Correa Neto
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2003
- Messages
- 8,548
OK, but just keep in mind that misinterpretations may also be made by those whose opinions are more closely related to yours...Correa:
"I understand your position. One of the things I am trying to say is that it can be easilly misinterpreted as an argument from authority. "
We do agree here. That is why I try to explain my positions, with supporting facts, ideas, or examples. By giving the reader some basis to further research the issue, it empowers the listener to exercise some of their own logical authority or critical thinking, and make up their own mind.
As for being misintrepreted, to some extend that would seem to occur regardless of what a person perceived as an authority says. So I simply try in good faith to provide more information, so others can make up their minds.
Its essential for any debate, I belive. Experts are people. They can be wrong. I am an expert in my field, and more than once I was wrong. OK, that was my argument from authority."However, on the other hand, I do think we all have the right to disagree with experts, within their field of expertise, when the data and or the analysis presented are found lacking."
I support you here completely.
Perhaps this above isn't specifically On Topic for the PGF, but it is essential foundation for debating the PGF.
OK. There are plenty of specific (as well as not-so-specific) subjects. Here's some.But I do welcome the discussion returning to PGF specifics, as you do.
Bill
-What sort of traces one would expect three hoaxers (a camera operator, a costume helper and a performer) to have left? Could these traces be found (and propperly interpreted) later?
-Why different people have different perceptions of Patty? Why I perceive “a bloke in a gorilla suit” while others see a real animal?
-PGF resolution- what can be really seen? Can we really evaluate hair lenght and distribution, for example?
-What would it take to build and "animate" a "basic Patty", something which would do the job within PGF resolution?
-Costumes with short hairs and seams.
-[add preffered subject here]
