Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Some people are aoathetic about all sorts of important things for which there is plenty of evidence in the real world. Poverty in their own countries, the bad things done by their governments, abuses of democracy, institutionalised racism, etc.

I don't see why the existence of God would be any different.
You really think that poverty, the bad things done by governments, abuses of democracy, institutionalised racism, etc. are even remotely comparable in importance to finding out a god actually exists. Do you realise the extreme life and death consequences of a god like the Christian one actually existing?
 
Last edited:
The point is that if there was credible evidence of a god people wouldn't have to be walking around looking for evidence for stuff, making up their minds only after careful consideration of pro & con as it would be world-wide headline news on every form of media that would be extremely difficult to ignore. You do realise this is all hypothetical?


Yes, I realize that it's hypothetical, so you don't really need to ask. Did it confuse you that I explicitly said so?!

The first part you quoted wasn't even a question. If Santa and Sasquatch were proven to be real it would be stupid not to believe in them as well. Although their reality would hardly be on the same level of importance as a god's reality. You do realise this is all hypothetical?


Yes, I do realize that it's all hypothetical. And the reason why I explicitly said so wasn't in order to confuse you about the fact. What you seem to confuse is people's reasons for giving up their religious faith. You confuse the actual reason why most people stop being religious with a prerequisite for doing so:

The question was why atheists were never theists or were theists, but then became atheists, not why they became theists.

The reason people can be apathetic about religion is because there’s no credible evidence of any god’s actual existence. Do you think people could or would be apathetic if there was?


FTFY! (Or am I mistaken about what you intended to write? Correct me if I'm wrong.)

You don't seem to get that the reason why people could be so tremendously wrong for thousands of years about the existence of God was that they needed him and so they invented him. And except for some professional theologians, they weren't really obsessed with evidence. They needed the comforting idea of a deity, a good father figure who'd watch out for them and reward them for being good and punish all the bad guys (if not here in reality where they were obviously thriving then at least beyond). They didn't need evidence (the Good Book even warned them against requiring evidence!), and yet they invented evidence all the time, for instance when a bad guy died untimely, it was obviously God's punishment, and when a good guy did, it was because God wanted to spare him from having to walk through the vale of tears or the valley of the shadow of death. And the evidence was always credible because they wanted and needed to believe. It can't really be more credible than that. (See Trump and his faithful followers if you still think that people need evidence in order to believe in something that they feel a need to believe in!)

And basically, things haven't changed much. In spite of education etc. people still decide to misinterpret the doctor when he tells them that there is no hope of prolonging life; all that's left is palliative treatment. I've collected a couple of good links here about this and similar questions.
 
You really think that poverty, the bad things done by governments, abuses of democracy, institutionalised racism, etc. are even remotely comparable in importance to finding out a god actually exists. Do you realise the extreme life and death consequences of a god like the Christian one actually existing?


I think we all do, but you seem to be the one who doesn't quite get that it's hypothetical!
 
You really think that poverty, the bad things done by governments, abuses of democracy, institutionalised racism, etc. are even remotely comparable in importance to finding out a god actually exists. Do you realise the extreme life and death consequences of a god like the Christian one actually existing?

Since your question can essentially be rephrased as "do you think that unimaginable human suffering and unnecessary death are even remotely comparable to unimaginable human suffering and unnecessary death?", then the answer is an easy yes. At best you're talking about a matter of degree.
 
Since your question can essentially be rephrased as "do you think that unimaginable human suffering and unnecessary death are even remotely comparable to unimaginable human suffering and unnecessary death?", then the answer is an easy yes. At best you're talking about a matter of degree.
You are forgetting/ignoring the consequences of an actual eternal afterlife of eternal bliss or suffering.
 
I think proof of god would change everyone's lives. They wouldn't just go around ignoring that.
 
You are forgetting/ignoring the consequences of an actual eternal afterlife of eternal bliss or suffering.

Yes but you are thinking about it rationally.

Many humans take up smoking though they know that they'd have a good chance of getting cancer in later life.

Indifference says nothing beyond the fact that people are indifferent.
 
Utter rubbish! Lack of evidence is obviously evidence of lack of evidence.

-Lack of evidence
versus
-Evidence of lack
is not the same.

That there is no positive evidence for god(s) doesn't mean that there are no god(s).

With regards
 
You are forgetting/ignoring the consequences of an actual eternal afterlife of eternal bliss or suffering.

Well, leaving aside the question of whether or not the Christian God* actually does imply those things, then as I said at best you're talking about a matter of degree. If your contention is that there is a certain threshold above which suffering not directly and immediately impacting people is something that cannot be ignored by anybody, then I'd ask for some evidence that this is true.

I would say that the existence of, to pick one example, the American healthcare system, in which tens of thousands of people die preventable deaths (usually with a great deal of suffering) because the system is run for profit, and the fact that that majority of Americans are blasé about this - despite the fact that this (or bankruptcy) could happen to them or those they love, and despite the wealth of evidence that nationalised healtcare is cheaper and saves more lives - is good evidence that people find being apathetic over this kind of thing quite easy. It's much easier to be concerned about the problems that are directly affecting you now than it is to worry about a potential future problem you may have.

*And, indeed, an appropriate question might be which Christian God? It's not, after all, as if Christianity is one homogeneous whole with all members believing the same things or believing that God has the same attributes.
 
Last edited:
... the American healthcare system, in which tens of thousands of people die preventable deaths (usually with a great deal of suffering) because the system is run for profit, and the fact that that majority of Americans are blasé about this - despite the fact that this (or bankruptcy) could happen to them or those they love, ...


That's probably the major reason why Americans need religion (and pay for it, too!) to the extent that they do - unlike more civilized countries.
 
That's probably the major reason why Americans need religion (and pay for it, too!) to the extent that they do - unlike more civilized countries.

Yeah, the church's request of 10% is very small potatoes compared to what the healthcare system in the US demands of a great many people for entrance into those pearly gates.
 
All this talk of God versus multiverses and fine tuning leaves me unimpressed.

We, (carbon based life form), may be one of many different possibilities. Out there, (in our universe or others), there may be other life forms of a completely different type. They may be pondering why their world is so fine tuned to be complimentary to their own existence. To the god believing theists I ask: What kind of life form is your god?

Yes, the weak anthropic principle is all that is needed. It has been alluded to upthread with the metaphor of the water thinking that the form the puddle is designed to fit it.

As an aside, I would say that given the laws of chemistry and physics, carbon-based life would be the most common and there are good reasons for thinking that liquid wayer would also be important... not that invalidates your argument.


Thanks for that jimbob. :)

I had hoped to get some input from theists in response to the final question in my post.

"What kind of life form is your god?"

This sort of strikes at the heart of the "fine tuning" argument so popular with theists I think. The god entity is a life form yes? One that is quite at home in any sort of environment perhaps?
 
Thanks for that jimbob. :)

I had hoped to get some input from theists in response to the final question in my post.

"What kind of life form is your god?"

This sort of strikes at the heart of the "fine tuning" argument so popular with theists I think. The god entity is a life form yes? One that is quite at home in any sort of environment perhaps?

As an aside, in year 5, my son was asked to draw their idea of god*

He drew an old man with a beard sitting on a cloud... and Zeus, Thor, Ganesh, and an alien (obviously aliens wouldn't have human gods). I was quite proud. I can't remember if I had introduced him to the FSM by that time.



*which I thought was pretty poor in a non-religious school, and somewhat unaware how offensive it might be to any Muslims.
 
........

I was an atheist until I was about 30 years old, then a theist afterwards. I started posting on atheist/theist discussion boards around 2000, and to me, a lot of Australians who have converted to atheism from theism suddenly start to believe that Christians MUST believe in the Bible, despite their own former position of not really caring what was in the Bible when they called themselves Christians.

.......


......

I am most interested in the above. Did you reason your way into theism? If so how did this work?

.......


Never did get an answer to this question GDon.

We hear so much of reason being used by atheists to explain their lack of belief, although responses on this thread seem to suggest it is not a common way for theists to lose their faith.

If you used reason to get into faith that would be interesting to hear about.
 
-Lack of evidence
versus
-Evidence of lack
is not the same.

That there is no positive evidence for god(s) doesn't mean that there are no god(s).
With regards

To the highlighted, it sure as hell means there is no reason to think there are god(s). Because otherwise I could have a million dollars in my checking account and not even know it because there is no evidence of it being there.

I'm pretty sure the reason for the lack of evidence for the hypothetical million in my checking account is that it isn't there. Pursuant to that reasoning, I'm going to play it safe and not write any large checks.

But I don't even buy your reasoning to the above extent. I think lack of evidence for god(s) is, in fact, evidence against god(s). It is an unlikely god whose existence cannot be differentiated from it's nonexistence.
 
Why don’t god-huggers say - “That there is no positive evidence for Titanosaur Argentinosaurus Vuinculensis(s) doesn't mean that there are no Titanosaur Argentinosaurus Vuintulensis(s)”? There’s good evidence that Titanosaur Argentinosaurus Vuinculensis(s) can possibly exists as there’s good evidence they once existed. Can't say that about any god.
 
Last edited:
Nobody has a psychological need for Titanosaur Argentinosaurus Vuinculensis.
 
To the highlighted, it sure as hell means there is no reason to think there are god(s). Because otherwise I could have a million dollars in my checking account and not even know it because there is no evidence of it being there.

I'm pretty sure the reason for the lack of evidence for the hypothetical million in my checking account is that it isn't there. Pursuant to that reasoning, I'm going to play it safe and not write any large checks.

But I don't even buy your reasoning to the above extent. I think lack of evidence for god(s) is, in fact, evidence against god(s). It is an unlikely god whose existence cannot be differentiated from it's nonexistence.

You are doing a light version of magical thinking. It goes like this: That you think/reason reality in toto is in certain way will not determine/cause reality to be in a certain way. Rather since you are a result of reality, you are caused by reality and you are the result(effect). Your thinking/reasoning is the result of being caused by reality as such.

So you(Y) are caused by natural reality(NR) or you are caused by another reality(AR). Another reality could e.g. be by a god or that you are a Boltzmann brain.
So it goes like this:
NR->Y
OR
AR->Y
but since you are the same, Y, you can't tell if reality is natural reality, NR, or another reality, AR.

All you have given evidence for, is what you believe reality is. Not what reality is independently of your mind.

For all the highlighted parts, they are cases of your thinking about what reality is to you, not what reality is independently of the mind.

With regard
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom