Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some Bigfooters would disagree. There certainly are reports of supersize Bigfoots (8ft+) and so they do not remain undetected. I think you may have meant unconfirmed, but then that is true for any BF of any size and at any time in history.

That statue was done in 1961, so nobody had seen Patterson's illustrated book or the PGF. The head has no crest, and it is not very bulky for its overall proportions. The physique is not much different than a muscular human male. The head looks "neanderthal-like". Many eyewitness reports from this time and earlier simply describe a large hairy "wild man". There is no mention of the artist's beliefs, and for all we know he could have been a complete skeptic. He's putting a hide loincloth on The Boss which seems odd now. But there certainly were reports of these wildmen being clothed in various ways.

Imagine yourself in 1961 and you are doing a Bigfoot statue (Sasquatch in Canada). How do you make it look? Big hairy wildman with a Boss of the Woods attitude. That's a check on all counts! Who was in a position to look at that statue and say Bigfoot doesn't look anything like that? Well?

Bill Munns did something similar with his Giganto figure. Really big hairy ape thing. That was done from only a jaw fragment. Bill has no clue if Giganto really looked like that or if it was covered with much long hair. Again, who is going to look at Munn's figure and say that Giganto didn't look anything like that? Well?


1934 and 1961...
[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/553407f2.png[/qimg] [qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/2e1384c7.jpg[/qimg]

Bill Munns created the Giganto standing and reaching for effect not as a means a Bigfoot prospect. If I'm not mistaken Bill himself conceeds that Giganto was a quadraped. In any event do you think that there are 12ft tall hairy humanoids out there? The Bigfoot statue as far as I'm concernd could be 6 ft or 26ft tall and it would still look like an Amateurish job. Munns Giganto is art the bigfoot statue is sholock
 
Hmmm.....Are we back to subjective interpretations of videos again? "A very likely explanation" is your opinion but your opinion carries little weight. The video is shot from such a great distance, that it is difficult to determine anything. Suggesting it is most likely (very likely?) a bigfoot with an infant is not very scientific at all and remains your biased opinion. But that is not what this thread is about.

Here are a few things that are not my opinion, Astro...

1) The object moves upward while the subject's arm moves downward.
The animated gifs show that unambiguously.

2) Masks don't lift up under their own power.


2) The lifted object is too massive to be a simple mask....

frame1liftaaa2.jpg


frame1pixels1OutLnd33.jpg


frame1pixels1OutLnd22.jpg



The "lifted mask" theory is simply....a load of crap. It was created purely as an alternative to a "Bigfoot w/infant" explanation.
The fact of the matter is....more than one person on the hillside that day said they saw the creature at fairly close range....including Owen Pate. That was the reason he had Lori get the camcorder out...to get it on tape if it reappeared....which it did. :)

Another detail we can be quite sure of, is that the Pate's had nothing to do with creating this video as a hoax.
Lori's father, Larry, has been actively posting on Bigfoot forums since this video was shot. The reason for that is simple...he's become interested in the subject of Bigfoot, since his daughter and son-in-law saw a real live Bigfoot, in person. ;)


Again.....the mask explanation falls short of explaining all the various little details surrounding this sighting/filming event. But if it makes the skeptics feel good...go right ahead and play make-believe.

I plan on making a comparable video which will show that the lifted object was, in no way, a mask. :)



Getting back to the PGF, I keep waiting for your response to my analysis that showed the arms on "bunny" (my term for "patty" these days) are not too long at all to be a human. Tick....Tock....The world wonders.


Could you provide a link to that post of yours, Astro...or at least tell me what page it was on? I'd appreciate it...it would save me a lot of time hunting for it.

In the meantime....in this comparison image...Patty's arms sure look a bit longer than the other guy's....

HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Bill Munns created the Giganto standing and reaching for effect not as a means a Bigfoot prospect. If I'm not mistaken Bill himself conceeds that Giganto was a quadraped.

I understand that. A considerable number of Bigfooters believe that Giganto is a good candidate as an ancestor of modern BF. It probably has much to do with the overall size which is speculated from the fossil bits. That and the psychological desire to point at some real fossil and say Bigfoot came from that.

In any event do you think that there are 12ft tall hairy humanoids out there?

Of course not. I would say the same about any wild undocumented hominoid living anywhere in the world - regardless of size.

The Bigfoot statue as far as I'm concernd could be 6 ft or 26ft tall and it would still look like an Amateurish job. Munns Giganto is art the bigfoot statue is sholock.

It was to be a tourist attraction and was probably used outside and needed to withstand the elements in southern British Columbia. Bill's model is fantastic but is made for indoor or protected display. Regardless, the 1961 Bigfoot statue is an outstanding piece of folk art. Maybe you have no appreciation for this kind of thing. I suspect that if it were now offered at a properly advertised auction, in decent condition, it would bring an amazing amount of money. I hope it's still around and is being cherished and shared. It is really worthy of cultural museum display.
 
Last edited:
I understand that. A considerable number of Bigfooters believe that Giganto is a good candidate as an ancestor of modern BF. It probably has much to do with the overall size which is speculated from the fossil bits. That and the psychological desire to point at some real fossil and say Bigfoot came from that.



Of course not. I would say the same about any wild undocumented hominoid living anywhere in the world - regardless of size.



It was to be a tourist attraction and was probably used outside and needed to withstand the elements in southern British Columbia. Bill's model is fantastic but is made for indoor or protected display. Regardless, the 1961 Bigfoot statue is an outstanding piece of folk art. Maybe you have no appreciation for this kind of thing. I suspect that if it were now offered at a properly advertised auction, in decent condition, it would bring an amazing amount of money. I hope it's still around and is being cherished and shared. It is really worthy of cultural museum display.


There was a series on PBS TV that visited tacky tourist traps. That statue would have been worthy of center stage.
 
In the meantime....in this comparison image...Patty's arms sure look a bit longer than the other guy's....

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Gorilla%20Suits/HaHaHaHaHaHa1.jpg[/qimg]

Couldn't that be from arm extenders? They're fairly standard in ape suits.
 
Here are a few things that are not my opinion, Astro...

1) The object moves upward while the subject's arm moves downward.
The animated gifs show that unambiguously.
2) Masks don't lift up under their own power.

2) The lifted object is too massive to be a simple mask....

Maybe in your subjective view these things are there but I don't see it. Again, the image is too small and you are seeing what you want to see in an image that is way overenlarged and lacks details that can be properly determined. You are seeing 'faces in the clouds'.

From what I understand the memorial day footage audio is not that convincing. The group recording the video made comments like the can make a million bucks and it looks like a guy or words to that effect. That does not sound like people witnessing something truly extraordinary.


Could you provide a link to that post of yours, Astro...or at least tell me what page it was on? I'd appreciate it...it would save me a lot of time hunting for it.

In the meantime....in this comparison image...Patty's arms sure look a bit longer than the other guy's....

Sigh...must I do everything for you? It was just before you disappeared for a few days promising to get back to me on it.

It is post # 13474.

As for "looking a bit longer than the other guy", that is not an accurate measurement at all. Are the two images to scale? Where do you measure the arm from? If we go from the armpit area to the finger tips (after all if it were a suit, the shoulders probably had padding on them), "bunny's" arms are about 5-10 pixels longer than the BBC image. However, if you look at the apparent height "Bunny" is also a bit taller (although we do not see the feet so that is subjective at best) by a few pixels. The image scale is too small and the arms are not in the same position to make a clear measurement or comparison. This is why I chose the image from frame 72, where the arm is almost straight down and "bunny" is standing fairly straight up (although still slouching). In that case, we also see the foot, which is supposed to be 14.5" long giving some scale to the image. There is also the case of height vs arm length ratio, which tends to indicate a normal human being.
 
Last edited:
Astrophotographer wrote:
From what I understand the memorial day footage audio is not that convincing. The group recording the video made comments like they can make a million bucks and it looks like a guy or words to that effect.
That does not sound like people witnessing something truly extraordinary.



I happen to have a copy of the full video, with the audiotrack.
I've listened to it several times...and it's absolutely convincing, because the group was getting a real charge (emotion) out of the possibility that they were about to get a real live Bigfoot on videotape.

It was one of the kids that said "we can make a million bucks"....and also, one of the kids, at about the same time, said..."I'm freaked".
They were all joking, and laughing....basically very enthused and excited about the whole event. Nothing about the conversation sounds rehearsed, in the least.

Because of Larry's continued interest in Bigfoot...it's extremely unlikely that he was in on this, as a hoax, purpurtrated by the Pate's. Because, if that was the case, he'd have NO reason, no motivation whatsoever, for posting on Bigfoot discussion boards.
Last year Larry sent me a long email, talking about the sighting, and the video. He also gave me the make and model number of the camcorder they used, at my request. I'm interested in making a re-creation video, using the same model camcorder, if possible...using a few different objects to simulate the lifted object.
There is a significant difference in size, or mass, between a mask and an infant animal....and that difference will be readily apparant in a video shot at the same resolution as the MD Video.
Take a guess, Astro, which one is going to more closely match, in size, the lifted object.


As for me "seeing faces in the clouds".....you're wrong, Astro. It's only the skeptics who can see an amazing amount of detail in the video. I've posted Morgoth's comments here, where he said he can see the white lining of the mask. :boggled:

One skeptic states the video is the ultimate "blobsquatch"...while another skeptic sees all the details of the mask, just so he can "expose the hoax".

Whatever "keeps the Bigfooties away" is what a skeptic will say....period. :)
 
Last edited:
Astrophotographer,

I wouldn't waste my time debating Sweaty. I once made the mistake of giving him benefit of the doubt in the past and I quickly realized that he ignores things that prove his points wrong. For example, I posted a link to a .gif showing the "lift" in the Memorial Day video was due to background noise and he ignored it and kept posting about how the "lift" was most likely due to an infant.

Oh, and I wonder if is this the arm band picture that GT/CS mentioned earlier:

handmove.gif
 
On the discussion between Bill Munns and Diogenes:

I can't blame Diogenes for saying that you said you didn't see , due to comments like the following from your latest entry on the Patterson film

"I would expect the shadow patterns diagrammed in red to consistently follow the shape diagrammed in green or blue, if those shadow patterns are proof or indication of seams on a suit, and they do not.

The inconsistencies diagrammed in red on the accompanying chart simply do not match my expectation of what evidence would indicate there is a seam on that body, in either the waist area or the hip line. Instead, the irregularities suggest to me some other explanation must be offered to account for the shifts in pattern."

But judging from your comments here, you didn't mean it that way. Both Diogenes and you seem to have gotten upset at each other missing what they felt was clear, which leads to obvious frustration on both sides, which has colored your responses to one another. I think it's safe to say that all three of us have had interpretation issues and haven't fully read things at times here, so there can't be any "finger-pointing" or casting of blame.

On the discussion between Dfoot and Bill Munns:

First of all, thanks for clearing up the Swamp Thing suit story. I thought Dfoot was doing a good job of clearing things up himself up until the late middle/end of his most recent post (especially the Bigfoot droppings part). Dfoot, I know you're frustrated, but typing that stuff really didn't help your case or getting Bill Munns to see your point of view. You're better than that.

As for the comments on your recent podcast appearance, I'm going by memory from listening to it earlier today since my computer and TalkShoe don't always "get along" and I don't want to spend five minutes fiddling around with things in order to get the show running for me again. I really wish the people behind "Let's Talk Bigfoot" would upload shows onto Youtube like this or this.

I will say that Dfoot was dead-on in his comments about how proponent authors filter information to make their cases look better (If I remember correctly, a butchered quote by John Napier has been toted as him endorsing the film), that talking about Patty's brow and comparing it to prehistoric hominids can confuse people about your opinion on whether or not the film is real, that Owen Caddy's work has problems with it, and the "effects artists today cast doubt on the film in order to look good/ensure that they won't get passed over" argument seems pretty oddball. Judging from his work history, Stan Winston didn't seemd to have any trouble getting work after the Alien Autopsy guys edited his comments to make it look like he thought the film was real. Also, if I recall correctly, he was taking longer than others in his analysis since he was under the impression that the film was made in the 40's. Also, I didn't get any indication that the effects artists who were contacted about the film by posters on the BFF thought that they were being approached by people who wanted to hire them.

Similarly, I can empathize with Dfoot being shocked that you didn't seem to know of two piece costumes, seeing as how you were in the business at a time when they were in use. I guess you just weren't in the "right" places at the "right" times.

I also found your comment about having issues with finding eyes on Patty a bit odd at first. I'm guessing you mean finding the exact location (and maybe size) of the eyes on Patty. It is admittedly hard (perhaps impossible) to clearly see eyes in the frames you used here and it could be argued that what seem to be eyes in pictures like this (bottom left) could be an artifact of some sort. This picture also might be of use to you (I didn't put the arrow in; it's from an article where someone is pointing out a, quote, "light spot" in order to deflate a claim by Greg Long).

I should note that references to the "tight fitting head" is typical proponent comment, as is "Why the sudden change, Dfoot?" Your trying to line up the eyes of a poser figure to eyes in Patty's head is also very similar to some stuff done by SweatyYeti. Combined, those details can make others think that you're a proponent who claims not to be one (which, as I noted in the past, is more common than you'd think). Speaking as someone who used to check in on cryptozoology-related stuff every so often (I think it was like a few times every year or so), I can empathize with you not knowing all the details of the Patterson Gimlin film, for not realizing the posting behavior of proponents here, or that proponent authors aren't giving their readers the full scoop about Bigfoot. The only possible way I couldn't empathize with you is if you chose to ignore such things after learning about them.

Also, if you really want others in the industry to comment on your work, you should send it to them. If they're not interested in Bigfoot, chances are that they aren't going to find your work while surfing the net.

And on a final note: If anyone feels that I'm misinterpreting them, please feel free to speak up.
 
AMM:

Don't know if you are listening to the download, or heard the actual chatroom podcast, because if you heard the actual thing, after the show officially closed and I thought it was over, I and the hosts talked "off the record" and apparently the chat room listeners could still hear it. I actually spoke about you as one of the few on this forum I respected, for your own research and your reasoned approach to issues.

Your latest post affirms my respect. Thank you.

Now on to specifics:

"I will say that Dfoot was dead-on in his comments about how proponent authors filter information to make their cases look better "

I'd have to say the filtering goes both ways.

"that talking about Patty's brow and comparing it to prehistoric hominids can confuse people about your opinion on whether or not the film is real,"

Can't change my right to speculate. If people misunderstand, well I can't live my life constrained by others' capacities to misunderstand. I can't dumb down my thoughts or my expression of them. I keep qualifying "If Patty's real" and that's far more disclaimer than most others give.

"that Owen Caddy's work has problems with it,"

As I don't fully understand the exact way he does his work, I reserve judgment on any "problems" as you say. But I respect the man, whom I've had considerable correspondence with.

"and the "effects artists today cast doubt on the film in order to look good/ensure that they won't get passed over" argument seems pretty oddball. "


You have to actually "play the game" with producers and interviewers when you're in the business to understand how much pressure there is to hype yourself, promise the impossible, and generally exude confidence to understand why the "I'm so great, I can spot a fake every time" thing is common. And you learn to say it to everybody, producers, interviewers, strangers, just to cover yourself. I'm not saying everybody does it, but I know it's common.

"Similarly, I can empathize with Dfoot being shocked that you didn't seem to know of two piece costumes, "

I focused on the 2001 Space Oddessy ape suits when I started, because they were the best so far (they weren't two piece suits), and I tended to focus on the mask mechanics. There's nothing exhaulted or mystical about a fur suit sectioned as opposed to a one piece jumpsuit. It's just a fur line across the hip, with shorter hair, is a lousey seam to try and hide, and I was focused on doing real gorilla replicas, not long hair junk gorillas. To match a real gorilla's torso and legs, a two piece suit would be unwise and the seam line would be a nightmare to connect without being obvious. So I thought about what I thought were superior future designs, not cruder past designs. And never anticipated then I'd be in thei forum now having to explain this all either.

"I also found your comment about having issues with finding eyes on Patty a bit odd at first".

I'm cautious about endorsing the enhanced facial illustrations of Patty, and so the eyes might be plus or minus an inch, in terms of determining location (based on what I see in the frames I have), and that would make a difference in planning how high or low a human head would fit inside Patty.

"Combined, those details can make others think that you're a proponent who claims not to be one "

Guess they are so used to people being false, they just don't understand somebody who is simply speaking from the heart what i really feel. My degree of "proponantcy" or skepticism is exactly what I say it is. I really don't know what Patty it. I am mystified. You just have to wonder, how many times to you have to say a truth about yourself, before people figure out it's the truth of yourself. At some point you just have to stop worrying about how others are misconstruing or misunderstanding things you say or do.

I had already answered this some time ago, but for me to specifically ask others in the business to analyse this issue, they reasonably should expect and ask for a consultant fee, and I'm not in a position to hire any consultants. If I were funded with a grant, I could.

I simply think if others in the business want to contribute to this discussion, they should in some form of published analysis, in any forum or manner they choose, as long as they offered reasoned analysis that explains how they got to their conclusions. And if other want their opinions, those people should do the asking. I just want to know for myself, so I'm doing my own study, and sharing what I find with others who might be interested. I'd love to see others contribute, but I will continue my study with or without them participating.

Bill
 
Last edited:
AMM:

On the thing about the eyes, and why I wasn't confident placing them exactly, here's two profiles of Patty and there's a lot of discrepency in the shape of them. One I traced in red dotted lines and the other I traced in blue dotted lines, and those profile shapes are more than an inch off in places (to scale of a 6' or more figure). So seeing such discrepencies between frames, I am hesitant to pick an exact eye position.

oddly, I just put this same image up "over there" in answer to another patty question.

Weird night.

Bill
 
AMM:

This one might be clearer.

I put an approximated eyeball in each face profile eye socket shadow, about where i'd expect an eye to be, and then took the two profile outlines (the red and blue dotted lines) and overlaid them in the center, so the two eyeballs aligned, and the blue profile outline is about one "eyeball" diameter lower in the top of it's skull than the red outlined head.

That would be a discrepency of about an inch, to scale.

So a human head might fit in the red outlined head more easily because of the higher skull top. A human head would be a tighter fit in the blue outlined profile.

Suffice to say, these estimations are based on the initial estimation of eye position. I doubt if the eyes could be lower (which would give more "headroom"). They might be higher, which would lessen the headroom even more.

That's why I'm hesitant or cautious to say how well a human head would fit into Patty's head, and wonder about a "tight fit".

Funny too, how my being cautious is perceived as odd. I thought caution in not leaping to rash conclusions was the wiser action.

Bill
 
picture didn't load.

I'll try later

Apologies: Can't get the picture upload thing working, and can't find a picture upload tutorial to explain it.
 
Last edited:
Astrophotographer,

I wouldn't waste my time debating Sweaty. I once made the mistake of giving him benefit of the doubt in the past and I quickly realized that he ignores things that prove his points wrong. For example, I posted a link to a .gif showing the "lift" in the Memorial Day video was due to background noise and he ignored it and kept posting about how the "lift" was most likely due to an infant.

Oh, and I wonder if is this the arm band picture that GT/CS mentioned earlier:

[qimg]http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y160/JTrojan/handmove.gif[/qimg]

I would say the same thing of crowillogic, they seem to just want to stir the pot. You offer them the "oppurtunity" to back up their point and then they run away to attack the next guy's point. I doubt he/she/it has a point.
 
To realize the preposterousness of a 10 ft or 12 ft tall Hominid/Primate.

Can't believe I had to clarify that for you, Crow.

Its when the height falls between 6 & 8ft that one can entertain the idea that a reportage might be more than hot air. You'll find that I questioned the immense heights very early on on BFF. I even posted a series of photos demonstrating what an 8ft, 10ft and 12ft Sasquatach would look like next to a human that stands 5'9". In my collage days I read this paperback Bigfooot book where the authors were making claims and full sized cutouts of 15ft tall Bigfoot. When I got to that part I put the book down and said to myself,"what a crock these guys are."
 
I happen to have a copy of the full video, with the audiotrack.
I've listened to it several times...and it's absolutely convincing, because the group was getting a real charge (emotion) out of the possibility that they were about to get a real live Bigfoot on videotape.

Actually, I read the quotes from the audiotrack at a bigfoot site. They are very unconvinced by this film and consider a hoax. It says a lot for a film if you can not convince the proponents of bigfoot that it shows a real bigfoot.

As for "seeing faces in the clouds", how are you arriving at the opinion that it is an infant? Why can't it be a can of corn, a backpack, a club, or anything else? Why an infant? If that is your claim you will have to do better than show an overenlarged blob as your evidence. There is not indication that there is an actual "infant" present in the video.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom