Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, and I wonder if is this the arm band picture that GT/CS mentioned earlier:

I am not a big fan at looking at details in these images since it is bordering on image resolution issues. The "armband" could also be light/shadow issues in the "fur" of "Bunny".

My contention continues to be where Sweaty determined that "Bunny's" arms are too long to be a human. I measured the length in frame 72 compared to the foot and height and it seems quite in the normal range of a human. I feel there are potential errors in my measurements but nothing that would show the arms being too long. IMO, the claim that "Bunny's" arms are too long is another one of those bigfoot myths that get passed around like the one about nobody being able to duplicate the "bunny" walk. It is repeated often enough that the proponents just state it as a matter of fact.
 
Its when the height falls between 6 & 8ft that one can entertain the idea that a reportage might be more than hot air.

What about the constant claims of extraordinary weights bolstered by supposed deep footprints that humans can't make?

A sasquatch that is 8 feet tall is certainly going to weigh more than your average human, but it also supposedly has much more foot surface area.

So why would it's feet sink any deeper than a human's in the same soil?

Even if we add 100 pounds to a sasquatch to account for it's muscular bulk compared to a human, it makes no sense.

We are told that Patty left 3.5 inch deep footprints at Bluff Creek while walking on 5" x 14.5" feet. We are told this by Bob Gimlin, who did an experiment at the site regarding the depth of the prints.

B: Some of them were down as far as three and a half inches deep into the softer soil. These particular ones we took here were, weren't quite so deep because they were flatter tracks.

Height chart for female sasquatches from Meet The Sasquatch by Murphy, Green and Steenburg. This is from 2004.

http://www.hancockhouse.com/products/product_images//MeeSas1.jpg
 
I am not a big fan at looking at details in these images since it is bordering on image resolution issues. The "armband" could also be light/shadow issues in the "fur" of "Bunny".

My contention continues to be where Sweaty determined that "Bunny's" arms are too long to be a human. I measured the length in frame 72 compared to the foot and height and it seems quite in the normal range of a human. I feel there are potential errors in my measurements but nothing that would show the arms being too long. IMO, the claim that "Bunny's" arms are too long is another one of those bigfoot myths that get passed around like the one about nobody being able to duplicate the "bunny" walk. It is repeated often enough that the proponents just state it as a matter of fact.

Just for a little history on the whole wristband thing. It really needs to be taken in context of how it was originally presented by Sweaty. He posted the pictures as beyond-a-doubt proof of bending fingers so I countered that they are beyond-a-doubt proof of a connection between the glove and the sleeve.

He has never offered an explanation for the crystal clear perfectly straight line between the glove and the sleeve yet he continues to jump up and down about bending fingers.:boggled:
 
Thanks for the vital info GC/CS, you think you are the only one waiting for an answer from Sweaty? Hah ha
 
Its when the height falls between 6 & 8ft that one can entertain the idea that a reportage might be more than hot air. You'll find that I questioned the immense heights very early on on BFF.

Bigfoot sighting hoaxer notes to self: Keep the height between 6-8 feet to maximize believability of phony story.
 
I don't even understand the basis of Sweety's argument. The red suit very obviously was not made to replicate Patty. Having shorter arms (if true) doesn't automatically lend itself to making proclamations about the authenticity of Patty.

This seems like more grasping for an argument, Sweety-style. ;)
 
I don't even understand the basis of Sweety's argument. The red suit very obviously was not made to replicate Patty. Having shorter arms (if true) doesn't automatically lend itself to making proclamations about the authenticity of Patty.

This seems like more grasping for an argument, Sweety-style. ;)

Ah, okay. I haven't been here long enough to recognize anyone's style yet.
 
AMM, I'm not making these claims, but I found these comparison photos of Patty's arm length and tube wearing a glove extension. I assume the glove gave tube an extra 4 inches of arm length. It looks like when their arm lengths are matched up, their elbows aren't -- providing Patty's elbow is located correctly. Also when the arm lengths are matched up, the legs don't seem to match. Likewise when the legs are matched up the heights don't. Their bodies seem similarly aligned so what's the deal? I don't get it. I found comparisons of Bob H that matched up with himself in the Morris costume. What kind of distortion is causing Patty to not match up? Any ideas?

 
While tube's elbow can be precisely located, the actual elbow of the mime inside of Patty cannot. I would suggest that the mime's elbow is somewhere within the blue circle that you used.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps. It's a safe bet that the mime's elbow is inside the blue circle. I haven't tried but the right arm appears to bend in enough frames to place the elbow relative to the arm bands. It might be informative to the arm length argument to locate it. But even if the elbow can't be placed what about the legs?
 
AMM, I'm not making these claims, but I found these comparison photos of Patty's arm length and tube wearing a glove extension. I assume the glove gave tube an extra 4 inches of arm length. It looks like when their arm lengths are matched up, their elbows aren't -- providing Patty's elbow is located correctly. Also when the arm lengths are matched up, the legs don't seem to match. Likewise when the legs are matched up the heights don't. Their bodies seem similarly aligned so what's the deal? I don't get it. I found comparisons of Bob H that matched up with himself in the Morris costume. What kind of distortion is causing Patty to not match up? Any ideas?

There are a lot of problems with aligning pictures of people with pictures of "bunny". The same thing can be said for 3D figures. Unless you precisely align the two images, you can make mistakes that might indicate one thing or the other. Not only do the two have to be properly aligned, they have to be in the proper position and seen from the same angle. A slight twist of the body can add or subtract length of the arms. A tip of the shoulders in one direction or another can also do the same. Add to this the problem with getting precise alignment positions on "Bunny". Where are the elbows, knees, waist, etc precisely at? Some are obvious, while others are not.

Lastly, if a suit is used it tends to sag and the landmarks may not be in the exact location the individual in the suit has them. For instance, the crotch/butt on "bunny" may sag but the actual individual in a "bunny" suit would have the crotch/butt much higher. Padding in the shoulders would tend to make the shoulders higher than the person in the suit. It all adds up to a potentially confusing, and misleading, scenario when people examine the film.

In your example, I do believe that if the knee of the person were bent a bit more forward then the top of the foot would be more properly aligned. This is just a guess and goes towards what I am saying. Aligning landmarks has to do with an exact match of the body that was inside the suit. Small variations can result in the problems you apparently are having.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps. It's a safe bet that the mime's elbow is inside the blue circle.

Yes, and it would still be a 'safe bet' even if the circle were smaller than it is. But your yellow dot is a point, not a circle.

I haven't tried but the right arm appears to bend in enough frames to place the elbow relative to the arm bands. It might be informative to the arm length argument to locate it.

If Patty's arms are padded sleeves covered with fur it could be difficult to precisely locate the mime's own elbow. I'm thinking of a thickly insulated down jacket. The sleeve (arm) does bend when the wearer bends their arm, but the elbow is deep inside the insulation. The "elbow" of the jacket sleeve may not perfectly coincide with that of the wearer. In fact, with some insulated jackets, you can bend your arm to some degree before the jacket arm even begins to bend - due to interior free space and/or insulation compression. Fur may even compound the illusion.

But even if the elbow can't be placed what about the legs?

It's a similar issue when you are dealing with a bulky padded suit.
 
Those comparison photos are from the BFF. I haven't tried to locate the elbow myself. Regardless of how bulky the suit is the arms and legs can only bend at the elbows and knees. Shoulder pads or a baggy crotch doesn't change that. By the same token it can't be claimed that the arms or legs are within human range. Either they can or can't be measured accurately. How would a suit hide the lower leg bone? Other comparisons I've seen of tube and dfoot with Patty seem to show the same thing. They can't seem to get the leg bend to match. I just find it curious that the misalignment appears consistent. I suspect those that claim Patty is within human proportions aren't posting the results. I would think that trying to nail down the position of the joints would be crucial to determining the mime's dimensions. Also it might be informative to see how/if tube's various body positions distorts his own proportions. The only way to make any claims is to measure the images. Surely we can match the body orientation for some of these frames.
 
This is crude and exaggerated. The brown arm is the Patty costume arm, and the blue one belongs to the mime.


ddc09b2c.jpg
 
Yikes, crude and exaggerated is right. :eek: I think you need a better illustration to make your point. If you exaggerate less, then the only way I can see to disguise the bend in the elbow is with a hard hinged false elbow. But this seems overly complicated to me. Who would bother? Maybe dfoot can enlighten us how a false elbow is done. But even with your drawing the joint appears to be at the center of the arm at the bend. Maybe even a bit lower.
 
My yucky drawing wasn't about the elbow location issue. It was about false arm length based on shoulder padding and a mime hand that doesn't fully enter the costume hand.

Nonethess, I think the mime elbow could be moved around (within a cut-away illustration like this) and still make the costume arm work like an arm.
 
I agree that shoulder pads/prosthetic arms/hand extensions could conceivably create a longer arm which bends at the right place. Kinda complicated though. But I thought it hadn't been established that the arm is long. I do tend to think that the arm does create the illusion that it is longer than normal. The swing and range of the arm seem to indicate this. I always thought that the arm proportions would be easier to disguise than the legs. I think the knees would be tricky.

Also, the wrist bands might present a problem for any hand extensions. They look a bit narrow to contain the mime's hands. Especially if the mime is moving the fingers.

Just trying to sort it all out.
 
Those comparison photos are from the BFF. I haven't tried to locate the elbow myself. Regardless of how bulky the suit is the arms and legs can only bend at the elbows and knees. Shoulder pads or a baggy crotch doesn't change that. By the same token it can't be claimed that the arms or legs are within human range. Either they can or can't be measured accurately. How would a suit hide the lower leg bone? Other comparisons I've seen of tube and dfoot with Patty seem to show the same thing. They can't seem to get the leg bend to match. I just find it curious that the misalignment appears consistent. I suspect those that claim Patty is within human proportions aren't posting the results. I would think that trying to nail down the position of the joints would be crucial to determining the mime's dimensions. Also it might be informative to see how/if tube's various body positions distorts his own proportions. The only way to make any claims is to measure the images. Surely we can match the body orientation for some of these frames.

However, zeroing in on those features are what is the problem. You may find the knee at a certain point but it could be slightly off. It is a subjective measurement and a suit could easily obscure the actual placement of the knee as demonstrated by some of the suits previously shown here in this thread.


I have stated the arm is within normal proportions by simply measuring the length of the arm in pixels. You can see what I stated here. I am not sure where you get the idea that people aren't posting results that show that "aunt bunny" is within normal proportions.

Based on what I measured, the length of the arm is well within normal proportions since it is essentially straight. If you want to lengthen the arm to inhuman proportion, then you need to shrink the size of the feet to human proportions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom