Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
blah blah blah genius, YOU made the claims, back them up or follow your own advice. The mere fact you want me to tread all your wittle posts shows me you be a troll..... not an especially good one either.

Ok so I'm a troll. Report me to the troll police.
 
Here is my response to your post...from a while ago, kitty....


kitakaze wrote:
Something between 0 and 100% is not in other words 'a reasonable chance'. They are not synonymous.

Actually, kitty, they are synonomous.

Evidence is weighed in terms of "probabilities"....and 'probabilities' refers to a chance of something being true (anywhere from a 'less than 1% chance'...all the way up to a '100% chance') A "chance" based on reason...which, stated differently, is a "reasonable chance".

For a piece of evidence to carry "weight"...it does not need to be "reliable"....because evidence doesn't necessarily mean that something is, in fact, true.....only that there is a percentage of probability that it is true.

You keep talking about evidence being "reliable"...but "reliable" is only required if we need to know that the subject of the evidence is true.
We don't need to know that Bigfoot exists for the evidence to simply indicate a chance that it exists.

Evidence can exist in any strength...from very weak, to very strong...indicating a chance of something being true, from very low, to very high.

The reason you can only refer to evidence in terms of it being "reliable", kitty, is simply because you, like all the other Robo-Skeptics here, are only interested in evidence which "proves" that Bigfoot exists. You cannot acknowledge, and weigh, evidence which simply indicates a 'chance' that Bigfoot exists.

You can only repeat the ONE, basic party-line... "The....evidence....is....not....reliable....it....does....not....prove....Bigfoot....exists".


And still you do not explain how you measure these probabilities. We'd love to hear your math but you won't give it because you don't have it.


Measuring the weight of a piece of evidence can be done roughly, as in 'small probability', or 'high probability'....and it can also be done more precisely, with numbers....but that requires much more complex calculating...and involves doing studies on the odds of something being mis-identified, or hoaxed.



The only conclusion that one can come to concerning the submitted evidence for the claim of bigfoot's existence is that in every case it is insufficient, unreliable, and in no instance points more towards a living bigfoot than a mundane cause. One can not hope to combine this poor evidence in an effort to create strong. You are in denial of weak coffee.


Spoken like a good Robot. :wink:


I have already dismantled this erroneous argument here...


Originally Posted by SweatyYeti
"Approximately 100 Million acres are designated as wilderness in the United States. This accounts for (only) 4.71% of the total land of the country..."



This is part of the 'remote fallacy'. That figure does not necessarily entail that all of that area is either appropriate to conceal a population of 8ft giant bipedal primates from classification by humans or support the dietary needs of such a hypothetical beast. On top of that we must keep in mind people such as bf2006 and Joyce's and their accounts telling us of bigfoots that will brazenly come into human populations.

....Much of the body of the alledged bigfoot reports come from areas that see significant human activity. Many bigfoot reports come from human inhabitated areas. We've seen at least three members here that report bigfoots in the immediate vicnity of human homes in well populated areas. The quality of these reports is no more reliable than any report that comes from a more remote area.



So....you've "dismantled" the idea that millions and millions of acres of wilderness in the U.S. is enough land for a small population of intellegent Primates to, for the most part, avoid human contact.

Well, you've convinced me, kitty! Clearly, it's impossible! :boggled:



I have made a detailed examination of indigenous NA myths and traditions. I have found not a single one that reliably correlates to bigfoot. I and others contributing to that examination have completely debunked many of the claims regarding this subject.


Good work, kitty! :)

While the Native Americans legends of Sasquatch can't be reliably (known to be) linked to Bigfoot....there is still a chance that they did refer to a real creature.

Wouldn't you agree??


I myself have determined the likelihood of bigfoot's existence to be extremely unlikely given the extreme poor quality of the evidence thus far submitted. That determination at the very least requires reliable evidence to be changed in favour of bigfoot's existence.


You mean "proof", kitty. ;) That's all you need to acknowledge that some of the evidence for Bigfoot carries a moderate amount of weight......right?


SweatyYeti wrote:
It's such a silly suit...:xtongue...so silly, in fact, that nobody seems to be able to re-create it.

Don't forget, Mad Hom....it's extremely easy to say Patty is a "silly suit".....yet so ridiculously tough to reproduce!



Busted! Back five spaces! 1000 footer points deducted! You think you can just try slipping that by again? You are absolutely desperate to try that again.

You know full well that this tactic is unacceptable without first identifying how many concerted efforts have been made to reproduce the PGF and it's subject. Also you have yet to specify how this could be accomplished given the lack of resolution, how to measure a success, and how you define the 'realism' you attribute to Patty. You, Sweaty, are absolutely one of the weakest debaters I have ever seen.


If the PG film "obviously" shows a man-in-a-suit....then why do we need such a "concerted effort" to reproduce it??

The "suit" is, allegedly, so laughable...yet apparantly much time, money, and effort would be required to reproduce it.
That simply doesn't make any sense.



Show me one instance of a claim of bigfoot evidence where a mundane cause is not more probable than one involving a living Bigfoot. Don't even try the PGF until you've substantiated your empty arguments.



One quick example....the Memorial Day Video.

The lifted object moves upwards apparantly under it's own power...hence...it's alive. A "living Bigfoot" is a more likely explanation for the lifted object, than a non-living mask.

Conversely, the "lifted-mask" theory is not the more probable explanation for the lift...because of the reason stated above, and also for the reason that a mask would not be "massive" enough to account for the mass of the lifted object.
A thin mask would barely even show-up at that low resolution, combined with the light-colored background.
The apparant mass of the object is more in-line with an infant's body.
__________________
 
Last edited:
Bill: I love all of those suits.

Still... your work is based on what you learned and did AFTER that time period. When I said you had zero experience with two-sectioned fur suits, it's not meant to be an insult. I'm saying it because that's what you have said. You said you'd never seen one before. Thus, zero experience.

I suggest going back to before you were in the business. That's what I had to do in order to track down the source of the Patterson suit. Study what they did and duplicate that. Forget what you have done since '69.

Right now I'm listening to you on "Let's Talk Bigfoot" and it's mostly about things that have nothing whatsoever to do with the Patterson suit. It's like discussing the "Cottingley Faerie" photos by going over the intricate structure of moth wings. By the time it's over people think they've just been instructed on how the Fairies could be real because moths are just so complex. Yet the actual Faerie photo was never really discussed. Amazing. And they eat it up too.

The real reason the quotes seemed so positive (to Bigfooters) from Hollywood back then has to do with the people writing the books and articles. And no one is saying the PG film is fake today because they are in "competition" with others or afraid of being embarrassed. That is ridiculous.

Here's what happened back then: Ken Petersen was one of those "positive quotes". He was quoted by Green extensively. He was actually an executive in charge of Mickey Mouse artists. He had nothing to do with suits at all. And all he did was say those famous words that "If it's fake it's better than what we could do." Straight from a man that had never touched a creature suit in his life to your ears thanks to John Green.

Green and others looked for any kind word and used that to promote the PG film as real. THAT is what was happening back then.

Pat Mason said he got nice compliments on the PG film when he tried to sell it, but they ALWAYS said it was fake in the end. That has since been twisted by Bigfoot writers to mean that it couldn't have been faked. They would take the "nice-work" compliment part of the conversation and leave out the bit where they tell him it's a fake.

I know for a fact that various creature fx experts were not quoted BECAUSE they said it was just a suit. I know because they told me about having to sit and watch the film in a screening room and laughing out loud that anyone thought it was real. The Bigfoot writers didn't like what they had to say and instead searched out little quotes here and there from other people trying to be polite to them.

One of the film processors questioned about the film's development said he refused to talk to Bigfoot writers anymore because they tended to change the meaning of what he said to them.

THAT is how it works Bill. Nothing to do with any "competition" or being afraid of being embarrassed later. It was a suit then and now and people have tried telling this to Bigfooters for many years. Nice compliments to the creator of it not withstanding. No one I know of has ever thought it was real. Sheesh:boggled: Something else that will be misunderstood and turned into yet another false factoid.

I'm listening to you describe the head in complete amazement. I could show the Wah head next to Patty to anyone else who works on creature suits and they would immediately realize what Wah and the guys had been up to and why Janos' wife got a case of amnesia about them when I put some questions to her. Yet I'm listening to you discuss Patty's "cranium" as if it's real and trying to use Poser to determine where things are. And you don't know where the eyes are? Are you serious? Tight fit? Jesus H. Christ.

It's just astounding the things you say sometimes. That is how this hoax goes on and on. You are feeding the fantasies of people who live in a make believe world.

Owen Caddy is simply meshing the background with the head to try to make the lips move more and you think that's good? Seriously dude, this is really nuts. That's what MK Davis did with the track he thought was there and a ton of other things that don't really exist in the film that he thinks he sees.

Bill, the JREF doesn't misunderstand what you are doing. It's pretty obvious. You're spinning yarns to fans that I think you've come to believe yourself. Nothing you've done so far has had much to do with truly researching the Patterson film at all.

No one is "terrified" that you're being misled. I'm just embarrassed for you. It's incredible that you've done all this talking around the subject and still learned so little about it.

You say you want JREF to ignore you but how can we? You've become another Krantz-Meldrum out there spouting nonsense that your peers would think delusional. If you insert yourself into the "make up expert authority" role then your complete misunderstanding of what's on the film and how the hoax harms people has to be talked about here. Understanding hoaxes and how they are propped up is part of what this forum is about.

There is a reason why 28 out of the 30 people attending the August 2004 BFRO expedition think they had an encounter with Bigfoot. I suspect being swarmed by Bigfeet might not be the root cause of it.

http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm134/Dfoot/post_scat.jpg
The above is some Bigfoot scat they think they found on the expedition. Pretty much sums up what I thought of the interview you did. Did you forget to correct the errors you promoted last time? Or were you too busy coming up with new BF scat to feed the sheeple?


(*Dfoot, his heart broken, shakes his head and runs out of the room... terrified.... sniff):dig:
 
Here is my response to your post...from a while ago, kitty....


kitakaze wrote:


Actually, kitty, they are synonomous.

Evidence is weighed in terms of "probabilities"....and 'probabilities' refers to a chance of something being true (anywhere from a 'less than 1% chance'...all the way up to a '100% chance') A "chance" based on reason...which, stated differently, is a "reasonable chance".

For a piece of evidence to carry "weight"...it does not need to be "reliable"....because evidence doesn't necessarily mean that something is, in fact, true.....only that there is a percentage of probability that it is true.

You keep talking about evidence being "reliable"...but "reliable" is only required if we need to know that the subject of the evidence is true.
We don't need to know that Bigfoot exists for the evidence to simply indicate a chance that it exists.

Evidence can exist in any strength...from very weak, to very strong...indicating a chance of something being true, from very low, to very high.

The reason you can only refer to evidence in terms of it being "reliable", kitty, is simply because you, like all the other Robo-Skeptics here, are only interested in evidence which "proves" that Bigfoot exists. You cannot acknowledge, and weigh, evidence which simply indicates a 'chance' that Bigfoot exists.

You can only repeat the ONE, basic party-line... "The....evidence....is....not....reliable....it....does....not....prove....Bigfoot....exists".





Measuring the weight of a piece of evidence can be done roughly, as in 'small probability', or 'high probability'....and it can also be done more precisely, with numbers....but that requires much more complex calculating...and involves doing studies on the odds of something being mis-identified, or hoaxed.






Spoken like a good Robot. :wink:






So....you've "dismantled" the idea that millions and millions of acres of wilderness in the U.S. is enough land for a small population of intellegent Primates to, for the most part, avoid human contact.

Well, you've convinced me, kitty! Clearly, it's impossible! :boggled:






Good work, kitty! :)

While the Native Americans legends of Sasquatch can't be reliably (known to be) linked to Bigfoot....there is still a chance that they did refer to a real creature.

Wouldn't you agree??





You mean "proof", kitty. ;) That's all you need to acknowledge that some of the evidence for Bigfoot carries a moderate amount of weight......right?





If the PG film "obviously" shows a man-in-a-suit....then why do we need such a "concerted effort" to reproduce it??

The "suit" is, allegedly, so laughable...yet apparantly much time, money, and effort would be required to reproduce it.
That simply doesn't make any sense.







One quick example....the Memorial Day Video.

The lifted object moves upwards apparantly under it's own power...hence...it's alive. A "living Bigfoot" is a more likely explanation for the lifted object, than a non-living mask.

Conversely, the "lifted-mask" theory is not the more probable explanation for the lift...because of the reason stated above, and also for the reason that a mask would not be "massive" enough to account for the mass of the lifted object.
A thin mask would barely even show-up at that low resolution, combined with the light-colored background.
The apparant mass of the object is more in-line with an infant's body.
__________________

It always comes back to the memorial day stuff with you, doesn't it?
 
Last edited:
I simply give back the mood that was offered to me.

bullpuckey you do, back in the annals of time you commented there could no bf in the Adirondacks, based on some rather aged experiences that you claim to have and don't make you an expert (if there is such a thing with BF) on the matter, and all I said was I would disagree with you. You then proceeded to wig out because I had the audacity to disagree with you. Not gonna waste my time to cite the BFF post in question, its there and people who care can look it up.

The PGF is a hoax and I'm interested to learn exactly how it was done.
Bigfoot/Sasquatach represented a relic population of hominid and that relic populaton died out in the early part of the last century.

Now if you want to discuss the PGF, Roger Patterson,and the circumstances of his film great if not don't expect me to accomadate your badgering.

You post opinion as fact and that is why your head is inverted in a way that makes it smell very bad.... Simple premise for debate slick, you post opinion as fact and then get all uppity when someone doesn't agree with ya. Troll or pinhead is up to the beholder, but you posted your so called facts:

PGF is a hoax: Burden of proof, yours.... cuz you stated it as a fact, not an opinion...

Bigfoot is extinct: burden of proof yours, see above..
 
C-Lodge said:
But seems some folks wanted one its a poor rendition regardless.

How do you know it is a poor rendition? Do you have information that I don't have?
 
I simply give back the mood that was offered to me. And unless you're comatose I can't see how you could miss the general attack dog atmosphere that permeates this forum. ALso if you look at the so called acidic posts I've made you'll see that they were made only after an acidic post was made to me first. You reap what you sow. If you want to get into a verbal joust with me fine I'm game what's the difference whether there's 30 or 31 knowitalls with a loaded keyboard aimed in my direction. Here's my stand on the Bigfoot issue.

The PGF is a hoax and I'm interested to learn exactly how it was done.
Bigfoot/Sasquatach represented a relic population of hominid and that relic populaton died out in the early part of the last century.

Now if you want to discuss the PGF, Roger Patterson,and the circumstances of his film great if not don't expect me to accomadate your badgering.

How do you know it is a poor rendition? Do you have information that I don't have?

Not so far.......
:jaw-dropp
 
Oh come on guys why are you bothering to try and make an argument out of that dumb statue? Mikey and Drew just scroll back the photo of that Bigfoot statue that's being worked on. Now tell me that that thing looks anything like a real animal should or could look. That thing looks like a claymation figure or carnival attraction.
 
Oh come on guys why are you bothering to try and make an argument out of that dumb statue? Mikey and Drew just scroll back the photo of that Bigfoot statue that's being worked on. Now tell me that that thing looks anything like a real animal should or could look. That thing looks like a claymation figure or carnival attraction.

YOU CLAIM that Bigfoot is extinct
YOU CLAIM that PGF is a hoax

Now you're obsessed with this statue, or are you just doing a silly gig hoping to change the subject.

I already told you, permission denied. Back up your claims.
 
It always comes back to the memorial day stuff with you, doesn't it?


What can I say...it's a great candidate for a legitimate Bigfoot video. :)

Until someone can come up with an alternate explanation which accounts for ALL the facts and details surrounding the multiple-witness sighting and the video, a 'Bigfoot with infant' will continue to be a very likely explanation.


Ray just suggested a trampoline as one possible explanation...:boggled:...but I'm not buying it. :p
 
Until someone can come up with an alternate explanation which accounts for ALL the facts and details surrounding the multiple-witness sighting and the video, a 'Bigfoot with infant' will continue to be a very likely explanation.

Hmmm.....Are we back to subjective interpretations of videos again? "A very likely explanation" is your opinion but your opinion carries little weight. The video is shot from such a great distance, that it is difficult to determine anything. Suggesting it is most likely (very likely?) a bigfoot with an infant is not very scientific at all and remains your biased opinion. But that is not what this thread is about. You want to talk about that start another thread.

Getting back to the PGF, I keep waiting for your response to my analysis that showed the arms on "bunny" (my term for "patty" these days) are not too long at all to be a human. Tick....Tock....The world wonders.
 
Oh come on guys why are you bothering to try and make an argument out of that dumb statue? Mikey and Drew just scroll back the photo of that Bigfoot statue that's being worked on. Now tell me that that thing looks anything like a real animal should or could look. That thing looks like a claymation figure or carnival attraction.

You are right, it does not look like a 'real' animal.
That is my point.
Show me a real bigfoot to compare it to and I'll reconsider.
 
William I take it you posted the photos to demonstrate that my statement discounts Giganto. Giganto is a very imposing beastie and theres little doubt that he cut a wide swath through his world when he was around. BUt my statement was designed more as a statement to discount the super size Bigfoot reports that abound. I've made no secret that I consider an upper height limit of 8ft for a hypothetical Sasquatach. A 12 footer would have way too many issues with remaining undetected.


Some Bigfooters would disagree. There certainly are reports of supersize Bigfoots (8ft+) and so they do not remain undetected. I think you may have meant unconfirmed, but then that is true for any BF of any size and at any time in history.

That statue was done in 1961, so nobody had seen Patterson's illustrated book or the PGF. The head has no crest, and it is not very bulky for its overall proportions. The physique is not much different than a muscular human male. The head looks "neanderthal-like". Many eyewitness reports from this time and earlier simply describe a large hairy "wild man". There is no mention of the artist's beliefs, and for all we know he could have been a complete skeptic. He's putting a hide loincloth on The Boss which seems odd now. But there certainly were reports of these wildmen being clothed in various ways.

Imagine yourself in 1961 and you are doing a Bigfoot statue (Sasquatch in Canada). How do you make it look? Big hairy wildman with a Boss of the Woods attitude. That's a check on all counts! Who was in a position to look at that statue and say Bigfoot doesn't look anything like that? Well?

Bill Munns did something similar with his Giganto figure. Really big hairy ape thing. That was done from only a jaw fragment. Bill has no clue if Giganto really looked like that or if it was covered with much long hair. Again, who is going to look at Munn's figure and say that Giganto didn't look anything like that? Well?


1934 and 1961...
553407f2.png
2e1384c7.jpg
 
YOU CLAIM that Bigfoot is extinct
YOU CLAIM that PGF is a hoax

Now you're obsessed with this statue, or are you just doing a silly gig hoping to change the subject.

I already told you, permission denied. Back up your claims.

So Mikey you seem to take issue with my Bigfoot is extinct and the PGF is a hoax. Then I must assume that you're in the camp that feels the PGF is real and that Bigfoot does exist. In which case why aren't you gracing the BFF? I suppose the badgers here have left you alone because you're a suitably nasty.

My claim that the PGF is a hoax is being well handled by Dfoot.
My position that Bigfoot went extinct is based on first hand expierence, not reading a book or surfing the internet. Actually being in a particular place with eyes and ears open. You see Mikey a person can learn the truth by actual expierence. We could debate the sky being green and have a real rip snorting time until one of us looked up to see that its blue. Well I was in the forest and my own eyes and ears told me that there wasn't a Bigfoot to be had.

Now what do you have to back up that the PGF is real and that there is still a Bigfoot stomping the forests?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom