Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
What about the constant claims of extraordinary weights bolstered by supposed deep footprints that humans can't make?

A sasquatch that is 8 feet tall is certainly going to weigh more than your average human, but it also supposedly has much more foot surface area.

So why would it's feet sink any deeper than a human's in the same soil?

Even if we add 100 pounds to a sasquatch to account for it's muscular bulk compared to a human, it makes no sense.

We are told that Patty left 3.5 inch deep footprints at Bluff Creek while walking on 5" x 14.5" feet. We are told this by Bob Gimlin, who did an experiment at the site regarding the depth of the prints.



Height chart for female sasquatches from Meet The Sasquatch by Murphy, Green and Steenburg. This is from 2004.

http://www.hancockhouse.com/products/product_images//MeeSas1.jpg

An 8ft bulky Sasquatach could weigh in at what 600-800 lbs? That would be sufficient to leave those deep footprints. One particular very bulky fellow I know stands 5'11" and tips the scales at 325. We don't need massive height to have great weight. However this is benginning to sound like it belongs on the "other forum". However if its understoodd that this is hypothetical then carry on.
 
Last edited:
I don't really know how anyone can come up with precise measurements of Patty. My drawing was meant to show how a costume can make a mime's arm look longer. There may be more than one way to accomplish that.

It is common for Bigfooters to claim that Patty's physical measurements exclude a mime in a suit. Then you have the inhuman gait claim going on as well. A believer can switch back and forth between claims, or stack them up together.

I just look at Patty walking and in still frames and say to myself - hell yes that could be a guy in a suit. But when I look at the popping thigh bulge - I switch the could be to is. There are other visible problems that reinforce that for me.
 
Bigfoot sighting hoaxer notes to self: Keep the height between 6-8 feet to maximize believability of phony story.

William you've given me a great idea! A book titled The Skeptics Guide To Bigfoot Hoaxing. I'll add that its wise to keep the telepathic element out of the hoax as well.
 
William you've given me a great idea! A book titled The Skeptics Guide To Bigfoot Hoaxing.

The best Bigfoot hoaxers that have ever lived might already be (or were when alive) skeptics.

I'll add that its wise to keep the telepathic element out of the hoax as well.

But the Bigfooters love to hear about "feeling of being watched", and "my hairs stood on end".
 
An 8ft bulky Sasquatach could weigh in at what 600-800

Who knows? We have Patty's claimed 3.5 inch deep tracks to work with. Patty weighs anywhere from 350-2,000 pounds depending on when you check and who you ask.

Get out a ruler and see what 3.5" really looks like. It would be up to the tops of the shoes I am wearing. My shoe would likely come off and be stuck in the ground if I sank in that far.

The PGF includes estimates of Patty's weight and a filmed experiment to show that weight, so it's valid to discuss it here, imo.

The point is that we have humans on the scene with feet considerably smaller than Patty's, who claim certain things.

Someone did an overlay at BFF showing that Patty may not actually be much bulkier than your average man.

Just imagine the sound a running 600-800 pound biped's feet would make as they pounded the ground and sank in 4 or 5 inches... We know Patty sank in a few inches just walking and she's a relatively small bigfoot.

Logically, a human should sink in the same amount or even more with less surface area to distribute our weight. Yet we don't, according to many footer examples.

Meldrum shows half tracks that are no deeper than full tracks...
 
However, zeroing in on those features are what is the problem. You may find the knee at a certain point but it could be slightly off. It is a subjective measurement and a suit could easily obscure the actual placement of the knee as demonstrated by some of the suits previously shown here in this thread.


I have stated the arm is within normal proportions by simply measuring the length of the arm in pixels. You can see what I stated here. I am not sure where you get the idea that people aren't posting results that show that "aunt bunny" is within normal proportions.

Based on what I measured, the length of the arm is well within normal proportions since it is essentially straight. If you want to lengthen the arm to inhuman proportion, then you need to shrink the size of the feet to human proportions.
Sorry Astro I missed your post where you measured Bunny's arm length. I had a look and I think you need to stick to the top of the shoulder, not the armpit, since we're trying to measure the bone length (or illusion).

I'm 6' 3" and my arm length is 32" (from the same point on Bunny). If Bunny's arm length is 35" and she is only 6' then our height/arm ratios are 2.3 and 2 respectively. That's a difference of 15%, which is significant. It amounts to a few inches longer than an average human her height. The arms aren't overly long but they appear to be longer than Bob H's. Now try to determine Bunny's wing span to height ratio. This includes both arms and her back width. Mine is about 1. Bunny's looks like it might be significantly more. Out of human range? Probably not, but if it was Bob H, he'd need hand extensions. And if hand extensions were used then the elbow placement is even more significant.

As far as other suits hiding the knee is concerned..I haven't seen any that don't just lower the crotch. That doesn't change the position of the knee. We also need to see the legs in motion. How about linking to a clip that demos this illusion (not a still)? It looks like we've got a fair number of frames of Bunny's knee to get a decent placement.
 
Óðinn said:
AMM, I'm not making these claims, but I found these comparison photos of Patty's arm length and tube wearing a glove extension. I assume the glove gave tube an extra 4 inches of arm length.

Hopefully tube can chime in with the measurements.

It looks like when their arm lengths are matched up, their elbows aren't -- providing Patty's elbow is located correctly. Also when the arm lengths are matched up, the legs don't seem to match. Likewise when the legs are matched up the heights don't. Their bodies seem similarly aligned so what's the deal? I don't get it. I found comparisons of Bob H that matched up with himself in the Morris costume. What kind of distortion is causing Patty to not match up? Any ideas?

Adding to the great points made by the others here on the matter:

1. If the Patty suit used costumed feet that "raised" the wearer higher than tube's shoes do, then any attempts to match up tube with Patty height-wise are screwed. Similarly, if the person in the suit isn't the same height as tube, any attempt to fit him into Patty would be, in my opinion, doomed to failure. This is especially a problem considering how costumes can disguise a person's size. For example, someone wearing this mask would appear to be somewhat taller than they really are due to the "crest." I should note that the mask I linked to has been sealed and mounted to act as a display piece, though. You can see more pictures of it here. Here is another way that a costume can disguise height

Another problem with the comparison pics is that they try to match up tube's shoulder with that of Patty. Here is a picture of Steve Calvert and here are two pictures of him in a gorilla costume. Notice the difference in the shoulders. Similarly, here is a picture of Ray "Crash" Corrigan and here is a picture of what is believed to be him in a suit. Here's a less-cropped version of that picture.

2. Not everyone is "built" the same way. Some tall people have long legs, others have long torsos, etc. Granted, I'm no expert, but I'd imagine that someone having longer or shorter arms than someone else could effect the placement of the elbow (which would in turn effect attempts to match them up with the elbow of someone else) or that differences in the length of legs could effect attempts to match up two different peoples' knees.

3. It's been said that the distance of the subject from the camera can effect how reliable a comparison between two pictures can be. I'm not going to pretend that I know how accurate that argument is, but it gets brought up here (That should take you to page three of "Creature Suit Analysis Part 6 - Comparative Anatomy" at the BFF).

Those comparison photos are from the BFF. I haven't tried to locate the elbow myself. Regardless of how bulky the suit is the arms and legs can only bend at the elbows and knees. Shoulder pads or a baggy crotch doesn't change that. By the same token it can't be claimed that the arms or legs are within human range. Either they can or can't be measured accurately. How would a suit hide the lower leg bone?

Dfoot posted pictures of suits that disguise the placement of the elbow and knees that supposedly allow for disguised bending awhile back. Hopefully, he can repost them for you. If the names of the movies and/or TV shows they were used in were provided, their flexibility could be confirmed.

I should note that although I've discussed how costumes can disguise joint placement, I personally suspect that the suit wearer and the way they positioned themselves have more to do with what we're talking about in the P/G film than those.
 
I'm 6' 3" and my arm length is 32" (from the same point on Bunny). If Bunny's arm length is 35" and she is only 6' then our height/arm ratios are 2.3 and 2 respectively. That's a difference of 15%, which is significant. It amounts to a few inches longer than an average human her height. The arms aren't overly long but they appear to be longer than Bob H's. Now try to determine Bunny's wing span to height ratio. This includes both arms and her back width. Mine is about 1. Bunny's looks like it might be significantly more. Out of human range? Probably not, but if it was Bob H, he'd need hand extensions. And if hand extensions were used then the elbow placement is even more significant..

The problem with measuring from the shoulder is you may not be measuring the shoulder if there is any padding, which in a suit, there probably is. Then you need to define the "shoulder". I measured extremely high (about halfway between the top of the arm to the neck) to show that the values are not excessive even in the most extreme situation. This is one of the reasons, I like the armpit measurement since it is fairly well defined in the image. This value is well within normal human range and, as noted, even with an extreme measurement the shoulder is also within normal range.

However, if you just measure from the top of the arm (using the centerline of the arm), the value of the actual armlength, shoulder to tip, drops to about 174 pixels, which is something a little more than 32". This puts the height to arm length close to the value you stated for yourself. Feel free to measure the values yourself. If you do not have software to do so, use a ruler. I would be interested in the values you obtain.

Like I said previously, it is very difficult to get accurate measurements because of the problems with padding in a suit, sagging of the suit, and where you choose your reference points. Add to the problem that Bunny is slouching and there never is a good shot that is perpendicular to the camera (this is probably the best frame that does this). To me there is nothing in the measurements to indicate extraordinary body proportions.
 
Another crude cut-away drawing by yours truly. This one shows an interior view of a hypothetical Bigfoot costume foot. The mime is wearing cowboy boots. The thick brown bottom is the flexible sole of the Bigfoot foot. You can see how this situation might add several inches to the height of the mime.


9fee8527.jpg
 
Another crude cut-away drawing by yours truly. This one shows an interior view of a hypothetical Bigfoot costume foot. The mime is wearing cowboy boots. The thick brown bottom is the flexible sole of the Bigfoot foot. You can see how this situation might add several inches to the height of the mime.


[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/9fee8527.jpg[/qimg]

Its al most a given that Bob H (if he wore the suit) would have been wearing cowboy boots.
 
Don't know if you are listening to the download, or heard the actual chatroom podcast, because if you heard the actual thing, after the show officially closed and I thought it was over, I and the hosts talked "off the record" and apparently the chat room listeners could still hear it. I actually spoke about you as one of the few on this forum I respected, for your own research and your reasoned approach to issues.

I had listened to the streaming version long after the podcast originally aired, but did not hear the part where you mentioned me. I don't know if I closed out too early or if that part got edited out for "reruns." In any case, thank you for the kind words.

I'd have to say the filtering goes both ways.

That's true in a general sense. I was focusing more on misrepresentation of facts and quotes by proponents. Although looking back, my statement made it sound like all proponents who write books on the matter do that, something which I don't know for sure. If anyone has any examples of this happening in something Bigfoot-related written by skeptics, I'm all ears.

Can't change my right to speculate. If people misunderstand, well I can't live my life constrained by others' capacities to misunderstand. I can't dumb down my thoughts or my expression of them. I keep qualifying "If Patty's real" and that's far more disclaimer than most others give.

Ah, I had forgotten if you had said "If Patty's real" during that discussion. If I had remembered, I wouldn't have brought this up.

As I don't fully understand the exact way he does his work, I reserve judgment on any "problems" as you say. But I respect the man, whom I've had considerable correspondence with.

Okay. I was just backing up Dfoot's point on the matter.

You have to actually "play the game" with producers and interviewers when you're in the business to understand how much pressure there is to hype yourself, promise the impossible, and generally exude confidence

That's true-to a degree-in terms of general employment; it's often expected that the prospective employ to "play up" their abilities somewhat during job interviews.

It's be funny to see how someone trying to use the P/G film as a way of picking a special effects artist would react if the person they approached explained that the film had too many issues with grain, et al. to be 100% sure about any details seen on film, but that the film was a hoax due to the issues related to the filming.

I focused on the 2001 Space Oddessy ape suits when I started, because they were the best so far (they weren't two piece suits), and I tended to focus on the mask mechanics....So I thought about what I thought were superior future designs, not cruder past designs.

Ah, okay.

I'm cautious about endorsing the enhanced facial illustrations of Patty, and so the eyes might be plus or minus an inch, in terms of determining location (based on what I see in the frames I have), and that would make a difference in planning how high or low a human head would fit inside Patty.

I see, so I was right about you being cautious about the exact location. I have no problem with that. It wouldn't surprise me if you already knew this, but I forgot to note that the placement of eyes on a suit doesn't always mean that the wearer is looking out of them, like in this suit.

Guess they are so used to people being false, they just don't understand somebody who is simply speaking from the heart what i really feel.

I should note that, while it wouldn't surprise me about some people lying about their beliefs, there are those who seem to honestly think they're not proponents because they're only partially convinced that it's real (or some argument similar to that effect). It's weird.

I simply think if others in the business want to contribute to this discussion, they should in some form of published analysis, in any forum or manner they choose, as long as they offered reasoned analysis that explains how they got to their conclusions. And if other want their opinions, those people should do the asking. I just want to know for myself, so I'm doing my own study, and sharing what I find with others who might be interested. I'd love to see others contribute, but I will continue my study with or without them participating.

I see, so it's just a general sort of hope rather than an expectation.

Getting back to the hip seams analysis, which (in a way) prompted this exchange in the first place, I figured I'll chime in on on the matter:

The second through fourth pictures in this were used to argue that what was said to be parts of the suit where fur was falling off or bare is actually due to sunlight reflecting off the fur. However, I don't know what frames they are from. Could this sort of thing also account for the "waist seam?"

As I suggested in another post, the other "seams" could be due to a boxer-brief like outfit worn under the suit. That could explain why they seem to move close to, but not exactly like a seam (if I'm reading the red and green lines on your images correctly). Could there be other explanations? Sure. Then again, considering the quality of the film, can we be sure of any details we see on it other than there's a furry figure walking in it?

Oh, and the first 30 seconds of this could offer some potential in terms of comparing folds and other suit issues to what's seen on the P/G footage.
 
AMM:

"It's be funny to see how someone trying to use the P/G film as a way of picking a special effects artist would react if the person they approached explained that the film had too many issues with grain, et al. to be 100% sure about any details seen on film, but that the film was a hoax due to the issues related to the filming. "

The only problem with this is the expectation the person asked knows enough about the issue to know the film grain disputes, the enhancements and their controversies, and the issues related to the filming. If they don't, just pointing to a shadow line in a still picture and saying "see, there's the seam" is simply the easy way out while looking smart.

"I should note that, while it wouldn't surprise me about some people lying about their beliefs, there are those who seem to honestly think they're not proponents because they're only partially convinced that it's real (or some argument similar to that effect). It's weird."

Well, the whole "proponant" label is so black and white, and human reality is shades of grey. I wouldn't be taking as much time as i am to study this if I thought there was nothing to study. Does that make me a "proponant"? I don't dismiss the possibility of a real cryptid species, although i cartainly can't prove it and am not directly trying. Does that make me a "proponant"? I think too many people simply want simplistic labels and black/white distinctions because they don't know how to think for themselves. Sad comment on the collective mentality of our culture, in my opinion.

"The second through fourth pictures in this were used to argue that what was said to be parts of the suit where fur was falling off or bare is actually due to sunlight reflecting off the fur. However, I don't know what frames they are from. Could this sort of thing also account for the "waist seam?"

Well, the waist seam is actually the more improbable, now that we've seen the suit research D has done. Seems the wetsuit split is the more common. So That agrues strongly for the waist shadow line being a light/shadow effect on some kind of curving contour of the fur instead.

"As I suggested in another post, the other "seams" could be due to a boxer-brief like outfit worn under the suit. That could explain why they seem to move close to, but not exactly like a seam (if I'm reading the red and green lines on your images correctly). Could there be other explanations? Sure. Then again, considering the quality of the film, can we be sure of any details we see on it other than there's a furry figure walking in it?"

The key thing, in my mind, is explaining shifting shadows, because seam structures should not shift that much. So a shadow pattern fluctuating significantly in its form over many frames would suggest in my mind an explanation other than a seam at that shadowed region. Seams, if you can see them, or shadows caused by then, have more of a continuity of shape. As far as stuff under fur causing lines, well furcloth as i know it is stiff enough that not much presses through it and keeps any recognizable shape. Furcloth tends to more buckle in clothlike fold patterns.

"I see, so it's just a general sort of hope rather than an expectation."

Yes. Wishful thinking, actually.


Bill
 
Wait a second...

I just realized that the picture on the bottom left in this image looks astoundingly close to this drawing by Roger Patterson. A drawing which he seemingly ripped-off from someone else.

I also discovered Patterson's drawing of the "old man" in the Ostman report. The page that I found it on also had a version of Patterson's "old woman" drawing that I had never seen before. Usually, I've seen it enlarged and flipped. However, seeing it this way makes me notice the similarity between how Patterson drew the sagging breasts and to what's seen on the P/G film. The breasts in the drawing don't jut out as much as they do in the film, but it's still close.

The drawing is shown in a similar position in this thread, which displays images from Roger Patterson's book, Do Abominable Snowmen of America Really Exist? This makes me suspect that the image was flipped for use in this comparison image.

I've also noted the similarity between the initials on the Ostman drawings and the ones on the Roe drawing. I dare say that Loren Coleman's attempt to claim that Kunstler copied the drawing from some unknown artist is laughably false.

Also, I found some pictures of the copies of the Patterson Bigfoot sculpture that were mentioned in the above link.

Due to the uncertain nature of blogs that don't let you directly link to entries, I'm going to quote the text of the entry I got those pictures from:

EXCLUSIVE: ROGER PATTERSON ARTWORK

"During the course of the late Roger Patterson's life, his artistic hands created the following sculpture, called "BigFoot," by Roger. You can own a copy of this historic piece today. Only $29.95, which includes postage. (For now, only copies will be sold in the United States). You can specify whether you want your cast in its natural color (shown here) or painted at the time of your order. We are the only site with official authorization to sell these bust with permission from Patricia Patterson herself. All proceeds go to Pat Patterson. Hurry, they will be up on this site for a limited time, possibly throught the end of November. Makes an excellent Christmas present for your loved ones! Just click on the image for a larger view."

source
 
Another crude cut-away drawing by yours truly. This one shows an interior view of a hypothetical Bigfoot costume foot. The mime is wearing cowboy boots. The thick brown bottom is the flexible sole of the Bigfoot foot. You can see how this situation might add several inches to the height of the mime.


9fee8527.jpg
That's a big one. A 21"er.
 
Its al most a given that Bob H (if he wore the suit) would have been wearing cowboy boots.

Well, that's what he says. If it's another person, they could have worn the same. It's not critical as almost any kind of footwear will elevate the person wearing them.

Another thing that may not be immediately apparent when looking at my drawing is the effect on a very large flexible foot when there is a smaller human foot inside. We push off with our ball and that will be located further back than the 'apparent' ball location of the fake foot. Meldrum says that BF has no ball, and that may be because all of the prints and casts that he has observed are faked. If you believe in Bigfoot, and you believe these things are Bigfoot tracks, and you do not see apparent ball action... then you say that Bigfoot must not have a ball.

Tube did experiments with a big flexible 'sole' strapped to the bottom of gym shoes. It created a sand ridge within the print that resembles the thing that Meldrum seems to connect with a mid-tarsal break. But tube's set-up is still not the same as a fully enclosed and complete flexible fake foot with his own foot inside. I know of no experiments in moist sand that actually use big fake feet with a human foot inside. Maybe Dfoot will be the one to do this with his own BF foot creations.

Interestingly, in his first paper, he illustrates a hypothetical BF foot showing an activated "ball hinge" in order to explain the Freeman "Walla Walla" half-tracks. Maybe what he means by ball is strictly the thickened cushion beneath this hinge (joint) which we have. The Wallace Alderfeet show a cushiony feature that is even called a double-ball because of its odd shape. I don't know where he stands on the Blue Creek/Onion Mountain tracks (observed and documented by Green & Dahinden) which were obviously created by the Alderfeet. If he thinks BF has no ball, then he should toss those out as fakes for that reason alone. "The hapless hoaxer created a fake ball. A real Bigfoot has no ball."

Odinn said:
That's a big one. A 21"er.

Like the arm drawing, this is meant to convey concepts. Neither are done to any scale and are exaggerated on purpose so that others can work with a concept. Maybe everyone already understood what I was trying to show. I do believe that these crude drawings represent what I was trying to show. Spark a concept and work from there. Bill and/or Dfoot should be in a position to support or deny those concepts as they would apply to the real world of working costumes.
 
Actually, I read the quotes from the audiotrack at a bigfoot site. They are very unconvinced by this film and consider a hoax. It says a lot for a film if you can not convince the proponents of bigfoot that it shows a real bigfoot.


There are some Bigfoot proponents who think the MD Video may show a real Bigfoot...and some who have no strong opinion, either way....mainly because of the video's low resolution.
The vast majority of people who see the video form their opinion of it based mainly on the low res, and don't take into consideration all the other details surrounding the sighting/video event.

You're a great example of what I'm talking about, Astro.

In your post, you said this....

Why can't it be a can of corn, a backpack, a club, or anything else? Why an infant?

and this...

There is no indication that there is an actual "infant" present in the video.


Those statements are a perfect example of what I mean.

If you had taken a good look at the animated gif showing that the object lifts up after the subject has let go of it...and also considered all the eyewitness testimonies from that day, and the conversation that was going on during the filming....you'd know that the video cannot show a "can of corn...a backpack...a club"...or just anything.

The fact of the matter is.....the explanation which best fits all the many details of this event, is the Bigfoot w/infant explanation.

Just one more little detail from the video to consider...
After the subject reappears into view, and the object is lifted-up....only 1 of the subject's arms is ever seen, either moving down from the head, or swinging. Why is that?? It seems odd that it's walking along, swinging just one arm.

One possible explanation...which makes sense...is that the subject has one of it's hands on the infant, keeping it steady on it's shoulders....the whole time that it's up there.
Again....the "Bigfoot w/infant" explanation fits, sensibly, all the small details that we can see within the video.


Of course...an alternate explanation could be that the other arm is simply down at the subject's side the whole time....but that only reinforces the notion that the lifted object is alive. Because, we know that the object lifts up after the one visible arm has let go of it....and if the other arm is down at the subject's side....then the object lifting up must be doing so under it's own power. Hence...it's a living being. :)

This video is like a murder mystery...which requires carefully putting together many small clues, to come up with the most sensible explanation for it.

Saying..."Blah blah blah...it's a blob blob blob"...as Mad Hom does, is NOT the intelligent, thoughtful approach to take. It's brain-dead analysis at it's all-time best! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom