Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Another conceptual drawing.

7ef3e258.jpg
 
Here are a few things that are not my opinion, Astro...

1) The object moves upward while the subject's arm moves downward.
The animated gifs show that unambiguously.

2) Masks don't lift up under their own power.


2) The lifted object is too massive to be a simple mask....

http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/frame1liftaaa2.jpg

http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/frame1pixels1OutLnd33.jpg

http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/frame1pixels1OutLnd22.jpg


The "lifted mask" theory is simply....a load of crap. It was created purely as an alternative to a "Bigfoot w/infant" explanation.
The fact of the matter is....more than one person on the hillside that day said they saw the creature at fairly close range....including Owen Pate. That was the reason he had Lori get the camcorder out...to get it on tape if it reappeared....which it did. :)

Another detail we can be quite sure of, is that the Pate's had nothing to do with creating this video as a hoax.
Lori's father, Larry, has been actively posting on Bigfoot forums since this video was shot. The reason for that is simple...he's become interested in the subject of Bigfoot, since his daughter and son-in-law saw a real live Bigfoot, in person. ;)


Again.....the mask explanation falls short of explaining all the various little details surrounding this sighting/filming event. But if it makes the skeptics feel good...go right ahead and play make-believe.

I plan on making a comparable video which will show that the lifted object was, in no way, a mask. :)






Could you provide a link to that post of yours, Astro...or at least tell me what page it was on? I'd appreciate it...it would save me a lot of time hunting for it.

In the meantime....in this comparison image...Patty's arms sure look a bit longer than the other guy's....

http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Gorilla Suits/HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg

Unless the current deal I'm working on takes up my time next month I'll have a chance to edit "PROJECT PATTY" for YouTube and show you a few things.

For now all I can offer is this humble photo of a man walking and then turning slightly to his left. Camera stays in the same precise position and never moves.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/LetusNoticethosearms.jpg

My God, the Cookie Monster used to figure this stuff out better than Bigfooters can. It's crap like this that hurts anyone trying to seriously look into this legend.

Thus, I must wear shades just to post about it.:cool:
 
WP:

"Bill and/or Dfoot should be in a position to support or deny those concepts as they would apply to the real world of working costumes."

On the foot thing, here's a basic starting point.

If you walk in a way that you raise and lower the feet more or less straight up and down (like "stamping" the foot), you can change the size of the foot quite a lot and still walk. All you do, if you increase the size of the foot, is increase the surface area on the ground, and if your body weight is the same, the foot pressure (in pounds per square inch) is diminished, and the foot will make a shallower impression in any soft ground material you are walking on. But the walking part is not hindered.

But if you are walking with a "rolling" step, where the heel touches down first with the forward step, then rolls until the foot is fully flat (as your body is directly over the foot) and then the foot bends at the ball, lifting up the heel and leaving the ball and toes pressed to the ground for the "push off", this type of walking can be complicated by foot structures which stick out further forward or backward.

Just a generalization here, but the more you increase the size of the artificial foot over the real foot, the more likely the person walking must adjust to the "stamping" walk to manage. Like walking around a pool with swimfins on.

From here, there are multiple considerations of an artificial foot design, the physical agility of the person wearing it, and the amount of practice the person has, which would determine how successfully a person could walk with artificial feet and simulate a rolling walk. So the stamping walk is the easier. The rolling walk would take more practice.

On the mechanics of artificial feet with bending sections and devices to control the bending, I'll defer that to others who have done more with it.

Bill
 
Those statements are a perfect example of what I mean.

If you had taken a good look at the animated gif showing that the object lifts up after the subject has let go of it...and also considered all the eyewitness testimonies from that day, and the conversation that was going on during the filming....you'd know that the video cannot show a "can of corn...a backpack...a club"...or just anything.

The fact of the matter is.....the explanation which best fits all the many details of this event, is the Bigfoot w/infant explanation.

The problem continues to be is that there is not one iota of evidence in that video that says "this is an infant". You are drawing a conclusion based on what you want to believe and not in what the data says. The data does not show an infant. It shows a blurry object that can be just about anything. You can continue to state it is the best explanation but it is not.
 
The problem continues to be is that there is not one iota of evidence in that video that says "this is an infant". You are drawing a conclusion based on what you want to believe and not in what the data says. The data does not show an infant. It shows a blurry object that can be just about anything. You can continue to state it is the best explanation but it is not.


If you really think that the lifted object could be "anything", Astro...then there's nothing more I can show you in the stills and animated gifs, that can help you to understand what's going on in the video.

But, for the sake of the rest of the blind skeptics on this board...in support of my claim that the object in question lifts up after the subject has let go of it....here's the 2-frame animated gif that shows that upward movement, unambiguously...;)...

LIFT02b.gif



For context...the whole lift sequence...


CompleteLift1AB.gif


Think whatever you like about it, Astro! :)
 
There's no use arguing with Sweaty, his mind is made up, it has been for a long time and it can't be changed. Bows and flows of angel hair and all that.....
After all if Noll says it's a bigfoot that's good enough for him.

One question Sweaty.
What do you think of the idea that there was a pod of BF's up there that day?
According to Lori's father, per his conversations with Owen, there had to be in order for the witness statements to be true.
 
Think whatever you like about it, Astro!

I just want to see something else other than a blurry blob that suggests it is actually an infant. So far, the evidence for your claim that it is a living infant bigfoot is inadequate and is based on your biased interpretation of a blob. It is not a careful and critical evaluation of the evidence. It is based on a "will to believe" and nothing more.

Like I said previously, I have read opinions by bigfoot proponents that state this is a hoax. To me that says a lot about the video because if you can not convince a bigfoot proponent that it is authentic, how can you convince everybody else?
 
I just want to see something else other than a blurry blob that suggests it is actually an infant. So far, the evidence for your claim that it is a living infant bigfoot is inadequate and is based on your biased interpretation of a blob. It is not a careful and critical evaluation of the evidence. It is based on a "will to believe" and nothing more.


You say that my analysis is not a "careful and critical evaluation of the evidence", Astro....but I noticed that you didn't point out even one specific flaw in any of my statements concerning what the evidence shows.

For instance....I said that the 2-frame animated gif unambiguously shows the lifted object moves upward after the visible arm can be seen moving downwards.
Is that not true? Is the line in the second frame higher than the line in the first frame?

There are several other things I could ask you about....but I won't, because it simply doesn't matter what your opinion is about the MD Video.
All that really matters is what someone has to contribute in the way of actual analysis...or counter-analysis.

Apparantly you're not interested in doing that.
 
Last edited:
You say that my analysis is not a "careful and critical evaluation of the evidence", Astro....but I noticed that you didn't point out even one specific flaw in any of my statements concerning what the evidence shows.

I have moved my comments to the thread on this if you want to discuss it further. Meanwhile, you continue to avoid the discussion concerning the analysis of the arm length of "bunny", which you claim is too long to be human. Tick...Tock..the world wonders.
 
I'm not sure if this video clip has already been posted in this thread.


Stan Winston talks about the PGF:

Basically it's walking like a man. It's a guy in a bad hair suit. Sorry. For a few hundred dollars they could have done this. For under a thousand dollars in that day (1967), they probably could have had this suit made. If one of my colleagues created this for a movie, he'd be out of business.


Then Janos Prohaska from many years earlier:

(Asked if it would be possible to create the costume) That would be a difficult... I don't think so. (Now speaking of prepping the costumed mime in such a suit) It would take about ten hours... the whole make-up job. And it looked to me very, very real. (I've been doing this now) since 1939... and if that was a costume, that was the best I have ever seen.
 
ATOMIC MYSTERY MONSTER -- I'd be happy to repost any pics to show how easy it is to change the joint position.

If you'll look closely at Patty you'll see that Bob H's own elbow SLIDES up and down past the elbow pad of the suit arm.

The upper body section stays stiffly in place as he moves as if carrying a backpack around. All of that is pretty normal for that type of two sectioned monster suit with the hands and feet already attached.

On the foot thing: I thought about going into a long-winded discussion of elastic hydrocarbon polymers being used as a colloidal suspension and gradually move into my thoughts on foot structure locomotion within vulcanized synthetic monster feet - but that would be ridiculous.:rolleyes:

In order to be less ridiculous I'll simply relay real-world experience to anyone reading this... It's a rubber foot 14 1/2 inches long worn by a man who wears a size 9 shoe (a 9 1/2 inch long human foot).

His foot inside the big monster foot looked like this:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/PRINT-sandbluffcopy.jpg

I'm having a tough time getting photobucket to accept video, so I'll show how a stuntman wearing big monster feet walks down the street and how that matches the supposed "impossible gait" cited by scientists with access to Poser when I get around to making that YouTube documentary. Till then, check out the way my stuntman's foot was bending here:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/LEE-foot-webcopy.jpg

His foot is actually straight and cannot bend that way. But, of course, the rubber foot can and does. Joints work that way too. Your shoulder or elbow MIGHT NOT be anywhere near the bending part of the suit. So anyone who draws lines on a suit thinking he's following the internal skeletal structure is fooling himself. It doesn't work that way.

Speaking of that mid-tarsal bend:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/185.jpg

Both of those prints were made by my boots. In the top one I seem to have a "mid-tarsal break" but of course that's impossible. However, if I were to add some rubber over the boot and some toes then I'd have a decent Bigfoot print in the sand suitable for Bigfoot convention lectures.

Here's something else to look for regarding boots:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/BingerSTEP2.jpg

We all know who cast that famous plaster. But I have to wonder if he ever considered the boot print in the mud matching the print inside his own cast. I've seen that kind of thing happen before - to myself. Once I was wearing a thinner pair of monster feet for a stunt and I shoved my Hi-Tech stunt boots inside the rubber feet. I noticed that on a couple of footprints the letters "Hi-Tech" showed through along with the ridges of my boot sole. It happens. That's why we usually wear flat soled shoes or go barefoot inside these thinner type feet.

Janos' bear feet would bend exactly like Patty's.
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/1.jpg

Here's one of Charlie Gemora's feet in 1930 when he was captured by "Our Gang":
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/bearshooter-2.jpg
That foot looks awfully familiar. Is it possible that someone using 1930's technology could produce Patty's feet? Yeah. Sure is.

And this one shows Rick Baker's "Harry and Henderson's" foot next to a rubber alien monster foot from the 50's. Both have dermal ridges, but Harry is more natural and the alien is more... well... Bigfoot-like (if you are going with the latest pseudoscience dermal theory from Chilcutt/Meldrum).

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/FOOTCOMPcopy.jpg
The one on the far right is my personal favorite though. It's a mold used to make fake feet. Looks a lot like one from Bluff Creek in '58. But who would have thought to use fake feet back then? Hoaxers just aren't that smart (I'm told).


But in the end we can see that Patty's feet are pretty easy to make. Even a cowboy like me can do it.
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/Patterson_Dfoot-first.jpg


Bill Munns -- All suit talk aside, I was wondering if you'd gotten around to finding out the answers to these questions:

1) Where did Gimlin say he mailed the film from and at what time?

2) What time did Al Hodgson say the film was mailed off to DeAtley and from where?

3) Whose name did DeAtley finally come up with to describe how the film got to him?

Those are questions that have to be answered at the start of any investigation into this matter. I was given incorrect answers by Bigfooters when I started. That's why now I search out all info for myself. I cannot take any Bigfoot researchers word for anything regarding this subject, unfortunately. There is too much emotional attachment there.
 
Dfoot:

"Bill Munns -- All suit talk aside, I was wondering if you'd gotten around to finding out the answers to these questions:

1) Where did Gimlin say he mailed the film from and at what time?

2) What time did Al Hodgson say the film was mailed off to DeAtley and from where?

3) Whose name did DeAtley finally come up with to describe how the film got to him?"


My answer to all three questions is: "I'm not investigating these men or their activities. "

Just curious. Did I ever say I was looking for answers to these questions? I sure don't recall such.

I'm investigating one issue: "Can studies of suit material dynamics and suit design determine if the PG figure is a suit?

That's it. Nothing else. Nada. Zip. Don't care who DeAtley or Hodgson are, what they did, or when.

:)

Bill
 
Dfoot said:
I'd be happy to repost any pics to show how easy it is to change the joint position.

That'd be great; thanks! I seem to recall one of an arm in a sleeve with a false elbow (it looked like a cycler's safety pad) and a large version of the picture that appears at about 00:28 seconds in this video of behind-the-scenes pictures of gorilla suits.

Oh, and if at all possible, please note the movie/tv show/etc. that they were used in so I can see if there are any clips of them in action on Youtube.

I'm not sure if this video clip has already been posted in this thread.

Yeah, I've posted it a few times. I'm glad you brought it up, though, as it reminded me that I found another video containing more comments by Prohaska (about 02:45 into the clip). There's also a scene later in the video where someone claims that the gait is inhuman. It wouldn't surprise me if this is the origin of the whole "inhuman gait" argument.
 
ATOMIC MYSTERY MONSTER - That pic is from a suit used in the movie BUDDY. I used it to demonstrate how the legs can be made to appear shorter and how the shoulder of the suit-wearer can be deeper inside the suit and have nothing to do with the shoulder pad that's usually drawn on as if it were the real joint of the arm.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/GORILLA-BUDDY-SUIT-webcopy.jpg

Maybe this is the elbow thing you mentioned:
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/MOTOBACK-DEMOweb2.jpg
That's just an illustration of how an elbow bend can be higher or lower on the person wearing it. If the suit is loose enough on the arm of the wearer (as Patty's is) then the real elbow joint of the wearer can slide up and down. If the pad is lower the upper arm seems longer. IF the pad is higher than the person's actual arm inside the suit he can still bend and swing the suit arm but the elbow joint seems too high and the forearm too long. Just a visual of how that happens sometimes.

But here is our Patty and the red indicates where soft pads are located.
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/PattyArmPADdemo-web.jpg
The green shows where the "skin" of Patty bunches up as the arm swings. This is because the "skin" is glued to the back structure and probably stitched at the circular area around the scapula pad. The scapula pad area is left loose and this gives that "muscle masses moving" look we keep hearing about.

I was able to demonstrate this as well as the "bubble hernia" effect when I marched across my backyard wearing that foam under a tee-shirt "skin". I don't know if many people interested in Patty really got it though.

BILL -Don't worry. No one is claiming you said anything about having investigated the PG film's origins. I'm just asking you simple questions and relaying to you the importance of looking into the answers.

For example: You were asked on the interview show about Bob Heironimus claiming the suit was made of horsehide. You answered as best you could. When it was over Bigfooters declared that YOU had pointed out to them that Bob H. was definitely a liar as this was not what you thought you were looking at.

The new "factoid" becomes, "Hollywood expert rules out Bob H's horsehide claims. Munns proves Heironimus is a liar." Of course, you never said that you only tried to answer a question and give your opinion. But by not knowing anything about the PG film and the various misunderstandings being touted as facts you become the victim of the same sort of "quoting" that you saw me become a victim of a few days back. (By you - btw):)

That's what I was trying to spare you all along.

Heironimus said that HIS BROTHER was TOLD BY ROGER about this horsehide business when Howard asked Roger where he got the suit. That's the story. Heironimus himself has been told several different things as to where the suit came from (Hollywood, Roger himself, and now Morris) but he has always said that he never asked Roger about it. He just wore the damn thing.

This is the same thing that happened with the "long list" of people lined up claiming to have worn the suit that we keep hearing about. The fact is that a couple of people have claimed that they thought they knew who wore it, but NO ONE had ever come forward and said, "Yeah. It was me." Not until Bob Heironimus himself stepped forward. Yet people around Yakima always knew this since he, Gimlin and Patterson pulled the hoax.

That's the kind of misinformation I was made a victim of and now I'm being quoted about - from way back when I actually believed what I was told by people I assumed were experts on the subject.

So here are the answers:

1) Gimlin said that AFTER he and Roger spent time with Hodgson they drove to the EUREKA POST OFFICE and air-mailed the film to DeAtley at 9 pm. PROBLEM? The post office was already closed.

2) Hodgson said that Roger told him they'd JUST GOTTEN BACK from the EUREKA POST OFFICE when he met them at 6:30 pm. They stayed there until they returned to their camp later that night. PROBLEM? That too doesn't fit with the things Patterson and Gimlin claimed went on prior to getting to the store. There simply wasn't enough time.

3) DeAtley always said he couldn't recall anything about the film, but one day he did give an explanation when told that the Post Office in Eureka would have been closed and neither Patterson's nor Gimlin's story matched reality. DeAtley then claimed his pilot had brought the film to him in his plane as he often ran such errands. PROBLEM? The pilot DeAtley used wasn't even in the USA all that year.

4) And finally, Bigfooters decided that the only thing to do is to claim that Gimlin couldn't tell the difference between the downtown Eureka Post Office and a local airport and so they must have had it specially flown from there. PROBLEM? Records show that NO PLANE flew anything to Washington at all that entire weekend.

All of that is just some info you should consider. Especially if you still can't see seams or pads evident in the film. Like me, you'll find yourself years later wondering why you didn't see what all the top creature suit guys saw all along from the beginning.

I'd also assumed Green was right about the weight of the creature that walked on Bluff Creek and Blue Mountain roads. I'd only seen one photo of the footprint and I simply accepted his word that he and others had investigated the prints and found them impossible to have been made by wooden feet. THEN I saw the clear photos posted by Rick Noll on BFF. I was shocked at how silly they really were. I had simply believed they knew what they were talking about.
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/straightstrider.jpg
http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/John2BGreen2B2.jpg

Many photos clearly show that these are simply stamped into the soft dirt and anyone's boot print presses just as far into the earth as these stamped tracks. So what the hell were they talking about all these years? They were living through wishful thinking and not critically looking at the evidence in front of them.

As Al DeAtley said, "They didn't want to know the truth." Well... I don't know about you but I'm interested in the truth. Whatever it is.
 
Last edited:
It seems to be an almost total meltdown and abandonment of the PGF on BFF. The 'old guard' proponents seem to have vanished or gone silent.

I can hardly find any active PGF proponent forum discussions, and this isn't just the BFF. The batch of new faces seem terribly ignorant of the situation with there being so much damaging evidence and rational skepticism towards this film. Has the whole PGF support system social network gone underground, or switched to email exchange?
 
It seems to be an almost total meltdown and abandonment of the PGF on BFF. The 'old guard' proponents seem to have vanished or gone silent.

I can hardly find any active PGF proponent forum discussions, and this isn't just the BFF. The batch of new faces seem terribly ignorant of the situation with there being so much damaging evidence and rational skepticism towards this film. Has the whole PGF support system social network gone underground, or switched to email exchange?


William P - I honestly feel that the arguments we've put forth here have had some impact on the PG film hoax. I'm amazed at how many people so quickly found the little quick edit I put on YouTube. It only shows a flash of the material with no explanation given. It was as if a bunch of Bigfooters rushed over to see it the minute it went up.

In May if I can make a documentary laying out what we've found step by step I think it can remain there as something skeptics and believers can click over to when arguing over this. It really helps seeing and hearing these things as opposed to just arguing in print.

With that in mind, here's part of an article taken from an autobiography written in 1917 concernng the writer's visit to the famous CARDIFF GIANT. These things tend to pop up every so often don't they? It does sound familiar...

(quote)

But in the autumn [1] of 1869 this peaceful region was in commotion from one end to the other. Strange reports echoed from farm to farm. It was noised abroad that a great stone statue or petrified giant had been dug up near the little hamlet of Cardiff, almost at the southern extremity of the valley; and soon, despite the fact that the crops were not yet gathered in, and the elections not yet over, men and women and children were hurrying from Syracuse and from the farm-houses along the valley to the scene of the great discovery.

I had been absent in a distant State for some weeks, and, on my return to Syracuse, meeting one of the most substantial citizens, a highly respected deacon in the Presbyterian Church, formerly a county judge, I asked him, in a jocose way, about the new object of interest, fully expecting that he would join me in a laugh over the whole matter; but, to my surprise, he became at once very solemn. He said, "I assure you that this is no laughing matter; it is a very serious thing, indeed; there is no question that an amazing discovery has been made, and I advise you to go down and see what you think of it."

Next morning, my brother and myself were speeding, after a fast trotter in a light buggy, through the valley to the scene of the discovery; and as we went we saw more and more, on every side, evidences of enormous popular interest. The roads were crowded with buggies, carriages, and even omnibuses from the city, and with lumber-wagons from the farms–all laden with passengers. In about two hours we arrived at the Newell farm and found a gathering which at first sight seemed like a county fair. In the midst was a tent, and a crowd was pressing for admission. Entering, we saw a large pit or grave, and, at the bottom of it, perhaps five feet below the surface, an enormous figure, apparently of Onondaga gray limestone. It was a stone giant, with massive features, the whole body nude, the limbs contracted as if in agony. It had a color as if it had lain long in the earth, and over its surface were minute punctures, like pores. An especial appearance of great age was given it by deep grooves and channels in its under side, apparently worn by the water which flowed in streams through the earth and along the rock on which the figure rested. Lying in its grave, with the subdued light from the roof of the tent falling upon it, and with the limbs contorted as if in a death struggle, it produced a most weird effect. An air of great solemnity pervaded the place. Visitors hardly spoke above a whisper.

Coming out, I asked some questions, and was told that the farmer who lived there had discovered the figure when digging a well. Being asked my opinion, my answer was that the whole matter was undoubtedly a hoax; that there was no reason why the farmer should dig a well in the spot where the figure was found; that it was convenient neither to the house nor to the barn; that there was already a good spring and a stream of water running conveniently to both; that, as to the figure itself, it certainly could not have been carved by any prehistoric race, since no part of it showed the characteristics of any such early work; that, rude as it was, it betrayed the qualities of a modern performance of a low order.
Nor could it be a fossilized human being; in this all scientific observers of any note agreed. There was ample evidence, to one who had seen much sculpture, that it was carved, and that the man who carved it, though by no means possessed of genius or talent, had seen casts, engravings, or photographs of noted sculptures. The figure, in size, in massiveness, in the drawing up of the limbs, and in its roughened surface, vaguely reminded one of Michelangelo's "Night and Morning." Of course, the difference between this crude figure and those great Medicean statues was infinite; and yet it seemed to me that the man who had carved this figure must have received a hint from those.

It was also clear that the figure was neither intended to be considered as an idol nor as a monumental statue. There was no pedestal of any sort on which it could stand, and the disposition of the limbs and their contortions were not such as any sculptor would dream of in a figure to be set up for adoration. That it was intended to be taken as a fossilized giant was indicated by the fact that it was made as nearly like a human being as the limited powers of the stone-carver permitted, and that it was covered with minute imitations of pores.

Therefore it was that, in spite of all scientific reasons to the contrary, the work was very generally accepted as a petrified human being of colossal size, and became known as "the Cardiff Giant."

One thing seemed to argue strongly in favor of its antiquity, and I felt bound to confess, to those who asked my opinion, that it puzzled me. This was the fact that the surface water flowing beneath it in its grave seemed to have deeply grooved and channeled it on the under side. Now the Onondaga gray limestone is hard and substantial, and on that very account used in the locks upon the canals: for the running of surface water to wear such channels in it would require centuries.

Against the opinion that the figure was a hoax various arguments were used. It was insisted, first, that the farmer had not the ability to devise such a fraud; secondly, that he had not the means to execute it; third, that his family had lived there steadily for many years, and were ready to declare under oath that they had never seen it, and had known nothing of it until it was accidentally discovered; fourth, that the neighbors had never seen or heard of it; fifth, that it was preposterous to suppose that such a mass of stone could have been brought and buried in the place without some one finding it out; sixth, that the grooves and channels worn in it by the surface water proved its vast antiquity.

To these considerations others were soon added. Especially interesting was it to observe the evolution of myth and legend. Within a week after the discovery, full-blown statements appeared to the effect that the neighboring Indians had abundant traditions of giants who formerly roamed over the hills of Onondaga; and, finally, the circumstantial story was evolved that an Onondaga squaw had declared, "in an impressive manner," that the statue "is undoubtedly the petrified body of a gigantic Indian prophet who flourished many centuries ago and foretold the coming of the palefaces, ana who, just before his own death, said to those about him that their descendants would see him again." [2] To this were added the reflections of many good people who found it an edifying confirmation of the biblical text, "There were giants in those days." There was, indeed, as undercurrent of skepticism among the harder heads in the valley, but the prevailing opinion in the region at large was more and more in favor of the idea that the object was a fossilized human being–a giant of "those days." Such was the rush to see the figure that the admission receipts were very large: it was even stated that they amounted to five per cent upon three millions of dollars, and soon came active men from the neighboring region who proposed to purchase the figure and exhibit it through the country. A leading spirit in this "syndicate" deserves mention. He was a horse-dealer in a large way and banker in a small way from a village in the next county,–a man keen and shrewd, but merciful and kindly, who had fought his way up from abject poverty, and whose fundamental principle, as he asserted it, was "Do unto others as they would like to do unto you, and–do it fust. [3] A joint-stock concern was formed with a considerable capital, and an eminent showman, "Colonel" Wood, employed to exploit the wonder.

A week after my first visit I again went to the place, by invitation. In the crowd on that day were many men of light and leading from neighboring towns,–among them some who made pretensions to scientific knowledge. The figure, lying in its grave, deeply impressed all; and as a party of us came away, a very excellent doctor of divinity, pastor of one of the largest churches in Syracuse, said very impressively, "Is it not strange that any human being, after seeing this wonderfully preserved figure, can deny the evidence of his senses, and refuse to believe, what is so evidently the fact, that we have here a fossilized human being, perhaps one of the giants mentioned in Scripture?"
Another visitor, a bright-looking lady, was heard to declare, "Nothing in the world can ever make me believe that he was not once a living being. Why, you can see the veins in his legs." (unquote)

- From Andrew White's Autobiography
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom