The point is that if there was credible evidence of a god people wouldn't have to be walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con as it would be world-wide headline news on every form of media that would be extremely difficult to ignore. You do realise this is all hypothetical?
Yes,
I realize that it's hypothetical, so you don't really need to ask. Did it confuse you that I explicitly said so?!
The first part you quoted wasn't even a question. If Santa and Sasquatch were proven to be real it would be stupid not to believe in them as well. Although their reality would hardly be on the same level of importance as a god's reality. You do realise this is all hypothetical?
Yes, I do realize that it's all hypothetical. And the reason why I explicitly said so wasn't in order to confuse you about the fact. What you seem to confuse is people's
reasons for giving up their religious faith. You confuse the actual reason why most people stop being religious with a
prerequisite for doing so:
The question was why atheists were never theists or were theists, but then became atheists, not why they became theists.
The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence. Do you think people could or would be apathetic if there was?
FTFY! (Or am I mistaken about what you intended to write? Correct me if I'm wrong.)
You don't seem to get that the reason why people could be so tremendously wrong for thousands of years about the existence of God was that they
needed him and so they
invented him. And except for some professional theologians, they weren't really obsessed with
evidence. They needed the comforting idea of a deity, a good father figure who'd watch out for them and reward them for being good and punish all the bad guys (if not here in reality where they were obviously thriving then at least
beyond). They didn't need
evidence (the Good Book even warned them against requiring evidence!), and yet they
invented evidence all the time, for instance when a bad guy died untimely, it was obviously God's punishment, and when a good guy did, it was because God wanted to spare him from having to walk through the vale of tears or the valley of the shadow of death. And the evidence was always
credible because they
wanted and
needed to believe. It can't really be more
credible than that. (See Trump and his faithful followers if you still think that people need evidence in order to
believe in something that they feel a
need to believe in!)
And basically, things haven't changed much. In spite of education etc. people still decide to misinterpret the doctor when he tells them that there is no hope of prolonging life; all that's left is palliative treatment. I've collected a
couple of good links here about this and similar questions.