarter and more in places. Harry is a 200 pounder and the best he could do was an imprint of about 1/2 of an inch on the rear portion of his shoe heel and one-eighth of an inch and less on the rest of his shoe imprint. We both agreed, considering the depth of the two imprints and the difference in the amount of bearing surface, that the creature that made these tracks would have to weigh at least 600 to 700 pounds.

"Harry" is his brother-in-law, who came to Bluff Creek with his wife after Titmus called them when he had finished looking at the film site. Estimating the weight of something based on the depth of its tracks can be tricky, especially when there's the possibility of a hoax (and when you consider the case of "Florida Three-Toes").

Speaking of track depth and weight issues, you might be interested in these links.

I also seem to recall a picture of one of the Titmus casts that has an odd depression in its heel; someone once compared it to a heel of a "cowboy boot." Hopefully I can find it again so (or maybe someone else will post it).

These two earlier pages from the thread have some mor einformation about Laverty and Titmus. Also, this post offers more on the problems between the Titmus map and Patterson and Gimlin's story.
 
Last edited:
Since I was so sleepy, I accidentally deleted the part where I wrote that I thought there were four tracks that showed signs of having been cast.

I may be wrong about the three Patterson castings. Titmus doesn't mention this in his letter to John Green, but I guess he told this to Krantz. I'll go with four unless I can find another reference.

I'm not quite sure about this yet. Many references to Laverty makes it sound like he (and his crew) found them while doing their job, but I did find some references to him having learned of the filming. The first is in an uncited "Squatchopedia" entry and the second comes from this BFF thread.

For what it's worth, Mr. Laverty said that he didn't see any tracks by the site on October 19th or 20th.

Laverty says he didn't see any Bigfoot tracks before he found the Patty tracks on Oct. 23. That is sometimes stated by proponents in a way that suggests it demonstrates that there were no Patty tracks prior to Oct. 20 on that sandbar. The fact is, they may have been there and he never saw them. The sand walk theater suggests that those prints may not have been visible from the logging road (where Laverty would drive). To find them you probably had to be seeking them. Prior to learning of the P&G filmed encounter, Laverty would have had no reason to be looking for BF tracks. He says he never saw any in all his years of working the area.

Laverty also mentions not ever seeing P&G in the area. OK, but I'm curious if he ever passed Louse Camp during the week prior to Oct. 20 giving him the opportunity to see the parked truck and campsite. If he drove to where the guys would be camped and saw nothing... that could be suspicious since they said they were camped there for about a week.

I also seem to recall a picture of one of the Titmus casts that has an odd depression in its heel; someone once compared it to a heel of a "cowboy boot." Hopefully I can find it again so (or maybe someone else will post it).

That was me who posted those. It's just an observation with some speculation. I guess it could be a boot heel showing through a flexible fake foot.

e3a3a486.jpg
a0be2943.jpg
 
The cowboy/Patty may have been someone sticking thier boot into the Patty track as a means of size comparison. But I don't think so I've maintained that the "suit walker" wearing cowboy boots inside fake suit feet could have left the secondary impression. Since cowboy boots have a substantial arch there's an excellent reason for the so called mid tarsel break which could be little more than unsupported fake flexible foot bunching up into the void left by the high cowboy boot heel.

Also while we're talking about foot prints the Laverty print photo (with twig) shows a much narrower and tapered foot compared to the squarish foot as seen on Patty. Patterson's photo holding casts show a square like foot.
 
I'm bringing this over from the Cathedral Of Her Pattyness , and throwing it into the Thunderdome ...

I would like my fellow skeptics to play Devil's advocate, and tell me why my thinking is flawed in the following observation .. Not just flawed because I don't think Patty is the real deal ...

Thank you ...


http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=21716
You might want to get out your copies of LMS, and follow along. It might help in visualizing what I wish to bring into question.

In the LMS footage, Patty first appears at about the 6 second mark for me.. ( PowerDVD on my computer )

Up until the 24 second mark, the camera is in almost constant motion, and there are very few frames where Patty can
be said to be very clear at all..

Of course, Roger is running to catch up ( in a parallel sense ), and the motion is understandable in that respect .
The 24 second mark is where he appears to stop and steady the camera, prior to the ' turn and look ' ..

Here is the frame I captured at this point..

24sec.gif


Of course, LMS is zoomed in, and it might be good to keep in mind, Roger was seeing something more like this ..

( From the ' Mysterious Monsters ' video )

MM24.GIF

Roger stays relatively still, and pans the camera, for the scene we are most familiar with, until Patty approaches some trees ( in the plane of view ) that are going to obscure her from view ..

36SEC.GIF


This occurs at about the 36 second mark on LMS ..

Now for the inconsistent ( IMO ) part, that doesn't really make sense ..

Roger starts moving again, and that would make sense, if he actually kept moving to position himself for a better
shot at Patty.
But he scrambles to a new position in about three seconds, and steadies the camera on the group of trees where Patty will be
seen to emerge, in another 6-7 seconds..

Here is a shot of the trees after Roger stops at his new location..

39SEC.GIF

46sec.gif


Here is the view when Patty emerges a few seconds later ..
Roger keeps the camera on Patty for about 4 more seconds, then repositions himself to continue filming for about another
15 seconds till the end of the segment ...

Why did Patterson, who had scrambled to catch up to Patty for the ' turn and look ' bit; stop and take some relatively steady
footage of those trees for seven seconds, waiting for Patty to emerge, rather than keep moving to get her into view?

Besides, why should he think she was going to emerge from behind those trees, rather than amble off in some other direction,
that would keep her out of clear view of the camera ?
Just something to think about ..
 
Correo/Ray it was mentioned that because I was in the forest doing research regarding the effects of acid rain on lakes that somehow my observations concerning the rest of the environment and what was or wasn't present in it somehow is invalid. That was the point of my post.
Crow, as Ray demonstrated, a bigfoot proponent could easilly dismiss you experience. Actually I think it would be more likely.

Examples:
- You were not looking for bigfoot.
- How many species which are known to exist where you worked were not seen by you?
- They are über-stealthy, one may have been watching you and you never knew about it.
- Maybe they weren't there.

I think you probably already read such reasonings anywhere else.

Again, when it comes to your "bigfeet are real but were extincted last century" idea, we consider the evidence you presented to back its first part ("bigfeet are real") weak. So, your field experience is not relevant in this particular case because there's no actual need to back the second part. ("were extinct last century").

Your experience (not finding bigfoot) is another small tidbit of information against the proposition "bigfeet are real" (at least the widespread bigfoot variety).
 
Diogenes said:
Why did Patterson, who had scrambled to catch up to Patty for the ' turn and look ' bit; stop and take some relatively steady
footage of those trees for seven seconds, waiting for Patty to emerge, rather than keep moving to get her into view?

1. Simple. Patterson studied bigfoot for years and was way ahead of his time, as well as ours, when it comes to knoweledge of its behavior. He predicted her behavior.
2. Simple. It was a wild guess or his best option. And it worked. Lucky guy.
3. Simple. The bloke in the gorilla bigfoot costume was following a script.
 
1. Simple. Patterson studied bigfoot for years and was way ahead of his time, as well as ours, when it comes to knoweledge of its behavior. He predicted her behavior.

Too bad we lost this researcher .. 40 Years later, and we know no more than he did when he captured this unbelievable footage ...

2. Simple. It was a wild guess or his best option. And it worked. Lucky guy..

Hey ! Stuff happens .. Can't argue with that ... You win ...

3. Simple. The bloke in the gorilla bigfoot costume was following a script.

Wait ! Stop the music !

I want arguments from the position that " ..... it's not a bloke in a suit ... "


You're in the Thunderdome,,, And don't forget it ....

Thunderdome.masscorporation.blogspot.com.jpg
 
Last edited:
Too bad we lost this researcher .. 40 Years later, and we know no more than he did when he captured this unbelievable footage ...
And it seems no one managed to get his notebooks and recover his methods... Or even considered getting them.

Hey ! Stuff happens .. Can't argue with that ... You win ...
Can't be that easy, LOL!

Wait ! Stop the music !

I want arguments from the position that " ..... it's not a bloke in a suit ... "
Sorry... Old habits die hard... Lemme see...

Patty thought Patterson would not be such a fool to think she would follow a straight line and get out of the woods in to open terrain instead of heading towards the woods.

Patty was heading Patterson away from her hidden offspring, hence the choice of the easy path.

Patty chose the easy path because she was not at her top health performance (hernia, recently gave birth, etc.).

Better?

No, I do not want to be bigfoot's new hero or warrior...
 
Last edited:
AMM:

(and others here who may wish to comment on this)

The following is a draft of remarks I would like to add to my notes, specifically in connection to the ideas I had expressed about the prospect of a hoax being done by more than three people, and some expectation of evidence for that on the filming site.

"(Draft)
On the issue of human activity at the filming site in connection with the filming:

The reported rainfall after the proported filming day would reasonably be expected to degrade evidence on the ground of human filming activity. And the arrival of Mr. Laverty and a crew of workers on the scene after those rains, seeing the "Patty" footprints and investigating them, would have contaminated the site with additional evidence of human activity. Finally, no actual evidence investigation specifically documenting the complete evidence of human activity on site was apparently conducted.

So I would conclude that evidence from the actual filming site simply does not exist to make any determination of how many humans were present on the day of the filming, or what their activities may have been, in relation to the subject being filmed.

So in the matter of my previously stated opinion that some evidence at the filming site of a support crew might be expected, the reality is that the issues of the site, the rain, and the contamination in the days after, all create a condition where no human activity, arguing for or against the number of people involved in filming a hoax, can be determined by the ground area where the film was made."

I invite any comments to consider before I post some form of remarks in a few days.

Bill
 
Last edited:
Greg

A simple explaniation of Patterson's choice of filming position involves the terrain he was filming on. He and the subject were seperated by debris and he either could have run to get to the clear patch she was taking or he could have continued to attempt to keep pace from his vantage point. He would have wasted a lot more time getting directly behind her and would have ended up with only somewhat more footage than he got from where he actually was. Gimlin with rifle behind Patty also helped insure that Patty was going to keep moving in the direction she began in. In the end what's a few seconds of film of a few trees?

Perhaps you should write a thesis on the inconsistancy of Roger Patterson's camera technique. Better yet ask a few professional wildlife photographers about how they deal with situations in the bush and filming animals exiting the scene.

That said you know the film is a fake so anything on it isn't going to make it any less fake.
 
Bill,

I only have one suggestion; everything else seems fine to me.

Finally, no actual evidence investigation specifically documenting the complete evidence of human activity on site was apparently conducted.

I suggest adding a comment specifying that Bob Titmus' investigation doesn't count (along with some reasons why), mainly so you don't have to deal with a deluge of "What about Bob Titmus?"-type comments.

Now I don't expect you to include this in your comment on the BFF, but I was curious as to your thoughts on the rain issue. One of the things that has me convinced that the film is a hoax is the fact that the tracks survived the heavy rain. I'm quite willing to consider that the tracks Titmus claimed were from Roger Patterson were those of someone else at the scene, but when I read stuff like this quote from Chris Murphy's PGF history:

They experienced great difficulties getting out of the area. The Bluff Creek road had caved away so they had to take the Onion Mountain route.

I've gotta wonder how the tracks survived in as good a condition (albeit not perfect) they were in. I could personally only see if happening if the tracks were (re)created long after the rain started, presumably after the originals were destroyed. Do you have any ideas on the matter?

Then again, Tube might be able to provide some insight on this, as I vaguely remember him commenting on leaving some tracks from his experiments exposed to the elements (although I don't think things were as severe as they were at Bluff Creek).

I should also note that Murphy's history of the film might not be entirely accurate, some of Murphy's claims contradict others who've weighed in on the issue (as noted here and, to a degree, here). I'd imagine that Dfoot would have some issues with the claim that Patterson and Gimlin sent the film via airplane, too.
 
AMM:

Thanks. I did write a brief phrase acknowledging the Bob Timus part,

On the other issue of the "Patty" prints and the rain, I will agree that their enduring the rain is curious. But I haven't even begun to get into those matters, (total learning curve overload here on the whole thing), so I can't offer any meaningful comment in that regard.

Bill
 
AMM:

Thanks. I did write a brief phrase acknowledging the Bob Timus part,

Ah, excellent.

On the other issue of the "Patty" prints and the rain, I will agree that their enduring the rain is curious. But I haven't even begun to get into those matters, (total learning curve overload here on the whole thing), so I can't offer any meaningful comment in that regard.

Fair enough. Please feel free to let us know when you get to that point on the matter.
 
AMM:

"My Quote:
On the other issue of the "Patty" prints and the rain, I will agree that their enduring the rain is curious. But I haven't even begun to get into those matters, (total learning curve overload here on the whole thing), so I can't offer any meaningful comment in that regard. "

(Your reply): Fair enough. Please feel free to let us know when you get to that point on the matter."

Given I've never even seen a cast footprint in person, never seen a trackway of impressions, and my real expertise in this regard is simply in general molding and casting with various gypsen plasters, any thoughts of mine on the intregity of plaster footprint casts is a long way off. About all I can contribute in this regard is issues about plaster itself.

But we'll see what the future holds.

Bill
 
AMM:

(and others here who may wish to comment on this)

The following is a draft of remarks I would like to add to my notes, specifically in connection to the ideas I had expressed about the prospect of a hoax being done by more than three people, and some expectation of evidence for that on the filming site.

"(Draft)
On the issue of human activity at the filming site in connection with the filming:

The reported rainfall after the proported filming day would reasonably be expected to degrade evidence on the ground of human filming activity. And the arrival of Mr. Laverty and a crew of workers on the scene after those rains, seeing the "Patty" footprints and investigating them, would have contaminated the site with additional evidence of human activity. Finally, no actual evidence investigation specifically documenting the complete evidence of human activity on site was apparently conducted.

So I would conclude that evidence from the actual filming site simply does not exist to make any determination of how many humans were present on the day of the filming, or what their activities may have been, in relation to the subject being filmed.

So in the matter of my previously stated opinion that some evidence at the filming site of a support crew might be expected, the reality is that the issues of the site, the rain, and the contamination in the days after, all create a condition where no human activity, arguing for or against the number of people involved in filming a hoax, can be determined by the ground area where the film was made."

I invite any comments to consider before I post some form of remarks in a few days.

Bill

When are you going to write your book?

Isn't that your whole reason for this hoax?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom